diff --git a/docs/hardening/log.md b/docs/hardening/log.md index 1cfba94..613d227 100644 --- a/docs/hardening/log.md +++ b/docs/hardening/log.md @@ -785,3 +785,74 @@ orchestration (subagent targets + 5 node helpers resolve; graceful degradation). axes a/b/d PASS. --- + +## Session 9 — Longform orchestrator (`newsletter`) + +> S9 status: re-grounded STATE's 7 S9 predicates against the actual `newsletter.md` (1594 lines, 16 +> phases) BEFORE talk (jerndisiplin: assert-after-read). Class agreed S9 steps 1–2: **guided/stateful +> long-form orchestrator, NOT post-emitting** — the feed-post predicates (hook 110–140, 1,200–1,800 +> band, no-body-link) do NOT apply; imposing them would be the S4/video category error the command +> itself already rejects (`:38–42`). All `file:line` below are tool-grounded against the FINAL file +> (no edits this session → final == 52e888a). + +### /linkedin:newsletter — long-form edition end-to-end, 16-phase stateful pipeline, NOT post-emitting + +**INTENT.** `newsletter` is the Longform orchestrator: take an edition (newsletter / essay / series +article) from load → calibration → verified research → skeleton+spine gates BEFORE prose → full draft +→ consistency/quality+voice-scrub → fact-check → editorial craft gate → persona sweep → headless +adversarial review → visual assets → LOCK (POST.html) → hook-gate → scheduling. Multi-session with a +maintained `edition-state.json`. Long-form quality is enforced by the **pipeline phases**, not +short-form hooks. + +**SIMULATE (grounded persona-sim, anchored to Step 6.5 headless fan-out).** +- **Persona (operator):** KTG producing a series edition; primær reader chosen in Step 1. +- **Walk:** Step 0 load (voice/persona graceful `:258`) → … → Step 6 persona sweep PASS → **Step 6.5 + freeze → fan out 5 cold archetypes** (`:1062–1069`, single message, all `linkedin-studio:`-namespaced, + foreground per principle 4; background loses Task `:79`) → **degradation gate** (`:1084–1086` "do not + proceed with a missing reviewer `[GATE]`") → consolidate via `SendUserFile` → Step 7.5 visual assets + (mcp-image not a hard dependency, external `cover-raw.png` fallback `:1222–1230`) → Step 8 LOCK + (`build-linkedin.mjs` → `linkedin/NN/POST.html`, exit-code N3 `:1388`) → Step 10 `queueAdd` (`:1486`). +- **Friction sought (the S2–S8 pattern: a missing buzzword gate / a missing fallback):** **NONE found.** + The category-correct equivalent of the short-form buzzword gate is the de-AI/voice-scrub + editorial + + language-reviewer gates, all present and wired. Every fan-out has a structured-return degradation gate. + +**EVALUATE (4 axes).** +- **(a) intention fidelity — PASS.** The 16-phase pipeline delivers the description's promise; primær + artifact `POST.html` is produced end-to-end at Step 8 lock (`:1379–1395`) with exit-code verification. +- **(b) algorithm/format bar (long-form honesty, NOT feed-post predicates) — PASS.** Native-newsletter § + (`:1508–1569`) is nøktern: "sells nothing", notification dedup not oversold ("not three guaranteed + touchpoints"), cold-start not inflated ("0→9K in 7 days were not cold starts"), downsides disclosed + (non-exportable / no-canonical / no-analytics / decay), sourcing note (`:1564`) separates LinkedIn + help-docs (high conf.) from practitioner ranges (medium) + flags the contested email-dedup; citation + `docs/remediation/research/03-coverage-gap-specs.md` §D5 exists (225 lines, §D5 ×8 — not dangling). +- **(c) quality rules (category-appropriate) — PASS.** Long-form quality is enforced by the pipeline + gates (skeleton 2.5 · spine 3a · consistency+voice-scrub 4 · fact-check 5 · editorial 5.5 · persona 6 + · headless 6.5 · hook 9), all present + wired. Short-form hooks correctly NOT imposed (`:38–42`); no + hollow gate found. +- **(d) agent-wiring + graceful degradation — PASS.** All 8 invoked subagents resolve to real + `agents/*.md`, all `subagent_type: linkedin-studio:`-namespaced (persona-reviewer ×5, fact-checker ×2, + voice-scrubber, language-reviewer, fact-reviewer, editorial-reviewer, content-reviewer, + content-repurposer). Render/queue helpers exist; `queueAdd(id, draftPath, schedDate, schedTime, + pillar, format, hookPreview, charCount)` 8-arg signature (qm`:63`) matches the call (`:1486`). All 9 + plugin-root ref/template files (`:1575–1594`) exist. Phase strings: `_doc.phases` (16) ↔ resumption + table (16) `diff` IDENTICAL. Degradation: voice/persona `:258` · mcp-image `:1222–1230` · exit-codes + ×4 (`:443/580/1144/1388`) · optional config+delingstekst `:1373–1377` · fan-out gates ×3 + (`:340/789/1086`). + +**HARDEN — NO CHANGE (verified clean).** +- 0 edits. `newsletter` is among the most iterated commands (v2.0→v4.1 hardened the long-form gates + across multiple production runs: Seres, Del 4 / Endring 9), and it shows: every axis passes with no + surgical opportunity at or below the axis-pass bar. +- **Deferrals:** none. **Anti-gold-plating:** no NICE-only polish pursued beyond axis-pass (stopping + rule, brief §). The native-newsletter follow-up noted in S2 STATE (reference-consistency for the + separate `video.md`/`linkedin-formats.md` 30 % surface) is NOT this command's surface — left in the + open-follow-ups list, not touched here. + +**VERIFY.** +- `bash scripts/test-runner.sh` → `Passed: 81 · Failed: 0 · Warnings: 0`; counts **29/19/26** (+6 + skills) unchanged; `git status --porcelain` empty → working tree byte-identical to `52e888a` (S8). +- Phase-string diff reproduced: `_doc.phases` ids vs resumption-table `currentPhase` ids → IDENTICAL, + 16↔16, in order. +- Disposition: **VERIFIED — NO CHANGE** (0 edits) · 0 deferrals · axes a/b/c/d all PASS. + +---