The skill-listing check emits a third finding for an oversized skill BODY
(v5.11 B7, RAW title "Skill body is large (loads on demand when the skill
runs)"). The body is an ON-DEMAND cost — it loads only when the skill is
invoked, not the always-loaded listing Claude reads every turn. The scanner is
careful to distinguish the two (RAW title + comment + evidence note).
But the humanizer-data SKL.static map had no entry for this title, so it fell
through to SKL._default ("A skill is using more of the listing budget than it
should"). The humanized title therefore claimed a listing-budget cost and
directly contradicted the finding's own humanized evidence ("loads ON DEMAND
only ... NOT every turn like the always-loaded listing") — the same internal
contradiction class as M-BUG-15/M-BUG-14, and the same "new finding type added
without a matching humanizer entry" gap the scanner checklist warns about.
Found by finding-granularity premise-verification of the linkedin-posts scan
before feeding it to the analyze pipeline (the prior session's pass focused on
the GAP findings and did not catch the SKL fall-through).
- humanizer-data.mjs: add SKL.static entry for "Skill body is large (loads on
demand when the skill runs)" with on-demand-correct title ("A skill's body is
large (it loads only when that skill runs)"), description, and recommendation.
No listing-budget language; tier1/tier3 forbidden-word checks pass.
- RED-first tests at both layers: humanizer.test.mjs (humanizeFinding path:
title is not the listing-budget _default, conveys on-demand body) and
humanizer-data.test.mjs (static entry exists, on-demand-correct).
RAW envelope unaffected (humanizer bypassed for --raw/--json), frozen v5.0.0
snapshots untouched, default-output fixtures contain no oversized-body skill so
no snapshot regen. Suite 1357->1359/0 (+2).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01683eAqVecv9VZfQzL8CQ9h
The t2_3 ("No path-scoped rules") and t3_6 ("No subagent isolation")
feature-gap checks iterate a collection (rule files / agent files) and return
false for an EMPTY one — so they fire even when the user has zero rules / zero
subagents, the same state their presence-gap siblings flag. But the humanized
titles presupposed the feature already exists:
- "Your rules all load on every conversation" (with zero rules)
- "Your subagents share Claude's main work folder" (with zero subagents)
The second directly contradicts GAP-005 "You haven't set up any specialized
helper agents yet" in the same report — a user cannot simultaneously have no
subagents and have subagents that lack isolation. Found by dogfooding the
analyze pipeline against linkedin-posts (premise-verifying each finding before
trusting the analyzer-agent's report).
Decided fix = align the two titles with the house "You haven't set up X yet"
absence framing (state-neutral: honest for both the zero-state and the
has-but-unconfigured state), NOT a base-feature presence gate in the scanner —
that would change the frozen v5.0.0 marketplace-medium baseline (zero
rules/agents, freezes these gaps firing) and break the RAW byte contract.
Mirrors M-BUG-14's humanizer-layer, copy-only approach.
- humanizer-data.mjs: title "Your rules all load on every conversation" ->
"You haven't set up path-scoped rules yet"; title "Your subagents share
Claude's main work folder" -> "You haven't set up subagent isolation yet".
description + recommendation unchanged. t3_5/t3_7 ("Your skills don't ...")
left as-is: their possessive is correct in the common case where skills
exist; the zero-skills edge is latent, not manifest here.
- RED-first unit test pins both titles existence-neutral (forbids "your rules
all load" / "your subagents"; feature still named).
Frozen v5.0.0 snapshots untouched (RAW bypasses humanizer); default-output
snapshot regenerated (2 titles only, no collateral). Verified on linkedin-posts:
GAP-004/005/011 now all consistently absence-framed. Suite 1356->1357/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01683eAqVecv9VZfQzL8CQ9h
The t2_2 feature-gap check is a pure presence check (rules file OR @import
present) with no length gate, consistent with its t2_3/t2_4/t2_5 siblings.
But the humanized copy claimed the file is "one big block" and that splitting
makes it "easier on the loading time" — an unconditional size/load-cost
overclaim. For a ~625-token non-modular CLAUDE.md the load saving is trivial,
so the description lied. Found by dogfooding feature-gap against linkedin-posts.
Decided fix = copy-softening, NOT a length gate in t2_2 (that would make it the
only size-gated check among the presence-check siblings + risks byte-stability
if a short non-modular CLAUDE.md fixture exists in snapshots).
- humanizer-data.mjs: title "one big block" -> "all live in one file";
description drops "long"/"loading time", keeps the honest structural
"split into linked files with @import or .claude/rules/" framing.
recommendation unchanged.
