feat(consume): the payload says what of the question it reached, and row 4 reads it

`coverage` carries three lists: the terms the pre-pass read the question as,
the terms no concept in the bundle answers, and the terms no delivered
excerpt answers. Without it a reader holding eight excerpts cannot tell a
bundle that ANSWERED its question from one that merely ranked something --
the two payloads have the same shape.

FACTS, AND NO VERDICT, which is a measurement and not caution. Two readings
were built and both falsified over 81 questions (16 synthetic, 65 across the
three real sets, 2026-09-20): the share of question terms a delivered
excerpt answers separates the synthetic controls at 0.33 against 0.50 and
REVERSES on real data (covered questions down to 0.27, one genuinely
uncovered question at 0.71); the share of a bundle tying the best lexical
match is ~0.00 for every real question either way. Question style dominates
the first, corpus size the second.

The one bar this repository declares is the gate's: `UNANSWERED_BAR = 2/3`
over `unanswered_in_bundle`, swept and collapsing at both ends -- at 0.50
eleven real covered questions are marked, at 0.70 the row falls to 5 of 6,
at 2/3 the row is 6 of 6 and 0 of 65 real questions are marked. The margin
is thin (0.6087 against 0.6667) and is published that way, together with
what it does not catch: r761-sk2's own known-negative sits at 0.2857.

Row 4: 3 of 6 RED -> 6 of 6 GREEN, with the 10 answered synthetic questions
held unmarked as the known-negative. The contract's SS 8 gains point 7, the
consumption skill is told to read the block, and the SS 7.4 known-positive
moves with the document (14 721/375 -> 16 389/417). Suite 2292 passed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Kjell Tore Guttormsen 2026-09-20 08:44:06 +02:00
commit 05cb19087a
Signed by: ktg
SSH key fingerprint: SHA256:JakMjO6FTBBzN0Bhfj9saOoEjaFxlSdYuZQQpM/lF9Q
8 changed files with 216 additions and 42 deletions

View file

@ -160,6 +160,11 @@ are permitted; the checker reads only the members this section names.
"known_positive": { "case": "<name>", "expected": 10406, "measured": 10406 }
},
"denominators": { "considered": 439, "withheld": 401, "delivered": 38 },
"coverage": {
"question_terms": ["<the terms the pre-pass read the question as>"],
"unanswered_in_bundle": ["<those no concept in the bundle answers>"],
"unanswered_in_payload": ["<those no delivered excerpt answers>"]
},
"excerpts": [
{
"bundle_id": "<id>",
@ -224,6 +229,27 @@ are permitted; the checker reads only the members this section names.
the enclosing concept's text inside `parent``text`, with that concept's
own `sha256`, and `truncated` where it was cut to fit — and then only from
the room its cut left, so that inherited text never displaces an excerpt.
7. A pre-pass SHOULD carry `coverage`: the terms it read the question as, the
ones no concept in the bundle answers, and the ones no delivered excerpt
answers. Without it a reader holding eight excerpts cannot tell a bundle
that answered its question from one that merely ranked something — the two
payloads have the same shape — and § 6's states are then unreachable from
the payload alone.
**Facts, and no verdict.** The member carries lists and never a score, a
confidence or a "weak" flag, because the two obvious verdicts were built
and falsified against 81 questions on 2026-09-20: the share of a question's
terms a delivered excerpt answers separates a synthetic corpus at 0.33
against 0.50 and then reverses on real data, where covered questions run
down to 0.27 while one genuinely uncovered question sits at 0.71; and the
share of a bundle tying the best lexical match is ~0.00 for every question
in a large bundle, covered or not. Question style dominates the first and
corpus size the second, so a pre-pass emitting a verdict would assert
across corpora what was measured on one. Where a bar belongs is in the
consumer's own judgement or in a gate that publishes its sweep.
The checker does not read this member, for the same reason: it holds a
payload's FORM, and these lists carry no claim a form can be held to.
## 9. Prohibitions