Kjell Tore Guttormsen
8d2968a482
Wave 3 / Step 9 of the remediation plan (Phase 1 — usable by a non-author).
The long-form review layer shipped Norwegian-locked: language-reviewer graded
unconditional Norwegian, voice-scrubber's gold standard was 'approved Norwegian
editions', and the editorial/content craft gates pointed at a 'skrivekontrakt §C2'
that does not ship. A non-Norwegian adopter would get English prose graded against
Norwegian idiom and a gate that depends on an unshipped contract.
- config/edition-state.template.json: add additive 'language' field (top-level,
default 'en') + a _doc entry. Threads into the language-dependent agents.
- agents/language-reviewer.md: new 'Language parameter' section — Norwegian-specific
checks (anglicism->Norwegian idiom, kanselli-stil) apply only when language=='no';
any other value grades that language's equivalents and never flags idiomatic
English as an anglicism. Default 'en'.
- agents/voice-scrubber.md: gold standard reframed to 'approved editions in the
configured language'; the Norwegian-chronicle calibration is the language=='no'
instantiation.
- agents/editorial-reviewer.md + agents/content-reviewer.md: the in-tree checklist
is now the operative, self-contained source of truth; Maskinrommet §C2 is an
optional upstream contract that does NOT ship (available only on the author's
runs). The gates work for an adopter without it.
- commands/newsletter.md: thread 'language' through the Step 6.5 cold-inputs and the
per-reviewer call inputs; the writing contract is now 'if it ships'.
Norwegian remains fully working when language: no (the author's case).
fact-reviewer.md was in the plan's file list but needed no change on inspection:
its F1-F4 checks (claims/quotes/numbers/sources) are language-agnostic; its
'Norwegian' mentions are boundary notes vs language-reviewer, which stay correct.
[skip-docs]: three-doc + version reconciliation is Step 21 (pre-review-gate); these
intermediate Wave commits are not pushed before the /trekreview gate.
Verify: edition-state JSON parses + has top-level language 'en'; language-reviewer
has 'language ==' references and no unconditional-Norwegian assertion; editorial
§C2 reframed to in-tree fallback ('operative source', 'does not ship'); agent
fixtures 35/35 pass; structural lint exit 0 (61 passed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
87 lines
11 KiB
JSON
87 lines
11 KiB
JSON
{
|
||
"_doc": {
|
||
"purpose": "Schema for edition-state.json — deterministic resumption state for a newsletter edition in production. Holds the current phase + per-article status so /linkedin:newsletter (Step 0) can resume exactly where a prior session stopped.",
|
||
"decision": "G — production state lives in the series folder (e.g. $LTL_SERIES_ROOT/<slug>/linkedin/edition-state.json, default $HOME/linkedin-series/<slug>/...), NOT in the plugin. This file is the schema-defining TEMPLATE only; copy + fill it in the series folder when producing an edition.",
|
||
"complements": "edition-config.json (static: calendar, freshness, captions) and <serie>/STATE.md (human-readable narrative state, overwritten each phase per the ONE-system continuity rule — there is no edition-HANDOVER.md). edition-state.json is the machine-readable companion: deterministic resumption + the durable fact-check log, immutable rules, and persona verdicts that the old HANDOVER §4/§5 used to carry.",
|
||
"lifecycle": "/linkedin:newsletter reads this in Step 0 and rewrites it at every phase transition. Article keys mirror edition-config.json (zero-padded strings: \"01\", \"02\", ..., or \"samle\").",
|
||
"phases": [
|
||
"load-context — read <serie>/STATE.md, voice profile, persona library, series brief (Step 0)",
|
||
"brief-calibration — angle, voice, audience personas, key points, leader-takeaway (Step 1)",
|
||
"research — parallel scoped mandates → verified notes, triangulation (Step 2)",
|
||
"skeleton-pitch — five-line skeleton (premise/problem/recommendation/payoff/forward) + section pitches, operator gate + persona-skjelett-sweep BEFORE prose (Step 2.5)",
|
||
"spine-prose — one paragraph per section against the gated skeleton, operator gate BEFORE full expansion (Step 3a)",
|
||
"draft — full prose expansion against the gated spine; may span sessions (Step 3b)",
|
||
"consistency-quality — threads, premise→conclusion arc, AI-slop removal, formatting dose (Step 4)",
|
||
