# Known limitations of v1 The review of v1 (06.11.2026) found 2 BLOCKER and 48 MAJOR findings. Both BLOCKERs and the MAJOR findings that are defects were fixed, each with a test. The MAJOR findings below were accepted: each one is a gap or a limitation, not wrong behaviour on the build path, and the reason is given. The finding numbers are the review's own order. ## Guards that work but have no test of their own The guard exists and was read in the code; what is missing is a test that would catch a regression in it. | # | Where | Untested guard | |---|---|---| | 12 | `gates/answers.py` | breach rules for find actions, `sed -i`, absolute Glob patterns, unparseable Bash | | 14 | `gates/answerset.py` | gate on the held-out set; the threshold refusal; freeze without `subset_of` | | 15 | `gates/calibration.py` | the layout's refusal when too few distinct fillers remain; duplicate call names | | 18 | `gates/repair_gate.py` | the fix-case judgement (diff, excerpts, findings) on a handmade result | | 27 | `okfwiki/kassemble.py` | refusal of reserved (`index`, `log`) or unsafe concept ids | | 28 | `okfwiki/kassemble.py` | the stop after an unfinished swap (`.-old` left behind) | | 31 | `okfwiki/kmerge.py` | the marked write: backup, marker and the recovery stop | | 34 | `okfwiki/kpack.py` | refusals to overwrite parts, home tasks, logs and the floor file | | 36 | `okfwiki/krepair.py` | `unknown-key` and `ambiguous-key` refusals in `task` and `fix` | | 37 | `okfwiki/krepair.py` | `relink --work` and its logged `moved` record | | 40 | `okfwiki/sources.py` | freeze's refusal of a bad name, a folder and a symlink; some `check` refusals | ## Measurement tooling | # | Where | Limitation | Why accepted | |---|---|---|---| | 13 | `gates/answerset.py`, `gates/multidoc.py` | run from a git worktree nested in the main checkout, a held-out path in the main checkout is not refused | run the answer-set tools from the main checkout | | 16 | `gates/calibration.py`, `okfwiki/reader.py` | the gate reads the verdicts file twice (the green-run record now has one shared parser) | extra reading, not a wrong result | | 22 | `okfwiki/cost.py` | user text between an unrecorded message and the next is counted as derived output | it can only raise measured cost, so the cost stop comes earlier, never later | | 23 | `okfwiki/cost.py` | derived output before the first helper is projected per batch | it can only raise the projection, which is reported, not used to stop | | 25 | `okfwiki/cost.py` | `cost isolation` takes no list of breaches set aside | the rule that asked for it was removed with the rule cut of 06.11.2026 | | 26 | `okfwiki/cost.py` | the read and diagnose breach count looks only at Read calls | the reader and diagnoser agents are given the Read tool only | ## Other | # | Where | Limitation | Why accepted | |---|---|---|---| | 3 | git history | three merge commits (62d5438, 73e5bf7, ad63d41) are not Conventional Commits | published history is not rewritten; later merges use `merge(...)` | | 39 | `okfwiki/reader.py` | when `collect --gate-passed` refuses a model, an older verdicts file at `--out` is left in place | `collect` exits 1, and the skill then runs the calibration gate on that model before anything is scored; deleting the earlier file would destroy a valid reading |