okf-wiki/gates/calibration-folder/draft.json
Kjell Tore Guttormsen 0fd86a23a3
okf-wiki 1.1.1
First public release, published as one snapshot. What changed between
versions is in CHANGELOG.md.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-14 21:03:20 +01:00

9421 lines
No EOL
404 KiB
JSON
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

{
"schema": "okf-wiki/calibration-draft/1",
"pairs": [
{
"id": "en1a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Whenever they are in the building, members can bring as many as two guests at once.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Members may bring up to two guests at a time, but only during staffed open sessions."
}
],
"why": "Guests are allowed only during staffed open sessions, not whenever a member is in the building."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u01",
"claim": "During staffed open sessions, members can bring as many as two guests at once.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Members may bring up to two guests at a time, but only during staffed open sessions."
}
],
"why": "Restates the two-guest limit and the staffed-session condition."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Completed inductions rose by 73 from one year to the next, reaching 360 in 2025–26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Members completed 360 inductions in 2025–26, against 297 the year before."
}
],
"why": "360 minus 297 is 63, not 73."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en1a-u02",
"claim": "Completed inductions rose by 63 from one year to the next, reaching 360 in 2025–26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Members completed 360 inductions in 2025–26, against 297 the year before."
}
],
"why": "360 minus 297 is 63."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Voting is open to every member who joined at least three months earlier.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Only Full and Concession members who joined at least three months ago may vote."
}
],
"why": "Only Full and Concession members may vote, not every member."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u03",
"claim": "Voting is open to Full and Concession members who joined at least three months earlier.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Only Full and Concession members who joined at least three months ago may vote."
}
],
"why": "Restates the tier and three-month conditions for voting."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "EL-01 is a set of four 80 W soldering stations that may only be used with lead-free solder supplied by the makerspace.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: EL-01 | B: Soldering stations (4) | C: Electronics bench | D: 2018 | E: 480 | F: 320 | G: Electronics bench | H: In service | I: Kwame Lindqvist | J: Four stations of 80 W each; lead-free solder only"
}
],
"why": "The row says lead-free solder only but nothing about who supplies it.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from its fixed twin, which no longer reads the unlabelled column C as the stations' location."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u04",
"claim": "EL-01 is a set of four 80 W soldering stations that may only be used with lead-free solder.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: EL-01 | B: Soldering stations (4) | C: Electronics bench | D: 2018 | E: 480 | F: 320 | G: Electronics bench | H: In service | I: Kwame Lindqvist | J: Four stations of 80 W each; lead-free solder only"
}
],
"why": "The row gives four 80 W stations at the electronics bench and lead-free solder only.",
"audit": "FIX: \"The electronics bench has\" rests on reading the unlabelled column C as a location, which the row alone does not state; the new wording uses only B and J."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Restricting fob access to 07:00–23:00 from 1 June 2025 led to three noise complaints from residents of the flats above Copperfold Yard.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "From 1 June 2025 fob access has been limited to 07:00– 23:00 every day, because three noise complaints were received from residents of the flats above Copperfold Yard between February and April 2025."
}
],
"why": "The complaints caused the restriction, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u05",
"claim": "Three noise complaints from residents of the flats above Copperfold Yard led to fob access being restricted to 07:00–23:00 from 1 June 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "From 1 June 2025 fob access has been limited to 07:00– 23:00 every day, because three noise complaints were received from residents of the flats above Copperfold Yard between February and April 2025."
}
],
"why": "The restriction was made because of the three complaints."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "A membership can be paused for at most three months in any twelve-month period, but the monthly fee is still charged while it is paused.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "You may pause your membership for up to 3 months in any 12-month period, for example while travelling or during illness. No fee is due during a pause, but you must empty your storage box unless you pay £3 a month to keep it."
}
],
"why": "No fee is due during a pause."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u06",
"claim": "A membership can be paused for at most three months in any twelve-month period, and no fee is charged while it is paused.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "You may pause your membership for up to 3 months in any 12-month period, for example while travelling or during illness. No fee is due during a pause, but you must empty your storage box unless you pay £3 a month to keep it."
}
],
"why": "Restates the pause limit and that no fee is due during a pause."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The 60 W CO2 laser cutter LC-01 had its tube replaced in February 2026 at a cost of £1,280.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: LC-01 | B: Laser cutter, 60 W CO2, bed 900 x 600 mm | C: Laser room | D: 2019 | E: 6800 | F: 1200 | G: Laser cutter | H: In service | I: Joss Tannery | J: Tube replaced February 2026 for £1,180; bed and one lens replaced after the fire on 12 August 2025"
}
],
"why": "The tube replacement cost £1,180, not £1,280."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u07",
"claim": "The 60 W CO2 laser cutter LC-01 had its tube replaced in February 2026 at a cost of £1,180.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: LC-01 | B: Laser cutter, 60 W CO2, bed 900 x 600 mm | C: Laser room | D: 2019 | E: 6800 | F: 1200 | G: Laser cutter | H: In service | I: Joss Tannery | J: Tube replaced February 2026 for £1,180; bed and one lens replaced after the fire on 12 August 2025"
}
],
"why": "The row's notes give the February 2026 tube replacement for £1,180."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Although members are allowed to stay on until 23:00, every machine has to be off by 22:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "For the same reason, the noisy machines (the table saw, planer-thicknesser, router table, mitre saw and dust extractor) must be switched off by 22:00, even though members may stay until 23:00."
}
],
"why": "The 22:00 cut-off applies only to the listed noisy machines, not to every machine.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from its fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u08",
"claim": "Although members are allowed to stay on until 23:00, the noisy machines (table saw, planer-thicknesser, router table, mitre saw and dust extractor) have to be off by 22:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "For the same reason, the noisy machines (the table saw, planer-thicknesser, router table, mitre saw and dust extractor) must be switched off by 22:00, even though members may stay until 23:00."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 22:00 rule for the listed noisy machines and the 23:00 stay.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim follows the excerpt word for word in the same order with synonyms swapped (a near copy) and adds \"in the building\", a scope the excerpt does not give."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "FDM printer 3D-01 stands on the steel fire shelf, and overnight prints are not permitted on it.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 3D-01 | B: FDM printer, bed 250 x 250 mm | C: 3D printing | D: 2020 | E: 450 | F: 350 | G: FDM 3D printing | H: In service | I: Ruth Abernethy-Quint | J: On the steel fire shelf; overnight prints allowed"
}
],
"why": "The row says overnight prints are allowed."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u09",
"claim": "FDM printer 3D-01 stands on the steel fire shelf, and overnight prints are permitted on it.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 3D-01 | B: FDM printer, bed 250 x 250 mm | C: 3D printing | D: 2020 | E: 450 | F: 350 | G: FDM 3D printing | H: In service | I: Ruth Abernethy-Quint | J: On the steel fire shelf; overnight prints allowed"
}
],
"why": "The row's notes say it is on the steel fire shelf and overnight prints are allowed."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The rise approved on 14 June 2026 was the reason electricity costs went up 19 per cent and insurance 15 per cent.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The rise was approved on 14 June 2026 because electricity costs rose 19 per cent and insurance 15 per cent."
}
],
"why": "The cost increases caused the rise, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u10",
"claim": "Increases of 19 per cent in electricity costs and 15 per cent in insurance were the reason for the rise approved on 14 June 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The rise was approved on 14 June 2026 because electricity costs rose 19 per cent and insurance 15 per cent."
}
],
"why": "The rise was approved because of those two cost increases."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Students in full-time education, members aged 65 or over and members on a low income can take Concession membership, with low income declared by the members themselves and checked by the treasurer once a year.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Concession membership is open to students in full-time education, to members aged 65 or over and to members on a low income, who self-declare."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the self-declaration is checked by the treasurer or yearly."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1a-u11",
"claim": "Students in full-time education, members aged 65 or over and members on a low income can take Concession membership, with low income declared by the members themselves.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Concession membership is open to students in full-time education, to members aged 65 or over and to members on a low income, who self-declare."
}
],
"why": "Restates the three eligible groups and the self-declaration."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Besides the Wednesday session from 13:00 to 16:00, the makerspace holds a staffed Saturday session from 10:00 to 16:00, which began on 7 January 2026 and averaged 11 attendees.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The new Wednesday session from 13:00 to 16:00 started on 7 January 2026 and averaged 11 attendees."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Staffed open sessions: Tuesday and Thursday 18:00–21:30, Wednesday 13:00–16:00 and Saturday 10:00–16:00."
}
],
"why": "The 7 January 2026 start and the 11-attendee average belong to the Wednesday session, not the Saturday one."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1a-u12",
"claim": "Besides the Saturday session from 10:00 to 16:00, the makerspace holds a staffed Wednesday session from 13:00 to 16:00, which began on 7 January 2026 and averaged 11 attendees.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The new Wednesday session from 13:00 to 16:00 started on 7 January 2026 and averaged 11 attendees."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Staffed open sessions: Tuesday and Thursday 18:00–21:30, Wednesday 13:00–16:00 and Saturday 10:00–16:00."
}
],
"why": "The handbook gives the Saturday hours and the slides give the Wednesday session's start and attendance."
},
{
"id": "en1a-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The table saw induction lasts 1.5 hours, and on 1 October 2026 there were 46 members waiting for it, with an average wait of 9 weeks.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The table shows the length of each induction and how many were completed in each of the last two years. Induction Length Completed 2024–25 Completed 2025–26 Woodshop basic 3 hours 81 96 Table saw 1.5 hours 36 41"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "On 1 October 2026, 46 members were waiting for woodshop basic, with an average wait of 9 weeks."
}
],
"why": "The waiting list of 46 members and the 9-week wait are for woodshop basic, not the table saw induction."
},
{
"id": "en1a-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1a-u13",
"claim": "The woodshop basic induction lasts 3 hours, and on 1 October 2026 there were 46 members waiting for it, with an average wait of 9 weeks.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The table shows the length of each induction and how many were completed in each of the last two years. Induction Length Completed 2024–25 Completed 2025–26 Woodshop basic 3 hours 81 96 Table saw 1.5 hours 36 41"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "On 1 October 2026, 46 members were waiting for woodshop basic, with an average wait of 9 weeks."
}
],
"why": "The report gives woodshop basic's 3-hour length and the slides give its waiting list."
},
{
"id": "en1a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "The 260 mm planer-thicknesser WS-09, built in 2011 and donated in 2017, was retired in October 2025 after its motor failed the month before.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: WS-09 | B: Planer-thicknesser, 260 mm | C: Woodshop | D: 2017 | E: 0 | F: 1500 | G: None | H: Retired | I: Ines Calloway | J: Built 2011 and donated 2017; motor failed September 2025; retired October 2025"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the build and donation years, the September 2025 motor failure and the October 2025 retirement."
},
{
"id": "en1a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Over the year to 31 March 2026 the membership grew by 27, to 214.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "We had 214 members on 31 March 2026, up from 187 a year earlier."
}
],
"why": "214 minus 187 is 27."
},
{
"id": "en1a-s03",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "The table saw WS-01 must never run at the same time as WS-03, which is the 310 mm planer-thicknesser bought in October 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: WS-01 | B: Table saw, 254 mm blade | C: Woodshop | D: 2018 | E: 1890 | F: 2000 | G: Table saw | H: In service | I: Ines Calloway | J: Two-person rule; never run at the same time as WS-03"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: WS-03 | B: Planer-thicknesser, 310 mm | C: Woodshop | D: 2025 | E: 2950 | F: 2200 | G: Planer-thicknesser and router table | H: In service | I: Ines Calloway | J: Bought October 2025 to replace WS-09; two-person rule"
}
],
"why": "WS-01's row forbids running with WS-03, and WS-03's row identifies it as the 310 mm planer-thicknesser bought in October 2025."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The operator's induction was put on hold for 60 days, and the laser was unusable for 4 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The laser was out of use for 4 days and the operator's induction was suspended for 30 days."
}
],
"why": "The induction was suspended for 30 days; 60 appears nowhere.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewording follows the twin t01 fix so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u01",
"claim": "The operator's induction was put on hold for 30 days, and the laser was unusable for 4 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The laser was out of use for 4 days and the operator's induction was suspended for 30 days."
}
],
"why": "Both durations, 30 days of suspension and 4 days out of use, are stated.",
"audit": "FIX: The first clause was a verbatim copy of the excerpt's second clause; reworded."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "The Wexcombe Community Trust's £3,000 grant was barred from being spent on dust extraction.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "A £3,000 grant from the Wexcombe Community Trust could only be spent on dust extraction."
}
],
"why": "The grant could ONLY be spent on dust extraction, the opposite of being barred from it."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u02",
"claim": "The Wexcombe Community Trust's £3,000 grant was restricted to being spent on dust extraction.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "A £3,000 grant from the Wexcombe Community Trust could only be spent on dust extraction."
}
],
"why": "'Could only be spent on dust extraction' means the grant was restricted to that purpose."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The supply is single-phase because the table saw and the planer-thicknesser cannot be run simultaneously.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The single-phase supply means the table saw and planer-thicknesser cannot run at the same time."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the single-phase supply is why the two machines cannot run together, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u03",
"claim": "The table saw and the planer-thicknesser cannot be run simultaneously because the supply is single-phase.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The single-phase supply means the table saw and planer-thicknesser cannot run at the same time."
}
],
"why": "The single-phase supply is stated as the reason the two machines cannot run at the same time."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Members logged 17 incidents in 2025–26, which was 8 fewer than the 23 logged in 2024–25.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Members recorded 17 incidents in the incident book in 2025–26, down from 23 in 2024–25."
}
],
"why": "23 minus 17 is 6, not 8."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en1b-u04",
"claim": "Members logged 17 incidents in 2025–26, which was 6 fewer than the 23 logged in 2024–25.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Members recorded 17 incidents in the incident book in 2025–26, down from 23 in 2024–25."
}
],
"why": "23 minus 17 gives 6 fewer incidents."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The rise in total income from £60,240 in 2024–25 to £69,010 in 2025–26 was the main reason the membership grew.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Total income rose from £60,240 in 2024–25 to £69,010 in 2025–26, mainly because of the larger membership."
}
],
"why": "The larger membership caused the income rise, not the reverse."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u05",
"claim": "The growth in membership was the main reason total income went up from £60,240 in 2024–25 to £69,010 in 2025–26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Total income rose from £60,240 in 2024–25 to £69,010 in 2025–26, mainly because of the larger membership."
}
],
"why": "The rise is attributed mainly to the larger membership."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Junior Saturdays, aimed at children aged 8 to 13, took place from 10:00 to 12:00 on the first and third Saturday of every month, and a parent had to stay for the whole session.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Junior Saturdays for children aged 8 to 13 ran on the first and third Saturday of each month from 10:00 to 12:00."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about a parent having to stay."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u06",
"claim": "Junior Saturdays, aimed at children aged 8 to 13, took place from 10:00 to 12:00 on the first and third Saturday of every month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Junior Saturdays for children aged 8 to 13 ran on the first and third Saturday of each month from 10:00 to 12:00."
}
],
"why": "Age range, days and times are all stated."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Gloves must not be worn when operating any machine in the workshop.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Do not wear gloves when using the table saw, the bandsaw or the pillar drill."
}
],
"why": "The glove ban covers only the table saw, the bandsaw and the pillar drill, not every machine."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u07",
"claim": "Gloves must not be worn when operating the table saw, the bandsaw or the pillar drill.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Do not wear gloves when using the table saw, the bandsaw or the pillar drill."
}
],
"why": "The three machines named are exactly those where gloves are forbidden."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "A 30-minute refresher can renew a lapsed induction only when it lapsed more than 12 months ago; otherwise the full induction has to be done again.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "A lapsed induction can be renewed with a 30-minute refresher, but only if it lapsed less than 12 months ago; after that, the full induction must be repeated."
}
],
"why": "The refresher applies only when the lapse is LESS than 12 months old; the claim reverses the condition."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u08",
"claim": "A 30-minute refresher can renew a lapsed induction only when it lapsed under 12 months ago; otherwise the full induction has to be done again.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "A lapsed induction can be renewed with a 30-minute refresher, but only if it lapsed less than 12 months ago; after that, the full induction must be repeated."
}
],
"why": "Restates the under-12-months condition for the refresher and the full repeat after that."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Damage or a fault must be reported straight away by attaching a red 'do not use' tag to the machine, making an entry in the fault book and telling the area lead.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Report any damage or fault at once by fixing a red 'do not use' tag to the machine and writing in the fault book."
}
],
"why": "Telling the area lead is not part of the stated reporting procedure."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u09",
"claim": "Damage or a fault must be reported straight away by attaching a red 'do not use' tag to the machine and making an entry in the fault book.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Report any damage or fault at once by fixing a red 'do not use' tag to the machine and writing in the fault book."
}
],
"why": "The tag and the fault-book entry are the two reporting steps given."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "On 15 September 2026, M-0233 passed a laser refresher; their induction had lapsed after 8 months, as their last laser use was in March 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026-09-15 | B: M-0233 | C: Full | D: Laser refresher | E: 30 | F: Joss Tannery | G: 0 | H: Passed | I: 6 | J: Last laser use March 2026, so the induction had lapsed after 6 months"
}
],
"why": "The row says the induction lapsed after 6 months; 8 appears nowhere.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewording follows the twin t10 fix so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u10",
"claim": "On 15 September 2026, M-0233 passed a laser refresher; their induction had lapsed after 6 months, as their last laser use was in March 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026-09-15 | B: M-0233 | C: Full | D: Laser refresher | E: 30 | F: Joss Tannery | G: 0 | H: Passed | I: 6 | J: Last laser use March 2026, so the induction had lapsed after 6 months"
}
],
"why": "Date, member, refresher, result and the 6-month lapse after March 2026 use are all in the row.",
"audit": "FIX: The causal 'needed because' link and 'Member' go beyond what the header-less row shows; reworded to the row's own content."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Every item in the textile corner must be switched off and unplugged when you leave the corner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TX-04 | B: Steam iron and board | C: Textile corner | D: 2022 | E: 85 | F: 2400 | G: None | H: In service | I: Hettie Galbraith | J: Switch off and unplug when leaving the corner"
}
],
"why": "The switch-off-and-unplug note applies to the steam iron and board (TX-04) only, not to all textile-corner equipment."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1b-u11",
"claim": "The steam iron and board in the textile corner must be switched off and unplugged when you leave the corner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TX-04 | B: Steam iron and board | C: Textile corner | D: 2022 | E: 85 | F: 2400 | G: None | H: In service | I: Hettie Galbraith | J: Switch off and unplug when leaving the corner"
}
],
"why": "The note on the TX-04 steam iron and board row says to switch off and unplug it when leaving the corner."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The embroidery machine bought in March 2026 takes hoops of up to 300 x 300 mm, while the two FDM printers bought in November 2025 have 200 x 300 mm beds.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TX-03 | B: Embroidery machine, max hoop 200 x 300 mm | C: Textile corner | D: 2026 | E: 1650 | F: 90 | G: Overlocker and embroidery machine | H: In service | I: Hettie Galbraith | J: Bought March 2026; bookable for up to 3 hours at a time"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Two FDM 3D printers with 300 × 300 mm beds, bought in November 2025 for £1,240 in total."
}
],
"why": "The sizes are swapped: the embroidery machine's maximum hoop is 200 x 300 mm and the printers' beds are 300 x 300 mm."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1b-u12",
"claim": "The embroidery machine bought in March 2026 takes hoops of up to 200 x 300 mm, while the two FDM printers bought in November 2025 have 300 x 300 mm beds.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TX-03 | B: Embroidery machine, max hoop 200 x 300 mm | C: Textile corner | D: 2026 | E: 1650 | F: 90 | G: Overlocker and embroidery machine | H: In service | I: Hettie Galbraith | J: Bought March 2026; bookable for up to 3 hours at a time"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Two FDM 3D printers with 300 × 300 mm beds, bought in November 2025 for £1,240 in total."
}
],
"why": "The register row gives the hoop size and March 2026 purchase; the report gives the printers' bed size and November 2025 purchase."
},
{
"id": "en1b-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The laser was booked for 81 per cent of its bookable hours in 2025–26, while at least one first-aid certificate holder was present at 87 per cent of staffed open sessions.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The laser was booked for 87 per cent of bookable hours in 2025–26."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Nine members hold a current first-aid certificate, and at least one of them was present at 81 per cent of staffed open sessions during the year."
}
],
"why": "The percentages are swapped: 87 per cent is the laser booking rate and 81 per cent is first-aid presence."
},
{
"id": "en1b-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1b-u13",
"claim": "The laser was booked for 87 per cent of its bookable hours in 2025–26, while at least one first-aid certificate holder was present at 81 per cent of staffed open sessions.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The laser was booked for 87 per cent of bookable hours in 2025–26."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Nine members hold a current first-aid certificate, and at least one of them was present at 81 per cent of staffed open sessions during the year."
}
],
"why": "The slides give the 87 per cent laser booking rate and the report the 81 per cent first-aid presence."
},
{
"id": "en1b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Safety glasses are required at all times in both the woodshop and the laser room, including for anyone who is not running a machine.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Wear safety glasses in the woodshop and the laser room at all times, even when you are not operating a machine."
}
],
"why": "Same rule in other words: always, in both rooms, even when not operating a machine."
},
{
"id": "en1b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Together, the new laser tube and the blades, belts, filters and small tools came to £3,585.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The largest single item was a new laser tube, fitted in February 2026 at a cost of £1,180 after the old tube had logged about 2,300 firing hours. Blades, belts, filters and small tools made up the remaining £2,405."
}
],
"why": "£1,180 for the tube plus the remaining £2,405 makes £3,585."
},
{
"id": "en1b-s03",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Unit 11, at 410 square metres, has more than twice the floor area of Unit 4.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Unit 11 is a ground-floor unit of 410 square metres, about 900 metres from Copperfold Yard."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Unit 4 has only 186 square metres and no room for more benches."
}
],
"why": "Twice 186 is 372, which is less than 410."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Hearing protection is required when operating any machine in the makerspace.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Wear hearing protection when using the table saw, planer-thicknesser, router table or mitre saw."
}
],
"why": "Hearing protection is required only for four named machines, not for every machine."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u01",
"claim": "Hearing protection is required when operating the mitre saw, the router table, the planer-thicknesser or the table saw.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Wear hearing protection when using the table saw, planer-thicknesser, router table or mitre saw."
}
],
"why": "The same four machines are listed as needing hearing protection."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Unit 4 has a single-phase supply because running the table saw and the planer-thicknesser together trips the main breaker.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Because the supply in Unit 4 is single-phase, the table saw and the planer-thicknesser must never run at the same time; doing so trips the main breaker."
}
],
"why": "The single-phase supply is the cause of the breaker tripping, not its consequence."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u02",
"claim": "Unit 4's single-phase supply is the reason the table saw and the planer-thicknesser must not be run together, since doing so trips the main breaker.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Because the supply in Unit 4 is single-phase, the table saw and the planer-thicknesser must never run at the same time; doing so trips the main breaker."
}
],
"why": "The rule is stated as a consequence of the single-phase supply, and running both trips the breaker."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Switching on the fume extractor has to happen only after the laser begins to fire.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "The fume extractor must be switched on before the laser starts firing."
}
],
"why": "The extractor must be switched on before the laser starts firing, not after.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded together with its twin t03 so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u03",
"claim": "Switching on the fume extractor has to happen before the laser begins to fire.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "The fume extractor must be switched on before the laser starts firing."
