17 bundles, 602 documents, five corpora: our goldens, portfolio-optimiser-claude,
catalog's green parity corpus, the wiki's bundle, and upstream's own four
reference bundles at the pinned commit. Read-only throughout; nothing was written
into a consumer tree and no consumer ran anything.
Every finding is on the JUDGE path, so none of them blocks v0.5.0a1, P2 or P3 —
both remaining pilot tests are emit-side. They are P4's work.
The two that matter most needed real data to surface:
- root_frontmatter conflates "permitted and ordered" with "required": 14 of 17
bundles fail with exactly one violation each, including all four of upstream's
own reference bundles, purely for exercising a MAY the emitter treats as
optional. We emit a MAY correctly and grade it as a MUST.
- TypePolicy.allowed cannot judge a consumer that quotes its scalars: 0/526 wiki
documents pass, 526/526 pass dequoted. The suite cannot see it because its
tests hand-build the mapping and never parse a file.
Also confirmed against real third-party v0.2 data: V-A3 holds — no upstream
`generated` value reads as owned, so a real v0.2 bundle cannot talk the collision
gate into overwriting.
Test C: C-E1 differed (the quoting gap), C-E2/C-E3/C-E4 as expected. The wiki's
copy went out through coord per their condition, never as a file here.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0186K8oLEnaFfXZ2dWGyHzrB
Kjell Tore Guttormsen
a8ceea9667