BREAKING CHANGE: the {NNN} in CA-{SCANNER}-{NNN} identifies the check that
produced the finding. It used to be the finding's position in that scanner's
output for that run, which made it unstable across CONFIGURATIONS, not just
across releases as STATE framed it. Measured on two fixtures: "No custom
subagents" was CA-GAP-007 on minimal-project and CA-GAP-004 on healthy-project.
A user who fixed an unrelated earlier gap silently renumbered every later one,
so a .config-audit-ignore pin retargeted to a neighbouring finding with no
version change at all.
Second measured arm: README already documented the opposite scheme. It and the
scanner headers describe ~20 numbers as check codes (CA-SKL-003 = oversized
body, CA-PLH-015 = folder shadowing, CA-TOK-006 = schema deferral), and the
counter could only produce those in the all-fire case -- source-order positions
are 4, 3 and 8. The documentation described the scheme; the implementation was
what was wrong. Every published number is preserved by construction and pinned
exhaustively in tests/lib/finding-codes.test.mjs.
scanners/lib/finding-codes.mjs is the single authority. Every finding() call
passes a `code`; an undeclared or missing one THROWS. No counter fallback --
that would reproduce D1's findGapId -> 'unknown' silent degradation and let a
half-converted scanner ship IDs that look valid. findingCounter/resetCounter
are deleted outright, not left as no-ops. Retirement is now a mechanism:
RETIRED_CODES tombstones a withdrawn key so its number is never reissued,
seeded with GAP t3_8 -- the D1 removal that opened this chunk.
IDs are consequently NOT unique per finding: one check failing in three files
emits three findings sharing an ID. That inverts which consumer is correct, so
every f.id/findingId site was classified before the change. diff-engine and
most of fix-engine already keyed on scanner+title+file (drift was never lying);
fix-engine's verification did not, and keyed on the ID alone -- fixing one of
two sibling instances marked both fixed, and the untouched one, still present
in the re-scan, was reported as a REGRESSION. Red test first, then keyed on
(findingId, file), which both planFixes and applyFixes already carry.
plugin-health's crossIds Set was measured and is a clean negative: cross
findings are allFindings.slice(crossPluginStart) and codes 18/19 are emitted
only in that tail, so the partition holds by construction.
unknownSuppressions() reports a pin that names no declared check, in the
--output-file payload (ux-rules rule 2 -- a stderr-only warning is invisible to
the commands) and only when one exists, so a clean config is byte-identical.
That is what makes the break safe: a stale pin goes loud instead of dying quiet.
Frozen tests/snapshots/v5.0.0/ untouched on disk. IDs are masked out of that
comparison (mask-finding-ids.mjs) rather than re-derived -- re-deriving
positional IDs would assert the retired scheme against itself, and #58's
isGapEntry off-by-one is the measured example of that misfiring. The dead
re-derivation is removed from strip-retired-gap.mjs. default-output snapshots
re-approved after confirming the diff is IDs and nothing else.
Guards, each seen red against its own defect: a missing code (scanner errors
out mid-sweep), an orphan declaration, a resurrected retired key, and a
documented ID naming no check. The sweep asserts the union across all 16
scanners, never per scanner -- a per-scanner assertion goes green on a partial
conversion.
Fasit written before implementation: docs/mbug28-id-semantics-fasit.local.md,
including one correction made before running (CML has 12 checks over 13 call
sites -- the anchored and calibrated char-budget arms are one check, which a
repeated-title sweep found and my call-site count had missed).
Suite 1535 -> 1573, 0 failing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MyqCQKK2ornJ1jFWwqx17E
`KNOWN_OPEN` in cli-unknown-flag-rejection.test.mjs named two CLIs as still
carrying the argument-swallow defect. That number was the previous session's
field of view, not a measurement. Measuring all fourteen found **7** open on
the unknown-flag arm and **10** on a second arm the deferral note never
described.
Arm 1 — unknown flag: with no `else` branch, `--zzz` leaves no trace. exit 0,
full payload, a confident answer to a question the caller did not ask.
Arm 2 — the sharper one: `a === '--output-file' && args[i + 1]` asks only
whether a next token EXISTS, never whether it is a value. `manifest`,
`campaign-cli` and `knowledge-refresh-cli` each wrote a file literally named
`--json` into the caller's working directory when handed `--output-file
--json`, exit 0, with `--json` mode silently dropped. A wrong answer is bad;
an unintended file on disk is worse.
