BREAKING CHANGE: the {NNN} in CA-{SCANNER}-{NNN} identifies the check that
produced the finding. It used to be the finding's position in that scanner's
output for that run, which made it unstable across CONFIGURATIONS, not just
across releases as STATE framed it. Measured on two fixtures: "No custom
subagents" was CA-GAP-007 on minimal-project and CA-GAP-004 on healthy-project.
A user who fixed an unrelated earlier gap silently renumbered every later one,
so a .config-audit-ignore pin retargeted to a neighbouring finding with no
version change at all.
Second measured arm: README already documented the opposite scheme. It and the
scanner headers describe ~20 numbers as check codes (CA-SKL-003 = oversized
body, CA-PLH-015 = folder shadowing, CA-TOK-006 = schema deferral), and the
counter could only produce those in the all-fire case -- source-order positions
are 4, 3 and 8. The documentation described the scheme; the implementation was
what was wrong. Every published number is preserved by construction and pinned
exhaustively in tests/lib/finding-codes.test.mjs.
scanners/lib/finding-codes.mjs is the single authority. Every finding() call
passes a `code`; an undeclared or missing one THROWS. No counter fallback --
that would reproduce D1's findGapId -> 'unknown' silent degradation and let a
half-converted scanner ship IDs that look valid. findingCounter/resetCounter
are deleted outright, not left as no-ops. Retirement is now a mechanism:
RETIRED_CODES tombstones a withdrawn key so its number is never reissued,
seeded with GAP t3_8 -- the D1 removal that opened this chunk.
IDs are consequently NOT unique per finding: one check failing in three files
emits three findings sharing an ID. That inverts which consumer is correct, so
every f.id/findingId site was classified before the change. diff-engine and
most of fix-engine already keyed on scanner+title+file (drift was never lying);
fix-engine's verification did not, and keyed on the ID alone -- fixing one of
two sibling instances marked both fixed, and the untouched one, still present
in the re-scan, was reported as a REGRESSION. Red test first, then keyed on
(findingId, file), which both planFixes and applyFixes already carry.
plugin-health's crossIds Set was measured and is a clean negative: cross
findings are allFindings.slice(crossPluginStart) and codes 18/19 are emitted
only in that tail, so the partition holds by construction.
unknownSuppressions() reports a pin that names no declared check, in the
--output-file payload (ux-rules rule 2 -- a stderr-only warning is invisible to
the commands) and only when one exists, so a clean config is byte-identical.
That is what makes the break safe: a stale pin goes loud instead of dying quiet.
Frozen tests/snapshots/v5.0.0/ untouched on disk. IDs are masked out of that
comparison (mask-finding-ids.mjs) rather than re-derived -- re-deriving
positional IDs would assert the retired scheme against itself, and #58's
isGapEntry off-by-one is the measured example of that misfiring. The dead
re-derivation is removed from strip-retired-gap.mjs. default-output snapshots
re-approved after confirming the diff is IDs and nothing else.
Guards, each seen red against its own defect: a missing code (scanner errors
out mid-sweep), an orphan declaration, a resurrected retired key, and a
documented ID naming no check. The sweep asserts the union across all 16
scanners, never per scanner -- a per-scanner assertion goes green on a partial
conversion.
Fasit written before implementation: docs/mbug28-id-semantics-fasit.local.md,
including one correction made before running (CML has 12 checks over 13 call
sites -- the anchored and calibrated char-budget arms are one check, which a
repeated-title sweep found and my call-site count had missed).
Suite 1535 -> 1573, 0 failing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MyqCQKK2ornJ1jFWwqx17E
CC 2.1.226's /doctor Check 8 covers auto mode with usage-weighted judgement.
The binding positioning forbids carrying a feature whose whole value is
duplicating a /doctor check, so the "adopt this feature" nudge goes. The
deterministic side stays: SET still validates autoMode structure and still
flags it as dead config in shared project settings. GAP dimensions 25 -> 24.
The title lived in FOUR tables, not the two the removal was scoped against:
the dimension list, scoring TITLE_TO_ID, the humanizer's static translations,
and the scoring denominators (TIER_COUNTS t3 8->7, TOTAL_DIMENSIONS 25->24,
MAX_WEIGHTED 42->41) -- the one that moves a user-visible number. findGapId
falls back to 'unknown' silently, so a partial removal would have degraded
without failing. A blanket sync invariant now asserts all four against
GAP_CHECKS instead of comparing occurrences pairwise; each arm was verified
red against its own defect (denominator drift, orphaned humanizer entry,
resurrected dimension).
Frozen tests/snapshots/v5.0.0/ stays untouched. strip-retired-gap.mjs is the
removal twin of strip-added-scanner.mjs: it strips the retired dimension from
whichever side still carries it and re-derives GAP IDs, since retiring a
dimension from mid-list shifts every later ID by one. Derived utilization
figures are dropped from comparison rather than recomputed -- recomputing them
in a test helper would assert the new arithmetic against itself, and
scoring.test.mjs already pins them exactly. Re-seeding was rejected: it would
silently bake in any other drift across every scanner those four files cover.
risk_score, risk_band, verdict, overallGrade, maturity and segment are
byte-identical across the change (severity info carries zero risk weight; GAP
is excluded from the overall grade). Utilization shifts 43 -> 44 on the fixture.
D2 (CA-SKL-002) is NOT removed. Verified against the primary source first: the
CC changelog carries exactly one budget-fraction statement (L3786, 2.1.32) and
nothing supersedes it, so our 2% is current and 002 is not a duplicate with a
stale figure. /doctor's ~1% could not be reconciled from the changelog and it
discloses its own numbers as disk estimates, so it is recorded, not adopted.
Left explicitly unverified in a code note: L3786 says "character budget" while
we express tokens -- a 4x difference nobody can settle from the wording.
Suite 1531 -> 1535, all green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01RsfPGxgwbR3MY54wDC6hat
The t2_3 ("No path-scoped rules") and t3_6 ("No subagent isolation")
feature-gap checks iterate a collection (rule files / agent files) and return
false for an EMPTY one — so they fire even when the user has zero rules / zero
subagents, the same state their presence-gap siblings flag. But the humanized
titles presupposed the feature already exists:
- "Your rules all load on every conversation" (with zero rules)
- "Your subagents share Claude's main work folder" (with zero subagents)
The second directly contradicts GAP-005 "You haven't set up any specialized
helper agents yet" in the same report — a user cannot simultaneously have no
subagents and have subagents that lack isolation. Found by dogfooding the
analyze pipeline against linkedin-posts (premise-verifying each finding before
trusting the analyzer-agent's report).
Decided fix = align the two titles with the house "You haven't set up X yet"
absence framing (state-neutral: honest for both the zero-state and the
has-but-unconfigured state), NOT a base-feature presence gate in the scanner —
that would change the frozen v5.0.0 marketplace-medium baseline (zero
rules/agents, freezes these gaps firing) and break the RAW byte contract.
Mirrors M-BUG-14's humanizer-layer, copy-only approach.
- humanizer-data.mjs: title "Your rules all load on every conversation" ->
"You haven't set up path-scoped rules yet"; title "Your subagents share
Claude's main work folder" -> "You haven't set up subagent isolation yet".
description + recommendation unchanged. t3_5/t3_7 ("Your skills don't ...")
left as-is: their possessive is correct in the common case where skills
exist; the zero-skills edge is latent, not manifest here.
- RED-first unit test pins both titles existence-neutral (forbids "your rules
all load" / "your subagents"; feature still named).
Frozen v5.0.0 snapshots untouched (RAW bypasses humanizer); default-output
snapshot regenerated (2 titles only, no collateral). Verified on linkedin-posts:
GAP-004/005/011 now all consistently absence-framed. Suite 1356->1357/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01683eAqVecv9VZfQzL8CQ9h
New AGT scanner flags the aggregate always-loaded cost of the agent listing
(every active agent's name+description is injected each turn so the model
knows what it can delegate to). Mirrors the SKL skill-listing pattern but
encodes the key honesty caveat: the agent-listing mechanism is INFERRED
(agents are absent from Claude Code's documented context breakdown), so the
token figure is an UPPER-BOUND estimate and the aggregate budget is a
config-audit heuristic anchored on 200k — not a CC-documented allotment.
- scanners/agent-listing-scanner.mjs + scanners/lib/agent-listing-budget.mjs
- 8 TDD tests (tests/scanners/agent-listing-scanner.test.mjs)
- AGT folds into the Token Efficiency health area (scoring.mjs)
- byte-stability: AGT added to strip-added-scanner (frozen v5.0.0 baselines
left untouched, same as OST/OPT); SC-5 default-output snapshot refreshed
- suite 1168 -> 1176 green
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
First detector of the 'is the config OPTIMAL?' axis (vs the existing 'correct?' scanners). New orchestrated scanner family CA-OPT (count 14->15), the deterministic half of the hybrid optimization lens.
