Phase 3 starts with a written mapping of the proving consumer's gates to
exactly one of Profile / Guard / Consumer, reviewed before any porting.
Drafted here against claude-code-llm-wiki's validate.py and bundle.py at
their 9ee5a8e, which is their single gate entrypoint, so the enumeration
is exhaustive against that commit and no other.
Reading the validator corrected two things this plan asserted before it
had been read, both of which would have produced a wrong STRICT_V1:
- Required frontmatter keys are FOUR (type, title, description,
timestamp), not the eight the plan listed. Those eight were a
truncation of FRONTMATTER_KEY_ORDER, which is an eleven-key allowlist
doubling as canonical emission order. frontmatter_schema therefore
needs three fields -- required, allowlisted, ordered -- not one
required/optional pair.
- Reserved files are THREE basenames, not two: README.md is reserved
like index.md and log.md but in a third way, present and exempt from
the document gates while still content-scanned. A two-valued
required/required-absent policy cannot express it.
Two of the 25 gates bundle checks from different columns
(LLM_OUTPUT_LINT, BUNDLE_URL_ALLOWLIST). They are decomposed per check
rather than assigned wholesale to a dominant column, which would have
moved the residue to the wrong side of the boundary.
Also recorded: index policy is the widest gap between the two profiles
(per-bundle vs per-directory, two link formats, append-if-absent vs
exact match, root index with or without frontmatter), and C4 is
confirmed with the operator -- profiles in code, no config-file loading
in v1.
Four open questions are addressed to the proving consumer in the
artifact; no porting until they and the table come back reviewed.
Kjell Tore Guttormsen
d8e466791c