"factcheck-sweep — risk-sorted, guilty-until-disproven, verification log (Step 5)",
|
||
"editorial-review — editor's craft gate: prose-craft (em-dash density, verbatim repetition, postulated numbers, contradictions, versal-tic) + narrative-architecture (concrete instantiation, theory-anchored hypotheses, series-title symmetry, equal action per addressee, un-overloaded conclusion), ≤10 flags BLOCK/REWORK/NICE, operator-gated via SendUserFile BEFORE the persona sweep (Step 5.5)",
|
||
"persona-sweep-prelock — reader jury, primary wins, convergence to clean YES (Step 6)",
|
||
"headless-review — adversarial review package run COLD on a FROZEN draft (no drafting-session context): content-reviewer (argument integrity) + language-reviewer (Norwegian language) + fact-reviewer (cold re-verification incl. pivot premises) + persona-reviewer in resonance & conversion modes. Fan-out from Step 6.5 or the standalone /linkedin:headless-review command; consolidated report operator-gated via SendUserFile BEFORE lock (Step 6.5)",
|
||
"annotation — optional annotatable review HTML for a manual pass (Step 7)",
|
||
"visual-assets — cover (+ optional inline figures) or carousel deck: brief → generate → operator-gate → approve, BEFORE lock so build-linkedin.mjs picks them up (Step 7.5)",
|
||
"lock-delivery — LOCK → POST.html all-in-one-place deliverable (Step 8)",
|
||
"hook-conversion-gate — persona gate on distribution text post-lock: would YOU click? (Step 9)",
|
||
"scheduling — register edition in plugin queue/state for native LinkedIn scheduling (Step 10)"
|
||
],
|
||
"articleStatusValues": ["pending", "in-progress", "locked", "scheduled"],
|
||
"editorialReview": "Per-article editorial-review record written by Step 5.5 (editorial-review phase). Runs AFTER fact-check (Step 5) and BEFORE the persona sweep (Step 6): the editorial-reviewer agent judges CRAFT (prose-craft + narrative-architecture), not reader-response, mirroring the Maskinrommet skrivekontrakt §C2. The report (≤10 flags, each with kategori P1–P5/A1–A5, quote/line-ref, direction, severity BLOCK/REWORK/NICE) is surfaced to the operator via SendUserFile; the operator decides which flags fold in. Shape: { reportPath, flagCount, byAxis: { prosa, arkitektur }, bySeverity: { block, rework, nice }, foldedIn, waived, status }. status ladder: pending → reviewed → folded. null until Step 5.5 runs. This is the craft companion to factcheckLog (truth) and personaSweep (response).",
|
||
"visualAssets": "Per-article visual-asset record written by Step 7.5 (visual-assets phase). Runs BEFORE lock because render/build-linkedin.mjs picks up linkedin/NN/cover.png + the edition-config credit/caption when it builds POST.html — generating images after lock would force a re-render. Shape: { format: \"standard\" | \"carousel\"; cover: { brief, route, candidates[], approved, status }; figures: [ { id, brief, placement, status } ]; carousel: null | { source, pdf, status } }. format \"standard\" = cover + optional inline figures (cover.png is mandatory per the KTG cover-directive); format \"carousel\" = typografisk deck via render/build-carousel.mjs instead of cover+inline (cover/figures stay empty). route: \"mcp-image\" (default, via mcp__mcp-image__generate_image) | \"external\" (DALL·E / Midjourney / photographer → linkedin/NN/cover-raw.png). status ladder: pending → briefed → generated → approved. candidates[] holds the cover-v<N>-kandidat.png attempts; approved is the fixed approved name (\"cover.png\") once the operator-gate passes. figures[].id = \"fig1\"..; placement = section reference in NN-utkast.md (figures are referenced in the draft via  and uploaded manually in the LinkedIn editor — build-linkedin.mjs does NOT embed them). Naming convention: cover.png (approved, fixed — what build-linkedin.mjs reads) | cover-v<N>-kandidat.png (attempts) | cover-raw.png (optional external pre-edit source) | fig<N>.png (inline). credit + caption are recorded in <serie>/linkedin/image-credit-caption.md and flow into edition-config.json coverCredit + captions[NN].",
|
||