CA-OPT-001 (low, Missed opportunity): a multi-step procedure in CLAUDE.md (>=6 consecutive numbered steps) that belongs in a skill. Reads recommendation + provenance from the best-practices register (BP-MECH-003). Conservative by design; the negative corpus proves null false-positives. Prose-judgment cases (lifecycle->hook, 'never'->permission) are deferred to the Chunk 2b opus analyzer.
Wiring mirrors OST: orchestrator entry, humanizer (OPT->'Missed opportunity' + family), scoring (OPT->'CLAUDE.md', existing area -> no new posture row -> byte-stable), strip-helper (OST,OPT), SC-5 regenerated under hermetic HOME (additive OPT entry only). 10 new tests; suite 1045->1055, self-audit A/A, readmeCheck passed (all verified with a clean HOME).
Note: the pre-existing TOK test reads the real ~/.claude (non-hermetic) -> run the suite with a clean HOME for deterministic results. Tracked as a separate follow-up.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
New orchestrated scanner output-style-scanner.mjs — first new family since
SKL. Three findings, each pinned to a CONFIRMED V-row of the steering-model
plan + re-verified against code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles:
- CA-OST-001 (medium, V10): user/project custom style missing
keep-coding-instructions:true (default false) → silently strips built-in
software-engineering instructions when active. Scoped to user/project.
- CA-OST-002 (low, V11): plugin style with force-for-plugin:true overrides the
user's selected outputStyle. Verifiseringsplikt correction — the plan bullet
said "project/user style," but force-for-plugin is plugin-styles-only per the
docs, so the check keys on source==='plugin'.
- CA-OST-003 (medium): settings outputStyle matching no built-in
(Default/Explanatory/Learning/Proactive, case-insensitive) nor discovered
custom style → dead config.
Byte-stability — a scanner addition, not a field addition. Growing the
scanners array + scanners_ok cannot be hidden by a field strip, but re-seeding
frozen v5.0.0 (the SKL precedent) would now bake in B2's hotspot triple +
claudeMd drift. So, per the B2 lesson, frozen v5.0.0 snapshots are PRESERVED
and the OST entry is stripped at compare time via new
tests/helpers/strip-added-scanner.mjs (wired into json/raw-backcompat + the
Step 5/6 humanizer tests); only SC-5 default-output is regenerated (additive
OST entry, diff reviewed). OST is fixture-gated (no output styles on
marketplace-medium / hermetic HOME → silent).
Wiring: orchestrator; humanizer (OST→Configuration mistake) + humanizer-data
OST family (title-coupled); scoring (OST→Settings, keeps 10 areas). Suite
1012→1023 (+11). Badges: scanners 14, tests 1023, TRANSLATIONS families 15.
Lore swept: README, CLAUDE.md, scanner-internals, humanizer.md. self-audit A/A.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Annotate every ranked TOK hotspot with the load-pattern triple
(loadPattern/survivesCompaction/derivationConfidence):
- hotspotLoadPattern() maps each discovery `type` → a deriveLoadPattern kind.
Rules reuse activeConfig.rules for precise `scoped` handling; claude-md maps
by scope. Two new deriveLoadPattern kinds back the rest: `command`
(on-demand — body loads on /invoke) and `harness-config` (external —
settings/keybindings/.mcp.json/hooks.json/plugin.json configure the CLI, not
the model context, so they cost no per-turn context tokens). Honest split:
the .mcp.json FILE is external; the MCP server's tool schemas are a separate
`always` hotspot.
Byte-stability — the opposite of B1's manifest. token-hotspots IS a byte-equal
SC-6/SC-7 CLI, and its hotspots ride inside scan-orchestrator + posture, so the
change touched SIX frozen-v5.0.0 comparisons across five test files. Resolved by
preserving the frozen baselines: a shared tests/helpers/strip-hotspot-load-pattern.mjs
strips the additive triple before each byte-equal compare (proves the original
schema is byte-identical). SC-5 default-output snapshots (scan-orchestrator +
token-hotspots) regenerated — diff reviewed as additive-only.
Tests 1008→1012. Self-audit A/A, scanner count unchanged at 13 (C bumps to 14).
Completes v5.6 B (B1 manifest + B2 token-hotspots).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fase 4 Items 2+3 (CC 2.1.114→181 gap-review). New orchestrated scanner
`skill-listing-scanner.mjs` (prefix SKL) flags every active skill whose
description exceeds the verified 1,536-char listing cap (CC 2.1.105, changelog
L1502). Past the cap, Claude Code silently truncates the description the model
reads to route skill invocation — dropping the trigger phrases at the tail.