- RED-first unit test pins the size-neutral copy (no "big"/"long"/"loading
time" in title/desc, structural split framing kept).
Frozen v5.0.0 snapshots untouched (RAW envelope bypasses humanizer); SC-5
default-output byte-stable (no non-modular GAP finding in those fixtures).
Suite 1355->1356/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01683eAqVecv9VZfQzL8CQ9h
The CC settings schema is passthrough (verified against the 2.1.193 binary): it
forwards unrecognized keys unchanged rather than rejecting them, so an arbitrary
unknown key is valid/forward-compatible, not an error — the finding's "silently
ignored" claim was factually wrong. The only real risk is a TYPO of a real key
(the intended setting then silently has no effect). Fix: flag an unknown key only
when it closely matches a known key (new levenshtein helper; edit distance <= 2,
both keys >= 4 chars); severity medium -> low; honest passthrough framing in the
scanner + humanizer. Also refreshed KNOWN_KEYS with 6 binary-verified keys
(agentPushNotifEnabled, remoteControlAtStartup, skipAutoPermissionPrompt,
skipDangerousModePermissionPrompt, skipWorkflowUsageWarning, tui). Suite 1341/0
(+12). Frozen v5.0.0 snapshots untouched (0 CA-SET findings there), no re-seed.
Dogfood ~/.claude/settings.json 6->0 (all 6 keys above were false unknown-key
findings; 0 typo flags introduced across 167 walked files).
The B3a cache filter already exposes discovery.staleCacheVersions; surface them
as a finding so the user knows the superseded plugin versions are safe to delete.
Honesty (Verifiseringsplikt): the finding loads on ZERO turns, so it must NOT
read as a per-turn token cost. TOK normally humanizes to "Wasted tokens"; a new
per-finding category override ('plugin-cache-hygiene' -> "Dead config") plus a
dedicated humanizer translation ("Old plugin versions are sitting on disk (safe
to delete) ... cost zero tokens per turn ... housekeeping, not a performance
problem") keep the prose accurate instead of the generic "using more space"
default. evidence carries the explicit "zero live-context impact" note.
- token-hotspots: Pattern H emits CA-TOK (low) from discovery.staleCacheVersions
when stale versions exist (`--global`); silent otherwise.
- humanizer: CATEGORY_TO_IMPACT lets a finding's category override the
scanner-default impact label (raw `category` field unchanged -> --json/--raw
byte-stable). humanizer-data: honest static translation for the finding.
- Tests: finding fires/severity/category, lists stale keys + zero-impact note,
silent when none; humanizer override -> Dead config; honest translation locked.
- Docs: tokens command render note (disk-cleanup, not a token problem) +
--no-exclude-cache flag; README + CLAUDE.md rows (7 patterns, cache-aware).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
First detector of the 'is the config OPTIMAL?' axis (vs the existing 'correct?' scanners). New orchestrated scanner family CA-OPT (count 14->15), the deterministic half of the hybrid optimization lens.
CA-OPT-001 (low, Missed opportunity): a multi-step procedure in CLAUDE.md (>=6 consecutive numbered steps) that belongs in a skill. Reads recommendation + provenance from the best-practices register (BP-MECH-003). Conservative by design; the negative corpus proves null false-positives. Prose-judgment cases (lifecycle->hook, 'never'->permission) are deferred to the Chunk 2b opus analyzer.
Wiring mirrors OST: orchestrator entry, humanizer (OPT->'Missed opportunity' + family), scoring (OPT->'CLAUDE.md', existing area -> no new posture row -> byte-stable), strip-helper (OST,OPT), SC-5 regenerated under hermetic HOME (additive OPT entry only). 10 new tests; suite 1045->1055, self-audit A/A, readmeCheck passed (all verified with a clean HOME).
Note: the pre-existing TOK test reads the real ~/.claude (non-hermetic) -> run the suite with a clean HOME for deterministic results. Tracked as a separate follow-up.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
New orchestrated scanner output-style-scanner.mjs — first new family since
SKL. Three findings, each pinned to a CONFIRMED V-row of the steering-model
plan + re-verified against code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles:
- CA-OST-001 (medium, V10): user/project custom style missing
keep-coding-instructions:true (default false) → silently strips built-in
software-engineering instructions when active. Scoped to user/project.