Two of the CLIs this catches were already in GUARDED and green on arm 1 while
arm 2 stood open a few lines away — the guard asserted one relation instead of
the invariant.
Fixed with a shared gate (`lib/cli-args.mjs`) that runs BEFORE each CLI's own
parse loop rather than replacing it: valid argv reaches the existing parser
byte-for-byte unchanged, so the byte-stability argument is structural rather
than empirical. `drift-cli`, `fix-cli` and `plugin-health-scanner` were
already correct on both arms and were moved into GUARDED instead of rewritten.
The three CLIs with a bespoke unknown-flag branch had it removed once the gate
made it unreachable.
Suite 1488 → 1531. Frozen v5.0.0 snapshots untouched; `self-audit
--check-readme` passed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014P6Rh59Mtj4uYrdYMCYZJE
Dogfooding `campaign` + `knowledge-refresh` against a throwaway ledger. Seven
defects, all found by running the commands as written and measuring, not by
reading them.
The headline pair only existed together. `knowledge-refresh` built
`STALE_AFTER="--stale-after 30"` and expanded it unquoted, trusting the shell to
split it in two. bash does; zsh — the macOS default, and what the Bash tool runs
here — does not. The CLI got one argv entry, matched no flag, and because it had
no unknown-flag branch, silently kept the 90-day default and reported "✓ All 14
register entries were re-verified within the last 90 days": a true-sounding
sentence about a threshold the user had just overridden. Fixing either half alone
leaves a silent wrong answer or a loud one; both are fixed, and a guard now
rejects any template that packs a flag and its value into one variable.
`knowledge-refresh` also read one register and wrote another: step 6 named an
unanchored `knowledge/best-practices.json` while the CLI reads
`${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/…`, which for an installed plugin is the cache. The
validation gate then ran the cached test against the cached register — green no
matter what was written. The two copies were byte-identical that day, which is
exactly why it was invisible.
`campaign` vouched for repos it could not read. `add /finnes/ikke` returned
`added` + exit 0; `refresh-tokens` then put the phantom in `swept[]` with a
0-token delta and left `skipped[]` empty, so the machine-wide bill claimed
coverage of three repos on a machine with two. Paths stay tracked — an unmounted
volume is a legitimate absence — but are reported as `addedUnverified`, and the
command names them.
Two class sweeps, both measured rather than assumed. `posture` was the single
scanner (1 of 14) whose fatal catch exited 1, which ux-rules defines as a normal
WARNING grade — a crash indistinguishable from a result. And all 13 payload
writers failed on a `--output-file` whose parent did not exist, which on a fresh
machine turned `campaign`'s first run into "the ledger may be corrupt"; they now
share `scanners/lib/write-output.mjs`.
Predicted breadth was too wide for the first time in five sessions: 6 of 8 CLIs
predicted to lack unknown-flag rejection, 4 measured. `drift` and `fix` already
reject them, via a construct the grep did not recognise — a grep matches an
implementation, the invariant is a behaviour. The sweep was rewritten to run each
CLI with a bogus flag and read the exit code.
Suite 1453 → 1469/0. Frozen snapshots untouched. `optimize-lens-cli` and
`token-hotspots-cli` share the unknown-flag defect and are deferred to the v5.14
argument-handling chunk with their positional-swallow arm; the count is recorded
in the guard rather than rounded down to zero.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_012NHWjN8EnoxSqRvMTLK2NE
process.exit() terminates immediately, but Node writes stdout asynchronously
when stdout is a pipe — everything still buffered is dropped. scan-orchestrator
measured 246 854 bytes to a file against 65 536 to a pipe (131 072 on another
run; the cut point is a flush race), so every machine consumer that pipes the
envelope got truncated, unparseable JSON. The failure reads like a corrupt file,
not like a cut-off, which is what made it survive this long. Reported by
org-ops, whose census pipes our output.
Closes the class rather than the one CLI where it was visible. campaign-cli,
campaign-export-cli, campaign-write-cli, knowledge-refresh-cli, drift-cli and
fix-cli all exited the same way on their success paths and were green only
because their payloads fit the pipe buffer today; size is not correctness. All
38 sites across 14 files now set process.exitCode and return, which is the
pattern self-audit.mjs already used.
