diff --git a/docs/hardening/log.md b/docs/hardening/log.md index 613d227..bad6210 100644 --- a/docs/hardening/log.md +++ b/docs/hardening/log.md @@ -856,3 +856,86 @@ short-form hooks. - Disposition: **VERIFIED — NO CHANGE** (0 edits) · 0 deferrals · axes a/b/c/d all PASS. --- + +## Session 10 — Longform companion (`headless-review`) + +> S10 status: re-grounded STATE's predicates against the actual `headless-review.md` (248 lines, 13 KB) +> BEFORE talk (jerndisiplin: assert-after-read). Class agreed S10 steps 1–2: **cold adversarial +> review-orchestrator, NOT post-emitting** — it emits a consolidated review report + optional +> `edition-state` persistence, never a feed post and never drafts prose; the feed-post predicates +> (hook 110–140, 1,200–1,800 band, no-body-link) do NOT apply — imposing them would be the S4/video +> category error (even further from feed-post than `newsletter`). The four archetype agents are +> SHARED with `newsletter` Step 6.5 → S9 agent findings reused as baseline. All `file:line` below are +> tool-grounded against the FINAL file (no edits this session → final == 1c31644). + +### /linkedin:headless-review — cold adversarial review package on a FROZEN long-form draft, NOT post-emitting + +**INTENT.** `headless-review` is the standalone surface of `newsletter` Step 6.5: read a frozen, +publish-ready (or pivoted) long-form draft COLD — with NONE of the drafting session's framing-bias — +through five independent archetypes and return direction-only flags, consolidated into one +operator-gated report. Two isolation layers: fresh session (strongest, `:64–68`) + per-archetype +subagent context (`:69–74`). The adversarial-independence layer the in-session gates structurally +cannot be (`:30–48`). + +**SIMULATE (grounded persona-sim, anchored to the Step 3 cold fan-out).** +- **Persona (operator):** KTG in a FRESH session running `--type all` on `/NN-utkast.md`. +- **Walk:** Step 1 resolve-from-disk (draft → edition-state `currentArticle` fallback → ask-once + `:103–104`; contract 3-tier fallback ending at always-present `longform-quality-rules.md` `:111–114`; + personas = newsletter Step 1 chain `:116–118`) → Step 2 freeze (`cp` snapshot `:126`, live-draft + fallback if `cp` unavailable `:130–131`) → **Step 3 fan out 5 archetypes** (single message, + `:135–136`; 4 `linkedin-studio:`-namespaced types, persona-reviewer ×2 modes `:141–146`) → + **degradation gate** (`:161–164` "re-run that one archetype — do not paper over a missing reviewer + `[GATE]`") → Step 4 consolidate (operator gates, never auto-resolve flags `:168–169`/`:196–197`; + convergence marked `:200–202`) → Step 5 surface via `SendUserFile` (else `file://` `:208–210`) + + optional persist `articles.NN.headlessReview` (`:211–215`). +- **Friction sought (the S2–S8 pattern: a missing buzzword gate / a missing fallback):** **NONE found.** + Not post-emitting → the category-correct quality bar is the reviewers grading against the writing + contract + the structured-return degradation gate, both present. Every fan-out call has a degradation + re-run path. + +**EVALUATE (4 axes).** +- **(a) intention fidelity — PASS.** The 5-step flow (resolve → freeze → parallel fan-out → consolidate + → surface/persist) delivers the description's promise; primær artifact is the consolidated report + (`:171–198`), surfaced + optionally persisted (`:204–215`). `allowed-tools` (`:18–26`) complete and + fully used (Read/Glob/Grep · Bash freeze · AskUserQuestion ask-once · Task fan-out · Write report+state). +- **(b) algorithm/format bar (long-form honesty, NOT feed-post predicates) — PASS.** Cold contract + (`:50–74`) nøktern: reviewers get a "deliberately starved context", exactly-what-they-get / + exactly-what-they-don't enumerated; two-layer isolation with honest caveats (Layer 1 "recommended … + strongest" not absolute; reload caveat for the v3.1.0 agents `:80–82`). Deliberate redundancy + (`fact-reviewer`↔`fact-checker`, `language-reviewer`↔`editorial` prose axis) disclosed as + on-purpose, not collapsed (`:234–237`). No feed-post predicate imposed. +- **(c) quality rules (category-appropriate) — PASS.** Review quality enforced by (1) reviewers judging + against the writing contract (`:111–114`), (2) the degradation gate requiring structured/populated + returns, not a hedged paragraph (`:161–164`), (3) operator-gates-the-fold-in — the command recommends, + never rewrites/gates (`:168–169`/`:196–197`/`:210`), (4) convergence-as-signal (`:200–202`). No hollow + gate found. +- **(d) agent-wiring + graceful degradation — PASS.** 4/4 invoked subagent types resolve to real + `agents/*.md` with matching frontmatter `name:`, all `subagent_type: linkedin-studio:`-namespaced + (content-reviewer · language-reviewer · fact-reviewer · persona-reviewer ×2 modes → "five + archetypes" `:5–6`/`:30–31`). 8/8 Reference Files (`:241–248`) exist. `articles.NN.headlessReview` + schema present + complete in `edition-state.template.json` (`:56–69`: frozenDraft · reviewers + {content,language,fact,personaResonance,personaConversion} · consolidatedReport · foldedIn · waived · + status; ladder pending→run→folded `:29`). Degradation ×5: freeze `cp` fallback `:130` · draft-missing + ask-once `:104` · persona fallback `:117` · `[GATE]` re-run `:163–164` · output-default `:93` + + SendUserFile-else-`file://` `:208–210`. + +**HARDEN — NO CHANGE (verified clean).** +- 0 edits. Borderline surfaced at talk: the freeze step (`:126`) assumes `review/` exists (no + `mkdir -p`). **Operator chose Alt A (no change).** Rationale: the freeze block is **byte-identical to + `newsletter` `:1050`** (S9-verified-clean), and `review/` is created by the render pipeline that + produces the draft (`build-html.mjs` → `./review/` newsletter `:1136`; skeleton/draft render + `:444`/`:580`); adding `mkdir -p` only here would drift from its S9-clean twin, and fixing both would + re-open S9 (out of S10 scope). The `cp`-unavailable fallback (`:130`) covers the degraded path loosely. +- **Deferrals:** none. **Anti-gold-plating:** the `mkdir -p` robustness improvement is a NICE below the + axis-pass bar — left as the operator's logged decision (Alt A), not pursued. + +**VERIFY.** +- `bash scripts/test-runner.sh` → `Passed: 81 · Failed: 0 · Warnings: 0`; counts **29/19/26** (+6 + skills) unchanged (count/version-consistency guards inside the lint passed); `git status --porcelain` + empty → working tree byte-identical to `1c31644` (S9). +- Predicates re-grounded against the final file: 4 namespaced subagent types (frontmatter `name:` + match) · 8/8 ref files exist · `headlessReview` schema `:56–69` · 5 degradation points · persona + chain = newsletter `:179–183` · "five archetypes" (wrapped) = 5 modes from 4 agents. +- Disposition: **VERIFIED — NO CHANGE** (0 edits) · 0 deferrals · axes a/b/c/d all PASS. + +---