- CA-OST-002 (low, V11): plugin style with force-for-plugin:true overrides the
user's selected outputStyle. Verifiseringsplikt correction — the plan bullet
said "project/user style," but force-for-plugin is plugin-styles-only per the
docs, so the check keys on source==='plugin'.
- CA-OST-003 (medium): settings outputStyle matching no built-in
(Default/Explanatory/Learning/Proactive, case-insensitive) nor discovered
custom style → dead config.
Byte-stability — a scanner addition, not a field addition. Growing the
scanners array + scanners_ok cannot be hidden by a field strip, but re-seeding
frozen v5.0.0 (the SKL precedent) would now bake in B2's hotspot triple +
claudeMd drift. So, per the B2 lesson, frozen v5.0.0 snapshots are PRESERVED
and the OST entry is stripped at compare time via new
tests/helpers/strip-added-scanner.mjs (wired into json/raw-backcompat + the
Step 5/6 humanizer tests); only SC-5 default-output is regenerated (additive
OST entry, diff reviewed). OST is fixture-gated (no output styles on
marketplace-medium / hermetic HOME → silent).
Wiring: orchestrator; humanizer (OST→Configuration mistake) + humanizer-data
OST family (title-coupled); scoring (OST→Settings, keeps 10 areas). Suite
1012→1023 (+11). Badges: scanners 14, tests 1023, TRANSLATIONS families 15.
Lore swept: README, CLAUDE.md, scanner-internals, humanizer.md. self-audit A/A.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per the official "what survives compaction" model (context-window.md):
only the project-root CLAUDE.md (+ unscoped rules) is re-injected after a
context compaction. Two additive, structural findings (low severity):
- RUL: a large (>50-line) PATH-SCOPED rule — reloads only on a matching
file read, and is not re-injected after compaction, so must-hold rules
can silently drop mid-session.
- CML: a NESTED (subdirectory) CLAUDE.md — not re-injected after
compaction (only the project root is).
Additive (no new scanner, count stays 13); one humanizer entry each;
hermetic temp-fixture tests (positive + negative). Suite 957 -> 961,
SC-5 byte-stable, self-audit A/A.
Known limitation (pre-existing, broader than A): the lightweight
frontmatter parser reads inline `paths:` but not YAML block sequences,
so block-sequence-scoped rules are still seen as unscoped. Deferred.
Part of v5.5.0 "steering-model I". Foundation (active-config-reader
enumeration) deferred to v5.6 with B.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
Plugin subagents silently ignore `hooks`/`mcpServers`/`permissionMode`
frontmatter — these are honored only for user/project agents in
.claude/agents/ (code.claude.com/docs sub-agents). Setting them in a
plugin agent is dead config; `permissionMode` is MEDIUM because it
implies a restriction Claude Code does not apply (false security).
hooks/mcpServers are LOW.
Additive to PLH's agent-frontmatter loop (no new scanner, count stays
13). One humanizer pattern covers the three field titles. Hermetic
temp-fixture test (positive + negative). Suite 954 -> 957, byte-stable.
Part of v5.5.0 "steering-model I". Foundation (active-config-reader
enumeration) deferred to v5.6 with B — A/E are additive and don't
consume it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
HKV: add Setup, UserPromptExpansion, PostToolBatch to VALID_EVENTS,
verified live against code.claude.com/docs/en/hooks.md (2026-06-19). A
valid hook using one of these was wrongly flagged "will never fire" — a
user could delete a working hook. Made the "(N total)" hint dynamic so
it can't drift again. Flagged the unverified kebab 'post-session' in a
comment (an existing test depends on it; follow-up check needed).
RUL: reword the globs finding. Only `paths:` is documented; whether CC
ever read `globs` is unverified, so the old "deprecated/legacy" framing
overclaimed (Verifiseringsplikt). New wording steers to the documented
`paths:` field. Updated the coupled fix-engine title match and the
humanizer entry (which also carried the "field was renamed" overclaim).
Suite 950 -> 954 (badge bumped). self-audit A/A, scanner count 13. No
version bump — these land in the pending v5.4.1 patch.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
settings-validator now validates the autoMode block (auto-mode classifier
config). Structure (medium): autoMode must be an object whose only keys are
environment/allow/soft_deny/hard_deny, each a string array ("$defaults" is a
valid entry); flags not-an-object, unknown-subkey, not-string-array. Dead-config
(low): Claude Code does not read autoMode from shared project settings
(.claude/settings.json), so an autoMode block committed there has no effect —
keyed on file.scope === 'project'.
Both premises primary-source-verified (code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config).
The plan's "test per-file scope first" gate passed: ConfigFile already carries
scope. SET is in the orchestrator; SC-5 re-checked, byte-equal (snapshot fixture
has no autoMode). Fixtures force-added (.claude/ is gitignored).
Tests +5 (944->949). Scanner count unchanged (13). --json/--raw byte-stable.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
PLH now validates each entry of a plugin.json `skills` field (string|array):
every entry must resolve to an existing directory inside the plugin root.
One finding per bad entry (medium, plugin-hygiene), problem ∈ {non-string,
escapes-root, not-found, not-a-directory}. Mirrors `claude plugin validate`.
String|array normalized so a non-string top-level value is caught too.
Verifiseringsplikt: the plan's "CC suggests the parent directory" error text
is NOT in the primary docs — dropped. Only the four primary-source-verified
conditions are asserted (escape backed by the path-traversal rule).
Tests +3 (941->944). Scanner count unchanged (13). --json/--raw byte-stable.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
PLH now flags a plugin.json component-path key (commands/agents/outputStyles)
that replaces a default folder still present on disk — Claude Code stops
scanning that folder, so its contents are silently ignored (dead config).
Mirrors CC's /doctor & `claude plugin list` warning (v2.1.140+).
Field set pinned to the docs' "replaces" category only (Verifiseringsplikt,
code.claude.com/docs path-behavior-rules): skills is excluded (adds to the
default skills/ scan — both load) as are hooks/mcpServers/lspServers (own
merge rules); a custom path that addresses the default folder is not flagged.
Tests +5 (936->941). Scanner count unchanged (13). --json/--raw byte-stable.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
Commands are namespaced (/name:command), so a command name shared by two
differently-named plugins keeps both reachable — it is ambiguity, not a hard
conflict. The check now mirrors COL's plugin-vs-plugin skill finding: severity
LOW (was HIGH), category plugin-hygiene, COL-shaped details.namespaces, and a
group-first shape (one finding per command name listing every namespace, not
pairwise). It keys on the declared namespace (was folder basename) and fires
only across 2+ distinct namespaces — when plugins share a declared name, the
namespace-collision finding (medium) is the right signal, so this stays silent.
Removes the inaccurate "only one wins" humanizer entry. Adds fixtures
(duplicate-command-name; a shared command in duplicate-plugin-name's colliding
namespace) and 4 tests. Suite 932->936. self-audit A 97 / A 100, scanners 13.
Two plugins that declare the same `name` in plugin.json collapse into one
component namespace (/name:command, name:skill, agent "name"). Resolution
between two installed same-name plugins is undocumented, so one plugin's
commands/skills/agents are silently shadowed and unreachable. PLH now flags
this at medium severity, keying on the declared `name` (not folder basename,
via new declaredName on scanSinglePlugin) with a COL-shaped details.namespaces
payload. Name-less plugins are excluded from the collision map.
Search-first (code.claude.com/docs/en/plugins): plugin components are
namespaced by the declared name, so a plugin component can never shadow a
user/project one — only a same-name collision loses components. This refutes
the original "plugin vs user vs project shadowing" framing in the backlog.
Adds humanizer pattern, fixture (duplicate-plugin-name: 2 colliding + 2
name-less), and 3 tests. Suite 929->932. self-audit A 97 / A 100, scanners 13.
Syklus 2 of Fase 4 Items 2+3. Flags when the sum of active skill
descriptions exceeds the listing budget (~2% of context, CC 2.1.32).
Design (operator-confirmed "fact-first, 200k anchor"):
- low severity (estimate) vs medium for the verified 1,536-char cap
- each description counted up to the 1,536 cap (what actually loads in
the listing) — avoids double-counting the tail CA-SKL-001 flags
- fires when sum > 2% x 200k = 4000 tok; evidence leads with the measured
sum + a calibration note that the budget scales 5x on 1M-context models
- aggregate emitted after the per-skill loop so the common case reads
001=cap, 002=aggregate (finding IDs are a sequential counter, not stable
semantic IDs — tests match on title, never NNN)
Also:
- tailored humanizer static entry for the aggregate title
- fix latent HOME leak in posture-grade-stability.test.mjs: it spawned
posture.mjs without hermeticEnv(), so a real ~/.claude leaked HOME-scoped
SKL/COL findings into the baseline grade (Token Efficiency A->B). Now
isolated like the 8 other CLI-spawning tests.
- docs sync: test count 868->875, scanner-internals, gap-matrix, plan status
Suite 875/875, no snapshot drift, self-audit clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
Fase 4 Items 2+3 (CC 2.1.114→181 gap-review). New orchestrated scanner
`skill-listing-scanner.mjs` (prefix SKL) flags every active skill whose
description exceeds the verified 1,536-char listing cap (CC 2.1.105, changelog
L1502). Past the cap, Claude Code silently truncates the description the model
reads to route skill invocation — dropping the trigger phrases at the tail.
HOME-scoped over all user + plugin skills via enumerateSkills (COL is the model).
- CA-SKL-001 (medium): description > 1,536 chars. Remediation folds in Item
2(b) — recommends disableBundledSkills + skillOverrides + trimming
(designvalg A: no standalone GAP-check, which would fire for nearly everyone).
- Designvalg B: v1 ships the verified cap ONLY. The aggregate 2%-of-context
listing budget is deferred — it needs a context-window assumption that would
turn a verified fact into a guess (would carry a CALIBRATION_NOTE if added).
- Choice C: recognize the skillOverrides settings key (CC 2.1.129) in
KNOWN_KEYS. Left OUT of TYPE_CHECKS — the value is a per-skill object
(off/user-invocable-only/name-only), not a string; a 'string' check (as the
plan sketched) would create a NEW false positive. Verify-first deviation.
Registration: scan-orchestrator (13th scanner), humanizer (SKL → 'Wasted
tokens' + static/_default translations), scoring SCANNER_AREA_MAP (→ Token
Efficiency; no 11th area), README badge 12→13, CLAUDE.md (finding-id +
test-count), docs/scanner-internals.md, gap-matrix + plan status notes.
Snapshots reseeded hermetically (SEED_SNAPSHOT/UPDATE_SNAPSHOT): SKL entry with
0 findings in empty HOME, scanners_ok 11→12, claudeMdEstimatedTokens bump from
the CLAUDE.md edits flowing through the cascade. Contamination grep clean.
Suite 868/868 (856 baseline + 11 SKL + 1 skillOverrides). RED→GREEN logged
per cycle.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
`.mcp.json` has no per-server `trust` key — verified 2026-06-18 against
code.claude.com/docs/en/mcp + /settings. MCP server approval is
dialog/settings-based (enableAllProjectMcpServers / enabledMcpjsonServers /
disabledMcpjsonServers), never a JSON field. The scanner's "Missing trust
level" (CA-MCP-001, medium) and "Invalid trust level" (high) were false
positives flagging a field that does not exist.
- scanner: delete both trust checks + VALID_TRUST_LEVELS; drop `trust` from
VALID_SERVER_FIELDS so a stray `trust` is now flagged as an unknown field
- humanizer: remove the two trust-level entries
- knowledge (5 files): point to the real approval mechanism, not a trust field
- fixtures: scrub `trust` (incl. the invalid "local" in optimal-setup)
- tests: flip assertions (no trust-level finding; stray trust -> unknown
field) + add knowledge-staleness re-freeze guards
- snapshots: reseed (marketplace-medium .mcp.json -8 tokens, hermetic)
- gap-matrix: mark the trust verify-first item DONE
Suite: 853/853 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
Wave 1 / Step 2 of v5.1.0 plain-language UX humanizer.
scanners/lib/humanizer-data.mjs exports TRANSLATIONS keyed by
scanner prefix (CML, SET, HKV, RUL, MCP, IMP, CNF, GAP, TOK, CPS,
DIS, COL, PLH). Each scanner has:
- static: exact-title -> {title, description, recommendation}
- patterns: array of {regex, translation} for template-literal titles
- _default: graceful fallback for unknown findings
Architectural change vs. plan: keys translations by exact scanner
title (not finding ID). Reason: finding IDs are sequence-based
(global counter in lib/output.mjs:34), not stable per finding-type
— two runs can produce different IDs for the same logical issue.
Title strings ARE stable (defined as string literals or template
patterns in the scanner source).
Translations follow research/03 SR-1..SR-17:
- active voice, second person, present tense
- sentences <= 25 words
- tier1 absolute prohibitions and tier3 domain jargon are kept out
of prose
- tier1/tier3 terms are permitted inside `backtick spans` (code
references like filenames and field names) — established
technical-doc convention
Test (12 cases): all 13 scanners covered; every static and pattern
entry has the 3 required fields; tier1 and tier3 forbidden-word
checks pass (with backtick-span exclusion); reference-stable
imports. All pass.
Regression: 657/657 tests (645 + 12 new).
Project: .claude/projects/2026-05-01-config-audit-ux-redesign/