Two contracts needed care rather than substitution: fail() is a never-returns
guard at ~25 call sites, so it throws a CliUsageError the top-level catch
renders with the identical "Error: " prefix and exit code 3; the path guards
needed an explicit return so main() stops instead of running on. Exit codes and
stderr text are unchanged, and the frozen v5.0.0 snapshots are untouched.
The class sweep is landed as a test, not as fourteen edits — it caught one site
this commit had missed. Suite 1443/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01B8sS1DuDV6bUJcyumLwbvj
Stale ~/.claude/plugins/cache versions polluted token-hotspots ranking and
inflated CNF duplicate-hook findings with config that loads on zero turns.
installPaths point INTO the cache, so a blunt "skip all of plugins/cache"
would drop ACTIVE plugins — the filter is therefore version-aware: it reads
the adjacent installed_plugins.json, keeps active version dirs, drops only
stale ones (and exposes them via discovery.staleCacheVersions for B3b).
- file-discovery: cacheVersionKey() + applyCacheFilter() (active vs stale via
installed_plugins.json; HOME-independent, derives the manifest from the cache
path); discoverConfigFiles/Multi gain { excludeCache } + staleCacheVersions.
Absent/unparseable manifest -> no filtering (never silently drop live config).
- token-hotspots-cli + scan-orchestrator: --exclude-cache (default ON for these
live-cost scans) / --no-exclude-cache restores the full walk.
- Tests: cacheVersionKey unit cases; stale-dropped/active-kept/no-manifest
discovery cases; CNF-drop proof (soft-spot verified, not assumed:
include=1 -> exclude=0 duplicate-hook findings).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fase 4 token-opt, Item 1 of gap-review NEXT STEP #2. The prompt-cache pattern corpus + TOK scanner were frozen at an "Opus 4.7" framing after CC shipped Opus 4.8 (default, 2.1.154) and Fable 5 (2.1.170). Model-era facts re-verified against the official changelog cache before editing.
The patterns are properties of prompt-caching, not of any model, so mechanic text is now model-neutral with a single "current default: Opus 4.8" anchor — preventing a re-freeze at the next model bump.
- rename knowledge/opus-4.7-patterns.md -> prompt-cache-patterns.md (git mv, history preserved); 6 reference sites updated
- TOK scanner: line-318 finding text (human-facing) made model-neutral; header + cache-prefix-scanner + CLI comments refreshed
- configuration-best-practices.md body + footnote 4.7 -> 4.8
- human-facing docs: commands/{tokens,help,manifest}.md, project CLAUDE.md, README, docs/scanner-internals.md
- gap-matrix row marked DONE; future Items 2/3 retargeted to new filename
Failing-test-first (Iron Law): +2 knowledge staleness guards (era-anchor + no-refreeze) +1 scanner assertion (no stale model anchor in finding text). Suite 853 -> 856 green; zero snapshot drift; self-audit A(97) PASS. CHANGELOG / v5 plan / ratified gap-plan keep historical opus-4.7-patterns refs (correct record of past state).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
Adds --raw flag to all 6 remaining CLIs and wires humanization into the
default rendering path. --json and --raw both bypass humanization for
v5.0.0 byte-equal output; default mode humanizes findings/diff/prose.
token-hotspots-cli: humanizes payload.findings before stdout JSON write.
plugin-health-scanner: humanizes finding titles in stderr brief summary;
--json/--raw write byte-identical v5.0.0-shape result to stdout.
drift-cli: humanizes diff.{newFindings,resolvedFindings,unchangedFindings,
movedFindings} before formatDiffReport; --raw applies to save and list
modes too. Baselines remain raw v5.0.0 on disk.
fix-cli: humanizes manual-finding titles in stderr fix-plan prose; both
--json and --raw produce identical machine-readable JSON to stdout.
manifest, whats-active: --raw is a no-op (no findings, inventory only)
but parsed for CLI surface consistency.
Decision on missing --output-file flag for drift-cli/fix-cli/plugin-health:
deferred. SC-6/SC-7 tests in Wave 4 will use stdout-redirect (the simpler
Alt B path) since these CLIs already write JSON to stdout in machine modes.
Test cli-humanizer.test.mjs covers all 6 CLIs. Three CLIs that read
environment state (plugin-health, manifest, whats-active) verify
mode-equivalence (--json == --raw) instead of frozen-snapshot byte-equal,
because their output reflects current marketplace state which drifts as
plugins are added since the Wave 0 capture.
Wave 3 / Step 7 of v5.1.0 humanizer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
