fix(ms-ai-architect): G7 idx-26g lukket — og §9.12s egen korpusmaaling var tatt over feil populasjon
Header **Status:** GA -> GA / Preview (Responsible AI scorecard). Begge kildesidene bekreftet ordrett ved live fetch: 'currently in public preview ... provided without a service-level agreement, and we don't recommend it for production workloads'. Begge titlene sier '(preview)'. Formen valgt etter aa ha sjekket alle seks korpusfilene i X / Preview (Y)-familien: parentesen navngir alltid det som ER i preview, aldri GA-flaten. DE TO BESLUTNINGENE VAR UAVHENGIGE, OG ENTRYEN BUNTET DEM. Banneret staar paa concept-siden, som ALLEREDE er filas Kilder #1 - saa preview-faktumet trengte ingen ny kilde. Bare de sju segmentene trengte how-to-siden. Delt opp i ratifiseringen slik at en kildebeslutning ikke gated en status-retting. STEMPELET RE-DATERT BEVISST 2026-08-04 -> 2026-08-09. En setning skrevet i dag under et fem dager gammelt verifiseringsstempel er nettopp idx-26h-defekten ('stempelet var FEIL DA DET BLE SATT, ikke foreldet') - denne gangen forfattet av editen selv. Re-datering paastaar hele §1, saa hele §1 ble re-maalt mot begge live-sidene. TREDJE LOCATOR, IKKE NAVNGITT AV ENTRYEN (ankere er en NEDRE grense, tiende gang): Kilder #1 sa 'Status: GA (public preview for some features)' to linjer under sin egen tittel som slutter paa '(preview)'. Banneret dekker hele funksjonen -> falskt, ikke bare upresist. Kilde #9 lagt til, 9-15 renummerert 10-16, Total kilder 15 -> 16. Trygt paa maaling: grep over linje 1-794 gav NULL prosa-kryssreferanser til kildenummer. Formen bevarer ogsaa telle-paastandens referent (teller entries, 16 entries / 9 URL-er), mens 'andre URL under #1' ville gitt 16 URL-er mot 15 entries - klassen idx-26j nettopp bokfoerte. RETTELSE: §9.12 (og idx-26j locator 5, og STATE) maalte **Status:** over ALLE 434 forekomster under skills/*/references/ - som blander header-feltet paa linje 4 med 47 SEKSJONSNIVAA-linjer i filkropper. To felt, to referenter, ett tall. Header-feltet alene (FNR<=10): 387 forekomster / 389 filer, 69 distinkte. GA 249 (ikke 252), Preview 1 (ikke 2), Komplett 1 (ikke 2). To-vokabular-funnet OVERLEVER rettelsen. Konsekvensen gjoer det ikke: 'setter konvensjonen for 389 filer ved uhell' er FALSK - 69 distinkte verdier, ~44 singletons, 35+ sammensatte GA/Preview-former. En sann sammensatt verdi SLUTTER SEG TIL etablert praksis. Paastanden som staar er smalere: fila hadde alt valgt produkttilgjengelighets-aksen, og editen gjorde dens valgte akse sann. Bokfoert, ikke reparert: idx-26k (denne filas fottekst, 3+2+1=6 - samme klasse som idx-26j locator 1, som BEKREFTER som maalt det 26j bare kunne kalle sannsynlig) + idx-26j re-scopet (locator 5 er ikke lenger blokkert paa korpusbeslutning; formen er naa presedens). **Last updated:** urort - verifisert at null av elleve tidligere ratifiserte korpus-editer rorte feltet. Koe: 8 aapne / 11 resolved. Suite 1047/1047. [skip-docs]
This commit is contained in:
parent
0470674801
commit
96639f7e52
3 changed files with 125 additions and 15 deletions
|
|
@ -1494,3 +1494,93 @@ file spans Transparency Notes (GA), Model Cards (practice) and the scorecard (pu
|
|||
preview) at once. **So idx-26g's header question is not local to either file — it is a
|
||||
corpus-wide field-semantics decision, and settling it one file at a time would set the
|
||||
convention by accident.**
|
||||
|
||||
### 9.13 idx-26g closed — and §9.12's own corpus measurement was taken over the wrong population
|
||||
|
||||
**The entry was right about the sources this time.** Both pages it names carry the Important
|
||||
banner verbatim — *"This feature is currently in public preview. This preview version is
|
||||
provided without a service-level agreement, and we don't recommend it for production
|
||||
workloads."* — and both titles read "(preview)". Fetched live 2026-08-09 rather than taken on
|
||||
the entry's word, because §9.12's lesson was that an entry can overstate its own evidence.
|
||||
|
||||
**The two decisions were independent, and the entry bundled them.** The banner sits on
|
||||
`concept-responsible-ai-scorecard`, which is *already* this file's Kilder #1. So the preview
|
||||
fact needed **no new citation at all**; only the seven-segment enumeration needed
|
||||
`how-to-responsible-ai-scorecard`. Separating them meant the ratification question could put
|
||||
the a/b/c citation choice where it actually belonged instead of letting a citation decision
|
||||
gate a status correction.
