diff --git a/commands/outreach.md b/commands/outreach.md index e2446a0..b18918a 100644 --- a/commands/outreach.md +++ b/commands/outreach.md @@ -16,10 +16,9 @@ allowed-tools: - Read - Glob - WebSearch - - WebFetch - AskUserQuestion - - Write - Task + - Bash --- # LinkedIn Outreach Orchestrator (Collaborations + Speaking) @@ -649,7 +648,8 @@ DM Amplification Protocol: Both partners share/comment on each other's version. Creates compound visibility effect. -Impact: DM amplification can boost first-hour engagement 2-3x. +Impact: this feeds the first-hour engagement that carries collaborative +content to its 2-3x reach (ref: collaborations-guide.md). ``` ### Step 5b: Speaking — Outreach by Channel @@ -918,24 +918,22 @@ LinkedIn: [profile URL] ## Step 7: Engagement-Pod Warning (Both Tracks) -**Post-March 2025 LinkedIn Algorithm Update:** +LinkedIn runs an active engagement-pod crackdown (see +`references/algorithm-signals-reference.md`): ``` ⚠️ ENGAGEMENT PODS: DO NOT USE -LinkedIn now actively detects and penalizes engagement pods: +What LinkedIn does to pods (its stated crackdown): +- Pod-style auto-comments are demoted out of "Most Relevant" +- Their reach is scoped to your own network — it stops spreading beyond it +- Repeat offenders get restricted -Detection methods: +How pods get detected: - Consistent same-person engagement patterns - Engagement timing clusters (everyone engages within minutes) -- Low dwell time on engaged posts (engage without reading) - Reciprocal engagement loops (A→B→A→B pattern) -Penalties: -- 30-55% reach reduction on detected posts -- Shadow suppression of pod participants -- Account credibility score reduction - INSTEAD, build genuine engagement through: - CEA method comments (Compliment, Expand, Ask) - 5x5x5 daily routine (organic engagement) diff --git a/docs/hardening/log.md b/docs/hardening/log.md index c51f2e0..ce64912 100644 --- a/docs/hardening/log.md +++ b/docs/hardening/log.md @@ -1545,3 +1545,71 @@ invokes WebFetch, Write, Glob, or Grep.** - Disposition: **FIXED** (2 edits, `commands/monetize.md`) · 0 deferrals · axes a/c PASS, axes b′/d PASS post-fix. --- + +### /linkedin:outreach — collab + speaking outreach orchestrator (track select → readiness → targets → format/pitch → production → pipeline persist) (S22) + +**INTENT.** Grow-tier **orchestrator** (unlocks ~1K), prose-heavy **+ agent-delegating + state-persisting**. +Two tracks (collab + speaking) under one paradigm, 11 steps (Step 0–10 `:65-1252`). Absorbed +`collab`/`speaking`/`authority` (capability checklist `:36-63` maps each predecessor function). **First in +the queue to BOTH delegate to an agent AND mutate real state** — shifts the weight onto axis-d. + +**SIMULATE (adversarial cold quality-reviewer; grounded prose-trace + throwaway state fixture — operator +chose the thorough path; touches no real state/data-dir).** Traced Step 0–10 against the file; verified every +mechanical claim (refs resolve, agent resolves, mutation exists, grants match body use, axis-b′ claims trace +to SSOT) with a tool, never by reasoning. + +**EVALUATE (relevant axes; mechanical predicate each).** +- **(a) intention: PASS** — checklist maps both predecessors; all 5 refs + SKILL.md resolve (Step 0 + + Reference Files); state path `~/.claude/linkedin-studio.local.md` correct post-M0 (per CLAUDE.md). +- **(b) algorithm/conversion-bar (axis-b′): 2 FINDINGS.** **B1** `:652` "DM amplification can boost + first-hour engagement **2-3x**" — over-quantified: 2-3x is SSOT for *collab reach* + (`collaborations-guide.md:32/165/187`), while the DM-loop's first-hour effect is held *qualitative* there + (`:335`). **B2** `:921-946` Step 7 pod-warning fabricated magnitudes — "**30-55%** reach reduction", + "shadow suppression", "account credibility score reduction", "penalizes", "**Post-March 2025** Update" + + "low dwell" detection (dwell unmeasurable per CLAUDE.md). SSOT (`algorithm-signals-reference.md:98`) states + ONLY: "auto-comments demoted out of 'Most Relevant', scoped to own network; repeat offenders restricted" + (Sachdeva 2026-02-16, high) + design rule "do not quote a percentage / soften penalty". Same S18/S21 + + follow-up-#1 pattern. +- **(c) quality rules: PASS** — prose templates only (no post emission); "thought leader"/"ecosystem" + appear only in search-queries / internal *goals* (`:230/:813/:820`), not in published post-copy (Rule 4). +- **(d) agent-wiring + grants + state + graceful: 3 FINDINGS.