HOME-scoped over all user + plugin skills via enumerateSkills (COL is the model).
- CA-SKL-001 (medium): description > 1,536 chars. Remediation folds in Item
2(b) — recommends disableBundledSkills + skillOverrides + trimming
(designvalg A: no standalone GAP-check, which would fire for nearly everyone).
- Designvalg B: v1 ships the verified cap ONLY. The aggregate 2%-of-context
listing budget is deferred — it needs a context-window assumption that would
turn a verified fact into a guess (would carry a CALIBRATION_NOTE if added).
- Choice C: recognize the skillOverrides settings key (CC 2.1.129) in
KNOWN_KEYS. Left OUT of TYPE_CHECKS — the value is a per-skill object
(off/user-invocable-only/name-only), not a string; a 'string' check (as the
plan sketched) would create a NEW false positive. Verify-first deviation.
Registration: scan-orchestrator (13th scanner), humanizer (SKL → 'Wasted
tokens' + static/_default translations), scoring SCANNER_AREA_MAP (→ Token
Efficiency; no 11th area), README badge 12→13, CLAUDE.md (finding-id +
test-count), docs/scanner-internals.md, gap-matrix + plan status notes.
Snapshots reseeded hermetically (SEED_SNAPSHOT/UPDATE_SNAPSHOT): SKL entry with
0 findings in empty HOME, scanners_ok 11→12, claudeMdEstimatedTokens bump from
the CLAUDE.md edits flowing through the cascade. Contamination grep clean.
Suite 868/868 (856 baseline + 11 SKL + 1 skillOverrides). RED→GREEN logged
per cycle.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
`.mcp.json` has no per-server `trust` key — verified 2026-06-18 against
code.claude.com/docs/en/mcp + /settings. MCP server approval is
dialog/settings-based (enableAllProjectMcpServers / enabledMcpjsonServers /
disabledMcpjsonServers), never a JSON field. The scanner's "Missing trust
level" (CA-MCP-001, medium) and "Invalid trust level" (high) were false
positives flagging a field that does not exist.
- scanner: delete both trust checks + VALID_TRUST_LEVELS; drop `trust` from
VALID_SERVER_FIELDS so a stray `trust` is now flagged as an unknown field
- humanizer: remove the two trust-level entries
- knowledge (5 files): point to the real approval mechanism, not a trust field
- fixtures: scrub `trust` (incl. the invalid "local" in optimal-setup)
- tests: flip assertions (no trust-level finding; stray trust -> unknown
field) + add knowledge-staleness re-freeze guards
- snapshots: reseed (marketplace-medium .mcp.json -8 tokens, hermetic)
- gap-matrix: mark the trust verify-first item DONE
Suite: 853/853 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ter3E2JSi1Khgmuf2kady8
The DIS scanner collapsed Tool(param) rules to the bare tool name, so
Agent(model:opus) deny + Agent(model:sonnet) allow (and the same for
WebFetch(domain:...)) were flagged as dead config — a false positive now
that CC 2.1.178 matches Tool(param:value) and 2.1.172 adds domain rules.
The conflict-detector shared the blind spot from the other side: a
wildcard deny like WebFetch(domain:*) did not cover a
WebFetch(domain:good.com) allow, so a genuine cross-scope conflict was
missed (false negative).
New shared scanners/lib/permission-rules.mjs:
- parseRule / paramMatches (glob)
- dominates(deny, allow) -> DIS dead-allow (deny fully covers allow)
- rulesIntersect(a, b) -> CNF cross-scope conflict (match sets intersect)
DIS now delegates to dominates; conflict-detector :156 delegates to
rulesIntersect. A bare deny still covers all params, so true positives
are preserved (Bash deny + Bash(npm:*) allow still flagged).
Re-seeded the marketplace-medium snapshots: the false-positive CA-DIS
finding (Read(src/**) allow + Read(./.env) deny) is correctly gone. This
changes snapshot CONTENT only — envelope schema is unchanged, so --json
and --raw stay byte-stable.
Full suite: 837/837 green (+25). self-audit PASS, A(100)/A(97).
The COL collision-scanner and the CLAUDE.md cascade resolve ~/.claude from
process.env.HOME (active-config-reader). Snapshot/byte CLIs were spawned with
the developer's real HOME, so they picked up installed plugins/skills and the
user CLAUDE.md — making the v5.0.0 + default-output snapshots machine- and
time-dependent. They were seeded 2026-05-01 with COL=1 (a real ~/.claude skill
collision) and drifted to COL=0 after the polyrepo split: 26 pre-existing
failures unrelated to Batch 1.