"personas": "Per-article resolved reader-persona set (input config), written/confirmed in Step 1. This makes personas configurable PER ARTIFACT, not just from one global plugin library: Step 1 resolves them in order — (1) already present here → use as-is; (2) <serie>/linkedin/personas.md (per-series file) → load; (3) plugin config/personas.local.md (or personas.template.md) library → select a subset; (4) none/insufficient → DEFINE interactively via AskUserQuestion. Exactly one entry has tier \"primær\" (the rest \"sekundær\"); «primær trumfer» on conflict. This set feeds BOTH the in-session sweep (Step 6) and the headless package (Step 6.5 / persona-reviewer). Each entry: { name, tier: \"primær\" | \"sekundær\", rolle, avkobler, overbeviser, ekspertise, sjargong, source: \"edition-state\" | \"series-file\" | \"plugin-library\" | \"interactive\" }. Default []: resolved on first Step 1.",
|
||
"headlessReview": "Per-article headless-review record written by Step 6.5 (headless-review phase). Runs AFTER the in-session persona sweep (Step 6) and BEFORE lock (Step 8), on a FROZEN snapshot of the publish-ready (or pivoted) draft, fanned out from the command layer (foreground) or invoked standalone via /linkedin:headless-review in a fresh/cold session. Five archetypes judge independently with NO drafting-session context: content-reviewer (argument integrity), language-reviewer (Norwegian language), fact-reviewer (cold re-verification incl. claims a late pivot bolted on), persona-reviewer mode=resonans (per active persona), persona-reviewer mode=konverter (primær, hook only). The consolidated report is surfaced to the operator via SendUserFile; the operator decides which flags fold in. Shape: { frozenDraft, reviewers: { content, language, fact, personaResonance, personaConversion } (each { reportPath, summary, status }), consolidatedReport, foldedIn, waived, status }. status ladder: pending → run → folded. null until Step 6.5 runs. This is the adversarial-independence companion to the in-session gates (editorialReview, personaSweep, factcheckLog) — deliberately redundant: a cold reader catches what the framing-biased in-session pass missed.",
|
||
"pivots": "Per-article pivot log (Endring 9c). A pivot is a substantive change to a draft AFTER a gate had already cleared — e.g. a new argument anchor / section added late (the Del 4 Security Champions case: +~530 words, 2 new sections, +42 %). Each /linkedin:pivot invocation appends one entry and moves currentPhase back so the cleared gates (Steps 5–6.5) re-run on the pivoted version before lock. Heuristic (documented, checked at the Step 8 lock precondition): if the current draft's word count differs > 20 % from the version that last cleared Step 6, OR it has > 2 new sections, a pivot-reopen is suggested/required. Each entry: { timestamp, reason, fromPhase, toPhase, wordCountBefore, wordCountAfter, deltaPct, newSections, gatesToRerun: [phase…] }. Default [].",
|
||
"language": "Review language for this series/edition (additive, default \"en\"). Threads into the long-form review agents so they grade against THIS language's rules: language-reviewer applies Norwegian-specific checks (anglicism→Norwegian idiom, «kanselli-stil») only when language == \"no\"; voice-scrubber's gold standard is the approved editions IN this language; any other value → the agents apply that language's equivalents and never grade prose against Norwegian idiom. \"no\" = Norwegian (the author's case). Resolved at Step 1 / load-context and passed to the language-dependent agents."
|
||
},
|
||
"schemaVersion": 1,
|
||
"series": {
|
||
"slug": "<series-slug>",
|
||
"title": "<Series title>"
|
||
},
|
||
"language": "en",
|
||
"currentArticle": "01",
|
||
"currentPhase": "load-context",
|
||
"updatedAt": "<ISO-8601 timestamp>",
|
||
"articles": {
|
||
"01": {
|
||
"title": "<Article 1 title>",
|
||
"phase": "load-context",
|
||
"status": "pending",
|
||
"personas": [],
|
||
"immutableRules": null,
|
||
"factcheckLog": null,
|
||
"editorialReview": null,
|
||
"personaSweep": {
|
||
"skeleton": null,
|
||
"resonance": null,
|
||
"conversion": null
|
||
},
|
||
"headlessReview": {
|
||
"frozenDraft": null,
|
||
"reviewers": {
|
||
"content": null,
|
||
"language": null,
|
||
"fact": null,
|
||
"personaResonance": null,
|
||
"personaConversion": null
|
||
},
|
||
"consolidatedReport": null,
|
||
"foldedIn": null,
|
||
"waived": null,
|
||
"status": "pending"
|
||
},
|
||
"visualAssets": {
|
||
"format": "standard",
|
||
"cover": {
|
||
"brief": null,
|
||
"route": null,
|
||
"candidates": [],
|
||
"approved": null,
|
||
"status": "pending"
|
||
},
|
||
"figures": [],
|
||
"carousel": null
|
||
},
|
||
"pivots": [],
|
||
"locked": false,
|
||
"scheduled": null
|
||
}
|
||
}
|
||
}
|