** **D1 PASS** — `Task subagent_type: + linkedin-studio:network-builder` (`:172`) resolves (`agents/network-builder.md`). **D2 PASS** — + `recordOutreachContact` is **NOT fabricated** (`state-updater.mjs:294`, CLI `--record-outreach :394`, + additive, `$`-safe). **D3 Bash MISSING** — Step 8c (`:1064`) runs `node …state-updater.mjs --record-outreach` + (needs Bash) but frontmatter didn't grant it; `firsthour.md` grants Bash for the same `node`-mutation + pattern → functional defect (command promised a mutation it couldn't execute). **D4 WebFetch orphan** + (`:19`, zero body use). **D5 Write orphan** (`:21`; `:410/:1040` are prose "Write a post", not tool use). + +**HARDEN (5 edits across 2 files — operator-approved scope extension to also fix the SSOT-diverging guide +source so the B2 rewrite can't be re-rendered from a stale reference).** +1. [REWORK · axis-d] `commands/outreach.md` frontmatter: dropped `- WebFetch` + `- Write` (orphans), + added `- Bash` (Step 8c needs it). allowed-tools now Read·Glob·WebSearch·AskUserQuestion·Task·Bash + (borderline Glob kept — S20 precedent). +2. [REWORK · axis-b′] `:652` (B1): re-attributed 2-3x to collab reach (where SSOT places it), kept the + first-hour effect qualitative + cite to `collaborations-guide.md`. +3. [REWORK · axis-b′] Step 7 (B2): replaced "Post-March 2025 Update" header + the fabricated + detection/penalties block with the SSOT crackdown statement (demote out of "Most Relevant" / scope to own + network / restrict repeat offenders) + cite; softened "penalizes", dropped "low dwell". +4. [REWORK · axis-b′, scope-extension] `references/collaborations-guide.md:349-370` (B2 propagation): same + SSOT rewrite of the "March 2025 Crackdown" section — dropped "shadow banning ALL future content / 90+ days + / 6+ months / permanent reach penalty", the date, and the speculative detection methods (browser-extension + tracking, linguistic fingerprinting). + +**VERIFY.** +- Re-grepped final files. `commands/outreach.md`: `grep WebFetch` → **NONE**, `^ - Write$` → **NONE**, + `^ - Bash$` → `:21`; B1 old form → **NONE** (new `:651`); B2 `30-55%|Post-March 2025|penalizes engagement + pods|credibility score|Low dwell|Shadow suppression` → **NONE** (SSOT text `:928-929`). + `references/collaborations-guide.md`: `90+ days|6+ months|never fully recover|permanent reach + penalty|Shadow banning affects ALL|March 2025 Crackdown` → **NONE** (SSOT text `:349/:364`). +- **D2/D3 throwaway fixture** (`/private/tmp/claude-*`, fictional, deleted after): `recordOutreachContact` + direct-call (no `writeState`), **10/10 assertions PASS** — additive insert after `last_post_date`, + `outreach_active` untouched when undeclared, pre-existing fields + custom section intact, newest-first + append, **`$`-safe** (`@kari$boss` preserved literally — S13 behavioral), section auto-created. +- `git diff --stat` = 2 files, **+20 / −28**. +- `bash scripts/test-runner.sh` → `Passed: 81 · Failed: 0 · Warnings: 0`, **exit 0**; counts **29/19** + unchanged (.md-only edits — node hook/analytics tests not triggered). +- Disposition: **FIXED** (5 edits, 2 files) · 0 deferrals · axes a/c PASS, axes b′/d PASS post-fix. + Note: state-updater HTML-comment lands between newest+older rows on repeat append = cosmetic, logged as + non-scope follow-up (the command calls the mutation correctly). + +--- diff --git a/references/collaborations-guide.md b/references/collaborations-guide.md index fe66f5a..3286af4 100644 --- a/references/collaborations-guide.md +++ b/references/collaborations-guide.md @@ -346,28 +346,22 @@ Include collaborator content in Featured: --- -## Engagement Pods: March 2025 Crackdown +## Engagement Pods: An Active Crackdown -LinkedIn's March 2025 update dramatically increased pod detection capabilities. +LinkedIn runs an active engagement-pod crackdown and keeps expanding how it +detects them (see `algorithm-signals-reference.md` — the algorithm SSOT). -### Detection Methods Now in Use +### How Pods Get Detected -- Browser extension tracking (LinkedIn detects pod-organizing extensions) -- Pattern analysis on comment timing (simultaneous engagement = red flag) +- Comment-timing analysis (simultaneous engagement = red flag) - Cross-account engagement correlation (same people always first to engage) -- Linguistic fingerprinting (similar comment patterns across accounts) +- Reciprocal engagement loops (the same accounts engaging each other) -### Consequences +### What LinkedIn Does -- Shadow banning affects ALL future content (not just the flagged post) -- Reach penalties persist for 90+ days -- Can take 6+ months to recover algorithmic trust -- Some accounts never fully recover - -### The Math Has Changed - -- **Old:** Pod engagement boosted first-hour metrics → more reach -- **New:** Pod engagement triggers detection → permanent reach penalty +- Pod-style auto-comments are demoted out of "Most Relevant" +- Their reach is scoped to your own network — it stops spreading beyond it +- Repeat offenders get restricted **Pods now hurt more than help.** Build authentic communities instead: - Genuine relationships with 3-5 aligned creators