Fix (test-only, no production change):
- tests/helpers/hermetic-home.mjs — empty temp HOME, mirroring the pattern
collision.test.mjs already uses for the COL unit test.
- 7 harnesses spawn CLIs (or call lint()) under the hermetic HOME, so output
depends only on committed fixtures. Determinism verified across runs.
- Re-seeded all snapshots under hermetic HOME via SEED_SNAPSHOT/UPDATE_SNAPSHOT
(added a SEED guard to the frozen v5.0.0 byte tests). Snapshots now reflect
the fixture alone (COL=0, fixture-only activeConfig counts).
- Also re-seeded the unused env-aware snapshots (manifest/whats-active/
plugin-health), which had baked dozens of real ~/.claude skill/plugin names
into the committed repo — privacy cleanup.
Full suite: 812/812 green, stable across 3 runs.
- Plugin README: add "What's New in v5.1.0" section with humanizer overview,
before/after example, plain-language vocabulary table, --raw flag docs.
Bump version badge 5.0.0 → 5.1.0. Add Version History row.
- Plugin CLAUDE.md: add humanizer.mjs + humanizer-data.mjs to Scanner Lib
table. Add "Plain-Language Output (v5.1.0)" section documenting output
modes, vocabularies, and Wave 5 lessons. Bump test count 635 → 792 across
52 test files.
- Marketplace root README: bump config-audit entry 5.0.0 → 5.1.0, update
one-line description to mention plain-language UX, add bullet for the
v5.1.0 humanizer, bump test count 635+ → 792+.
Test-normalizer hardening (consequence of growing CLAUDE.md):
walkClaudeMdCascade walks upward from the marketplace-medium fixture into
this plugin's own CLAUDE.md, so any docs edit ripples into
`scanners[*].activeConfig.claudeMdEstimatedTokens`. The v5.0.0 byte-stability
contract is about scanner internals being unchanged, not ancestor input
content being frozen. Normalizers in json-backcompat, raw-backcompat,
posture-humanizer, scan-orchestrator-humanizer, and snapshot-default-output
now strip claudeMdEstimatedTokens to <ANCESTOR_DERIVED>. The
default-output snapshot for scan-orchestrator was re-seeded via
UPDATE_SNAPSHOT=1 (intent: Wave 6 docs additions; humanizer prose
unchanged).
Verify:
- grep -E "5\.1\.0|v5\.1\.0" README.md CLAUDE.md ../../README.md | wc -l = 12
- node --test 'tests/**/*.test.mjs' = 792/792 pass
- self-audit configGrade A (97), pluginGrade A (100), readmeCheck.passed true
Step 12 of v5.1.0 humanizer Wave 4. Adds tests/snapshot-default-output
.test.mjs and seeds three snapshots in tests/snapshots/default-output/
that capture humanized default-mode output for representative CLIs.
Coverage:
- scan-orchestrator: stdout JSON envelope (humanized findings); time
fields normalized.
- token-hotspots-cli: stdout JSON envelope (humanized payload.findings);
duration_ms normalized.
- posture: stderr humanized scorecard; (Xms) durations normalized.
Snapshot envelope is uniform on disk: { kind: 'json', payload: ... }
for JSON streams and { kind: 'text', payload: '...' } for stderr text.
This keeps the snapshot files self-describing and easy to read.
Re-seeding requires UPDATE_SNAPSHOT=1 — drift fails the test by design,
so any humanizer prose change is intentional and re-approved.
Tests: 764 to 767 (+3 SC-5 cases). Full suite passes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wave 0 / Step 0 of the v5.1.0 plain-language UX humanizer plan.
Captures v5.0.0 baseline output for all 8 CLIs at
tests/snapshots/v5.0.0/ — these snapshots are immutable references
for SC-6 (--json byte-equal) and SC-7 (--raw byte-equal) tests in
later waves.
- 5 CLIs captured via --output-file: scan-orchestrator, posture,
token-hotspots-cli, manifest, whats-active
- 3 CLIs captured via stdout redirect (no --output-file support):
drift-cli (after baseline seed), fix-cli, plugin-health-scanner
- Posture stderr scorecard captured separately for SC-7 stderr-mode
comparison
docs/v5.1.0-test-audit.md classifies all 42 .title references in
7 known test files: 34 will break under humanization (literal
string equality / substring), 8 are safe (test fixtures or error
formatting). This document is the change list for Step 4.
Project: .claude/projects/2026-05-01-config-audit-ux-redesign/