|
||||
|
||||
**Ratified:** header `**Status:** GA` → `**Status:** GA / Preview (Responsible AI scorecard)`,
|
||||
and the how-to page added as Verified source #9 with 9–15 renumbered to 10–16, `**Total
|
||||
kilder**` 15 → 16. The parenthetical form was chosen over the terser `varies by feature`
|
||||
after checking all six corpus files in the `X / Preview (Y)` family: in every one, the
|
||||
parenthetical names *what is in preview*, never the GA surface. Renumbering was safe on
|
||||
measurement, not assumption — grep over lines 1–794 found **zero** prose cross-references to
|
||||
source numbers. The chosen form also preserves the counting claim's pre-existing referent: it
|
||||
still counts numbered entries (16 entries, 9 carrying URLs), whereas the "second URL under
|
||||
Kilder #1" form would have left the file holding 16 URLs against 15 entries — the undefined-
|
||||
referent class idx-26j had booked one commit earlier.
|
||||
|
||||
**The stamp was re-dated deliberately, because otherwise this edit would have authored the
|
||||
idx-26h defect.** §1's stamp read `2026-08-04`. Adding a sentence written on 2026-08-09
|
||||
underneath it would have produced text sitting under a verification date five days its senior
|
||||
— *"the stamp was false when it was set, not stale."* Re-dating claims all of §1, so all of §1
|
||||
was re-measured against both live pages: the seven segments map 1:1 to the how-to page's "How
|
||||
to read your scorecard"; `Du konfigurerer` matches the concept page's "target accuracy and
|
||||
target error rate"; the Formål bullets match its three unaddressed-needs bullets; the Verdi
|
||||
bullets match "building trust and gaining their approval for deployment"; and the YAML
|
||||
workflow block, the one piece that is synthesis rather than quotation, has every step grounded
|
||||
in "Who should use a Responsible AI scorecard?".
|
||||
|
||||
**A third locator the entry did not name.** Kilder #1 read `Status: GA (public preview for
|
||||
some features)` — two lines below its own title ending in "(preview)". The banner covers the
|
||||
whole feature, so this was false rather than merely imprecise. Anchors are a lower bound,
|
||||
tenth instance.
|
||||
|
||||
#### The correction: §9.12 measured `**Status:**` over the wrong population
|
||||
|
||||
§9.12 (and idx-26j's fifth locator, and the STATE hand-off built on both) reported the field's
|
||||
value space as `GA` 252 · `Preview` 2 · `Komplett` 2 alongside `Established Practice` 43 ·
|
||||
`Gjeldende` 18 · `Reference` 7. Those counts were taken over **every** `**Status:**` occurrence
|
||||
under `skills/*/references/` — 434 of them — which silently merges the line-4 header field with
|
||||
**47 section-level `**Status:**` lines inside file bodies**. Two different fields, two different
|
||||
referents, one number.
|
||||
|
||||
Re-measured on the header field alone (`FNR<=10`): **387 occurrences over 389 files, 69
|
||||
distinct values.** Corrected: `GA` **249** (not 252) · `Preview` **1** (not 2) · `Komplett`
|
||||
**1** (not 2). `Established Practice` 43, `Gjeldende` 18 and `Reference` 7 hold as stated.
|
||||
|
||||
The two-vocabulary finding **survives the correction** — document maturity and product
|
||||
availability genuinely are mixed in one field, and that observation was right. What does not
|
||||
survive is the *consequence*: **"settling it one file at a time would set the convention by
|
||||
accident" is false.** The header field carries 69 distinct values over 387 files, roughly 44 of
|
||||
them appearing exactly once, and 35+ are compound GA/Preview forms. There is no single
|
||||
convention available to be set by accident; an accurate compound value *joins* an established
|
||||
practice. The claim that survives is narrower and does not need a corpus-wide decision to
|
||||
license the edit: **this file had already chosen the product-availability axis for its header,
|
||||
and the edit made its chosen axis truthful.** Choosing an axis for 389 files was never on the
|
||||
table.
|
||||
|
||||
This is the §9.11 defect class turned on the *measurement* rather than the resolution — a
|
||||
premise measured over a population wider than the field it was reporting on. The cheapest
|
||||
ground-truth check (`FNR<=10`) was cheaper than the corpus-wide operator decision it would
|
||||
have triggered.
|
||||
|
||||
#### Booked rather than repaired
|
||||
|
||||
- **idx-26k (new).** This file's footer reads `**MCP calls gjennomført**: 5 (3 docs_search, 2
|
||||
docs_fetch, 1 code_sample_search)` — components summing to 6. Same class as idx-26j's first
|
||||
locator in the sibling, different wording and different field name. That **confirms as
|
||||
measured** what idx-26j could only call likely: the footer form is replicated. Not repaired
|
||||
here, because the referent is undefined in the same way (historical generation run, or
|
||||
current provenance?) and idx-26j owns the form decision. Changing 5 to 6 would pick a
|
||||
referent by stealth.
|
||||
- **idx-26j re-scoped.** Its fifth locator is no longer blocked on a corpus-wide decision: the
|
||||
form is now precedent. Its header (`**Status:** GA`, spanning Transparency Notes GA, Model
|
||||
Cards practice, scorecard preview) is false the same way, and a divergence from the ratified
|
||||
form would now be *introduced* by that entry rather than inherited.
|
||||
- **Untouched, on precedent:** `**Last updated:**` — verified that zero of the eleven prior
|
||||
ratified corpus edits modified that field. `Verifisert: 2026-02` on sources 1–8 — those pages
|
||||
were not re-fetched.
|
||||
|
||||
**Queue:** 8 open / 11 resolved. **Suite:** 1047/1047.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue