# Brief — SB-S3e: hygiene + triple-post reconciliation (the LAST S3 slice)

> **Slice:** SB-S3e — the focused finale of SB-S3. Carries the two coupled deliverables the S3d split deferred: **(b) retire the dead `content-history.md`** + **(c) triple-post reconciliation** (silo 1 post-tracking ↔ silo 2 brain published-records ↔ silo 3 analytics). After this slice the second-brain arc is complete (S4 EØS DMA-connector is optional).
> **Status:** DRAFT (brief + plan written; light-Voyage hardening + go-before-code gate pending).
> **Predecessors:** SB-S0 (scaffold seeds the bare tree) · SB-S1 (`ingest/published/` gold-signal records = silo 2) · SB-S3c (`assemble.ts` built the silo 2↔3 join; deliberately did NOT touch silo 1) · SB-S3d (the ops-centre reader — independent).

## 1. Operator decision context (2026-06-23)

The original S3d charter bundled three deliverables; the S3d brief (§1) found a clean fault line and **split**: (a) the ops centre shipped as S3d (additive, no silo contact); **(b) + (c) are coupled and move here, to S3e**. They are coupled because **the content-history back-fill question *is* the reconciliation question**: `content-history.md` was a *second* auto-written record of created posts, so deciding its fate (retire vs resurrect) and deciding how the auto-tracked creation stream reconciles to the brain graph are the same decision. Both touch the loose, regex-mutated post-tracking silo that S3c deliberately avoided. S3e is the deliberate, isolated finale for that surgery.

## 2. The gap — grounded in code

A "post created via the plugin" leaves **three** separate records, and they do not agree:

| # | Silo | Path / writer | Carries | Join key? |
|---|------|---------------|---------|-----------|
| **1** | **post-tracking** | `## Recent Posts` in `$HOME/.claude/linkedin-studio.local.md` — auto-written by the Stop-hook → `updatePostTracking` (`state-updater.mjs:114-126`) | `[date] "hook (≤60c preview)" (charCount) - topic` | **none** |
| **2** | **brain published-record** | `ingest/published/<contentId>.md` under the brain dataRoot — written **only** by manual `brain ingest --file …` (`cli.ts:122-138`) | `contentId`, `published_date`, `specifics[]`, `trends[]`, full `body` | `contentId` (internal) |
| **3** | **analytics** | `analytics/posts/*.json` under the brain dataRoot — from the LinkedIn CSV import | `title`, `publishedDate`, `metrics` | none (no body, no URN) |

**S3c built the silo 2↔3 join** (`assemble.ts: assemblePostGraph`) by a confidence-tiered title-prefix + date heuristic, answering the arc's north-star query *"which raw material actually performs?"* (`specifics → post → measured analytics`).

**Two gaps remain, and they are the same coin:**

- **Silo 1 is joined to nothing.** The complete *auto-captured* stream of created posts (silo 1) never meets the graph. The graph (silo 2→3) sees **only** the subset the user *manually* ran `brain ingest` on — so the "which raw material performs" payoff is **blind to every post the user created but never hand-ingested.** Verified: silo 2 has **no auto-capture** — `assemble`'s empty-state message literally instructs the user to `brain ingest --file …` manually (`cli.ts:182`); STATE lists auto-capture as the explicit *optional* S3c-bonus, i.e. it does not exist.
- **The dead `content-history.md`** is a *fourth*, genuinely-orphaned record (date/hook/topic/format/words/chars/source), written by flaky Stop-hook prose (`state-update-reminder.md:67-86`) and read by **nobody** (verified: the only `content-history` mentions in code are a `migrate-data.mjs` MOVE entry, its test, the `.gitignore`/SC2 data-class guards, and a `session-start.mjs` *comment* — zero readers). It is redundant with silo 1 (both auto-written, both unread by the graph) and resurrecting it would solve nothing the join needs. **Honesty nuance (the prose lies):** the writer prose being deleted *claims* the log "enables `/linkedin:report` and `analytics-interpreter` to track content production" (`state-update-reminder.md:85`) — but that was **never wired** (grep-verified: no command/agent reads the file; the `profile.md`/`analyze.md`/`audit.md` "content history" hits are the *conceptual* "have you posted on this topic" signal, not file reads). The claim is aspirational dead prose, which *strengthens* retirement — but it must be named so a mid-deletion reader doesn't chase a phantom reader.

## 3. Scope — what is IN (S3e)

### (b) Retire the dead `content-history.md` — clean deletion across its plumbing

Verified surfaces (grounded this session):

1. **Writer prose** — remove Section 5 "Content History Log" from `hooks/prompts/state-update-reminder.md:67-86` (the flaky generator). This is the only thing that ever wrote the file.
2. **Template** — delete `config/content-history.template.md`.
3. **Migration** — remove the B1 entry from `MOVE_FILES` in `hooks/scripts/migrate-data.mjs:33` (`['assets/analytics/content-history.md', 'analytics/content-history.md']`).
4. **Migration test** — drop the content-history fixture write (`__tests__/migrate-data.test.mjs:37`), its two assertions (`:56`, `:61`), and trim the test-(a) description (`:50`). Test **count** unchanged (5 cases a–e stay) → hook-suite total unchanged.
5. **`.gitignore:44`** — remove `assets/analytics/content-history.md`.
6. **Gate guard** — remove the `assets/analytics/content-history\.md` alternative from `SC2_CLASSES` (`test-runner.sh:592`). The SC2 check stays (one pass/fail) → **gate total unchanged**.
7. **Reference doc** — remove `content-history.md` from the data-tree diagram (`references/data-path-convention.md:26`).
8. **Comment** — drop `content-history` from the `session-start.mjs:94` comment list.

**NOT in scope of (b):** `state-updater.mjs`'s `pruneContentHistory` (despite the name, it operates on the **live `## Recent Posts`** in the state file — `:138-172` — and is untouched), and any *conceptual* "content history" prose (e.g. `README:120` `/linkedin:profile` "content-history alignment" reads as the concept, not the file — verify-then-leave; never delete a conceptual mention).

### (c) Triple-post reconciliation — read-side joiner (recommended fork)

Extend the brain's read-only assembler so silo 1 is reconciled against the graph, **without writing the state file** (faithful to S3c's "read, never write").

1. **A new pure reconcile core** (`scripts/brain/src/reconcile.ts`): `reconcileRecentPosts({ recentPosts, records, graph })` — takes the parsed silo-1 entries + the **full `PublishedRecord[]`** (which carry `body`) + the existing `PostGraphNode[]`, and returns, per silo-1 entry, whether it is present in the brain (a matched published record) and/or analytics, with an explicit confidence tier — surfacing the **coverage gap**: created posts that never reached the brain graph. **Why `records` and not graph-only:** `PostGraphNode` carries `contentId` + analytics match but **no `body`** (`assemble.ts:48-54`), so the hook→post prefix-match needs the `PublishedRecord.body`; the core matches `hook → record.body`, then `record.id → graph node` for the analytics tier. No FS/clock/network in the core (the `assemble.ts` discipline).
2. **A thin read-only state-file parser** (`parseRecentPosts(stateText)`): extract `[date] "hook" (chars) - topic` rows from the `## Recent Posts` section. The format source of truth is the **writer** `updatePostTracking` (`state-updater.mjs:116`: `- [date] "hook" (chars) - topic`) — **not** `pruneContentHistory`'s regex, which is **date-only** (`:145`, `/^- \[(\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2})\] .+$/gm`) and captures no hook/chars/topic. `parseRecentPosts` is the *first* full-field reader of this section; it shares only the date-anchor shape with the pruner. A golden-string test pins a writer-produced entry round-tripping through `parseRecentPosts`.
3. **A new brain IO seam for the state file.** Silo 1 lives at `STATE_FILE || $HOME/.claude/linkedin-studio.local.md` — **outside** the brain dataRoot (`LINKEDIN_STUDIO_DATA`). A new `loadRecentPosts()` IO resolves that path with the canonical precedence already exported as `data-root.mjs: getStateFile()` — `STATE_FILE` first, else `join(resolveHome(), '.claude', 'linkedin-studio.local.md')` where `resolveHome() = HOME || USERPROFILE || homedir()` (NOT bare `homedir()` — that would ignore a `HOME`/`USERPROFILE` override the writer honours). Reads read-only; absent → `[]` (fresh-clone safe). This is a **genuinely new root-skew caveat** (the state file resolves via `STATE_FILE`, a *different* root than the brain dataRoot — not a mirror of `assemble.ts`'s `ANALYTICS_ROOT` note, which is about the analytics *dir* under `LINKEDIN_STUDIO_DATA`). (A hook-side `.mjs` reconciler is **pathguard-blocked** — new `.mjs` under `hooks/scripts/` is forbidden — so the brain TS side is the only clean home; it copies `getStateFile()`'s chain since it cannot import the `.mjs`.)
4. **A CLI subcommand** `brain reconcile` (`cli.ts`): loads silo 1 + the assembled graph, prints the per-post coverage report (in brain / in analytics / orphaned-in-state), and a one-line summary ("N created posts, M in the brain graph, K un-ingested → `brain ingest` them to feed the graph"). Read-only.
5. **Deterministic gate section** (new Section, modelled on 16e/16d): unconditional checks that the reconcile wiring exists (CLI subcommand registered; core exported). `ASSERT_BASELINE_FLOOR` bumped by exactly the new unconditional checks.
6. **Brain-suite tests** (RED first): `reconcile.test.ts` — coverage tiers (present/absent/orphaned), the truncated-hook prefix limit, empty-state degradation. `BRAIN_TESTS_FLOOR` bumped by the new passing count (recorded live, not assumed).

**Honest limits of read-side (documented, not hidden):** (i) silo 1 carries only a **≤60-char truncated hook preview**, a weaker prefix signal than silo 2's full body → lower match confidence, reported honestly as a tier, never as proof. (ii) Read-side **cannot retroactively assign** the `specifics`/`trends` ids a post was built from — those were never captured for un-ingested posts; the join can only say "this created post is missing from the graph," not reconstruct its raw material. (iii) The true gap-closer is **auto-capture at drafting** (silo-2 record minted with specifics/trends at creation) — explicitly a **follow-up, not S3e** (STATE's S3c-bonus). S3e ships the *honest read-side reconciliation + the coverage signal that motivates auto-capture next.*

## 4. Non-goals — what is OUT (deferred)

- **Write-side stamping** — embedding a `contentId` into the `## Recent Posts` entry. Rejected for S3e: it requires a `contentId` to *exist* at post-creation, i.e. **auto-capture** (out of scope), and it mutates the `$`-injection-defended regex silo (`updatePostTracking` already had to use replacement *functions* to stay `$`-safe — `state-updater.mjs:117-125`). Heavier + riskier + premature. See §8 fork 2.
- **Auto-capture at drafting** (the real gap-closer) — minting a silo-2 published record with specifics/trends ids at post-creation. The motivated follow-up; S3e's coverage report is what makes its value legible.
- **Resurrecting `content-history.md`** as a live read tributary (the back-fill arm of fork 1) — it would add a second weak auto-record the graph still can't join. Rejected; retirement chosen.
- **Any change to `pruneContentHistory` / `## Recent Posts` writer / `state-updater.mjs`** — S3e reads silo 1, never writes it.
- **A second reconcile consumer** (a command/agent that *acts* on the coverage report) — S3e ships the `brain reconcile` view; wiring an agent to nudge "ingest these" is follow-on.
- **`assemble.ts` join-heuristic changes** — reconcile *consumes* the existing graph; it does not re-tune the silo 2↔3 matcher.

## 5. Boundaries / invariants (must hold)

- **READ-only into the state silo** — S3e adds no write path to `## Recent Posts` or any state-file field; `state-updater.mjs` stays the sole writer of silo 1.
- **READ-only into generation** — `brain consolidate --apply --confirm` stays the sole writer of `profile.md`; reconcile writes nothing.
- **Retirement is plumbing-only** — (b) removes a dead file + its writer/migration/guards; it must not touch the live `## Recent Posts`, `pruneContentHistory`, or any conceptual "content history" prose.
- **No new hook `.mjs`** — pathguard forbids new `.mjs` under `hooks/scripts/`; reconcile lives in `scripts/brain/` (TS). Editing the existing `migrate-data.mjs` (a deletion) is an Edit of an existing file → allowed.
- **State-file root precedence mirrored exactly** — `loadRecentPosts()` resolves `STATE_FILE || $HOME/.claude/linkedin-studio.local.md`, identical to the `.mjs` side; a divergence would silently read the wrong file.
- **Fresh-clone / empty-state safe** — missing state file or empty `## Recent Posts` → reconcile degrades to a clean empty report, never a crash (mirrors `loadAnalyticsRows`).
- **Migration idempotency intact** — removing the B1 MOVE entry must not break `migrate-data`'s `.migrated`-marker idempotency or the COPY/MOVE classes; the remaining test cases (b–e) stay green.
- **TDD iron law** — the failing reconcile test (and the failing gate-section self-test) land BEFORE the reconcile code.

## 6. Success criteria (testable)

- **SC1 — content-history retired:** `grep -rn "content-history" hooks/ config/ scripts/test-runner.sh .gitignore references/data-path-convention.md` (NO `--include` filter — it must reach `.gitignore` and the `.md` ref-doc, which an extension-filter would silently skip) returns **zero** (file, writer, MOVE entry, gitignore line, SC2 alternative, ref-doc, comment all gone); the template file is deleted. The README `:120` *conceptual* mention is intentionally outside this grep set (concept, not file). *(grep + `ls` assertion — identical command in the plan, SC1)*
- **SC2 — migration green after retirement:** `(cd … && node --test hooks/scripts/__tests__/migrate-data.test.mjs)` passes with cases a–e; no content-history assertion remains. *(hook suite)*
- **SC3 — reconcile core correct (RED-first, LOGIC-RED not import-RED):** `reconcile.test.ts` asserts the three coverage tiers (in-graph / in-brain-only / orphaned-in-state), truncated-hook degradation, and empty-state → empty report. **RED proof recorded:** the artifact must show the **named tier assertions failing** (e.g. "expected `orphaned-in-state` for the un-ingested entry") against a **stub `reconcile.ts` that compiles but mis-classifies** (returns `[]` / wrong tiers) — a bare `MODULE_NOT_FOUND` import-RED proves nothing about the assertion logic and is rejected as vacuous. `BRAIN_TESTS_FLOOR` bumped to the recorded new count. *(brain suite)*
- **SC4 — reconcile wired:** `brain reconcile` runs end-to-end on a seeded fixture (silo 1 + published + analytics) and prints the coverage report + summary; a new gate Section asserts the CLI subcommand + core export exist (unconditional self-test + real-file grep). *(lint + manual run)*
- **SC5 — gate green + floor honoured:** `scripts/test-runner.sh` stays green; TOTAL recounted **live** at land (current 97; + the new unconditional checks). `ASSERT_BASELINE_FLOOR` bumped by exactly that many; SC2-dry-run still passes with the narrowed `SC2_CLASSES`.
- **SC6 — root-skew (manual/behavioural — EXPECTED to land as a real pass):** with `STATE_FILE` pointing at a temp state file, `brain reconcile` reads silo 1 from it; with it unset it falls back to `$HOME/.claude/linkedin-studio.local.md`. This is a trivial `STATE_FILE` env toggle in a temp dir — exercisable in the same shell that runs the gate — so the **default expected landing state is a real behavioural pass**, not a hedge. **Fallback (verifiseringsplikt):** only if the env toggle genuinely cannot run, record wiring-inspected-only, NOT a behavioural pass — the hedge must never become a standing excuse to skip a runnable check.
- **SC7 — counts reconciled:** `architecture.md` S3 build-row marked S3e ✅ (arc complete); STATE telling updated (gate total, ASSERT floor, brain floor); no CLAUDE.md command/agent/reference-doc count change (no new command/agent; `reconcile.ts` is a brain module + CLI subcommand, not a plugin surface — confirm at the gate whether `brain reconcile` warrants a one-line CLAUDE.md mention).

## 7. Verification

- **Deterministic (gate):** SC1/SC4/SC5 via grep + the new gate Section in `test-runner.sh`; SC2 via the migrate-data hook test; SC3 via the brain suite (`cd scripts/brain && npm install` before the gate, else warn-skip — STATE rule).
- **Behavioural (manual, documented — the honest limit):** SC4 end-to-end run + SC6 root-skew — recorded in STATE/changelog at land; never overclaim a behavioural pass not run (verifiseringsplikt).

## 8. Open questions for brief-review / the go-gate

1. **Fork 1 — content-history: retire vs back-fill.** Recommended **retire** — zero readers, redundant with silo 1, and back-fill resurrects a second weak auto-record the graph still cannot join. Confirm.
2. **Fork 2 — reconciliation: read-side joiner vs write-side stamp.** Recommended **read-side** — faithful to S3c's read-only invariant, avoids the `$`-injection regex silo, and write-side is blocked on auto-capture (no `contentId` exists at creation today) so it would be premature. Cost honestly stated: a new cross-seam read (brain TS → state file). Confirm; write-side + auto-capture become the flagged follow-up.
3. **Scope of (c): build the read-side joiner now, or document-the-design + defer the build?** Recommended **build now** — the coverage report is the genuine deliverable that closes the arc and motivates auto-capture; a doc-only finale under-delivers the last slice. Confirm the build.
4. **CLAUDE.md surface for `brain reconcile`.** The brain CLI is an internal tool, not a plugin command — recommended: a one-line architecture note, no command-count change. Confirm.

## 9. Light-Voyage review — folded

Three reviewers ran on the brief + plan (2026-06-23):

- **`voyage:scope-guardian`: ALIGNED** — 0 creep, 0 gaps, 0 dependency issues. All 14 IN items (b1–b8, c1–c6) map to a plan step; no NON-GOAL file is touched (the scope fence is consistent with the steps, and slightly broader/defensive); doc reconciliation is proportional (architecture build-row + STATE telling only). Every referenced file/line/symbol verified against the live codebase.
- **`voyage:brief-reviewer`: REVISE** → 4 [FIX]es folded:
  - **FIX-1** (load-bearing): the parser must mirror the **writer** `updatePostTracking` (`state-updater.mjs:116`), NOT `pruneContentHistory` — whose `:145` regex is **date-only** and captures no hook/chars/topic. Folded into §3(c).2 (+ a golden-string round-trip test). The "they never disagree" claim was rebuilt on the writer-format source of truth. ✅
  - **FIX-2** (honesty): the writer prose being deleted *claims* `/linkedin:report` + `analytics-interpreter` as readers, but they were never wired — aspirational dead prose. Named in §2 so the "zero readers" verdict is auditable, not asserted. ✅
  - **FIX-3** (testability): SC3 RED tightened to a **logic-RED** (named tier assertions fail against a mis-classifying stub), rejecting a vacuous import-RED. ✅
  - **FIX-4** (testability + consistency): SC6 pre-committed as an **expected real behavioural pass** (trivial env toggle), wiring-only as documented fallback; and the root-skew caveat is **genuinely new** (state file via `STATE_FILE`), not a mirror of `assemble.ts`'s `ANALYTICS_ROOT` note — cite `data-root.mjs: getStateFile()` as the canonical precedence. Folded into §3(c).3 + SC6. ✅
  - Also folded: the **core signature** corrected to `{ recentPosts, records, graph }` (graph-only cannot prefix-match — `PostGraphNode` has no `body`), and **SC1's grep** unified with the plan's (no `--include` filter, which would skip `.gitignore`/`.md`).
- **`voyage:plan-critic`: REVISE (3 blockers + 6 major + 4 minor)** — folded into `plan-sb-s3e.md` §"Plan-critic — folded". The three blockers were real factual errors against the code, each verified directly before folding: (B1) `listPublished()` is body-less → use `runAssemble`'s inline `parsePublishedRecord` loader (`cli.ts:162-176`, which already builds a `bodyById` Map); (B2) the core signature contradiction (= the brief's signature fold); (B3) the `:145`-regex misattribution (= FIX-1). Majors: the `getStateFile()` HOME-chain (not bare `homedir()`), single-literal gate decoys, Check-B literal-name constraint, recorded gate TOTAL (verified live **97**), demonstrated migrate idempotency, and the SC1 grep unification.

**Net:** scope unchanged (ALIGNED); the folds correct three load-bearing factual errors in the reconcile design (body-less loader, wrong regex, wrong HOME seam) + harden the RED guarantee and the gate's non-vacuity. The retirement arm (b) was already nearly executable; the reconcile arm (c) is now grounded in the actual `assemble.ts`/`ingest.ts`/`cli.ts` shapes.