}
],
"why": "It restates that the extractor is switched on before firing starts.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy of the excerpt (same order, only synonyms swapped) and 'the laser's' adds an ownership the excerpt does not state."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Paid for out of the move fund, the Unit 11 electrical survey and design makes up the whole of the £14,200 three-phase job.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Electrical survey and design, Unit 11 | B: Expenditure | C: 4500 | D: 0 | E: Sunniva Okafor | F: First part of the £14,200 three-phase work; paid from the move fund"
}
],
"why": "The survey and design is only the first part of the £14,200 three-phase work, not all of it.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded together with its twin t04 so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u04",
"claim": "Paid for out of the move fund, the Unit 11 electrical survey and design makes up the opening portion of the £14,200 three-phase job.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Electrical survey and design, Unit 11 | B: Expenditure | C: 4500 | D: 0 | E: Sunniva Okafor | F: First part of the £14,200 three-phase work; paid from the move fund"
}
],
"why": "The row's note calls it the first part of the £14,200 three-phase work, paid from the move fund.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim copies column F nearly word for word after the row name; reworded."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Each Junior Saturdays session takes up to 15 children, who pay £4 each.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Junior Saturdays | B: Income | C: 900 | D: 784 | E: Hettie Galbraith | F: £4 per child; at most 12 children per session"
}
],
"why": "The cap is 12 children per session, not 15.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded together with its twin t05 so the pair stays one change apart; 15 still does not occur in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u05",
"claim": "Each Junior Saturdays session takes up to 12 children, who pay £4 each.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Junior Saturdays | B: Income | C: 900 | D: 784 | E: Hettie Galbraith | F: £4 per child; at most 12 children per session"
}
],
"why": "The row's note gives £4 per child and at most 12 children per session.",
"audit": "FIX: Same order as column F with only two words swapped, which counts as a copy; reworded."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "The deposit for Unit 11, two months' rent at £3,900, falls due in February 2027 and comes out of the move fund rather than the operating budget.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Deposit for Unit 11 | B: Expenditure | C: 7800 | D: 0 | E: Sunniva Okafor | F: Two months' rent at £3,900; due February 2027; paid from the operating budget, not the move fund"
}
],
"why": "The deposit is paid from the operating budget, not the move fund."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u06",
"claim": "The deposit for Unit 11, two months' rent at £3,900, falls due in February 2027 and comes out of the operating budget rather than the move fund.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Deposit for Unit 11 | B: Expenditure | C: 7800 | D: 0 | E: Sunniva Okafor | F: Two months' rent at £3,900; due February 2027; paid from the operating budget, not the move fund"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says two months' rent at £3,900, due February 2027, paid from the operating budget and not the move fund."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The proposal would raise both the Concession fee and the Associate fee by £3 each.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Concession would rise from £18 to £20, and Associate from £12 to £14."
}
],
"why": "Both fees rise by £2 (18 to 20 and 12 to 14), not £3."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en1c-u07",
"claim": "The proposal would raise both the Concession fee and the Associate fee by £2 each.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Concession would rise from £18 to £20, and Associate from £12 to £14."
}
],
"why": "£18 to £20 and £12 to £14 are each a £2 rise."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "In the event that the landlord extends the Unit 4 lease past 30 September 2027, the committee will turn the move down.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "If the move is rejected, the committee will ask the landlord to extend the Unit 4 lease beyond 30 September 2027."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the committee asks for an extension if members reject the move, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded together with its twin t08 so the pair stays one swap apart."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u08",
"claim": "In the event that the move is turned down, the committee will seek an extension of the Unit 4 lease from the landlord to run past 30 September 2027.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "If the move is rejected, the committee will ask the landlord to extend the Unit 4 lease beyond 30 September 2027."
}
],
"why": "A rejected move leads the committee to seek an extension of the Unit 4 lease beyond 30 September 2027.",
"audit": "FIX: Same words in the same order as the excerpt with only 'If'->'Should' and 'beyond'->'past' swapped, which counts as a copy; reworded."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "The sole candidate for chair is Sunniva Okafor, who headed the search for new premises and has served on the committee for six years.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Sunniva Okafor, who led the search for new premises, is the only candidate for chair."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about how long Sunniva Okafor has served on the committee."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u09",
"claim": "The sole candidate for chair is Sunniva Okafor, who headed the search for new premises.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Sunniva Okafor, who led the search for new premises, is the only candidate for chair."
}
],
"why": "She led the search for new premises and is the only candidate for chair."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Both the 23:00 end of fob access and the 22:00 stop for noisy machines are due to the single-phase power supply.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Power: the supply is single-phase, so the table saw and the planer-thicknesser cannot run at the same time without tripping the main breaker.  Neighbours: the flats above the yard are the reason fob access ends at 23:00 and noisy machines must stop at 22:00."
}
],
"why": "These limits are caused by the flats above the yard; the single-phase supply only stops two machines running together.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded together with its twin t10 so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u10",
"claim": "Both the 23:00 end of fob access and the 22:00 stop for noisy machines are due to the flats above the yard.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Power: the supply is single-phase, so the table saw and the planer-thicknesser cannot run at the same time without tripping the main breaker.  Neighbours: the flats above the yard are the reason fob access ends at 23:00 and noisy machines must stop at 22:00."
}
],
"why": "The flats above the yard are named as the reason for both time limits.",
"audit": "FIX: 'At Unit 4' is a scope the excerpt never names, so the supported claim goes beyond it; removed."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Of the 38 active volunteers in 2025–26, twenty-one are approved inductors and nine have a first-aid certificate, all nine being inductors as well.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "In 2025–26, 38 active volunteers logged 2,940 hours running open sessions, inducting members, repairing machines, cleaning and keeping the accounts. Twenty-one of them are approved inductors, and nine hold a first-aid certificate."
}
],
"why": "Whether the first-aiders are also inductors is not stated."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en1c-u11",
"claim": "Of the 38 active volunteers in 2025–26, twenty-one are approved inductors and nine have a first-aid certificate.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "In 2025–26, 38 active volunteers logged 2,940 hours running open sessions, inducting members, repairing machines, cleaning and keeping the accounts. Twenty-one of them are approved inductors, and nine hold a first-aid certificate."
}
],
"why": "Twenty-one of the 38 volunteers are inductors and nine hold a first-aid certificate."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Unit 4 runs on a three-phase supply, as does Unit 11.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Electricity | B: Expenditure | C: 8900 | D: 8140 | E: Tobias Wrenfield | F: Single-phase supply at Unit 4"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Unit 11 is a ground-floor unit of 410 square metres with a three-phase supply, a separate 18 square metre room for dust extraction, a ceiling height of 4.2 metres and a 3-metre-wide roller door that will let us bring in full sheets of plywood."
}
],
"why": "The three-phase supply belongs to Unit 11; Unit 4's supply is single-phase."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1c-u12",
"claim": "Unit 4 runs on a single-phase supply, while Unit 11 has a three-phase supply.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-equipment-inductions-budget.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Electricity | B: Expenditure | C: 8900 | D: 8140 | E: Tobias Wrenfield | F: Single-phase supply at Unit 4"
},
{
"file": "copperfold-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Unit 11 is a ground-floor unit of 410 square metres with a three-phase supply, a separate 18 square metre room for dust extraction, a ceiling height of 4.2 metres and a 3-metre-wide roller door that will let us bring in full sheets of plywood."
}
],
"why": "The budget row gives Unit 4 a single-phase supply and the report gives Unit 11 a three-phase supply."
},
{
"id": "en1c-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Junior Saturdays cost £8 per child per session, while the Youth fee would stay at £8 a month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The Youth fee would stay at £8 a month."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Junior Saturdays are for children aged 8–13 and cost £4 per child per session."
}
],
"why": "£8 is the monthly Youth fee; Junior Saturdays cost £4 per child per session."
},
{
"id": "en1c-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en1c-u13",
"claim": "Junior Saturdays cost £4 per child per session, while the Youth fee would stay at £8 a month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "The Youth fee would stay at £8 a month."
},
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Junior Saturdays are for children aged 8–13 and cost £4 per child per session."
}
],
"why": "The handbook gives £4 per child per session for Junior Saturdays and the slides keep the Youth fee at £8 a month."
},
{
"id": "en1c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "All incidents, near-misses included, have to be recorded in the incident book no later than 24 hours afterwards.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-member-handbook-v4.docx.md",
"text": "Enter every incident, including near-misses, in the incident book within 24 hours."
}
],
"why": "It restates the 24-hour rule for every incident including near-misses."
},
{
"id": "en1c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "The proposed Full membership fee is £4 a month more than the current one.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "copperfold-agm-2026-slides.pptx.md",
"text": "Full membership would rise from £30 to £34 a month."
}
],
"why": "A rise from £30 to £34 is £4 a month."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Issues labelled good-first-issue are permanently reserved for people making their first contribution.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Issues labelled good-first-issue are reserved for first-time contributors for 14 days after they are labelled."
}
],
"why": "The reservation lasts only 14 days after labelling, not permanently."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u01",
"claim": "For 14 days after an issue gets the good-first-issue label, it is kept for people making their first contribution.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Issues labelled good-first-issue are reserved for first-time contributors for 14 days after they are labelled."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt reserves such issues for first-time contributors for 14 days after labelling."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "For corpora above 20,000 notes, patch 2.4.1 brought in a bug that corrupts the index.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.1 | B: 2025-06-03 | C: Patch | D: 2025-06-03 | E: 0 | F: 0 | G: 22 | H: Priya Halloran | I: Introduced index corruption bug for corpora over 50,000 notes"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the threshold as 50,000 notes, not 20,000.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded with its twin t02 so the twin is no longer a near-copy of the row note; the 20,000 threshold stays the one change."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u02",
"claim": "For corpora above 50,000 notes, patch 2.4.1 brought in a bug that corrupts the index.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.1 | B: 2025-06-03 | C: Patch | D: 2025-06-03 | E: 0 | F: 0 | G: 22 | H: Priya Halloran | I: Introduced index corruption bug for corpora over 50,000 notes"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says 2.4.1 introduced an index corruption bug for corpora over 50,000 notes.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-copy of the row note (same words, same order, two or three swaps); reworded."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Because releases 2.5.0 and 2.6.0 both came out seven days behind schedule, a second release candidate was needed for each.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Releases 2.5.0 and 2.6.0 each shipped 7 days late because they needed a second release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The second release candidate caused the delay, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded with its twin t03 so the pair stays one swap of cause and effect apart."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u03",
"claim": "Because a second release candidate was needed for each, releases 2.5.0 and 2.6.0 both came out seven days behind schedule.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Releases 2.5.0 and 2.6.0 each shipped 7 days late because they needed a second release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the 7-day delay of both releases was caused by needing a second release candidate.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-copy of the excerpt (same order, only '7 days' and 'they needed' swapped); reworded."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Minor version 2.4.0 introduced a tag cache to make searches by tag faster.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.0 | B: 2025-05-20 | C: Minor | D: 2025-05-20 | E: 0 | F: 1 | G: 276 | H: Priya Halloran | I: Tag cache added"
}
],
"why": "The row says only that a tag cache was added; its purpose of speeding up tag searches is not stated."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u04",
"claim": "Minor version 2.4.0 introduced a tag cache.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.0 | B: 2025-05-20 | C: Minor | D: 2025-05-20 | E: 0 | F: 1 | G: 276 | H: Priya Halloran | I: Tag cache added"
}
],
"why": "The row lists 2.4.0 as Minor with the note that a tag cache was added."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Planned release dates are fixed a year ahead and stay put when a release is late, so a delayed release makes the next cycle longer.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The planned dates are set a year in advance and do not move when a release is late; a delayed release simply shortens the following cycle."
}
],
"why": "A delayed release shortens the following cycle; it does not lengthen it."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u05",
"claim": "Planned release dates are fixed a year ahead and stay put when a release is late, so a delayed release makes the next cycle shorter.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The planned dates are set a year in advance and do not move when a release is late; a delayed release simply shortens the following cycle."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says planned dates do not move and a delayed release shortens the following cycle."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The Seedling mentoring programme pairs a newcomer with a maintainer for 13 weeks, the same length as the cadence the four minor releases followed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The Seedling mentoring programme pairs a new contributor with one maintainer for 12 weeks."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Four minor releases followed the 13-week cadence, always on a Tuesday."
}
],
"why": "The 13 weeks belong to the release cadence; the Seedling programme lasts 12 weeks."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2a-u06",
"claim": "The Seedling mentoring programme pairs a newcomer with a maintainer for 12 weeks, one week shorter than the cadence the four minor releases followed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The Seedling mentoring programme pairs a new contributor with one maintainer for 12 weeks."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Four minor releases followed the 13-week cadence, always on a Tuesday."
}
],
"why": "The guide gives Seedling 12 weeks and the slide gives the release cadence as 13 weeks, so Seedling is one week shorter."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "After an incremental reindex, any user could end up with a corrupted index, however few notes they had.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Users with more than 50,000 notes could get a corrupted index after an incremental reindex."
}
],
"why": "The risk is stated only for users with more than 50,000 notes."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u07",
"claim": "After an incremental reindex, users holding over 50,000 notes could end up with a corrupted index.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Users with more than 50,000 notes could get a corrupted index after an incremental reindex."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says users with more than 50,000 notes could get a corrupted index after an incremental reindex."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Line coverage reached 84.2% at year end, up from 76.5% at the end of 2024, while the automated tests grew from 1,874 to 2,416.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "2,416 automated tests at year end, up from 1,874, with line coverage of 84.2% (end of 2024: 79.5%)."
}
],
"why": "Coverage at the end of 2024 was 79.5%, not 76.5%."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u08",
"claim": "Line coverage reached 84.2% at year end, up from 79.5% at the end of 2024, while the automated tests grew from 1,874 to 2,416.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "2,416 automated tests at year end, up from 1,874, with line coverage of 84.2% (end of 2024: 79.5%)."
}
],
"why": "All figures match the excerpt: 2,416 tests up from 1,874 and coverage 84.2% against 79.5%."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Each commit needs a Signed-off-by line affirming the right to submit it under the project licence, and a bot closes pull requests with unsigned commits after 7 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Every commit must carry a Signed-off-by line confirming that you have the right to submit the work under the project licence. Pull requests with unsigned commits are not merged."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about a bot or closing pull requests after 7 days; unsigned pull requests are only said not to be merged."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u09",
"claim": "Each commit needs a Signed-off-by line affirming the right to submit it under the project licence, and pull requests containing unsigned commits do not get merged.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Every commit must carry a Signed-off-by line confirming that you have the right to submit the work under the project licence. Pull requests with unsigned commits are not merged."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt requires a Signed-off-by line on every commit and says pull requests with unsigned commits are not merged."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Two of the four minor releases needed a second release candidate because the maintainers had voted in December 2025 to lengthen the feature freeze from 7 to 14 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Because two of the four minor releases needed a second release candidate, the maintainers voted in December 2025 to lengthen the feature freeze from 7 days to 14 days before each minor release."
}
],
"why": "The second release candidates were the reason for the vote, not its consequence."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u10",
"claim": "The maintainers voted in December 2025 to lengthen the feature freeze from 7 to 14 days because two of the four minor releases had needed a second release candidate.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Because two of the four minor releases needed a second release candidate, the maintainers voted in December 2025 to lengthen the feature freeze from 7 days to 14 days before each minor release."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the second release candidates as the reason for the December 2025 vote to lengthen the freeze."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Ruth Abernethy, who was elected chair by the maintainers, leads the meeting, and every one of the nine maintainers is invited.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "All 9 maintainers are invited, and Ruth Abernethy chairs the meeting."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt does not say how Ruth Abernethy became chair."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u11",
"claim": "Ruth Abernethy leads the meeting, and every one of the nine maintainers is invited.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "All 9 maintainers are invited, and Ruth Abernethy chairs the meeting."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says Ruth Abernethy chairs the meeting and all 9 maintainers are invited."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Security problems should be raised in public issues rather than through the private security address described in section 6.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Do not report security problems in public issues. Use the private security address described in section 6."
}
],
"why": "The guide forbids reporting security problems in public issues and directs them to the private address."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2a-u12",
"claim": "Security problems should be raised through the private security address described in section 6 rather than in public issues.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Do not report security problems in public issues. Use the private security address described in section 6."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt forbids public-issue reports of security problems and points to the private security address in section 6."
},
{
"id": "en2a-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The fix for advisory KW-SA-2025-02 shipped in patch 2.3.1, while advisory KW-SA-2025-01 was addressed by the security release 2.5.2.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Two of them were unscheduled: 2.4.2 was published on Saturday 7 June to fix the index corruption bug described in section 5, and 2.5.2 was the security release for advisory KW-SA-2025-02."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.3.1 | B: 2025-03-04 | C: Patch | D: 2025-03-04 | E: 0 | F: 0 | G: 18 | H: Tobias Wren | I: Includes fix for KW-SA-2025-01"
}
],
"why": "The advisories are swapped: 2.3.1 fixed KW-SA-2025-01 and 2.5.2 was the release for KW-SA-2025-02.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded with its twin t13 so the pair stays one swap of the advisories apart."
},
{
"id": "en2a-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2a-u13",
"claim": "The fix for advisory KW-SA-2025-01 shipped in patch 2.3.1, while advisory KW-SA-2025-02 was addressed by the security release 2.5.2.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Two of them were unscheduled: 2.4.2 was published on Saturday 7 June to fix the index corruption bug described in section 5, and 2.5.2 was the security release for advisory KW-SA-2025-02."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.3.1 | B: 2025-03-04 | C: Patch | D: 2025-03-04 | E: 0 | F: 0 | G: 18 | H: Tobias Wren | I: Includes fix for KW-SA-2025-01"
}
],
"why": "The spreadsheet row links 2.3.1 to KW-SA-2025-01 and the report links 2.5.2 to KW-SA-2025-02.",
"audit": "FIX: Second half copied the report excerpt word for word ('2.5.2 was the security release for advisory KW-SA-2025-02'); reworded."
},
{
"id": "en2a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Release 2.7.0, with Saoirse Lindqvist as release manager, came out on schedule on Tuesday 17 February 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Both changes apply from release 2.7.0, planned for 17 February 2026, whose release manager is Saoirse Lindqvist."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Release 2.7.0 shipped on its planned date, Tuesday 17 February 2026."
}
],
"why": "The report names Saoirse Lindqvist as release manager of 2.7.0 and the slide says it shipped on its planned date, Tuesday 17 February 2026."
},
{
"id": "en2a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Since the index is kept apart from the notes, the note files themselves were not harmed at any point.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Note files were never damaged, because the index is stored separately."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says note files were never damaged because the index is stored separately."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "For 2.4.0 (Large), peak memory rose by 8.6%, an increase that stayed just below the 10% threshold.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.0 | B: Large | C: 100000 | D: 471 | E: 139.7 | F: 112 | G: 330 | H: 1318 | I: -14.5 | J: Peak memory +9.4%, just under the 10% threshold"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the peak memory rise for 2.4.0 on the large corpus as +9.4%, not 8.6%.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows, still one change (8.6 for 9.4) from t01."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u01",
"claim": "For 2.4.0 (Large), peak memory rose by 9.4%, an increase that stayed just below the 10% threshold.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.4.0 | B: Large | C: 100000 | D: 471 | E: 139.7 | F: 112 | G: 330 | H: 1318 | I: -14.5 | J: Peak memory +9.4%, just under the 10% threshold"
}
],
"why": "The row for 2.4.0 Large notes peak memory +9.4%, just under the 10% threshold.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows, and less close to the note's wording."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "In 2025, six pull requests received the perf-regression label, and 3 of them were merged once approved.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Six pull requests were labelled perf-regression in 2025; four were merged after approval."
}
],
"why": "Four of the six labelled pull requests were merged, not 3.",
"audit": "FIX: The changed number 5 is a digit that occurs in the excerpt's '2025'; 3 occurs nowhere in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u02",
"claim": "In 2025, six pull requests received the perf-regression label, and four of them were merged once approved.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Six pull requests were labelled perf-regression in 2025; four were merged after approval."
}
],
"why": "The slide states six pull requests were labelled perf-regression and four were merged after approval."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "For 2.5.0 (Large), the tag cache was made smaller because peak memory fell.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.5.0 | B: Large | C: 100000 | D: 471 | E: 142.9 | F: 104 | G: 298 | H: 1104 | I: -7.1 | J: Smaller tag cache lowered peak memory"
}
],
"why": "The note says the smaller tag cache lowered peak memory; the claim reverses cause and effect.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows; kept as the exact cause-effect swap of the reworded t03."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u03",
"claim": "For 2.5.0 (Large), peak memory fell because the tag cache was made smaller.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.5.0 | B: Large | C: 100000 | D: 471 | E: 142.9 | F: 104 | G: 298 | H: 1104 | I: -7.1 | J: Smaller tag cache lowered peak memory"
}
],
"why": "The row note says a smaller tag cache lowered peak memory for 2.5.0 Large.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows, and 'a smaller tag cache brought peak memory down' was the note's words in the note's order."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Of the 64 issues still without a label after 7 days, 50 came after the rota had started.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "64 issues were unlabelled after 7 days, 50 of them before the rota began."
}
],
"why": "The slide says 50 of them were before the rota began, not after."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u04",
"claim": "Of the 64 issues still without a label after 7 days, 50 came before the rota had started.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "64 issues were unlabelled after 7 days, 50 of them before the rota began."
}
],
"why": "The slide says 64 issues were unlabelled after 7 days, 50 of them before the rota began."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "For 2.5.0 (Small), the index build change of +2.5% went over the 5% threshold.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.5.0 | B: Small | C: 10000 | D: 48 | E: 12.4 | F: 16 | G: 47 | H: 171 | I: -5.9 | J: Index build +2.5%, under the 5% threshold"
}
],
"why": "The note says the +2.5% index build change was under the 5% threshold, not over it.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows, still one change (over for below) from t05."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u05",
"claim": "For 2.5.0 (Small), the index build change of +2.5% stayed below the 5% threshold.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2.5.0 | B: Small | C: 10000 | D: 48 | E: 12.4 | F: 16 | G: 47 | H: 171 | I: -5.9 | J: Index build +2.5%, under the 5% threshold"
}
],
"why": "The row for 2.5.0 Small notes index build +2.5%, under the 5% threshold.",
"audit": "FIX: The row alone never says that B is the corpus (that comes from the header row), so 'on the large/small corpus' and 'release' go beyond the excerpt; reworded to what the row shows."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Since 1 January 2026, every module has required two approvals per change, where one used to be enough.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Since 1 January 2026, changes to the index and store modules need two approvals instead of one."
}
],
"why": "Only changes to the index and store modules need two approvals, not changes to any module.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (every module for the index and store modules) from the reworded t06."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u06",
"claim": "Since 1 January 2026, the index and store modules have required two approvals per change, where one used to be enough.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Since 1 January 2026, changes to the index and store modules need two approvals instead of one."
}
],
"why": "The slide says changes to the index and store modules need two approvals instead of one since 1 January 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim was the excerpt's sentence in the same order with only words swapped (Since/From, need/requires, instead of/rather than), a near-verbatim copy."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Apart from the release manager's version bump pull request, maintainers are permitted to merge pull requests they authored themselves.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "A maintainer must not merge their own pull request. The only exception is the release manager, who may merge the version bump pull request after one approval from another maintainer."
}
],
"why": "The guide says a maintainer must not merge their own pull request; the claim turns the ban into a permission."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u07",
"claim": "Apart from the release manager's version bump pull request, maintainers are not permitted to merge pull requests they authored themselves.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "A maintainer must not merge their own pull request. The only exception is the release manager, who may merge the version bump pull request after one approval from another maintainer."
}
],
"why": "The guide forbids self-merging with the single exception of the release manager's version bump pull request."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Tests that require network access are skipped in every test run and are not counted towards coverage, so they should not be added.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Do not add tests that need network access; they are skipped in the nightly run and do not count towards coverage."
}
],
"why": "The guide says such tests are skipped in the nightly run only, not in every run."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u08",
"claim": "Tests that require network access are skipped in the nightly run and are not counted towards coverage, so they should not be added.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Do not add tests that need network access; they are skipped in the nightly run and do not count towards coverage."
}
],
"why": "The guide says network tests are skipped in the nightly run, do not count towards coverage, and should not be added."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "When two issues duplicate each other, the newer one is closed with a link to the older one, and the maintainer on triage duty copies any extra detail across.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Duplicates are closed with a link to the older issue, even if the newer issue has more detail; the detail is copied across."
}
],
"why": "The guide says the detail is copied across but does not say who copies it."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u09",
"claim": "When two issues duplicate each other, the newer one is closed with a link to the older one, and any extra detail is copied across.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Duplicates are closed with a link to the older issue, even if the newer issue has more detail; the detail is copied across."
}
],
"why": "The guide says duplicates are closed with a link to the older issue even when the newer has more detail, and the detail is copied across."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The project keeps only one Windows runner because Windows testing happens just in the 03:00 UTC nightly run.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Every pull request is tested on Linux and macOS. Windows is tested only in the nightly run at 03:00 UTC, because the project has a single Windows runner."
}
],
"why": "The report says Windows is tested only nightly because there is a single Windows runner; the claim swaps cause and effect."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u10",
"claim": "Windows testing happens just in the 03:00 UTC nightly run because the project keeps only one Windows runner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Every pull request is tested on Linux and macOS. Windows is tested only in the nightly run at 03:00 UTC, because the project has a single Windows runner."
}
],
"why": "The report gives the single Windows runner as the reason Windows is tested only in the nightly run."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "A mentee in the spring cohort dropped out in the fourth week due to school exams and later joined the autumn cohort instead.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "One spring mentee withdrew in week 4 because of school exams."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the mentee who withdrew later joined the autumn cohort."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2b-u11",
"claim": "A mentee in the spring cohort dropped out in the fourth week due to school exams.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "One spring mentee withdrew in week 4 because of school exams."
}
],
"why": "The report says one spring mentee withdrew in week 4 because of school exams."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The Sunday benchmark runs start at 03:00 UTC, and the nightly Windows tests at 02:00 UTC.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Windows is tested only in the nightly run at 03:00 UTC. If the nightly Windows run fails because of your merged pull request, you are expected to help fix it within 7 days; otherwise the pull request may be reverted."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Benchmarks run on a dedicated machine with 8 cores and 32 GB of memory, every Sunday at 02:00 UTC and on every release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The times are swapped between subjects: benchmarks run at 02:00 UTC and the nightly Windows tests at 03:00 UTC."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2b-u12",
"claim": "The Sunday benchmark runs start at 02:00 UTC, and the nightly Windows tests at 03:00 UTC.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Windows is tested only in the nightly run at 03:00 UTC. If the nightly Windows run fails because of your merged pull request, you are expected to help fix it within 7 days; otherwise the pull request may be reverted."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Benchmarks run on a dedicated machine with 8 cores and 32 GB of memory, every Sunday at 02:00 UTC and on every release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The guide puts the nightly Windows run at 03:00 UTC and the report puts the Sunday benchmarks at 02:00 UTC."
},
{
"id": "en2b-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Applications for the spring 2025 cohort closed on 2 February, and that cohort ran from 3 March to 25 May 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Cohort Dates Applications Mentees accepted Mentees completed Spring 2025 3 March to 25 May 2025 19 6 5"
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The spring 2026 cohort started on 2 March with applications closed on 2 February."
}
],
"why": "The 2 February application deadline belongs to the spring 2026 cohort, not the spring 2025 cohort."
},
{
"id": "en2b-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2b-u13",
"claim": "Applications for the spring 2026 cohort closed on 2 February, and the spring 2025 cohort ran from 3 March to 25 May 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Cohort Dates Applications Mentees accepted Mentees completed Spring 2025 3 March to 25 May 2025 19 6 5"
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The spring 2026 cohort started on 2 March with applications closed on 2 February."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives 2 February as the spring 2026 application close, and the report table gives spring 2025 as 3 March to 25 May 2025."
},
{
"id": "en2b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Across the two Seedling cohorts, just one of the 11 accepted mentees did not complete the 12 weeks.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The two Seedling cohorts accepted 11 mentees, and 10 completed the 12 weeks."
}
],
"why": "11 accepted minus 10 who completed leaves one who did not complete."
},
{
"id": "en2b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "The 14 flaky tests moved to quarantine during 2025 are more than the cap of 10 on how many tests can sit in quarantine simultaneously.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "A flaky test may be moved to quarantine for at most 21 days, after which it must be fixed or deleted. No more than 10 tests may be in quarantine at the same time."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "During 2025, 14 flaky tests were moved to quarantine."
}
],
"why": "The report gives 14 quarantined tests in 2025 and the guide caps simultaneous quarantine at 10.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt never calls the quarantine cap a contributor rule, so that label is a detail beyond the excerpts; reworded without it."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "In June 2025 the project opened 131 issues and closed 122, and the median first response was 34 hours.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: June | B: 131 | C: 122 | D: 82 | E: 28 | F: 21 | G: 27 | H: 11 | I: No rota | J: 37 reports of index corruption after 2.4.1"
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Month (2025) | B: Issues opened (count) | C: Issues closed (count) | D: Bug reports (count) | E: Feature requests (count) | F: Questions and other (count) | G: Median first response (hours) | H: Unlabelled after 7 days (count) | I: Triage arrangement | J: Notes"
}
],
"why": "The June row gives a median first response of 27 hours, not 34."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2c-u01",
"claim": "In June 2025 the project opened 131 issues and closed 122, and the median first response was 27 hours.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: June | B: 131 | C: 122 | D: 82 | E: 28 | F: 21 | G: 27 | H: 11 | I: No rota | J: 37 reports of index corruption after 2.4.1"
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Month (2025) | B: Issues opened (count) | C: Issues closed (count) | D: Bug reports (count) | E: Feature requests (count) | F: Questions and other (count) | G: Median first response (hours) | H: Unlabelled after 7 days (count) | I: Triage arrangement | J: Notes"
}
],
"why": "The header names columns B, C and G as issues opened, issues closed and median first response in hours, and the June row gives 131, 122 and 27."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "A permanent ban needs 4 of the 5 committee votes, whereas a change to the code of conduct would need 4 of the 5 council votes.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Changes to the licence or the code of conduct would need 4 of the 5 council votes."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "A permanent ban needs a unanimous decision of the committee."
}
],
"why": "The 4-of-5 threshold belongs to the council; a permanent ban needs a unanimous committee decision."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2c-u02",
"claim": "A permanent ban needs every committee member to agree, whereas a change to the code of conduct would need 4 of the 5 council votes.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Changes to the licence or the code of conduct would need 4 of the 5 council votes."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "A permanent ban needs a unanimous decision of the committee."
}
],
"why": "The guide requires a unanimous committee decision for a permanent ban, and the slide gives 4 of the 5 council votes for code of conduct changes."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The release signing key expired on 8 September 2025 because release 2.5.1 came out 3 days late.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The release signing key, created on 8 September 2023 with a lifetime of 2 years, expired on 8 September 2025. This was discovered while signing 2.5.1 and delayed that release by 3 days."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the expired key delayed 2.5.1, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u03",
"claim": "Release 2.5.1 came out 3 days late because the release signing key had expired on 8 September 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The release signing key, created on 8 September 2023 with a lifetime of 2 years, expired on 8 September 2025. This was discovered while signing 2.5.1 and delayed that release by 3 days."
}
],
"why": "The key expired on 8 September 2025, which was discovered while signing 2.5.1 and delayed that release by 3 days."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "All releases can go out on any day, weekends included, without first publishing a release candidate.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Security releases may be published on any day of the week and do not need a release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The rule is stated only for security releases, not for all releases."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u04",
"claim": "Security releases can go out on any day, weekends included, without first publishing a release candidate.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Security releases may be published on any day of the week and do not need a release candidate."
}
],
"why": "Security releases may be published on any day of the week and do not need a release candidate."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "December was a holiday period in which more people were active, and a weekly rota was in place.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: December | B: 81 | C: 76 | D: 39 | E: 30 | F: 12 | G: 39 | H: 6 | I: Weekly rota | J: Holiday period; fewer people active"
}
],
"why": "The row says fewer people were active in December, not more.",
"audit": "FIX: \"Still applied\" implies the rota was in place before December, which the row alone does not show; dropped to match the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u05",
"claim": "December was a holiday period in which fewer people were active, and a weekly rota was in place.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: December | B: 81 | C: 76 | D: 39 | E: 30 | F: 12 | G: 39 | H: 6 | I: Weekly rota | J: Holiday period; fewer people active"
}
],
"why": "The December row lists a weekly rota and notes a holiday period with fewer people active.",
"audit": "FIX: \"Still applied\" implies the rota was in place before December, which the row alone does not show."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "A committee member having to step aside made one decision take 19 days, 5 more than the 14 it should have taken, and that decision ended in a permanent ban.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "One decision took 19 days instead of 14 because a committee member had to step aside."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says what the delayed decision's outcome was; the permanent ban is added."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en2c-u06",
"claim": "A committee member having to step aside made one decision take 19 days, 5 more than the 14 it should have taken.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "One decision took 19 days instead of 14 because a committee member had to step aside."
}
],
"why": "The decision took 19 days instead of 14 because a member stepped aside, and 19 minus 14 is 5."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "A disk failure kept the self-hosted Linux runners offline for 9 days in October 2025, during which only documentation-only pull requests were merged; afterwards the project added a spare runner as a backup.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The self-hosted Linux runners were offline from 14 to 22 October 2025, 9 days in all, after a disk failure. During the outage only documentation-only pull requests were merged, and 41 other pull requests waited until the runners were back."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says a spare runner was added after the outage."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u07",
"claim": "A disk failure kept the self-hosted Linux runners offline for 9 days in October 2025, during which only documentation-only pull requests were merged.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The self-hosted Linux runners were offline from 14 to 22 October 2025, 9 days in all, after a disk failure. During the outage only documentation-only pull requests were merged, and 41 other pull requests waited until the runners were back."
}
],
"why": "The runners were offline 14 to 22 October 2025, 9 days, after a disk failure, and only documentation-only pull requests were merged then."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Reports to the committee are acknowledged within 48 hours, and a decision follows within 21 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The committee acknowledges a report within 48 hours and decides within 14 days."
}
],
"why": "The committee decides within 14 days, not 21."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u08",
"claim": "Reports to the committee are acknowledged within 48 hours, and a decision follows within 14 days.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The committee acknowledges a report within 48 hours and decides within 14 days."
}
],
"why": "The committee acknowledges a report within 48 hours and decides within 14 days."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Council nominations close on 21 April 2026, while applications for Seedling autumn 2026 close on 21 April.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Seedling autumn 2026 runs from 31 August to 22 November, with applications closing on 3 August."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Nominations run from 1 to 21 April 2026 and voting from 1 to 14 May 2026. The council takes office on 1 July 2026."
}
],
"why": "21 April is the end of council nominations; Seedling applications close on 3 August."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2c-u09",
"claim": "Council nominations close on 21 April 2026, while applications for Seedling autumn 2026 close on 3 August.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Seedling autumn 2026 runs from 31 August to 22 November, with applications closing on 3 August."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "Nominations run from 1 to 21 April 2026 and voting from 1 to 14 May 2026. The council takes office on 1 July 2026."
}
],
"why": "The guide has nominations running from 1 to 21 April 2026, and the slide has Seedling applications closing on 3 August."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "As performance lead, Mateus Kowalczyk approves all pull requests.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Mateus Kowalczyk | B: Performance lead | C: 2022-06 | D: Benchmarks and search speed | E: 3 | F: 139 | H: Approves perf-regression pull requests"
}
],
"why": "He approves only perf-regression pull requests, not all of them."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u10",
"claim": "As performance lead, Mateus Kowalczyk approves perf-regression pull requests.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-releases-benchmarks-triage.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Mateus Kowalczyk | B: Performance lead | C: 2022-06 | D: Benchmarks and search speed | E: 3 | F: 139 | H: Approves perf-regression pull requests"
}
],
"why": "The row lists Mateus Kowalczyk as performance lead with the note that he approves perf-regression pull requests."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "The new key created on 11 September 2025 runs out on 11 September 2028, and a reminder issue is opened automatically 90 days after that date.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The new key, created on 11 September 2025, has a lifetime of 3 years and expires on 11 September 2028. A reminder issue is now opened automatically 90 days before the key expires."
}
],
"why": "The reminder is opened 90 days before the key expires, not after.",
"audit": "FIX: Changed \"signing key\" to \"new key\" to stay one change from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u11",
"claim": "The new key created on 11 September 2025 runs out on 11 September 2028, and a reminder issue is opened automatically 90 days ahead of that date.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The new key, created on 11 September 2025, has a lifetime of 3 years and expires on 11 September 2028. A reminder issue is now opened automatically 90 days before the key expires."
}
],
"why": "The new key expires on 11 September 2028 and a reminder issue is opened automatically 90 days before it expires.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt calls it only \"the new key\" and never says it is a signing key, so \"signing\" goes beyond the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Because the feature freeze grew from 7 to 14 days starting with release 2.7.0, two of the four minor releases of 2025 needed a second release candidate.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The feature freeze was 7 days until the end of 2025. It was extended to 14 days from release 2.7.0 because two of the four minor releases in 2025 needed a second release candidate."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the second release candidates in 2025 caused the longer freeze."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en2c-u12",
"claim": "Because two of the four minor releases of 2025 needed a second release candidate, the feature freeze grew from 7 to 14 days starting with release 2.7.0.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "The feature freeze was 7 days until the end of 2025. It was extended to 14 days from release 2.7.0 because two of the four minor releases in 2025 needed a second release candidate."
}
],
"why": "The freeze was extended from 7 to 14 days from 2.7.0 because two of the four 2025 minor releases needed a second release candidate."
},
{
"id": "en2c-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Imogen Varga has been lead maintainer since 2019, while Felix Ondrasek became the standing substitute in 2019.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Since 2019 the founder, Imogen Varga, has served as lead maintainer with the final say when maintainers cannot agree."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felix Ondrasek has been the standing substitute since January 2026."
}
],
"why": "2019 is when Imogen Varga became lead maintainer; Felix Ondrasek has been standing substitute since January 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: The twin differed by more than one change (verb, connective and date); reworded so only the date differs from t13."
},
{
"id": "en2c-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en2c-u13",
"claim": "Imogen Varga has been lead maintainer since 2019, while Felix Ondrasek became the standing substitute in January 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Since 2019 the founder, Imogen Varga, has served as lead maintainer with the final say when maintainers cannot agree."
},
{
"file": "kettlewick-maintainers-meeting-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felix Ondrasek has been the standing substitute since January 2026."
}
],
"why": "The report has Imogen Varga as lead maintainer since 2019, and the slide has Felix Ondrasek as standing substitute since January 2026."
},
{
"id": "en2c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "At most two members of the council can be employed by the same organisation.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-contributor-guide-and-release-process.docx.md",
"text": "No more than 2 council members may work for the same organisation."
}
],
"why": "The guide says no more than 2 council members may work for the same organisation."
},
{
"id": "en2c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Bug reports made up more than half of the 1,138 issues opened in 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "kettlewick-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "1,138 issues were opened in 2025: 602 bug reports, 341 feature requests and 195 questions and other issues."
}
],
"why": "602 of 1,138 issues were bug reports, and 602 is more than half of 1,138."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Society telescopes were lent out 97 times in 2025, up from 81 loans in 2024, and 63 different members made use of the scheme.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Members borrowed a society telescope 97 times in 2025, compared with 81 times in 2024, and 58 different members used the scheme."
}
],
"why": "The source gives 58 different members using the loan scheme, not 63."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u01",
"claim": "Society telescopes were lent out 97 times in 2025, up from 81 loans in 2024, and 58 different members made use of the scheme.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Members borrowed a society telescope 97 times in 2025, compared with 81 times in 2024, and 58 different members used the scheme."
}
],
"why": "The loan counts for both years and the 58 members are all stated."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The dome rotation motor burnt out on 19 February because the committee had lowered the dome's operating wind limit from 40 km/h to 35 km/h.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "On 19 February the dome rotation motor burnt out while the dome was being closed in a sustained wind of 42 km/h. The dome stayed out of use until 26 March, and the repair cost £2,350. As a result, the committee lowered the wind limit for operating the dome from 40 km/h to 35 km/h in edition 4 of the operating handbook, which took effect on 1 February 2026."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the motor failure led the committee to lower the wind limit, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: The year 2025 is not in the excerpt (it only says 19 February); dropped it, twin fixed in step."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u02",
"claim": "Because the dome rotation motor burnt out on 19 February, the committee lowered the dome's operating wind limit from 40 km/h to 35 km/h.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "On 19 February the dome rotation motor burnt out while the dome was being closed in a sustained wind of 42 km/h. The dome stayed out of use until 26 March, and the repair cost £2,350. As a result, the committee lowered the wind limit for operating the dome from 40 km/h to 35 km/h in edition 4 of the operating handbook, which took effect on 1 February 2026."
}
],
"why": "The source says the limit was lowered as a result of the motor burning out.",
"audit": "FIX: The year 2025 is not in the excerpt, which only says 19 February; dropped it."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "At the end of 2025 the society had 19 keyholders, and every one of them was qualified to run the Pennick Telescope in the main dome.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "At the end of 2025 there were 19 keyholders, two more than a year earlier, who are trained to open and close the observatory on their own responsibility. Eight of the keyholders are qualified to operate the Pennick Telescope in the main dome."
}
],
"why": "Only eight of the 19 keyholders are qualified to operate the Pennick Telescope, not all of them."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u03",
"claim": "At the end of 2025 the society had 19 keyholders, and eight of them were qualified to run the Pennick Telescope in the main dome.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "At the end of 2025 there were 19 keyholders, two more than a year earlier, who are trained to open and close the observatory on their own responsibility. Eight of the keyholders are qualified to operate the Pennick Telescope in the main dome."
}
],
"why": "Both the 19 keyholders and the eight qualified Pennick operators are stated."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Booking is allowed for pier 1, on which the society's 254 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope is mounted.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Pier 1 carries the society's 254 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope and may not be booked."
}
],
"why": "The handbook says pier 1 may not be booked.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Annexe' is not in the excerpt; reworded without it to stay one change from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u04",
"claim": "Booking is not allowed for pier 1, on which the society's 254 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope is mounted.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Pier 1 carries the society's 254 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain telescope and may not be booked."
}
],
"why": "The handbook states that pier 1 carries the 254 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain and may not be booked.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Annexe' and 'members' go beyond the excerpt, which says only that pier 1 may not be booked."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Only keyholders receive the lower gate code, which is changed twice a year, on 1 January and 1 July, so that former keyholders lose access.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "The code on the lower gate is changed every 6 months, on 1 January and 1 July, and is given only to keyholders."
}
],
"why": "The handbook gives no reason for changing the code; locking out former keyholders is an added reason."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en3a-u05",
"claim": "Only keyholders receive the lower gate code, which is changed twice a year, on 1 January and 1 July.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "The code on the lower gate is changed every 6 months, on 1 January and 1 July, and is given only to keyholders."
}
],
"why": "A change every 6 months on two fixed dates is twice a year, and the code goes only to keyholders."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Without exception, everyone has to be off the site by 03:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "The site must be vacated by 03:00, unless the duty director has approved an all-night session at least 24 hours in advance."
}
],
"why": "The 03:00 rule has an exception for all-night sessions approved by the duty director at least 24 hours ahead.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt says 'the site', not 'the observatory site'; dropped the word, twin fixed in step. | FIX2: Twin t06 is reworded to avoid a near-copy, so this is rewritten to stay one change (the exception dropped) from it."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u06",
"claim": "Unless an all-night session has had the duty director's approval at least 24 hours ahead, everyone has to be off the site by 03:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "The site must be vacated by 03:00, unless the duty director has approved an all-night session at least 24 hours in advance."
}
],
"why": "It restates the 03:00 rule together with its exception for pre-approved all-night sessions.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt says 'the site', not 'the observatory site'; dropped the added word. | FIX2: Same order as the excerpt with 'the duty director has approved an all-night session at least 24 hours' verbatim and only a few words swapped, so it counts as a copy."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The Dobsonian T07 was withdrawn on 28 November 2025 to have its primary mirror recoated and is expected back in April 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T07 | B: Dobsonian | C: 200 | D: 1200 | E: 21 | F: 2017 | G: Under repair | H: Yes | I: Withdrawn | J: Withdrawn 18 Nov 2025 for primary mirror recoating; expected back April 2026"
}
],
"why": "T07 was withdrawn on 18 November 2025, not 28 November."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u07",
"claim": "The Dobsonian T07 was withdrawn on 18 November 2025 to have its primary mirror recoated and is expected back in April 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T07 | B: Dobsonian | C: 200 | D: 1200 | E: 21 | F: 2017 | G: Under repair | H: Yes | I: Withdrawn | J: Withdrawn 18 Nov 2025 for primary mirror recoating; expected back April 2026"
}
],
"why": "The row's note gives the 18 Nov 2025 withdrawal for mirror recoating and the expected return in April 2026."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "The hydrogen-alpha solar telescope T12 is used for the solar open day and at the observatory, and it is also lent out to members.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T12 | B: Hydrogen-alpha solar telescope | C: 40 | D: 400 | E: 3.1 | F: 2021 | G: Good | H: No | I: Observatory use | J: Solar open day and observatory use only; never lent"
}
],
"why": "The row says T12 is for the solar open day and observatory use only and is never lent."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u08",
"claim": "The hydrogen-alpha solar telescope T12 is used for the solar open day and at the observatory, and it is never lent out.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T12 | B: Hydrogen-alpha solar telescope | C: 40 | D: 400 | E: 3.1 | F: 2021 | G: Good | H: No | I: Observatory use | J: Solar open day and observatory use only; never lent"
}
],
"why": "The row's note restricts T12 to the solar open day and observatory use and says it is never lent."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Between 3 February and 10 March 2026, the course takes place every evening.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "This course runs on six Tuesday evenings from 3 February to 10 March 2026."
}
],
"why": "The course meets on six Tuesday evenings, not every evening in that period.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Spring' is not in the excerpt; reworded without it to stay one change from the fixed twin. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t09, which drops 'First Light' because the excerpt says only 'This course'."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u09",
"claim": "Between 3 February and 10 March 2026, the course takes place on six Tuesday evenings.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "This course runs on six Tuesday evenings from 3 February to 10 March 2026."
}
],
"why": "The slide states six Tuesday evenings between those dates.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Spring' is not in the excerpt, and the claim was a near-verbatim copy of the excerpt. | FIX2: The excerpt says only 'This course' and never names First Light, so the name goes beyond the excerpt text."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Borrowing a telescope shortens the time it takes to complete the course.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Completing the course also shortens the wait before you can borrow a telescope."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: completing the course shortens the wait to borrow a telescope, not the reverse.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Society' telescope is not in the excerpt; dropped it, twin fixed in step. | FIX2: The course name 'First Light' stands only in the file name, not in the excerpt text; dropped in step with the twin."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u10",
"claim": "Completing the course shortens the time a person must wait before borrowing a telescope.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Completing the course also shortens the wait before you can borrow a telescope."
}
],
"why": "The slide says completing the course shortens the wait before borrowing a telescope.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt says 'a telescope', not 'a society telescope'; dropped the added word. | FIX2: 'First Light' is not in the excerpt text (only the file name), so a reader that looks for every word in the excerpt could reject it; dropped."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Every session is held in the warm room at Tallow Hill Observatory, lasting from 19:30 until 21:30, with a break for hot drinks at 20:30.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Each session runs from 19:30 to 21:30 in the warm room at Tallow Hill Observatory."
}
],
"why": "A hot-drinks break at 20:30 is not mentioned.",
"audit": " | FIX3: \"First Light\" stood only in the file name."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3a-u11",
"claim": "Every session is held in the warm room at Tallow Hill Observatory, lasting from 19:30 until 21:30.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Each session runs from 19:30 to 21:30 in the warm room at Tallow Hill Observatory."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives the time and the place of each session.",
"audit": " | FIX3: \"First Light\" stood only in the file name."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The 406 mm Pennick Telescope is fixed on pier 1 of the Annexe, whereas the Schmidt-Cassegrain T02 sits in the 4.2 m dome.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The 4.2 m dome houses the 406 mm Pennick Telescope."
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T02 | B: Schmidt-Cassegrain | C: 254 | D: 2540 | E: 27.5 | F: 2011 | G: Good | H: No | I: Observatory use | J: Fixed on Annexe pier 1"
}
],
"why": "The locations are swapped between the two telescopes: the Pennick Telescope is in the dome and T02 is fixed on Annexe pier 1."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3a-u12",
"claim": "The 406 mm Pennick Telescope sits in the 4.2 m dome, whereas the Schmidt-Cassegrain T02 is fixed on pier 1 of the Annexe.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The 4.2 m dome houses the 406 mm Pennick Telescope."
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T02 | B: Schmidt-Cassegrain | C: 254 | D: 2540 | E: 27.5 | F: 2011 | G: Good | H: No | I: Observatory use | J: Fixed on Annexe pier 1"
}
],
"why": "The slide places the Pennick Telescope in the dome and the inventory row places T02 on Annexe pier 1."
},
{
"id": "en3a-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Becoming a keyholder takes at least 6 months of membership, the three-session training and committee approval, and keyholder status must be renewed every three years.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "To become a keyholder a member must have been a member for at least 6 months, complete the three-session keyholder training and be approved by the committee."
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fourteen volunteers hold the society's safeguarding certificate, which is needed for any work with school groups and must be renewed every three years."
}
],
"why": "The three-year renewal applies to the safeguarding certificate, not to keyholder status."
},
{
"id": "en3a-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3a-u13",
"claim": "Becoming a keyholder takes at least 6 months of membership, the three-session training and committee approval, while the safeguarding certificate needed for school-group work must be renewed every three years.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "To become a keyholder a member must have been a member for at least 6 months, complete the three-session keyholder training and be approved by the committee."
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fourteen volunteers hold the society's safeguarding certificate, which is needed for any work with school groups and must be renewed every three years."
}
],
"why": "The keyholder requirements come from the handbook and the three-year safeguarding renewal from the annual report."
},
{
"id": "en3a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "A participant completes the course by being present at five or more of its six sessions; of the 29 who signed up for it in 2025, 24 finished it.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "You complete the course by attending at least five of the six sessions."
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "In 2025, 24 of the 29 people who enrolled completed the course."
}
],
"why": "24 of 29 enrolled completed in 2025, and completing means attending at least five of the six sessions.",
"audit": "FIX: Applying this course's five-of-six rule to the 2025 cohort assumes the 2025 course had the same six sessions and rule; reworded to join the two facts without that step. | FIX2: The course name 'First Light' appears only in the file name, not in either excerpt, so a reader checking the excerpt text finds no words for it; named as 'the course' instead."
},
{
"id": "en3a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Ninety per cent of those who were members at the close of 2024 renewed, 154 people out of 171.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Of the 171 members at the end of 2024, 154 renewed, a renewal rate of 90%."
}
],
"why": "It restates the 154 of 171 renewals and the 90% rate in other words."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Loan L25-089 of telescope T08 came back on 10 December 2025, 14 days after its due date, and was charged a late fee of £24.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Loan no. | B: Telescope ID | C: Member no. | D: Borrower age group | E: Start date | F: Due date | G: Returned date | H: Days late (days) | I: Late fee (£) | J: Renewed | K: Notes"
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L25-089 | B: T08 | C: M0356 | D: Adult | E: 2025-10-29 | F: 2025-11-26 | G: 2025-12-10 | H: 14 | I: 28 | J: No"
}
],
"why": "The row gives a late fee of £28 in column I, not £24."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3b-u01",
"claim": "Loan L25-089 of telescope T08 came back on 10 December 2025, 14 days after its due date, and was charged a late fee of £28.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Loan no. | B: Telescope ID | C: Member no. | D: Borrower age group | E: Start date | F: Due date | G: Returned date | H: Days late (days) | I: Late fee (£) | J: Renewed | K: Notes"
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L25-089 | B: T08 | C: M0356 | D: Adult | E: 2025-10-29 | F: 2025-11-26 | G: 2025-12-10 | H: 14 | I: 28 | J: No"
}
],
"why": "The header names H as days late and I as late fee in pounds, and the row gives 14 and 28 with a return date of 2025-12-10."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Loan L25-086 of telescope T09 was renewed a single time for 14 days even though there was a waiting list.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L25-086 | B: T09 | C: M0320 | D: Adult | E: 2025-10-15 | F: 2025-11-26 | G: 2025-11-26 | H: 0 | I: 0 | J: Yes | K: Renewed once for 14 days; no waiting list"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says there was no waiting list, not that there was one."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u02",
"claim": "Loan L25-086 of telescope T09 was renewed a single time for 14 days, with no waiting list in place.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L25-086 | B: T09 | C: M0320 | D: Adult | E: 2025-10-15 | F: 2025-11-26 | G: 2025-11-26 | H: 0 | I: 0 | J: Yes | K: Renewed once for 14 days; no waiting list"
}
],
"why": "The note on the row reads 'Renewed once for 14 days; no waiting list'."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "In entry L26-001 (T04, M0502, adult), the note records a First Light completer from autumn 2025 who was recommended by the course leader and states that the 1-month rule was applied.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L26-001 | B: T04 | C: M0502 | D: Adult | E: 2026-01-03 | F: 2026-01-17 | G: 2026-01-17 | H: 0 | I: 0 | J: No | K: First Light completer (autumn 2025); 1-month rule applied"
}
],
"why": "Nothing in the row says the borrower was recommended by the course leader.",
"audit": "FIX: The row says only 'First Light completer', never that First Light is a course; dropped 'course' to stay one change from the fixed twin. | FIX2: Rewritten to stay one change (the course-leader recommendation) from the reworded twin t03."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u03",
"claim": "In entry L26-001 (T04, M0502, adult), the note records a First Light completer from autumn 2025 and states that the 1-month rule was applied.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L26-001 | B: T04 | C: M0502 | D: Adult | E: 2026-01-03 | F: 2026-01-17 | G: 2026-01-17 | H: 0 | I: 0 | J: No | K: First Light completer (autumn 2025); 1-month rule applied"
}
],
"why": "The row shows an adult borrower of T04 noted as a First Light completer from autumn 2025 with the 1-month rule applied.",
"audit": "FIX: The row says only 'First Light completer', so calling First Light a course goes beyond the excerpt. | FIX2: Without the header row the excerpt never says L26-001 is a loan or T04 a telescope, so 'Loan' and 'telescope' go beyond the row."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Sessions 1 to 5 run regardless of the weather, which is why they are held indoors.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Sessions 1 to 5 go ahead in any weather, because they are held indoors."
}
],
"why": "Being indoors is the reason the sessions run in any weather, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Dropped 'of the course', which the excerpt does not give, to stay one change from the fixed twin. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t04 so the pair stays one change (the swapped cause) apart."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u04",
"claim": "Sessions 1 to 5 are held indoors, which is why they run regardless of the weather.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Sessions 1 to 5 go ahead in any weather, because they are held indoors."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives being held indoors as the reason sessions 1 to 5 run in any weather.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt says only 'Sessions 1 to 5' and never ties them to a course, so 'of the course' goes beyond it. | FIX2: The claim was the excerpt's two clauses swapped with almost all its words kept, a near-copy; given a different sentence shape."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "No more than 9 people, the operator included, may be inside the dome at one time.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The dome holds at most 8 people, including the operator."
}
],
"why": "The dome's limit is 8 people including the operator, not 9."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u05",
"claim": "No more than eight people, the operator included, may be inside the dome at one time.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The dome holds at most 8 people, including the operator."
}
],
"why": "The slide caps the dome at 8 people including the operator."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Only red light may be used anywhere on the site, the warm room included.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Outside the warm room, only red light is allowed anywhere on the site."
}
],
"why": "The red-light rule applies only outside the warm room, so it does not cover the warm room."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u06",
"claim": "Only red light may be used anywhere on the site except the warm room.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Outside the warm room, only red light is allowed anywhere on the site."
}
],
"why": "The slide limits light to red everywhere outside the warm room."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The dome rotation motor broke down on 19 February 2025 because the dome's sustained wind limit had been cut from 40 to 35 km/h.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Changed in edition 4: the sustained wind limit for the dome was 40 km/h in edition 3. It was lowered to 35 km/h because the dome rotation motor failed on 19 February 2025 while the dome was being closed in a sustained wind of 42 km/h."
}
],
"why": "The motor failure caused the lower wind limit; the lower limit did not cause the failure."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u07",
"claim": "The dome's sustained wind limit was cut from 40 to 35 km/h because the dome rotation motor broke down on 19 February 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Changed in edition 4: the sustained wind limit for the dome was 40 km/h in edition 3. It was lowered to 35 km/h because the dome rotation motor failed on 19 February 2025 while the dome was being closed in a sustained wind of 42 km/h."
}
],
"why": "The handbook says the limit was lowered from 40 to 35 km/h because of the motor failure during closing in a 42 km/h wind.",
"audit": "FIX: The twin differed from u07 by more than the swapped cause (it added the 42 km/h clause), and 'was closed' misstates 'was being closed'; reworded to be exactly the reverse of u07."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Alcohol is banned on the whole site with one exception: on the summer solar open day it is allowed anywhere except the warm room.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Alcohol is not allowed anywhere on the site, except at the summer solar open day, when it is allowed in the warm room only."
}
],
"why": "On the open day alcohol is allowed only in the warm room, not everywhere but the warm room."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u08",
"claim": "Alcohol is banned on the whole site with one exception: on the summer solar open day it is allowed in the warm room and nowhere else.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Alcohol is not allowed anywhere on the site, except at the summer solar open day, when it is allowed in the warm room only."
}
],
"why": "The handbook bans alcohol on the site except in the warm room on the summer solar open day."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Every volunteer at the observatory needs a valid safeguarding certificate, which has to be renewed every three years.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Every volunteer working with a school group must hold a current safeguarding certificate, renewed every three years."
}
],
"why": "The certificate rule covers volunteers working with school groups, not every volunteer."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u09",
"claim": "Volunteers who work with a school group need a valid safeguarding certificate, which has to be renewed every three years.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Every volunteer working with a school group must hold a current safeguarding certificate, renewed every three years."
}
],
"why": "The handbook requires a current safeguarding certificate, renewed every three years, for each volunteer working with a school group."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The nine evenings that took place attracted 338 visitors in total, and those on 7 March and 5 September were booked out.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The nine evenings that went ahead drew 318 visitors, just over 35 per evening, and two of them, on 7 March and 5 September, were fully booked."
}
],
"why": "The nine evenings drew 318 visitors, not 338.",
"audit": "FIX: Dropped 'public', which the excerpt does not give, to stay one change from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3b-u10",
"claim": "The nine evenings that took place attracted 318 visitors in total, and those on 7 March and 5 September were booked out.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The nine evenings that went ahead drew 318 visitors, just over 35 per evening, and two of them, on 7 March and 5 September, were fully booked."
}
],
"why": "The report gives 318 visitors for the nine evenings held and names 7 March and 5 September as fully booked.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt says only 'nine evenings', never that they were public, so 'public' goes beyond it."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Held on Saturday 21 June 2025, the summer solar open day drew 412 visitors, more than the 365 of 2024, thanks to advertising in the local paper.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The summer solar open day was held on Saturday 21 June 2025 from 10:00 to 16:00. Visitors looked at the Sun safely through the hydrogen-alpha solar telescope T12 and through projection screens, and 412 people attended, against 365 in 2024."
}
],
"why": "The report gives no reason for the rise, and says nothing about advertising in a local paper."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en3b-u11",
"claim": "Held on Saturday 21 June 2025, the summer solar open day drew 412 visitors, more than the 365 of 2024.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The summer solar open day was held on Saturday 21 June 2025 from 10:00 to 16:00. Visitors looked at the Sun safely through the hydrogen-alpha solar telescope T12 and through projection screens, and 412 people attended, against 365 in 2024."
}
],
"why": "The report gives 412 attendees on 21 June 2025 against 365 in 2024, so attendance rose."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "A non-member pays a £40 course fee, while the refundable loan deposit for loans starting from 1 January 2026 is £35.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "On 10 September 2025 the committee decided to raise the refundable loan deposit from £30 to £40 for all loans starting on or after 1 January 2026."
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The course fee is £20 for members and £35 for non-members."
}
],
"why": "The £40 belongs to the loan deposit and the £35 to the non-member course fee; the claim swaps them.",
"audit": "FIX: Dropped 'First Light', which neither excerpt names, to stay one change from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3b-u12",
"claim": "A non-member pays a £35 course fee, while the refundable loan deposit for loans starting from 1 January 2026 is £40.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "On 10 September 2025 the committee decided to raise the refundable loan deposit from £30 to £40 for all loans starting on or after 1 January 2026."
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The course fee is £20 for members and £35 for non-members."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives £35 as the non-member course fee and the report raises the loan deposit to £40 for loans from 1 January 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: The slide excerpt says only 'The course fee' and never names First Light, so the name goes beyond the excerpts."
},
{
"id": "en3b-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The loan induction for telescopes of 15 kg or more lasts about ten minutes, while walking the roughly 400 m footpath from the lower gate takes 45 minutes.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Telescopes weighing 15 kg or more, which at present are the 150 mm and 200 mm Dobsonians, may be lent only to a member who has completed the 45-minute loan induction."
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The footpath from the lower gate is about 400 m long and takes about ten minutes."
}
],
"why": "The 45 minutes belongs to the loan induction and the ten minutes to the footpath walk; the claim swaps them."
},
{
"id": "en3b-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3b-u13",
"claim": "The loan induction for telescopes of 15 kg or more lasts 45 minutes, while walking the roughly 400 m footpath from the lower gate takes about ten minutes.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Telescopes weighing 15 kg or more, which at present are the 150 mm and 200 mm Dobsonians, may be lent only to a member who has completed the 45-minute loan induction."
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The footpath from the lower gate is about 400 m long and takes about ten minutes."
}
],
"why": "The handbook names a 45-minute induction for telescopes of 15 kg or more and the slide gives about ten minutes for the 400 m footpath."
},
{
"id": "en3b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Three of the people who enrolled in the spring 2025 run did not complete it, and that run was full.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Spring run, 4 February to 11 March 2025: 16 enrolled (the maximum), 13 completed."
}
],
"why": "16 enrolled and 13 completed, so 3 did not complete, and 16 was the maximum.",
"audit": "FIX: The annual-report excerpt says only 'Spring run' and never names First Light, so the name goes beyond the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en3b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Loan L25-096 is listed under 14-17 and was co-signed by a parent, member M0489; for members aged 14 to 17, the rules make an adult member's co-signature on the loan form a condition of borrowing.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Members aged 14 to 17 may borrow only a telescope weighing less than 10 kg, and only with an adult member co-signing the loan form."
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: L25-096 | B: T14 | C: M0488 | D: 14-17 | E: 2025-12-06 | F: 2025-12-20 | G: 2025-12-20 | H: 0 | I: 0 | J: No | K: Co-signed by parent, member M0489"
}
],
"why": "The handbook requires an adult member to co-sign for borrowers aged 14 to 17, and the row shows a 14-17 borrower whose loan was co-signed by a parent who is member M0489.",
"audit": "FIX: The row says only 'parent', never that the co-signer is an adult, so calling M0489 an adult member who meets the rule rests on world knowledge. | FIX2: Without the header row nothing shows that column D is the borrower's age or that the parent is the borrower's; the claim now keeps to the row's own values."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Members can reserve any pier in the Annexe for their own telescopes, no more than twice a month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Members may book Annexe piers 2 and 3 for their own telescopes, at most twice a month."
}
],
"why": "Only Annexe piers 2 and 3 can be booked, not any pier."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u01",
"claim": "Members can reserve piers 2 and 3 in the Annexe for their own telescopes, no more than twice a month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Members may book Annexe piers 2 and 3 for their own telescopes, at most twice a month."
}
],
"why": "It restates which piers members may book and the twice-a-month limit."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Up to 50 bookings are accepted for the public evening on Friday 6 February 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The next public evening is on Friday 6 February 2026, and bookings are capped at 40."
}
],
"why": "Bookings are capped at 40, not 50."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u02",
"claim": "Up to 40 bookings are accepted for the public evening on Friday 6 February 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "The next public evening is on Friday 6 February 2026, and bookings are capped at 40."
}
],
"why": "Bookings for that evening are capped at 40."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "No sky reading was taken at the Spring Moon public evening on 2025-03-07 because the event was fully booked.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-03-07 | B: Fri | C: Public evening | D: Spring Moon | E: Held | G: 95 | H: 40 | J: Priya Lindgren | K: Fully booked; Annexe telescopes only; no sky reading as Moon above horizon"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the Moon being above the horizon as the reason for no sky reading; being fully booked is a separate note."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u03",
"claim": "No sky reading was taken at the Spring Moon public evening on 2025-03-07 because the Moon was above the horizon.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-03-07 | B: Fri | C: Public evening | D: Spring Moon | E: Held | G: 95 | H: 40 | J: Priya Lindgren | K: Fully booked; Annexe telescopes only; no sky reading as Moon above horizon"
}
],
"why": "The note says no sky reading as Moon above horizon."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Replacing the eyepiece and finder set that comes with each telescope now costs about £45 because the deposit went up from £30 to £40.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "the deposit was £30 for loans starting before 1 January 2026. It was raised to £40 because the replacement cost of the eyepiece and finder set lent with each telescope has risen to about £45."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the deposit rose because the replacement cost rose, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u04",
"claim": "The deposit went up from £30 to £40 because replacing the eyepiece and finder set that comes with each telescope now costs about £45.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "the deposit was £30 for loans starting before 1 January 2026. It was raised to £40 because the replacement cost of the eyepiece and finder set lent with each telescope has risen to about £45."
}
],
"why": "The deposit was raised because the replacement cost of the set has risen to about £45."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The insurer's 2026 quote is 18% higher than the 2025 premium partly because of the membership fees the committee proposes from 1 April 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Our insurer has quoted £2,171 for 2026, an increase of 18% on the £1,840 paid in 2025. The committee also wants to build a dome reserve of £3,000 by the end of 2027, so that a future motor failure can be repaired without delay. For these two reasons the committee proposes the following membership fees from 1 April 2026, subject to approval at the Annual General Meeting on 14 March 2026:"
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the higher insurance quote is one of the reasons for the proposed fees, not a result of them."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u05",
"claim": "The membership fees the committee proposes from 1 April 2026 are motivated partly by a 2026 insurance quote 18% higher than the 2025 premium.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Our insurer has quoted £2,171 for 2026, an increase of 18% on the £1,840 paid in 2025. The committee also wants to build a dome reserve of £3,000 by the end of 2027, so that a future motor failure can be repaired without delay. For these two reasons the committee proposes the following membership fees from 1 April 2026, subject to approval at the Annual General Meeting on 14 March 2026:"
}
],
"why": "The insurance increase is one of the two reasons given for the fee proposal."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Loan telescopes are handed out and taken back in the warm room on Saturdays 10:00-12:00 and Wednesdays 19:00-20:00, because the warm room is kept locked at all other times; any other time needs the Loans Officer's written agreement in advance.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Telescopes are collected and returned in the warm room on Saturdays from 10:00 to 12:00 and on Wednesdays from 19:00 to 20:00. No other times are possible unless the Loans Officer agrees in writing beforehand."
}
],
"why": "No reason is given for the fixed times; the warm room being locked otherwise is not stated."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u06",
"claim": "Loan telescopes are handed out and taken back in the warm room on Saturdays 10:00-12:00 and Wednesdays 19:00-20:00; any other time needs the Loans Officer's written agreement in advance.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "Telescopes are collected and returned in the warm room on Saturdays from 10:00 to 12:00 and on Wednesdays from 19:00 to 20:00. No other times are possible unless the Loans Officer agrees in writing beforehand."
}
],
"why": "It restates the collection place, times and the written-agreement exception."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Site S5, Hartsmoor Farm, has a lit farmyard 300 m to its south whose lights are switched off by 23:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S5 | B: Hartsmoor Farm | C: 6.8 | D: 20.6 | E: 20.8 | F: 12 | G: 0.2 | H: Gwen Haddow | I: Lit farmyard 300 m to the south"
}
],
"why": "The row notes the lit farmyard but says nothing about when its lights are switched off."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u07",
"claim": "Site S5, Hartsmoor Farm, has a lit farmyard 300 m to its south.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S5 | B: Hartsmoor Farm | C: 6.8 | D: 20.6 | E: 20.8 | F: 12 | G: 0.2 | H: Gwen Haddow | I: Lit farmyard 300 m to the south"
}
],
"why": "The notes column says lit farmyard 300 m to the south."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "One 14-day renewal is allowed, and only when another member is on that telescope's waiting list.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "One renewal of 14 days, only if no other member is on the waiting list for that telescope"
}
],
"why": "Renewal is allowed only if no other member is on the waiting list, not when one is."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u08",
"claim": "One 14-day renewal is allowed, and only when no other member is on that telescope's waiting list.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "One renewal of 14 days, only if no other member is on the waiting list for that telescope"
}
],
"why": "It restates the single 14-day renewal and its waiting-list condition."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Each site's average sky was brighter than its 2024 average, by 0.1 to 0.3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Every site recorded a darker average sky than in 2024, by between 0.1 and 0.3."
}
],
"why": "Every site recorded a darker sky than in 2024, not a brighter one."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u09",
"claim": "Each site's average sky was darker than its 2024 average, by 0.1 to 0.3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Every site recorded a darker average sky than in 2024, by between 0.1 and 0.3."
}
],
"why": "Every site recorded a darker average sky than in 2024, by between 0.1 and 0.3."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Schools pay nothing for evening visits, which are open to schools at any distance from the observatory, for pupils aged 9 or over.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Evening visits are free for schools, but they are open only to schools within 25 km of the observatory and only to pupils aged 9 or over."
}
],
"why": "Evening visits are open only to schools within 25 km, not at any distance."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u10",
"claim": "Schools pay nothing for evening visits, which are open to schools no more than 25 km from the observatory, for pupils aged 9 or over.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Evening visits are free for schools, but they are open only to schools within 25 km of the observatory and only to pupils aged 9 or over."
}
],
"why": "It restates that evening visits are free and limited to schools within 25 km and pupils aged 9 or over."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Site S4, Wrexley Green village hall, is described as the brightest site, with 36 pledges in the streets around it.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S4 | B: Wrexley Green village hall | C: 3.1 | D: 20.2 | E: 20.4 | F: 19 | G: 0.2 | H: Owen Pryce | I: Brightest site; 41 pledges in the surrounding streets"
}
],
"why": "The row records 41 pledges, not 36.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to match its fixed twin, which no longer asserts a notes column the bare row does not label."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en3c-u11",
"claim": "Site S4, Wrexley Green village hall, is described as the brightest site, with 41 pledges in the streets around it.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S4 | B: Wrexley Green village hall | C: 3.1 | D: 20.2 | E: 20.4 | F: 19 | G: 0.2 | H: Owen Pryce | I: Brightest site; 41 pledges in the surrounding streets"
}
],
"why": "The notes column says brightest site; 41 pledges in the surrounding streets.",
"audit": "FIX: The row does not label column I as notes, and the claim copied the note's wording; reworded without the notes column, twin u11 changed to stay one number apart."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Ashcombe churchyard (site S6) is noted for the largest improvement and was also the darkest site, at 21.3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S6 | B: Ashcombe churchyard | C: 4 | D: 20.3 | E: 20.6 | F: 16 | G: 0.3 | H: Tomasz Wren | I: Largest improvement"
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The darkest site was the observatory itself, at 21.3, and the brightest was Wrexley Green village hall, at 20.4."
}
],
"why": "The darkest site at 21.3 was the observatory itself, not Ashcombe churchyard."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3c-u12",
"claim": "Ashcombe churchyard (site S6) is noted for the largest improvement, while the darkest site was the observatory itself, at 21.3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S6 | B: Ashcombe churchyard | C: 4 | D: 20.3 | E: 20.6 | F: 16 | G: 0.3 | H: Tomasz Wren | I: Largest improvement"
},
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "The darkest site was the observatory itself, at 21.3, and the brightest was Wrexley Green village hall, at 20.4."
}
],
"why": "The spreadsheet row marks S6 as largest improvement and the report names the observatory as darkest at 21.3."
},
{
"id": "en3c-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "S1, Tallow Hill Observatory, marked as the darkest site, had a 2025 average of 20.8 magnitudes per square arcsecond.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S1 | B: Tallow Hill Observatory | C: 0 | D: 21.1 | E: 21.3 | F: 22 | G: 0.2 | H: Marta Ilves | I: Darkest site"
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Sky readings at our six monitoring sites averaged 20.8 magnitudes per square arcsecond in 2025."
}
],
"why": "20.8 is the average across all six monitoring sites, not the figure for S1."
},
{
"id": "en3c-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en3c-u13",
"claim": "S1, Tallow Hill Observatory, is marked as the darkest site, while the six monitoring sites together averaged 20.8 magnitudes per square arcsecond in 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-telescopes-loans-sessions.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: S1 | B: Tallow Hill Observatory | C: 0 | D: 21.1 | E: 21.3 | F: 22 | G: 0.2 | H: Marta Ilves | I: Darkest site"
},
{
"file": "first-light-course-introduction.pptx.md",
"text": "Sky readings at our six monitoring sites averaged 20.8 magnitudes per square arcsecond in 2025."
}
],
"why": "The row marks S1 as darkest site and the slide gives 20.8 as the six-site average."
},
{
"id": "en3c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "A borrowed telescope must not be passed on to other people, even relatives who are not covered by the loan.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-observatory-handbook.docx.md",
"text": "The telescope may not be lent on to anyone else, including family members who are not covered by the loan."
}
],
"why": "It restates the ban on lending the telescope on, including to uncovered family members."
},
{
"id": "en3c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "The campaign's pledge count rose by 107 over the year to 31 December 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "tallow-hill-annual-report-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "By 31 December 2025 the campaign had 312 pledges, up from 205 a year earlier."
}
],
"why": "312 minus 205 is 107.",
"audit": "FIX: 312 against 205 gives only the net rise, so 'gained 107 pledges' could be disputed if some pledges were withdrawn; state it as a net increase."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "All 37 boats that took part in the Open Regatta came from six visiting clubs.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The Open Regatta attracted 37 boats, 15 of them from six visiting clubs, which is 8 more boats than in 2025."
}
],
"why": "Only 15 of the 37 boats came from visiting clubs, not all of them.",
"audit": "FIX: Twin closeness: the twin also names six visiting clubs, so the unsupported claim should differ only in 'all' versus 'fifteen of'."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u01",
"claim": "Fifteen of the 37 boats that took part in the Open Regatta came from six visiting clubs.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The Open Regatta attracted 37 boats, 15 of them from six visiting clubs, which is 8 more boats than in 2025."
}
],
"why": "The report states 37 boats, 15 of them from six visiting clubs."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "A thunderstorm forced the abandonment of the 26 April Spring Series race, while the 15 July Summer Evening Series race was cancelled for lack of a qualified safety boat helm.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The Spring Series race on 26 April was cancelled because no qualified safety boat helm was available, which is the first time in six years that a race has been lost for that reason. The Summer Evening Series race on 15 July was abandoned after the first lap because of a thunderstorm."
}
],
"why": "The causes are swapped: 26 April was lost for lack of a safety boat helm and 15 July to a thunderstorm.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one swap (the two races) away from the reworded twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u02",
"claim": "A thunderstorm forced the abandonment of the 15 July Summer Evening Series race, while the 26 April Spring Series race was cancelled for lack of a qualified safety boat helm.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The Spring Series race on 26 April was cancelled because no qualified safety boat helm was available, which is the first time in six years that a race has been lost for that reason. The Summer Evening Series race on 15 July was abandoned after the first lap because of a thunderstorm."
}
],
"why": "Each race is given the cause the report names for it.",
"audit": "FIX: The second clause is a near-verbatim copy of the excerpt sentence with only 'after the first lap' dropped."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Of the nine members waiting for a mooring, the committee thinks most will be offered one ahead of the 2028 season.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "We now have a waiting list for moorings for the first time since 2019. Nine members are on it, and the committee expects that most of them will not be offered a mooring before the 2028 season."
}
],
"why": "The committee expects most of them will NOT be offered a mooring before the 2028 season.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (the negation) from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u03",
"claim": "Of the nine members waiting for a mooring, the committee thinks most will not be offered one ahead of the 2028 season.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "We now have a waiting list for moorings for the first time since 2019. Nine members are on it, and the committee expects that most of them will not be offered a mooring before the 2028 season."
}
],
"why": "Restates that most of the nine will not be offered a mooring before the 2028 season.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Not ... until the 2028 season' implies they will get a mooring in 2028, which the excerpt does not say; also 'does not expect' is weaker than 'expects ... will not'."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "The Lookout Room can take up to 24 people, serves both as the race office and as a training room, and is kept locked outside race days and training sessions.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The main room holds up to 80 people and the Lookout Room up to 24. The Lookout Room is used as the race office and for training; food and drink other than water are not allowed in it, because the training charts and radios are kept there."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the Lookout Room is locked outside race days and training sessions.",
"audit": "FIX: Twin closeness: reworded to be the twin's wording plus the one added locking detail."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u04",
"claim": "The Lookout Room can take up to 24 people and serves both as the race office and as a training room.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The main room holds up to 80 people and the Lookout Room up to 24. The Lookout Room is used as the race office and for training; food and drink other than water are not allowed in it, because the training charts and radios are kept there."
}
],
"why": "Capacity 24 and use as race office and for training are both stated."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "No duties are required of a member who is 75 or older on 1 March, and such a member is not allowed to volunteer for them.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Members aged 75 or over on 1 March are exempt from duties but may still volunteer for them."
}
],
"why": "The handbook says such members may still volunteer, not that they are barred.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (allowed versus not allowed) from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u05",
"claim": "No duties are required of a member who is 75 or older on 1 March, but such a member is still allowed to volunteer for them.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Members aged 75 or over on 1 March are exempt from duties but may still volunteer for them."
}
],
"why": "Restates the exemption and the permission to volunteer.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy: same words in the same order with a few synonyms swapped."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The Boat Replacement Fund paid £4,200 for the Tern 12 boat T7, which was bought in May 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T7 | B: Tern 12 | C: 2107 | D: 2026 | E: 3.6 | F: 52 | G: 0 | H: New | I: 2026-05-09 | J: 64 | K: Bought May 2026 for £3,900 from Boat Replacement Fund"
}
],
"why": "T7 was bought for £3,900, not £4,200.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (the price) from the fixed twin; 4,200 still does not occur in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u06",
"claim": "The Boat Replacement Fund paid £3,900 for the Tern 12 boat T7, which was bought in May 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T7 | B: Tern 12 | C: 2107 | D: 2026 | E: 3.6 | F: 52 | G: 0 | H: New | I: 2026-05-09 | J: 64 | K: Bought May 2026 for £3,900 from Boat Replacement Fund"
}
],
"why": "The row's class and note give the class, month, price and fund.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy of the note cell 'Bought May 2026 for £3,900 from Boat Replacement Fund' with one word swapped."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Being out of use since 22 August 2026 has caused a leak in the centreboard case of Heron 14 H2.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: H2 | B: Heron 14 | C: 1402 | D: 2011 | E: 4.3 | F: 98 | G: 0 | H: Poor | I: 2026-03-21 | J: 38 | K: Out of use since 22 August 2026: centreboard case leak; winter repair"
}
],
"why": "The leak is the reason H2 is out of use, not a consequence of it.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded so the swap of cause and effect is the only change from the fixed twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u07",
"claim": "A leak in its centreboard case has kept Heron 14 H2 out of use since 22 August 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: H2 | B: Heron 14 | C: 1402 | D: 2011 | E: 4.3 | F: 98 | G: 0 | H: Poor | I: 2026-03-21 | J: 38 | K: Out of use since 22 August 2026: centreboard case leak; winter repair"
}
],
"why": "The note gives the date out of use, the centreboard case leak as reason and a winter repair.",
"audit": "FIX: Twin closeness: the winter-repair clause and the sentence shape made it more than one change from its unsupported pair."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Mallard, an aluminium workboat, is used only for mooring work and may be helmed only by the Moorings Officer.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Mallard | B: Workboat (aluminium) | C: n/a | D: 2008 | E: 5.5 | F: 520 | G: 20 | H: Fair | I: 2026-02-28 | J: 46 | K: Mooring work only; not a primary safety boat"
}
],
"why": "The row says nothing about who may helm Mallard."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u08",
"claim": "Mallard, an aluminium workboat, is used only for mooring work and does not serve as a primary safety boat.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Mallard | B: Workboat (aluminium) | C: n/a | D: 2008 | E: 5.5 | F: 520 | G: 20 | H: Fair | I: 2026-02-28 | J: 46 | K: Mooring work only; not a primary safety boat"
}
],
"why": "The class and note state an aluminium workboat for mooring work only, not a primary safety boat."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Under the committee's proposal, from 1 March 2027 the full adult rate would be £298 and the family rate £460.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The committee proposes a full adult rate of £298 and a family rate of £450 from 1 March 2027."
}
],
"why": "The proposed family rate is £450, not £460.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Raising' is not given by the excerpt (no current rate is in it); removed so the only error is the family rate, and 460 still does not occur in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u09",
"claim": "Under the committee's proposal, from 1 March 2027 the full adult rate would be £298 and the family rate £450.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The committee proposes a full adult rate of £298 and a family rate of £450 from 1 March 2027."
}
],
"why": "Both proposed rates and the start date match the slide.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Raising' goes beyond the excerpt, which gives the proposed rates but no current rate to compare with."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "In summer the bar opens every weekday evening from 18:00 to 22:30 and on Saturday and Sunday afternoons from 12:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "In summer the bar opens on Wednesdays 18:00 to 22:30, Saturdays 12:00 to 18:00 and Sundays 12:00 to 17:00."
}
],
"why": "The evening opening is on Wednesdays only, not every weekday."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u10",
"claim": "In summer the bar opens on Wednesday evenings from 18:00 to 22:30 and on Saturday and Sunday afternoons from 12:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "In summer the bar opens on Wednesdays 18:00 to 22:30, Saturdays 12:00 to 18:00 and Sundays 12:00 to 17:00."
}
],
"why": "Wednesday 18:00-22:30 and Saturday and Sunday from 12:00 are the stated summer hours."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Each person signing in guests is capped at three guests per day and at six sign-ins per season for any one guest, and each guest must sign the visitors' book on arrival.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "You may sign in up to 3 guests a day, and the same guest up to 6 times a season."
}
],
"why": "No visitors' book condition is mentioned.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one added condition away from the fixed twin. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t11 so the pair differs only by the added visitors' book condition."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4a-u11",
"claim": "Each person signing in guests is capped at three guests per day and at six sign-ins per season for any one guest.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "You may sign in up to 3 guests a day, and the same guest up to 6 times a season."
}
],
"why": "Restates both guest limits.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy: the excerpt's words in the same order with 'up to' and the subject swapped. | FIX2: The excerpt says 'You' and never says 'member', so 'A member's' adds a scope; reworded to keep the per-person limit without it."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Subscriptions follow a club year starting on 1 October, while the report covers a club year that began on 1 October 2025 and ended on 30 September 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The club year for subscriptions runs from 1 March to the last day of February."
},
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "This report covers the club year from 1 October 2025 to 30 September 2026."
}
],
"why": "The 1 October to 30 September span is the annual report's club year; the subscription year runs from 1 March to the end of February.",
"audit": "FIX: Twin closeness: the old claim was a fragment of the twin, not one change from it; now only the subscription start date is taken from the report. | FIX2: 'annual' comes only from the file name; dropped in step with the twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4a-u12",
"claim": "Subscriptions follow a club year starting on 1 March, while the report covers a club year that began on 1 October 2025 and ended on 30 September 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The club year for subscriptions runs from 1 March to the last day of February."
},
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "This report covers the club year from 1 October 2025 to 30 September 2026."
}
],
"why": "Each span is attributed to the document and subject that states it.",
"audit": "FIX: The first clause copied the handbook sentence nearly word for word, and the unsupported twin was not one change away. | FIX2: The excerpt says 'This report', and 'annual' comes only from the file name, an extra adjective; dropped."
},
{
"id": "en4a-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The general reserve paid £3,900 for the Tern 12 boat T8 in May 2026, while the AGM is asked to approve spending £7,390 of the general reserve on the slipway repair.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T8 | B: Tern 12 | C: 2108 | D: 2026 | E: 3.6 | F: 52 | G: 0 | H: New | I: 2026-05-09 | J: 58 | K: Bought May 2026 for £3,900 from Boat Replacement Fund"
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The AGM is also asked to approve £7,390 from the general reserve for the slipway repair."
}
],
"why": "T8 was paid from the Boat Replacement Fund; the general reserve is the source proposed for the slipway repair.",
"audit": "FIX: Twin closeness: now the fund paying for T8 is the one change from the twin."
},
{
"id": "en4a-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4a-u13",
"claim": "The Boat Replacement Fund paid £3,900 for the Tern 12 boat T8 in May 2026, while the AGM is asked to approve spending £7,390 of the general reserve on the slipway repair.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T8 | B: Tern 12 | C: 2108 | D: 2026 | E: 3.6 | F: 52 | G: 0 | H: New | I: 2026-05-09 | J: 58 | K: Bought May 2026 for £3,900 from Boat Replacement Fund"
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The AGM is also asked to approve £7,390 from the general reserve for the slipway repair."
}
],
"why": "Each funding source is attributed to the item it pays for in its own excerpt.",
"audit": "FIX: First clause was a near-verbatim copy of the note cell, and 'asked to draw' shifts the excerpt's 'asked to approve'."
},
{
"id": "en4a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "A family membership costs £430, and the full adult rate of £285 is £15 higher than the full adult subscription was in 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "A full adult membership costs £285 and a family membership costs £430."
},
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The full adult subscription rose from £270 in 2025 to £285 in 2026."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives the £430 family rate and the report the rise from £270 to £285, a £15 increase.",
"audit": "FIX: 'In 2026' for the family rate is not given by the slide excerpt, which has no date."
},
{
"id": "en4a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Tern 12 T2 has a small crack in the gelcoat of its transom, which is to be checked every month.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: T2 | B: Tern 12 | C: 2102 | D: 2014 | E: 3.6 | F: 52 | G: 0 | H: Fair | I: 2026-03-14 | J: 88 | K: Small gelcoat crack on transom; check monthly"
}
],
"why": "The row's note states a small gelcoat crack on the transom to be checked monthly."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The club paid for two members to qualify as senior instructors mainly because training costs went up from £3,720 to £4,860.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Two members qualified as senior instructors at the club's expense, which is the main reason training costs rose from £3,720 to £4,860."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the paid qualifications are the main reason the training costs rose, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "en4b-u01",
"claim": "Training costs went up from £3,720 to £4,860, mainly because the club paid for two members to qualify as senior instructors.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Two members qualified as senior instructors at the club's expense, which is the main reason training costs rose from £3,720 to £4,860."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names the club-funded qualification of two senior instructors as the main reason training costs rose from £3,720 to £4,860."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Built in 1984, the slipway measures 43 metres in length and 4.5 metres in width.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The slipway was built in 1984 and is 34 metres long and 4.5 metres wide."
}
],
"why": "The slipway is 34 metres long, not 43."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u02",
"claim": "Built in 1984, the slipway measures 34 metres in length and 4.5 metres in width.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The slipway was built in 1984 and is 34 metres long and 4.5 metres wide."
}
],
"why": "Year built, length and width are all stated in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "While the slipway is closed from 2 January to 28 February 2027, the safety boats will use a temporary pontoon at the north beach and members can still launch their own boats.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The slipway will be closed to everyone from 2 January to 28 February 2027, which is two days longer at each end than the contractor's works, so that the site can be set up and cleared safely. During that time the safety boats will launch from the temporary pontoon at the north beach, and members will not be able to launch their own boats at all."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says members will not be able to launch their own boats at all during the closure."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u03",
"claim": "While the slipway is closed from 2 January to 28 February 2027, the safety boats will use a temporary pontoon at the north beach and members cannot launch their own boats.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The slipway will be closed to everyone from 2 January to 28 February 2027, which is two days longer at each end than the contractor's works, so that the site can be set up and cleared safely. During that time the safety boats will launch from the temporary pontoon at the north beach, and members will not be able to launch their own boats at all."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the closure dates, the temporary pontoon for safety boats and that members cannot launch their own boats."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Members of any age, along with guests they have signed in, can be served at the bar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The bar serves only members aged 18 or over and their signed-in guests."
}
],
"why": "The bar serves only members aged 18 or over, not members of any age."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u04",
"claim": "Only members who are at least 18, along with guests they have signed in, can be served at the bar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The bar serves only members aged 18 or over and their signed-in guests."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt limits bar service to members aged 18 or over and their signed-in guests."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "The minimum third-party liability cover required for any boat on a mooring is £3 million, and the insurance certificate must be shown to the Moorings Officer each April.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Every moored boat must have third-party liability insurance of at least £3 million."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says nothing about showing a certificate to the Moorings Officer or about April.",
"audit": "FIX: Dropped 'club' before 'mooring' (the excerpt says only 'moored boat') so the pair differs from its twin t05 by the added certificate clause alone. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t05 so the pair differs only by the added certificate clause."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u05",
"claim": "The minimum third-party liability cover required for any boat on a mooring is £3 million.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Every moored boat must have third-party liability insurance of at least £3 million."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt requires every moored boat to have at least £3 million of third-party liability insurance.",
"audit": " | FIX2: Near-verbatim copy: the excerpt's sentence in the same order with only synonyms swapped (moored boat, must have, insurance, at least)."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Because launching trolleys have been taken beyond the yellow marker, the lower section of the slipway is damaged.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Launching trolleys must not be taken beyond the yellow marker on the slipway, because the lower section is damaged."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the damage as the reason for the trolley rule, not trolleys as the cause of the damage."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u06",
"claim": "Because the lower section of the slipway is damaged, launching trolleys have to stop at the yellow marker.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Launching trolleys must not be taken beyond the yellow marker on the slipway, because the lower section is damaged."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt forbids taking trolleys beyond the yellow marker because the lower section is damaged."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Fuel may be kept inside the boat shed or the clubhouse as well as in the fuel locker outside the boat shed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Fuel must not be kept in the boat shed or the clubhouse; it is stored only in the fuel locker outside the boat shed, which holds no more than 100 litres of petrol."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says fuel must not be kept in the boat shed or the clubhouse."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u07",
"claim": "Fuel may not be kept inside the boat shed or the clubhouse; its only place is the fuel locker outside the boat shed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Fuel must not be kept in the boat shed or the clubhouse; it is stored only in the fuel locker outside the boat shed, which holds no more than 100 litres of petrol."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt forbids fuel in the boat shed and clubhouse and stores it only in the fuel locker outside the shed."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The N07 entry for C. Dewhurst and Merrybell records payment on 24 April 2026 and notes that the committee allowed late payment once.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N07 | B: C. Dewhurst | C: Merrybell | D: Small cruiser | E: 6.8 | F: 265 | G: No | H: 2026-03 | I: Let | J: Paid 14 April 2026; committee allowed late payment once"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the payment date as 14 April 2026, not 24 April.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded in step with t08 so the twins stay one change (the date) apart. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t08 so the pair stays one change (the date) apart."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u08",
"claim": "The N07 entry for C. Dewhurst and Merrybell records payment on 14 April 2026 and notes that the committee allowed late payment once.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N07 | B: C. Dewhurst | C: Merrybell | D: Small cruiser | E: 6.8 | F: 265 | G: No | H: 2026-03 | I: Let | J: Paid 14 April 2026; committee allowed late payment once"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says paid 14 April 2026 and that the committee allowed late payment once.",
"audit": "FIX: Without the header row the row does not show that C. Dewhurst owns Merrybell, so the possessive goes beyond the excerpt. | FIX2: The row lists the payment date and the committee's allowance side by side but never says this payment was the late one; the appositive asserted it."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Teal, the day boat listed under N11 with H. Oduya, is the smallest boat on any of the club's moorings.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N11 | B: H. Oduya | C: Teal | D: Day boat | E: 5.2 | F: 210 | G: Yes | H: 2025-03 | I: Let | J: Smallest boat on the north trot"
}
],
"why": "The row says Teal is the smallest boat on the north trot only, not on every mooring."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u09",
"claim": "Teal, the day boat listed under N11 with H. Oduya, is the smallest boat on the north trot.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N11 | B: H. Oduya | C: Teal | D: Day boat | E: 5.2 | F: 210 | G: Yes | H: 2025-03 | I: Let | J: Smallest boat on the north trot"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says it is the smallest boat on the north trot."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Everybody out on the water has to wear a buoyancy aid, but on the pontoons juniors do not have to wear one.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Everyone afloat must wear a buoyancy aid, and juniors must wear one on the pontoons too."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says juniors must wear a buoyancy aid on the pontoons too.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded in step with t10 so the twins stay one change (the polarity) apart."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u10",
"claim": "Everybody out on the water has to wear a buoyancy aid, and on the pontoons juniors have to wear one as well.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Everyone afloat must wear a buoyancy aid, and juniors must wear one on the pontoons too."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt requires buoyancy aids for everyone afloat and for juniors on the pontoons as well.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim was a near-verbatim copy of the excerpt (same order, two words swapped)."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "No boat may be launched while the Officer of the Day is flying the red flag, and boats already afloat must then return to shore.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "When the Officer of the Day flies the red flag, no boat may launch."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt only forbids launching; it says nothing about boats already afloat returning to shore."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4b-u11",
"claim": "No boat may be launched while the Officer of the Day is flying the red flag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "When the Officer of the Day flies the red flag, no boat may launch."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says no boat may launch when the Officer of the Day flies the red flag."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "N16, like moorings N09 and N17, has been out of use since its sinker failed inspection in March 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "two north trot moorings, N09 and N17, have been out of use since their sinkers failed inspection in March 2026; they will be replaced over the winter, and their former holders will be offered them first."
},
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N16 | B: W. Harker | C: Orion | D: Small cruiser | E: 7 | F: 265 | G: Yes | H: 2026-03 | I: Let | J: Chain renewed March 2026"
}
],
"why": "The failed sinker inspection and out-of-use status belong to N09 and N17; the spreadsheet row shows N16 as let, with its chain renewed in March 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded in step with t12 so the twins stay one change apart."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4b-u12",
"claim": "N16 had its chain renewed in March 2026, the same month in which moorings N09 and N17 were taken out of use after their sinkers failed inspection.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "two north trot moorings, N09 and N17, have been out of use since their sinkers failed inspection in March 2026; they will be replaced over the winter, and their former holders will be offered them first."
},
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: N16 | B: W. Harker | C: Orion | D: Small cruiser | E: 7 | F: 265 | G: Yes | H: 2026-03 | I: Let | J: Chain renewed March 2026"
}
],
"why": "The report places the failed sinker inspections of N09 and N17 in March 2026, and the spreadsheet row notes the chain of N16 was renewed in March 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: Without the header row the spreadsheet row does not say N16 is a mooring, so the label 'Mooring' goes beyond the excerpts. | FIX2: The second half copies the report excerpt word for word ('N09 and N17, have been out of use since their sinkers failed inspection'); reworded, and u12 is still one change away."
},
{
"id": "en4b-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Juniors must be at least 8 years old, and from that age they may sail club boats without an instructor present if they hold Level 3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Juniors may sail club boats without an instructor present only from the age of 14 and only if they hold Level 3."
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Juniors must be at least 8 years old and able to swim 50 metres in clothes with a buoyancy aid."
}
],
"why": "The age of 8 is the slides' minimum for juniors; the handbook sets 14 as the minimum age for sailing club boats without an instructor."
},
{
"id": "en4b-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4b-u13",
"claim": "Juniors must be at least 8 years old, but they may sail club boats without an instructor present only from 14 and with Level 3.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Juniors may sail club boats without an instructor present only from the age of 14 and only if they hold Level 3."
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Juniors must be at least 8 years old and able to swim 50 metres in clothes with a buoyancy aid."
}
],
"why": "The slides set the junior minimum age at 8 and the handbook sets 14 plus Level 3 for sailing club boats without an instructor."
},
{
"id": "en4b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Charges for missed duties came to £1,085 over the season, since each of the 31 duties missed without a swap cost £35.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The duty system asked for 564 duties during the season. Members completed 533 of them and 31 were missed without a swap, each of which was charged at £35 under the current rules."
}
],
"why": "31 missed duties at £35 each make £1,085."
},
{
"id": "en4b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Helmed by Owen Fairclough with Lily Fairclough crewing, the Heron 14 in position 1 finished on 9 net points after sailing 9 races.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Position | B: Helm | C: Crew | D: Class | E: Sail no. | F: Club yardstick | G: Races sailed | H: Net points | I: Notes"
},
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 1 | B: Owen Fairclough | C: Lily Fairclough | D: Heron 14 | E: 3317 | F: 1085 | G: 9 | H: 9 | I: Series winners; two discards"
}
],
"why": "The header names columns B, C, G and H as helm, crew, races sailed and net points, and the row gives their values for position 1."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Dogs are not allowed in the boat park or on the pontoons at any time.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Dogs are not allowed in the boat park or on the pontoons on junior training days."
}
],
"why": "The ban applies only on junior training days, not at all times."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u01",
"claim": "On junior training days, dogs are banned from both the boat park and the pontoons.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Dogs are not allowed in the boat park or on the pontoons on junior training days."
}
],
"why": "Restates the ban with its limit to junior training days."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "A junior younger than 14 may leave the clubhouse alone and does not have to be picked up by a parent or guardian.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Juniors under 14 must be collected from the clubhouse by a parent or guardian, and may not leave on their own."
}
],
"why": "The rule says juniors under 14 must be collected and may not leave on their own."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u02",
"claim": "A junior younger than 14 cannot leave the clubhouse alone and has to be picked up by a parent or guardian.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Juniors under 14 must be collected from the clubhouse by a parent or guardian, and may not leave on their own."
}
],
"why": "Restates the collection rule for juniors under 14."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "One Spring Series race was cancelled and one Summer Evening race abandoned because race entry fees fell by £150.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Race entry fees fell slightly, by £150, because one Spring Series race was cancelled and one Summer Evening race was abandoned."
}
],
"why": "The fall in entry fees was the effect of the cancelled and abandoned races, not their cause."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u03",
"claim": "Race entry income dropped slightly, by £150, as a result of one cancelled Spring Series race and one abandoned Summer Evening race.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Race entry fees fell slightly, by £150, because one Spring Series race was cancelled and one Summer Evening race was abandoned."
}
],
"why": "Restates the cause and effect in the same direction as the text."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Under the lease, which lasts until 2041, the ground rent stays at £9,500 per year until the rent review due in April 2031.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The ground rent is fixed at £9,500 a year until the next rent review in April 2029 under the lease, which runs until 2041."
}
],
"why": "The next rent review is in April 2029, not 2031."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u04",
"claim": "Under the lease, which lasts until 2041, the ground rent stays at £9,500 per year until the rent review due in April 2029.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The ground rent is fixed at £9,500 a year until the next rent review in April 2029 under the lease, which runs until 2041."
}
],
"why": "Restates the rent, the review date and the lease end."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "The mooring laying day, held on 10 April 2027, is not a sailing day, and only the workboat Mallard is used.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-03 | B: Saturday | C: Mooring laying day | D: 09:30 | E: Alan Treadgold | F: Sam Ridley | G: Will Harker | H: - | I: 0 | J: Workboat Mallard only; not a sailing day"
}
],
"why": "The row dates the mooring laying day 2027-04-03, not 10 April."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u05",
"claim": "The mooring laying day, held on 3 April 2027, is not a sailing day, and only the workboat Mallard is used.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-03 | B: Saturday | C: Mooring laying day | D: 09:30 | E: Alan Treadgold | F: Sam Ridley | G: Will Harker | H: - | I: 0 | J: Workboat Mallard only; not a sailing day"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the date 2027-04-03 and the note on the workboat and no sailing."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "For Spring Series race 6 on Sunday 16 May 2027, Owen Fairclough replaces Ivo Marchetti in an agreed swap because Ivo Marchetti is away on holiday.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-05-16 | B: Sunday | C: Spring Series race 6 | D: 10:30 | E: Priya Castellan | F: Owen Fairclough | G: Joel Oduya | H: Ivo Marchetti | I: 2 | J: Swap agreed: Owen Fairclough replaces Ivo Marchetti"
}
],
"why": "The row gives no reason for the swap; the holiday is invented."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u06",
"claim": "For Spring Series race 6 on Sunday 16 May 2027, an agreed swap puts Owen Fairclough in Ivo Marchetti's place.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-05-16 | B: Sunday | C: Spring Series race 6 | D: 10:30 | E: Priya Castellan | F: Owen Fairclough | G: Joel Oduya | H: Ivo Marchetti | I: 2 | J: Swap agreed: Owen Fairclough replaces Ivo Marchetti"
}
],
"why": "The row records the date, the race and the agreed swap."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Every club member must attend the safety boat refresher held at the season opening on 10 April 2027.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-10 | B: Saturday | C: Season opening and safety boat refresher | D: 10:00 | E: Fiona Brackley | F: Fiona Brackley | G: Joel Oduya | H: Ruth Penhallow | I: 1 | J: Refresher required for all 2027 safety boat helms"
}
],
"why": "The refresher is required only for the 2027 safety boat helms, not for every member."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u07",
"claim": "Every safety boat helm for 2027 must attend the safety boat refresher held at the season opening on 10 April 2027.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-10 | B: Saturday | C: Season opening and safety boat refresher | D: 10:00 | E: Fiona Brackley | F: Fiona Brackley | G: Joel Oduya | H: Ruth Penhallow | I: 1 | J: Refresher required for all 2027 safety boat helms"
}
],
"why": "The row says the refresher on 2027-04-10 is required for all 2027 safety boat helms."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "During the closure, members are still able to launch their own boats, and the safety boats operate from the north beach pontoon.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Members cannot launch their own boats during the closure; the safety boats will use the north beach pontoon."
}
],
"why": "Members cannot launch their own boats during the closure.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt speaks only of 'the closure' and never names the slipway, so 'while the slipway is shut' adds a second unsupported detail beside the reversed polarity; reworded to the excerpt's own scope."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u08",
"claim": "During the closure, members are unable to launch their own boats, and the safety boats operate from the north beach pontoon.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Members cannot launch their own boats during the closure; the safety boats will use the north beach pontoon."
}
],
"why": "Restates both halves of the closure rule.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt never says the closure is of the slipway, so the supported twin went beyond the excerpt; reworded to 'during the closure', still one change from u08."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "The cancellation of one Spring Series race left no safety boat helm available.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "One Spring Series race was cancelled because no safety boat helm was available."
}
],
"why": "The missing helm caused the cancellation, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u09",
"claim": "The lack of an available safety boat helm led to the cancellation of one Spring Series race.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "One Spring Series race was cancelled because no safety boat helm was available."
}
],
"why": "Restates the cause and effect in the same direction."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Frostbite Series races take place on Sundays between 8 November and 20 December 2026, with the first warning at 11:00, and are open to non-members.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The Frostbite Series runs on Sundays from 8 November to 20 December 2026, with first warning at 11:00."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about non-members taking part."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "en4c-u10",
"claim": "Frostbite Series races take place on Sundays between 8 November and 20 December 2026, with the first warning at 11:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "The Frostbite Series runs on Sundays from 8 November to 20 December 2026, with first warning at 11:00."
}
],
"why": "Restates the days, dates and first warning time."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "The 2026 junior membership rate is £120, the same as the season fee for junior training.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The season fee for junior training is £120 for junior members; children who are not members cannot join the programme."
},
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Membership category 2026 rate (£) Proposed 2027 rate (£) Full adult 285 298 Family 430 450 Junior (under 18) 95 95"
}
],
"why": "£120 is the junior training season fee; the 2026 junior membership rate is £95."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4c-u11",
"claim": "The 2026 junior membership rate is £95, which is less than the £120 season fee for junior training.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "The season fee for junior training is £120 for junior members; children who are not members cannot join the programme."
},
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Membership category 2026 rate (£) Proposed 2027 rate (£) Full adult 285 298 Family 430 450 Junior (under 18) 95 95"
}
],
"why": "The report gives the junior rate as 95 and the handbook gives the training fee as £120."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "An Officer of the Day must be at least 18 and hold the Club Powerboat Certificate, while a safety boat helm needs at least one full season of membership.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "An Officer of the Day must have been a member for at least one full season."
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "A safety boat helm must be 18 or over and hold the Club Powerboat Certificate; crew must be 16 or over."
}
],
"why": "The age and certificate rule belongs to the safety boat helm and the full-season rule to the Officer of the Day."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4c-u12",
"claim": "A safety boat helm must be at least 18 and hold the Club Powerboat Certificate, while an Officer of the Day needs at least one full season of membership.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "An Officer of the Day must have been a member for at least one full season."
},
{
"file": "new-members-welcome-evening-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "A safety boat helm must be 18 or over and hold the Club Powerboat Certificate; crew must be 16 or over."
}
],
"why": "Each requirement is given to the role its source names."
},
{
"id": "en4c-u13",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Spring Series race 1 is held on the season opening day, Saturday 10 April 2027.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Finally, the 2027 season will begin with the fitting-out work party on Saturday 27 March 2027. The boatman will lay the mooring buoys from the workboat on Saturday 3 April, so moored boats can go on their moorings from that afternoon, and the season opening day is Saturday 10 April."
},
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-11 | B: Sunday | C: Spring Series race 1 | D: 10:30 | E: Priya Castellan | F: Mark Okonjo | G: Kit Rasmussen | H: Hannah Oduya | I: 2"
}
],
"why": "Saturday 10 April is the season opening day; Spring Series race 1 is on Sunday 2027-04-11."
},
{
"id": "en4c-t13",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "en4c-u13",
"claim": "Spring Series race 1 is held on Sunday 11 April 2027, the day after the season opening day on Saturday 10 April.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "Finally, the 2027 season will begin with the fitting-out work party on Saturday 27 March 2027. The boatman will lay the mooring buoys from the workboat on Saturday 3 April, so moored boats can go on their moorings from that afternoon, and the season opening day is Saturday 10 April."
},
{
"file": "fleet-moorings-results-and-duty-rota.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2027-04-11 | B: Sunday | C: Spring Series race 1 | D: 10:30 | E: Priya Castellan | F: Mark Okonjo | G: Kit Rasmussen | H: Hannah Oduya | I: 2"
}
],
"why": "The report dates the opening day 10 April 2027 and the rota dates race 1 on Sunday 2027-04-11."
},
{
"id": "en4c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Incidents, near misses and injuries, whether afloat or ashore, have to be reported within 24 hours to Safety Officer Fiona Brackley through the incident book kept in the race office.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "club-rules-safety-and-duty-handbook-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Every incident, near miss or injury on the water or ashore must be reported to the Safety Officer, Fiona Brackley, within 24 hours, using the incident book in the race office."
}
],
"why": "Restates the reporting rule with its deadline, person and book."
},
{
"id": "en4c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "If the AGM approves the slipway spending, the general reserve would still be £6,210 above the committee's £35,000 minimum.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "commodores-annual-report-2025-26.pdf.md",
"text": "The committee's policy is that the general reserve must not fall below £35,000, which is roughly four months of running costs. If the AGM approves the use of £7,390 for the slipway, the general reserve will fall to £41,210 and will stay above that floor."
}
],
"why": "£41,210 minus the £35,000 floor is £6,210."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Kåre Myrvold er borettslagets vaktmester i 60 prosent stilling, mens forretningsførsel og revisjon er tjenester som kjøpes inn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Borettslaget har en vaktmester, Kåre Myrvold, i 80 % stilling. Forretningsførsel og revisjon kjøpes inn som tjenester."
}
],
"why": "The caretaker's position is 80 %, not 60 %.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the reworded twin t01. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t01 so the pair stays one change (the percentage) apart."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u01",
"claim": "Kåre Myrvold er borettslagets vaktmester i 80 prosent stilling, mens forretningsførsel og revisjon er tjenester som kjøpes inn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Borettslaget har en vaktmester, Kåre Myrvold, i 80 % stilling. Forretningsførsel og revisjon kjøpes inn som tjenester."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 80 % caretaker position and the bought-in management and audit services.",
"audit": "FIX: The second clause copied the excerpt with only 'inn' dropped; reworded. | FIX2: The first clause kept the excerpt's words nearly in order, and 'kjøper' makes the borettslag the buyer where the excerpt's passive names no buyer."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Det nye taket på sykkelbod sør er ennå ikke bestilt, men arbeidet skal gjøres i juni.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Nytt tak på sykkelbod sør | C: Sykkelbod sør | D: 118000 | E: Høy | F: Kåre Myrvold | G: Bestilt; utføres i juni"
}
],
"why": "The row says the new roof is already ordered (Bestilt), not that it is not ordered."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u02",
"claim": "Det nye taket på sykkelbod sør er allerede bestilt, og arbeidet skal gjøres i juni.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Nytt tak på sykkelbod sør | C: Sykkelbod sør | D: 118000 | E: Høy | F: Kåre Myrvold | G: Bestilt; utføres i juni"
}
],
"why": "The status reads 'Bestilt; utføres i juni' for the new roof on the south bicycle shed."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi forsikringen økte med 10 % til 486 000 kr, ble det flere vannskader.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Forsikringen økte med 10 % til 486 000 kr etter flere vannskader."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the water damage came first and the insurance rose after it."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u03",
"claim": "Etter flere vannskader gikk forsikringen opp med 10 % til 486 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Forsikringen økte med 10 % til 486 000 kr etter flere vannskader."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 10 % rise to 486 000 kr following several water damages."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Planlegger man selskap i leiligheten etter kl. 22:00, bør naboene i oppgangen få beskjed på forhånd, og et slikt varsel gir da rett til å bryte ro-tiden.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Den som skal ha selskap i leiligheten etter kl. 22:00, bør varsle naboene i oppgangen på forhånd. Et varsel gir likevel ikke rett til å bryte ro-tiden."
}
],
"why": "The rule says a notice does NOT give a right to break the quiet hours.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the reworded twin t04."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u04",
"claim": "Planlegger man selskap i leiligheten etter kl. 22:00, bør naboene i oppgangen få beskjed på forhånd, men et slikt varsel gir ingen rett til å bryte ro-tiden.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Den som skal ha selskap i leiligheten etter kl. 22:00, bør varsle naboene i oppgangen på forhånd. Et varsel gir likevel ikke rett til å bryte ro-tiden."
}
],
"why": "Restates the advice to notify neighbours and that a notice gives no right to break the quiet hours.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim copied the excerpt nearly word for word (only 'i leiligheten' dropped, which also widened the scope); reworded with the scope kept."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "For 2026 er det satt opp maling av trapperom i alle bygningene, med en estimert kostnad på 172 000 kr og planlagt utført i august.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: År | B: Tiltak | C: Bygning | D: Estimert kostnad (kr) | E: Prioritet | F: Ansvarlig | G: Status"
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Maling av trapperom | C: A | D: 172000 | E: Middels | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Planlagt august"
}
],
"why": "The row covers only building A, not all the blocks.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the corrected twin t05."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1a-u05",
"claim": "For 2026 er det satt opp maling av trapperom i bygning A, med en estimert kostnad på 172 000 kr og planlagt utført i august.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: År | B: Tiltak | C: Bygning | D: Estimert kostnad (kr) | E: Prioritet | F: Ansvarlig | G: Status"
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Maling av trapperom | C: A | D: 172000 | E: Middels | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Planlagt august"
}
],
"why": "The header names columns A, C, D and G as year, building, estimated cost and status, which the row fills with 2026, A, 172000 and 'Planlagt august'.",
"audit": "FIX: 'vedlikeholdsplanen' is not in the excerpt words and 'blokk' and singular 'trapperommet' go beyond the row's 'Bygning' A and 'trapperom'; reworded to the excerpt's terms."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Etter at felleskostnadene ble økt med 6 % fra 1. januar 2025, kom de til 5 184 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felleskostnadene utgjorde 5 184 000 kr etter en økning på 4 % fra 1. januar 2025."
}
],
"why": "The increase was 4 %, not 6 %."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u06",
"claim": "Etter at felleskostnadene ble økt med 4 % fra 1. januar 2025, kom de til 5 184 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felleskostnadene utgjorde 5 184 000 kr etter en økning på 4 % fra 1. januar 2025."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 4 % increase from 1 January 2025 and the total of 5 184 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Forprosjektet for balkonger og fasader ble vedtatt på en ekstraordinær generalforsamling i november 2025, mens endringen til ro-tid fra kl. 22:00 søndag til torsdag ble vedtatt i april 2026 med 47 stemmer for og 3 mot.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "En ekstraordinær generalforsamling ble holdt 18. november 2025. Den vedtok å sette i gang et forprosjekt for balkonger og fasader med en kostnadsramme på 1,2 mill. kr. Vedtaket ble gjort med 47 stemmer for og 3 stemmer mot."
},
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Fra 1. mai 2026 begynner ro-tiden kl. 22:00 på søndager til torsdager, mot kl. 23:00 tidligere. Endringen ble vedtatt på generalforsamlingen 21. april 2026 med 49 stemmer for og 17 stemmer mot, fordi styret mottok 14 skriftlige klager på støy i 2025."
}
],
"why": "The vote of 47 for and 3 against belongs to the balcony and facade pre-project; the quiet-hours change passed 49 to 17.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the corrected twin t07."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1a-u07",
"claim": "Forprosjektet for balkonger og fasader ble vedtatt på en ekstraordinær generalforsamling i november 2025, mens endringen til ro-tid fra kl. 22:00 søndag til torsdag ble vedtatt i april 2026 med 49 stemmer for og 17 mot.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "En ekstraordinær generalforsamling ble holdt 18. november 2025. Den vedtok å sette i gang et forprosjekt for balkonger og fasader med en kostnadsramme på 1,2 mill. kr. Vedtaket ble gjort med 47 stemmer for og 3 stemmer mot."
},
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Fra 1. mai 2026 begynner ro-tiden kl. 22:00 på søndager til torsdager, mot kl. 23:00 tidligere. Endringen ble vedtatt på generalforsamlingen 21. april 2026 med 49 stemmer for og 17 stemmer mot, fordi styret mottok 14 skriftlige klager på støy i 2025."
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt gives the November 2025 pre-project decision, the second the April 2026 quiet-hours vote of 49 to 17.",
"audit": "FIX: 'den nye ro-tiden fra kl. 22:00' dropped the excerpt's Sunday-to-Thursday limit and could be read as every day; the days are added."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Fuktmålinger tatt etter en vannlekkasje i kjelleren har vist at det trengs drenering langs nordveggen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Drenering langs nordveggen | C: D | D: 198000 | E: Høy | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Fuktmålinger viste behov"
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the moisture measurements followed a leak in the basement."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u08",
"claim": "Fuktmålinger har vist at det trengs drenering langs nordveggen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2026 | B: Drenering langs nordveggen | C: D | D: 198000 | E: Høy | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Fuktmålinger viste behov"
}
],
"why": "The row for drainage along the north wall says moisture measurements showed the need."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Den største kostnadsposten hvert år er vedlikehold og reparasjoner, med 1 236 800 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vedlikehold og reparasjoner kostet 1 236 800 kr og var den største posten."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt states this for one set of accounts only, not for every year.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the reworded twin t09."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u09",
"claim": "Den største kostnadsposten var vedlikehold og reparasjoner, med 1 236 800 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vedlikehold og reparasjoner kostet 1 236 800 kr og var den største posten."
}
],
"why": "Restates the cost of 1 236 800 kr and that it was the largest item.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim copied the excerpt in the same word order with 'som' added and 'kostnadsposten' for 'posten'; reworded."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Skal oppussingen vare mer enn én dag, må naboene i samme oppgang minst tre dager før start varsles med et oppslag som viser varigheten og telefonnummeret til den som pusser opp.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Den som skal pusse opp i mer enn én dag, skal varsle naboene i samme oppgang med oppslag minst 3 dager før arbeidet starter. Oppslaget skal vise hvor lenge arbeidet varer."
}
],
"why": "The rule requires the notice to show the duration only; a phone number is not mentioned."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u10",
"claim": "Skal oppussingen vare mer enn én dag, må naboene i samme oppgang minst tre dager før start varsles med et oppslag som viser varigheten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Den som skal pusse opp i mer enn én dag, skal varsle naboene i samme oppgang med oppslag minst 3 dager før arbeidet starter. Oppslaget skal vise hvor lenge arbeidet varer."
}
],
"why": "Restates the notice rule: more than one day, same stairwell, at least 3 days ahead, showing the duration."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "De to vaskemaskinene som ikke ble skiftet ut i september 2025, er fra 2014, og det samme gjelder taktekket.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "I september 2025 ble de to eldste vaskemaskinene byttet ut for til sammen 64 800 kr. De to andre maskinene er fra 2014 og skal etter planen byttes i 2027."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2029 | B: Nytt taktekke | C: A | D: 1640000 | E: Middels | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Tekket er fra 1996"
}
],
"why": "The year 2014 belongs to the washing machines; the roofing is from 1996.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the corrected twin t11."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1a-u11",
"claim": "De to vaskemaskinene som ikke ble skiftet ut i september 2025, er fra 2014, mens taktekket er fra 1996.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "I september 2025 ble de to eldste vaskemaskinene byttet ut for til sammen 64 800 kr. De to andre maskinene er fra 2014 og skal etter planen byttes i 2027."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2029 | B: Nytt taktekke | C: A | D: 1640000 | E: Middels | F: Torbjørn Leirvik | G: Tekket er fra 1996"
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt dates the two remaining machines to 2014, the plan row dates the roofing to be renewed to 1996.",
"audit": "FIX: 'etter vedlikeholdsplanen' and 'skal fornyes' are not words of the excerpts (the row has no header); the roof clause is cut to what the row states."
},
{
"id": "no1a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi rommet ble leid ut i flere døgn enn året før, gikk døgnleien for fellesrommet i blokk D opp fra 400 kr til 450 kr fra 1. januar 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fellesrommet i blokk D er 62 m² og har plass til 40 personer. Fra 1. januar 2025 ble leien økt fra 400 kr til 450 kr per døgn, fordi rengjøring etter utleie ble satt bort. Rommet ble leid ut i 64 døgn i 2025, mot 51 døgn i 2024."
}
],
"why": "The rent rose because cleaning after rentals was outsourced, not because of the higher number of rental days.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten to stay one change from the reworded twin t12."
},
{
"id": "no1a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1a-u12",
"claim": "Fordi rengjøringen etter utleie ble satt bort, gikk døgnleien for fellesrommet i blokk D opp fra 400 kr til 450 kr fra 1. januar 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fellesrommet i blokk D er 62 m² og har plass til 40 personer. Fra 1. januar 2025 ble leien økt fra 400 kr til 450 kr per døgn, fordi rengjøring etter utleie ble satt bort. Rommet ble leid ut i 64 døgn i 2025, mot 51 døgn i 2024."
}
],
"why": "Restates the rent increase for the common room in block D and its stated reason, outsourced cleaning.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim repeated the excerpt's second sentence nearly word for word; reworded."
},
{
"id": "no1a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Fellesvaskeriet har to tørketromler, og en utskifting av tørketromler er ført opp med merknaden at den vurderes etter tilstand.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fellesvaskeriet har fire vaskemaskiner, to tørketromler og ett tørkerom."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2028 | B: Utskifting av tørketromler | C: B | D: 54000 | E: Lav | F: Kåre Myrvold | G: Vurderes etter tilstand"
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt gives the two tumble dryers in the laundry, the plan row says their replacement is assessed by condition.",
"audit": "FIX: Nothing in the excerpts says the dryers in the plan row are the laundry's two dryers; the claim no longer joins them."
},
{
"id": "no1a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "I 2025 var det to dugnader: 41 av 72 husstander møtte på vårdugnaden 26. april, og 35 husstander deltok på høstdugnaden 18. oktober.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Det ble holdt to dugnader i 2025. På vårdugnaden 26. april deltok 41 av 72 husstander, og på høstdugnaden 18. oktober deltok 35 husstander."
}
],
"why": "Restates the two work days of 2025 and the attendance at each.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt does not say who held the work days ('Det ble holdt'), so 'Borettslaget arrangerte' adds an agent; removed."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Elektrisk verktøy kan brukes i hobbyverkstedet hver dag i uka, men bare innenfor faste tidsrom.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "I hobbyverkstedet er elektrisk verktøy bare tillatt på hverdager kl. 10:00–20:00 og på lørdager kl. 11:00–16:00. Elektrisk verktøy skal aldri brukes på søndager og helligdager."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt allows power tools only on weekdays and Saturdays and forbids them on Sundays and public holidays, not every day."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u01",
"claim": "Elektrisk verktøy kan brukes i hobbyverkstedet på hverdager og lørdager, men bare innenfor faste tidsrom.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "I hobbyverkstedet er elektrisk verktøy bare tillatt på hverdager kl. 10:00–20:00 og på lørdager kl. 11:00–16:00. Elektrisk verktøy skal aldri brukes på søndager og helligdager."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt allows power tools on weekdays 10-20 and Saturdays 11-16, i.e. on those days within fixed hours."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle, også de som ikke er beboere, slipper å betale for å bruke hobbyverkstedet i blokk C, som ble åpnet 1. mars 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hobbyverkstedet i blokk C åpnet 1. mars 2025 og er gratis for beboerne."
}
],
"why": "The workshop is free for the residents only; the claim widens it to everyone, non-residents included.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim adds a since-opening time scope the excerpt does not give (it says only that the workshop is free for residents now); reworded to the same scope as the new twin, keeping the one change residents -> everyone. | FIX2: 'Borettslaget' is not in the excerpt, which speaks only of 'beboerne', so the claim added a second, not-mentioned element; now the only change from twin t02 is residents -> everyone."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u02",
"claim": "Beboerne slipper å betale for å bruke hobbyverkstedet i blokk C, som ble åpnet 1. mars 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hobbyverkstedet i blokk C åpnet 1. mars 2025 og er gratis for beboerne."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the workshop opened 1 March 2025 and is free for the residents.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Siden åpningen ... har kunnet bruke uten å betale' asserts the workshop has been free since opening, a time scope the excerpt does not give."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Fra 1. januar 2026 går felleskostnadene opp med 7 %.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Felleskostnader | B: 5184000 | C: 5495000 | D: 6 | E: Økning på 6 % fra 1. januar 2026"
}
],
"why": "The row gives an increase of 6 %, not 7 %."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u03",
"claim": "Fra 1. januar 2026 går felleskostnadene opp med 6 %.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Felleskostnader | B: 5184000 | C: 5495000 | D: 6 | E: Økning på 6 % fra 1. januar 2026"
}
],
"why": "The row's note states an increase of 6 % from 1 January 2026 for the common costs."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Av de 312 feilmeldingene vaktmesteren fikk i 2025, ble 96 % rettet innen 14 dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Vaktmesteren registrerte 312 feilmeldinger fra beboerne i 2025, mot 278 i 2024. 87 % av feilmeldingene ble utbedret innen 14 dager."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says 87 % were fixed within 14 days, not 96 %."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u04",
"claim": "Av de 312 feilmeldingene vaktmesteren fikk i 2025, ble 87 % rettet innen 14 dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Vaktmesteren registrerte 312 feilmeldinger fra beboerne i 2025, mot 278 i 2024. 87 % av feilmeldingene ble utbedret innen 14 dager."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives 312 fault reports in 2025 and says 87 % were fixed within 14 days."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi vedlikeholdskostnadene steg fra 874 500 kr i 2024 til 1 236 800 kr i 2025, ble det satt i gang ny LED-belysning i trapperommene, reparasjon av en taklekkasje i blokk C og en tilstandsrapport for balkonger og fasader.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Kostnadene til vedlikehold og reparasjoner var 1 236 800 kr i 2025, mot 874 500 kr i 2024. Økningen skyldes i hovedsak tre store poster: ny LED-belysning i trapperommene, reparasjonen av en taklekkasje i blokk C og tilstandsrapporten for balkonger og fasader."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the three items caused the cost increase; the claim makes the increase the cause of the items."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u05",
"claim": "Vedlikeholdskostnadene steg fra 874 500 kr i 2024 til 1 236 800 kr i 2025, hovedsakelig på grunn av ny LED-belysning i trapperommene, reparasjon av en taklekkasje i blokk C og en tilstandsrapport for balkonger og fasader.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Kostnadene til vedlikehold og reparasjoner var 1 236 800 kr i 2025, mot 874 500 kr i 2024. Økningen skyldes i hovedsak tre store poster: ny LED-belysning i trapperommene, reparasjonen av en taklekkasje i blokk C og tilstandsrapporten for balkonger og fasader."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives both amounts and names the three items as the main reason for the increase."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Nedgangen på 11 % er hovedårsaken til at trapperommene fikk ny belysning.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Nedgangen på 11 % skyldes først og fremst den nye belysningen i trapperommene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the new lighting caused the 11 % drop, not that the drop caused the lighting.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded so it is a clean cause-effect swap of the reworded twin."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u06",
"claim": "Ny belysning i trapperommene er hovedårsaken til nedgangen på 11 %.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Nedgangen på 11 % skyldes først og fremst den nye belysningen i trapperommene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names the new stairwell lighting as the main cause of the 11 % drop.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy of the excerpt (same opening 'Nedgangen på 11 % skyldes', one synonym swapped)."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Nye lekeapparater på uteområdet er planlagt i 2029 med middels prioritet, fordi dagens apparater fra 2009 ble underkjent ved en sikkerhetskontroll.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: År | B: Tiltak | C: Bygning | D: Estimert kostnad (kr) | E: Prioritet | F: Ansvarlig | G: Status"
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2029 | B: Nye lekeapparater | C: Uteområde | D: 210000 | E: Middels | F: Petter Nygård-Ulvik | G: Dagens apparater er fra 2009"
}
],
"why": "Neither the header nor the row mentions a safety inspection; the row only says the current equipment is from 2009."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1b-u07",
"claim": "Nye lekeapparater på uteområdet er planlagt i 2029 med middels prioritet, og dagens apparater er fra 2009.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: År | B: Tiltak | C: Bygning | D: Estimert kostnad (kr) | E: Prioritet | F: Ansvarlig | G: Status"
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2029 | B: Nye lekeapparater | C: Uteområde | D: 210000 | E: Middels | F: Petter Nygård-Ulvik | G: Dagens apparater er fra 2009"
}
],
"why": "The header shows column A is the year and E the priority; the row gives 2029, Middels and the status note about 2009."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Ryddeaksjonen i oktober, der sykler uten merking blir fjernet, varsles på oppslagstavlene og med en lapp på hver sykkel fire uker i forveien.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Umerkede sykler fjernes ved ryddeaksjonen i oktober, etter fire ukers varsel på oppslagstavlene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt mentions only notice on the notice boards, not a tag on each bicycle."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u08",
"claim": "Ryddeaksjonen i oktober, der sykler uten merking blir fjernet, varsles på oppslagstavlene fire uker i forveien.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Umerkede sykler fjernes ved ryddeaksjonen i oktober, etter fire ukers varsel på oppslagstavlene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says unmarked bicycles are removed in October after four weeks' notice on the notice boards."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Leien dekker ikke gulvvasken etter utleie, og leietakeren må selv rydde og tørke av bord og benker før vedkommende går fra rommet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Leietakeren skal rydde og tørke av bord og benker før rommet forlates. Gulvvask etter utleie er inkludert i leien."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says floor washing after a rental is included in the rent.",
"audit": "FIX: 'hun' gives the generic tenant a gender the excerpt does not give and reads unnaturally; reworded in step with the twin, keeping the one polarity change."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u09",
"claim": "Leien dekker gulvvasken etter utleie, og leietakeren må selv rydde og tørke av bord og benker før vedkommende går fra rommet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Leietakeren skal rydde og tørke av bord og benker før rommet forlates. Gulvvask etter utleie er inkludert i leien."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the tenant tidies and wipes tables and benches, and floor washing is included in the rent.",
"audit": "FIX: 'hun' gives the generic tenant a gender the excerpt does not give and reads unnaturally."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Borettslaget fikk utgifter som følge av innbruddene, selv om beboernes egne forsikringer dekket det som ble stjålet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Ingen av innbruddene førte til kostnader for borettslaget, fordi de stjålne gjenstandene var dekket av beboernes egne forsikringer."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says none of the break-ins caused the housing cooperative any costs."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1b-u10",
"claim": "Borettslaget fikk ingen utgifter som følge av innbruddene, siden beboernes egne forsikringer dekket det som ble stjålet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Ingen av innbruddene førte til kostnader for borettslaget, fordi de stjålne gjenstandene var dekket av beboernes egne forsikringer."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says no break-in led to costs for the cooperative because the residents' own insurance covered the stolen items."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Forsikringen øker med 6 % etter vannskadene i 2025, mens felleskostnadene ble satt opp 6 % med virkning fra 1. januar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Forsikring | B: 486000 | C: 525000 | D: 8 | E: Økning på 8 % etter vannskadene i 2025"
},
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felleskostnadene ble økt med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026 til om lag 6 360 kr i snitt per måned."
}
],
"why": "The 6 % belongs to the common costs; the spreadsheet gives the insurance an increase of 8 %.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded in step with the twin so the date no longer scopes the insurance clause; the error (insurance given the common costs' 6 %) is unchanged. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t11 so the pair stays one change (the insurance percentage) apart."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1b-u11",
"claim": "Forsikringen øker med 8 % etter vannskadene i 2025, mens felleskostnadene ble satt opp 6 % med virkning fra 1. januar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Forsikring | B: 486000 | C: 525000 | D: 8 | E: Økning på 8 % etter vannskadene i 2025"
},
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Felleskostnadene ble økt med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026 til om lag 6 360 kr i snitt per måned."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives the 6 % rise in common costs and the spreadsheet row the 8 % insurance rise after the 2025 water damage.",
"audit": "FIX: The leading 'Fra 1. januar 2026' can be read as dating the insurance increase too, a date the insurance row does not give. | FIX2: The common-cost clause copied the slide sentence with one verb swapped; reworded."
},
{
"id": "no1b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "De fire innbruddene i kjellerboder i januar og februar 2025 skjedde i blokk B, samme blokk som har vaskeriet i kjelleren.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "I januar og februar 2025 ble det registrert 4 innbrudd i kjellerboder i blokk C. I alle tilfellene var kjellerdøra blitt stående åpen."
},
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Vaskeriet ligger i kjelleren i blokk B og har fire vaskemaskiner, to tørketromler og ett tørkerom."
}
],
"why": "The break-ins were in block C; block B is where the laundry is, according to the house rules."
},
{
"id": "no1b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1b-u12",
"claim": "De fire innbruddene i kjellerboder i januar og februar 2025 skjedde i blokk C, mens vaskeriet ligger i kjelleren i blokk B.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "I januar og februar 2025 ble det registrert 4 innbrudd i kjellerboder i blokk C. I alle tilfellene var kjellerdøra blitt stående åpen."
},
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Vaskeriet ligger i kjelleren i blokk B og har fire vaskemaskiner, to tørketromler og ett tørkerom."
}
],
"why": "The annual report places the four break-ins in block C and the house rules place the laundry in the basement of block B."
},
{
"id": "no1b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Sykkelbodene ved blokk A og blokk D har til sammen 84 plasser, tolv flere i den nordre enn i den søndre.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Sykkelbod nord ved blokk A har 48 plasser, og sykkelbod sør ved blokk D har 36 plasser."
}
],
"why": "48 + 36 = 84 places, and 48 - 36 = 12 more in the north shed."
},
{
"id": "no1b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Styrehonoraret på 186 000 kr for 2026, som styret foreslo, ble vedtatt av generalforsamlingen 21. april 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Styret foreslår et styrehonorar på 186 000 kr for 2026, mot 180 000 kr for 2025."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Styrehonorar | B: 180000 | C: 186000 | D: 3.3 | E: Vedtatt av generalforsamlingen 21. april 2026"
}
],
"why": "The slide gives the board's proposal of 186 000 kr for 2026 and the spreadsheet row records the board fee as adopted by the general meeting on 21 April 2026."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Sykkelboden sør har fått et ladeskap med 10 låsbare rom for elsykkelbatterier, og batterier får bare lades i disse skapene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-05-16 | B: Ladeskap med 8 låsbare rom for elsykkelbatterier | C: Sykkelbod sør | D: 39800 | E: Innleid elektriker | F: Lading er bare tillatt i disse skapene"
}
],
"why": "The charging cabinet has 8 lockable compartments, not 10."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u01",
"claim": "Sykkelboden sør har fått et ladeskap med 8 låsbare rom for elsykkelbatterier, og batterier får bare lades i disse skapene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-05-16 | B: Ladeskap med 8 låsbare rom for elsykkelbatterier | C: Sykkelbod sør | D: 39800 | E: Innleid elektriker | F: Lading er bare tillatt i disse skapene"
}
],
"why": "Restates the 8-compartment cabinet in the south bike shed and the rule that charging is only allowed there."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Det stemmes skriftlig i alle saker, også om rehabiliteringen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Avstemningen om rehabiliteringen skjer skriftlig."
}
],
"why": "Only the vote on the rehabilitation is said to be written, not the votes in all matters."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u02",
"claim": "Det stemmes skriftlig i saken om rehabiliteringen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Avstemningen om rehabiliteringen skjer skriftlig."
}
],
"why": "Restates that the vote on the rehabilitation is held in writing."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "LED-belysningen med bevegelsessensor som ble montert i alle trapperommene, økte strømforbruket i fellesarealene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-03-21 | B: LED-belysning med bevegelsessensor i alle trapperom | C: A, B, C, D | D: 186000 | E: Innleid elektriker | F: Ga lavere strømforbruk i fellesarealer"
}
],
"why": "The row says the lighting gave lower, not higher, power use in the common areas."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u03",
"claim": "LED-belysningen med bevegelsessensor som ble montert i alle trapperommene, reduserte strømforbruket i fellesarealene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-03-21 | B: LED-belysning med bevegelsessensor i alle trapperom | C: A, B, C, D | D: 186000 | E: Innleid elektriker | F: Ga lavere strømforbruk i fellesarealer"
}
],
"why": "Restates that the motion-sensor LED lighting in all stairwells lowered power use in the common areas."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Valgkomiteen har to medlemmer, Oddbjørg Rise og Jonas Fjellstad, som begge ble valgt av generalforsamlingen i 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Valgkomiteen består av Oddbjørg Rise og Jonas Fjellstad."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about when or by whom the two members were elected."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no1c-u04",
"claim": "Valgkomiteen har to medlemmer, Oddbjørg Rise og Jonas Fjellstad.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Valgkomiteen består av Oddbjørg Rise og Jonas Fjellstad."
}
],
"why": "The committee is made up of the two named people, so it has two members."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Forsikringspremien ventes å stige med 8 % fordi felleskostnadene økes med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Styret har vedtatt å øke felleskostnadene med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026. Økningen skyldes resten av forprosjektet, som er budsjettert til 1 051 500 kr, en ventet økning i forsikringspremien på 8 % og høyere gebyrer for vann, avløp og renovasjon."
}
],
"why": "The expected 8 % premium rise is one cause of the 6 % fee increase, not its effect."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u05",
"claim": "Felleskostnadene økes med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026, blant annet fordi forsikringspremien ventes å stige med 8 %.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Styret har vedtatt å øke felleskostnadene med 6 % fra 1. januar 2026. Økningen skyldes resten av forprosjektet, som er budsjettert til 1 051 500 kr, en ventet økning i forsikringspremien på 8 % og høyere gebyrer for vann, avløp og renovasjon."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names the expected 8 % premium rise among the reasons for the 6 % increase."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Det utføres byggearbeid alle dager i uka, og da mellom kl. 07:00 og 17:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Byggearbeid foregår bare på hverdager kl. 07:00–17:00."
}
],
"why": "Construction work happens only on weekdays, not every day of the week.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded with its twin to drop the added time scope 'i byggeperioden', which the excerpt does not give."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u06",
"claim": "Det utføres byggearbeid kun på hverdager, og da mellom kl. 07:00 og 17:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Byggearbeid foregår bare på hverdager kl. 07:00–17:00."
}
],
"why": "Restates that construction work is limited to weekdays from 07:00 to 17:00.",
"audit": "FIX: 'I byggeperioden' adds a time scope the excerpt does not state; reworded without it and without copying the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Beboeren skal teste røykvarsleren i leiligheten hvert femte år, og brannslukningsapparatene kontrolleres også hvert femte år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Røykvarsleren i leiligheten skal testes av beboeren hvert år innen 1. desember."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-11-27 | B: Kontroll og service av brannslukningsapparater | C: A, B, C, D | D: 18900 | E: Innleid servicefirma | F: Kontroll hvert femte år"
}
],
"why": "The five-year interval belongs to the fire extinguishers; the smoke detector is tested every year."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1c-u07",
"claim": "Beboeren skal teste røykvarsleren i leiligheten hvert år, mens brannslukningsapparatene kontrolleres hvert femte år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Røykvarsleren i leiligheten skal testes av beboeren hvert år innen 1. desember."
},
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-11-27 | B: Kontroll og service av brannslukningsapparater | C: A, B, C, D | D: 18900 | E: Innleid servicefirma | F: Kontroll hvert femte år"
}
],
"why": "The yearly smoke detector test comes from the house rules and the five-yearly extinguisher check from the maintenance row."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Fellesgjelden ble redusert med 720 000 kr i løpet av 2025, til 11 640 000 kr ved årets slutt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Lånet ble nedbetalt med 620 000 kr i 2025, og fellesgjelden gikk ned fra 12 260 000 kr ved inngangen av året til 11 640 000 kr per 31. desember 2025."
}
],
"why": "The joint debt fell by 620 000 kr (12 260 000 to 11 640 000), not 720 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u08",
"claim": "Fellesgjelden ble redusert med 620 000 kr i løpet av 2025, til 11 640 000 kr ved årets slutt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Lånet ble nedbetalt med 620 000 kr i 2025, og fellesgjelden gikk ned fra 12 260 000 kr ved inngangen av året til 11 640 000 kr per 31. desember 2025."
}
],
"why": "The loan was paid down by 620 000 kr and the joint debt ended the year at 11 640 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi det er forbudt å glasse inn balkongen før rehabiliteringen avsluttes i oktober 2028, skal de nye balkongene få en felles innglassingsløsning.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Innglassing av balkong er ikke tillatt før rehabiliteringen av balkongene er ferdig i oktober 2028, fordi de nye balkongene får en felles løsning for innglassing."
}
],
"why": "The common glazing solution is the reason for the ban, not a consequence of it.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded so it stays one swap away from the reworded twin."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u09",
"claim": "Fordi de nye balkongene skal få en felles innglassingsløsning, er det forbudt å glasse inn balkongen før rehabiliteringen avsluttes i oktober 2028.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Innglassing av balkong er ikke tillatt før rehabiliteringen av balkongene er ferdig i oktober 2028, fordi de nye balkongene får en felles løsning for innglassing."
}
],
"why": "Restates the glazing ban until October 2028 and its stated reason, the common glazing solution.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim is a near-verbatim copy of the excerpt with only a few words dropped; reworded."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Et tidligere lagerrom ble bygget om til hobbyverksted fordi beboerne hadde bedt om det, og verkstedet åpnet 1. mars 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-02-14 | B: Ombygging av tidligere lagerrom til hobbyverksted | C: C | D: 52300 | E: Vaktmester og innleid snekker | F: Åpnet for beboere 1. mars 2025"
}
],
"why": "No reason for the conversion, such as residents asking for it, is given."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u10",
"claim": "Et tidligere lagerrom ble bygget om til hobbyverksted, og verkstedet åpnet for beboerne 1. mars 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "vedlikeholdsplan-og-budsjett-2026.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 2025-02-14 | B: Ombygging av tidligere lagerrom til hobbyverksted | C: C | D: 52300 | E: Vaktmester og innleid snekker | F: Åpnet for beboere 1. mars 2025"
}
],
"why": "Restates the conversion of a former storeroom into a hobby workshop opened to residents on 1 March 2025."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Det holdes dugnad 25. april og 17. oktober 2026, og den som ikke møter, må betale gebyr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Vårdugnaden holdes 25. april 2026 og høstdugnaden 17. oktober 2026. Det ilegges ikke gebyr for å utebli fra dugnad."
}
],
"why": "No fee is charged for staying away from a dugnad."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no1c-u11",
"claim": "Det holdes dugnad 25. april og 17. oktober 2026, og den som ikke møter, slipper gebyr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Vårdugnaden holdes 25. april 2026 og høstdugnaden 17. oktober 2026. Det ilegges ikke gebyr for å utebli fra dugnad."
}
],
"why": "Restates the two dugnad dates and that absence carries no fee."
},
{
"id": "no1c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Byggekomiteen som leder forprosjektet, har fem medlemmer, like mange som hagekomiteen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Forprosjektet ledes av en byggekomité med fire medlemmer: Ingrid Solbakk, Torbjørn Leirvik og to beboere som ikke sitter i styret."
},
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hagekomiteen har fem medlemmer og ledes av Vibeke Strand."
}
],
"why": "Five members is the garden committee's size; the building committee has four."
},
{
"id": "no1c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no1c-u12",
"claim": "Byggekomiteen som leder forprosjektet, har fire medlemmer, ett færre enn hagekomiteen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Forprosjektet ledes av en byggekomité med fire medlemmer: Ingrid Solbakk, Torbjørn Leirvik og to beboere som ikke sitter i styret."
},
{
"file": "generalforsamling-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hagekomiteen har fem medlemmer og ledes av Vibeke Strand."
}
],
"why": "The building committee has four members and the garden committee five, so one fewer."
},
{
"id": "no1c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Det er lov å spille ball på plenen fram til klokken 20.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "husordensregler-og-praktisk-informasjon.docx.md",
"text": "Ballspill på plenen er tillatt fram til kl. 20:00."
}
],
"why": "Restates that ball games on the lawn are allowed until 20:00."
},
{
"id": "no1c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Renten sank med 0,25 prosentpoeng fra utgangen av 2024 til utgangen av 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "aarsberetning-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Renten var 4,40 % ved utgangen av 2024 og 4,15 % ved utgangen av 2025."
}
],
"why": "4,40 % minus 4,15 % is a fall of 0,25 percentage points."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Styret behandlet 84 saker fordelt på 11 møter, mot 61 saker på 9 møter året før.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Styret har holdt 11 styremøter og behandlet 74 saker, mot 9 møter og 61 saker året før."
}
],
"why": "The board handled 74 cases, not 84."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u01",
"claim": "Styret behandlet 74 saker fordelt på 11 møter, mot 61 saker på 9 møter året før.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Styret har holdt 11 styremøter og behandlet 74 saker, mot 9 møter og 61 saker året før."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives 11 meetings and 74 cases, against 9 meetings and 61 cases the year before."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Antallet aktive utøvere i langrennsgruppa økte fra 96 i 2025 til 106 i mars 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Langrennsgruppa hadde 96 aktive utøvere i 2025, og 101 per mars 2026."
}
],
"why": "The group had 101 active athletes in March 2026, not 106."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u02",
"claim": "Antallet aktive utøvere i langrennsgruppa økte fra 96 i 2025 til 101 i mars 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Langrennsgruppa hadde 96 aktive utøvere i 2025, og 101 per mars 2026."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives 96 active athletes in 2025 and 101 as of March 2026."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "For å ha stemmerett må et medlem ha betalt kontingenten for 2025, men det stilles ikke noe krav til alder.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Bare medlemmer som har fylt 15 år og har betalt kontingenten for 2025, har stemmerett."
}
],
"why": "Voting rights also require the member to have turned 15, so not every paying member of any age may vote.",
"audit": "FIX: The twin states a necessary condition while this claim is a different sentence shape (Alle ... har stemmerett), so it is reworded to sit one change from the twin: the age requirement is replaced by no age requirement."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u03",
"claim": "For å ha stemmerett må et medlem både ha fylt 15 år og ha betalt kontingenten for 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Bare medlemmer som har fylt 15 år og har betalt kontingenten for 2025, har stemmerett."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt limits voting rights to members aged 15 or more who have paid the 2025 fee."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Leietakere av Granlihytta må betale vaskegebyr ved hver avreise, uansett om hytta er vasket.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Vaskegebyr Granlihytta | B: Leietaker | C: 600 | D: 600 | E: 2 | F: ganger 2025 | G: Når hytta ikke er vasket før avreise"
}
],
"why": "The cleaning fee applies only when the cabin has not been cleaned before departure, not always."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u04",
"claim": "Leietakere av Granlihytta må betale vaskegebyr dersom hytta ikke er vasket før de reiser.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Vaskegebyr Granlihytta | B: Leietaker | C: 600 | D: 600 | E: 2 | F: ganger 2025 | G: Når hytta ikke er vasket før avreise"
}
],
"why": "The row charges the tenant a cleaning fee when the cabin is not cleaned before departure."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Idrettsskolen tok opp flere barn enn tidligere fordi medlemsveksten på 43 personer for det meste kom blant barn under 13 år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Laget hadde 684 medlemmer per 31. desember 2025, mot 641 ett år tidligere. Det er en økning på 43 medlemmer, eller 6,7 prosent. Veksten kom i hovedsak blant barn under 13 år, fordi idrettsskolen tok inn flere barn enn før."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the sports school's larger intake as the cause of the growth among children, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u05",
"claim": "Medlemsveksten på 43 personer kom for det meste blant barn under 13 år, fordi idrettsskolen tok opp flere barn enn tidligere.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Laget hadde 684 medlemmer per 31. desember 2025, mot 641 ett år tidligere. Det er en økning på 43 medlemmer, eller 6,7 prosent. Veksten kom i hovedsak blant barn under 13 år, fordi idrettsskolen tok inn flere barn enn før."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the growth of 43 came mainly among children under 13 because the sports school took in more children."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi alle som går Granlirunden etter mørkets frembrudd, må bruke hodelykt, er løypa ikke opplyst.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "etter mørkets frembrudd skal alle i Granlirunden ha hodelykt, fordi løypa ikke er opplyst."
}
],
"why": "The missing lighting is the reason for the headlamp rule, not its consequence."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u06",
"claim": "Fordi Granlirunden ikke er opplyst, må alle som går der etter mørkets frembrudd, bruke hodelykt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "etter mørkets frembrudd skal alle i Granlirunden ha hodelykt, fordi løypa ikke er opplyst."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt requires a headlamp after dark because the trail is not lit."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Tillegget for etteranmelding gjelder i alle klasser og er inkludert i startkontingenten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Tillegg for etteranmelding | B: Alle klasser | C: 100 | D: 100 | E: 19 | F: etteranmeldte 2025 | G: Kommer i tillegg til startkontingenten"
}
],
"why": "The row says the late-entry surcharge comes on top of the entry fee, not that it is included in it."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u07",
"claim": "Tillegget for etteranmelding gjelder i alle klasser og betales i tillegg til startkontingenten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Tillegg for etteranmelding | B: Alle klasser | C: 100 | D: 100 | E: 19 | F: etteranmeldte 2025 | G: Kommer i tillegg til startkontingenten"
}
],
"why": "The row applies the surcharge to all classes and says it comes in addition to the entry fee."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Er det flere enn 60 påmeldte i et semester, får nye barn plass før barn som deltok semesteret før.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Det er plass til 60 barn per semester. Er det flere påmeldte, går barn som var med forrige semester foran nye barn, og deretter gjelder rekkefølgen for påmelding."
}
],
"why": "Children from the previous semester go ahead of new children, not after them."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u08",
"claim": "Er det flere enn 60 påmeldte i et semester, får barn som deltok semesteret før, plass før nye barn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Det er plass til 60 barn per semester. Er det flere påmeldte, går barn som var med forrige semester foran nye barn, og deretter gjelder rekkefølgen for påmelding."
}
],
"why": "With more than 60 sign-ups, the excerpt puts children from the previous semester ahead of new children."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Rolf Engebakken er foreslått som møteleder, slik han også var på årsmøtet året før.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Møteleder er foreslått å være Rolf Engebakken."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says nothing about who chaired the previous year's meeting."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u09",
"claim": "Rolf Engebakken er foreslått som møteleder.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Møteleder er foreslått å være Rolf Engebakken."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names Rolf Engebakken as the proposed chair."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Et barn kan være med på to treninger uten å betale før det kreves medlemskap og betalt treningsavgift, men en forelder må være til stede på disse treningene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Barn kan prøve to treninger gratis før de må være medlem og ha betalt treningsavgift."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt sets no condition that a parent must attend the free trial sessions."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2a-u10",
"claim": "Et barn kan være med på to treninger uten å betale før det kreves medlemskap og betalt treningsavgift.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Barn kan prøve to treninger gratis før de må være medlem og ha betalt treningsavgift."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt allows two free trial sessions before membership and the training fee are required."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "I 2025 hadde orienteringsgruppa 27 aktive medlemmer, mens konkurransegruppa for 13–16 år hadde 41 utøvere.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Orienteringsgruppa hadde 41 aktive medlemmer i 2025."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Konkurransegruppa for 13–16 år hadde 27 utøvere og gikk 34 renn utenfor Lyngmoen i 2025."
}
],
"why": "The claim gives the orienteering group the competition group's 27 and the competition group the orienteering group's 41."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2a-u11",
"claim": "I 2025 hadde orienteringsgruppa 41 aktive medlemmer, mens konkurransegruppa for 13–16 år hadde 27 utøvere.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Orienteringsgruppa hadde 41 aktive medlemmer i 2025."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Konkurransegruppa for 13–16 år hadde 27 utøvere og gikk 34 renn utenfor Lyngmoen i 2025."
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt gives the orienteering group 41 active members in 2025 and the second gives the competition group 27 athletes."
},
{
"id": "no2a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Skiutlånet er bare for medlemmer som er minst 25 år, mens et medlem som leier overnatting på Granlihytta, må være under 13 år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Utlånsordningen for ski hadde 46 par klassiske ski og 30 par skøyteski ved utgangen av 2025. Ordningen er bare for medlemmer under 13 år."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Overnatting Granlihytta per natt | B: Medlem | C: 150 | D: 150 | E: 248 | F: gjestedøgn 2025 | G: Leietaker må være medlem og minst 25 år"
}
],
"why": "The claim swaps the age rules: under 13 belongs to the ski loan and at least 25 to the cabin tenant."
},
{
"id": "no2a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2a-u12",
"claim": "Skiutlånet er bare for medlemmer under 13 år, mens et medlem som leier overnatting på Granlihytta, må være minst 25 år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Utlånsordningen for ski hadde 46 par klassiske ski og 30 par skøyteski ved utgangen av 2025. Ordningen er bare for medlemmer under 13 år."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Overnatting Granlihytta per natt | B: Medlem | C: 150 | D: 150 | E: 248 | F: gjestedøgn 2025 | G: Leietaker må være medlem og minst 25 år"
}
],
"why": "The report limits the ski loan to members under 13 and the spreadsheet row requires a cabin tenant to be a member of at least 25."
},
{
"id": "no2a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Kontingenten for voksne 20–66 år ble økt etter et vedtak på årsmøtet som ble holdt i klubbhuset på Lyngmoen torsdag 19. mars 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Medlemskontingent | B: Voksen 20–66 år | C: 600 | D: 650 | E: 268 | F: medlemmer per 31.12.2025 | G: Økt etter vedtak på årsmøtet 19.03.2026"
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Årsmøtet holdes torsdag 19. mars 2026 kl. 19:00 i klubbhuset på Lyngmoen."
}
],
"why": "The row says the adult fee was raised by the annual meeting of 19.03.2026, and the slide places that meeting on a Thursday in the clubhouse at Lyngmoen."
},
{
"id": "no2a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "For utøvere yngre enn 13 år er det ikke obligatorisk å delta i konkurranser.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Konkurranse er frivillig for alle under 13 år."
}
],
"why": "Competition being voluntary for everyone under 13 means it is not required of them."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Ved utleveringen av utlånsski i utstyrsboden lørdag 8. november 2025 ble 48 par levert ut.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 08.11.2025 | B: lørdag | C: Utlevering av utlånsski | D: Utstyrsboden | E: Marte Kvamsdal | F: 3 | G: 4 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 38 par levert ut"
}
],
"why": "The row says 38 pairs were handed out, not 48."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u01",
"claim": "Ved utleveringen av utlånsski i utstyrsboden lørdag 8. november 2025 ble 38 par levert ut.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 08.11.2025 | B: lørdag | C: Utlevering av utlånsski | D: Utstyrsboden | E: Marte Kvamsdal | F: 3 | G: 4 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 38 par levert ut"
}
],
"why": "The row for 08.11.2025 (Utlevering av utlånsski, Utstyrsboden) notes 38 pairs handed out."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Skøytetraseen i Storrunden kjøres opp hver dag i uka.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Skøytetraseen i Storrunden kjøres opp bare på tirsdager, torsdager og lørdager, slik at klassisksporet holder seg fint de andre dagene."
}
],
"why": "The skating track is groomed only on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, not every day."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u02",
"claim": "Skøytetraseen i Storrunden kjøres opp tre dager i uka: tirsdag, torsdag og lørdag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Skøytetraseen i Storrunden kjøres opp bare på tirsdager, torsdager og lørdager, slik at klassisksporet holder seg fint de andre dagene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names exactly these three days for grooming the skating track."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Taklekkasje, en ny pipe og en ny grunnmur under vedboden førte til at vedlikeholdet i 2025 kostet 188 400 kr, og taklekkasjen var den største enkeltposten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vedlikeholdet kostet 188 400 kr i 2025 på grunn av taklekkasje, ny pipe og ny grunnmur under vedboden."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives no breakdown, so nothing says the roof leak was the largest item.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from the reworded twin t03."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u03",
"claim": "Taklekkasje, en ny pipe og en ny grunnmur under vedboden førte til at vedlikeholdet i 2025 kostet 188 400 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vedlikeholdet kostet 188 400 kr i 2025 på grunn av taklekkasje, ny pipe og ny grunnmur under vedboden."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 2025 maintenance cost and its three causes.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim kept the excerpt's words in nearly the same order (only 'på grunn av' swapped and 'i 2025' moved), so it counts as a copy."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Alle medlemmer kan bruke smøreboden ved lysløypa, og smøremidler som inneholder fluor er tillatt på lagets ski.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Smøreboden ved lysløypa er åpen for alle medlemmer, men smørejern og fluorfrie pulver skal bare brukes når en trener er til stede. Det er forbudt å bruke smøremidler med fluor på lagets ski."
}
],
"why": "Fluor wax on the club's skis is forbidden, not allowed."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u04",
"claim": "Alle medlemmer kan bruke smøreboden ved lysløypa, men smøremidler som inneholder fluor er ikke tillatt på lagets ski.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Smøreboden ved lysløypa er åpen for alle medlemmer, men smørejern og fluorfrie pulver skal bare brukes når en trener er til stede. Det er forbudt å bruke smøremidler med fluor på lagets ski."
}
],
"why": "The wax hut is open to all members, and fluor wax on the club's skis is forbidden."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Lyngmorennet søndag 9. februar 2025 hadde 412 startende, mens rennet 8. februar 2026 hadde 368.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Det 31. Lyngmorennet gikk søndag 9. februar 2025 med 368 startende."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 08.02.2026 | B: søndag | C: Funksjonær under Lyngmorennet | D: Lysløypa og Granlirunden | E: Øystein Brekke | F: 83 | G: 6 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 412 startende; teller som to vakter fra 2026–27"
}
],
"why": "The 412 starters belong to the race on 08.02.2026 and the 368 to the race on 9 February 2025; the claim swaps them."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2b-u05",
"claim": "Lyngmorennet søndag 9. februar 2025 hadde 368 startende, mens rennet 8. februar 2026 hadde 412.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Det 31. Lyngmorennet gikk søndag 9. februar 2025 med 368 startende."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 08.02.2026 | B: søndag | C: Funksjonær under Lyngmorennet | D: Lysløypa og Granlirunden | E: Øystein Brekke | F: 83 | G: 6 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 412 startende; teller som to vakter fra 2026–27"
}
],
"why": "The slide gives 368 starters for 9 February 2025 and the sheet row for the race day 08.02.2026 notes 412 starters."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi strømkostnaden for lysløypa gikk ned fra 71 200 kr til 61 200 kr, slukkes lyset i Storrunden fra 2025 kl. 22:00 og ikke kl. 23:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fra 1. januar 2025 slås lyset i Storrunden av kl. 22:00 i stedet for kl. 23:00, som var tidligere praksis. Endringen ble vedtatt for å spare strøm. Som følge av endringen falt strømkostnaden for lysløypa fra 71 200 kr i 2024 til 61 200 kr i 2025, en nedgang på 14 prosent."
}
],
"why": "The earlier switch-off caused the lower electricity cost, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u06",
"claim": "Fordi lyset i Storrunden fra 2025 slukkes kl. 22:00 og ikke kl. 23:00, gikk strømkostnaden for lysløypa ned fra 71 200 kr til 61 200 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Fra 1. januar 2025 slås lyset i Storrunden av kl. 22:00 i stedet for kl. 23:00, som var tidligere praksis. Endringen ble vedtatt for å spare strøm. Som følge av endringen falt strømkostnaden for lysløypa fra 71 200 kr i 2024 til 61 200 kr i 2025, en nedgang på 14 prosent."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the cost fell as a result of the earlier switch-off."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "421 løpere stilte til start i det 32. Lyngmorennet, som ble arrangert søndag 8. februar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Det 32. Lyngmorennet gikk søndag 8. februar 2026 med 412 startende."
}
],
"why": "The 32nd race had 412 starters, not 421."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u07",
"claim": "412 løpere stilte til start i det 32. Lyngmorennet, som ble arrangert søndag 8. februar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Det 32. Lyngmorennet gikk søndag 8. februar 2026 med 412 startende."
}
],
"why": "Restates the 32nd race's date and its 412 starters."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle medlemmer, uansett alder, kan låne ski av laget mot et depositum på 300 kr per par.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Laget låner ut ski til medlemmer under 13 år. Depositumet er 300 kr per par og betales tilbake når skiene leveres innen 30. april 2027."
}
],
"why": "Ski lending is limited to members under 13."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u08",
"claim": "Medlemmer som er yngre enn 13 år, kan låne ski av laget mot et depositum på 300 kr per par.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Laget låner ut ski til medlemmer under 13 år. Depositumet er 300 kr per par og betales tilbake når skiene leveres innen 30. april 2027."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt limits lending to members under 13 and sets the deposit at 300 kr per pair."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Ved kontrollen av lysarmaturene i Storrunden og Barnerunden lørdag 11. oktober 2025 ble seks armaturer skiftet ut med LED-armaturer.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 11.10.2025 | B: lørdag | C: Kontroll av lysarmaturer | D: Storrunden og Barnerunden | E: Eivind Rustad | F: 4 | G: 4 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 6 armaturer skiftet"
}
],
"why": "The row says six fittings were replaced but says nothing about LED."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u09",
"claim": "Ved kontrollen av lysarmaturene i Storrunden og Barnerunden lørdag 11. oktober 2025 ble seks armaturer skiftet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 11.10.2025 | B: lørdag | C: Kontroll av lysarmaturer | D: Storrunden og Barnerunden | E: Eivind Rustad | F: 4 | G: 4 | H: 1 | I: Utført | J: 6 armaturer skiftet"
}
],
"why": "The row for 11.10.2025 notes that 6 fittings were replaced during the check."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Å leie hele hytta en helg, fra fredag kl. 16:00 til søndag kl. 15:00, koster 3 500 kr, og også andre enn medlemmer har adgang til slik helgeleie.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hele hytta kan leies for en helg, fra fredag kl. 16:00 til søndag kl. 15:00, for 3 500 kr. Helgeleie av hele hytta er kun for medlemmer."
}
],
"why": "Weekend rental of the whole cabin is for members only.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from the reworded twin t10."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u10",
"claim": "Å leie hele hytta en helg, fra fredag kl. 16:00 til søndag kl. 15:00, koster 3 500 kr, og bare medlemmer har adgang til slik helgeleie.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hele hytta kan leies for en helg, fra fredag kl. 16:00 til søndag kl. 15:00, for 3 500 kr. Helgeleie av hele hytta er kun for medlemmer."
}
],
"why": "Restates the weekend period, the price and the members-only rule.",
"audit": "FIX: The first clause copied the excerpt's first sentence word for word with only 'for en helg' dropped."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "At kafévaktene i Granlihytta starter kl. 10:30, er grunnen til at kafeen der åpner kl. 11:00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Kafévakter i Granlihytta går fra kl. 10:30 til 15:30, fordi kafeen skal være klar ved åpning kl. 11:00."
}
],
"why": "The shifts start at 10:30 because the café opens at 11:00, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to mirror the reworded twin t11 with only cause and effect swapped."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2b-u11",
"claim": "At kafeen i Granlihytta åpner kl. 11:00, er grunnen til at kafévaktene der starter kl. 10:30.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Kafévakter i Granlihytta går fra kl. 10:30 til 15:30, fordi kafeen skal være klar ved åpning kl. 11:00."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the 11:00 opening as the reason for the 10:30 start.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim kept the excerpt's wording and order almost unchanged ('fordi kafeen skal være klar ... kl. 11:00'), so it counts as a copy."
},
{
"id": "no2b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Dugnadsavgiften er 600 kr per vakt som ikke blir tatt, og vaskegebyret for en hytte som ikke er vasket før avreise, er 600 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Familier som ikke tar vaktene sine, betaler en dugnadsavgift på 800 kr per vakt."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Leietakeren skal vaske hytta før avreise. Blir hytta ikke vasket, belastes et vaskegebyr på 600 kr."
}
],
"why": "600 kr is the cleaning fee for the cabin; the volunteer-shift fee is 800 kr per shift."
},
{
"id": "no2b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2b-u12",
"claim": "Dugnadsavgiften er 800 kr per vakt som ikke blir tatt, og vaskegebyret for en hytte som ikke er vasket før avreise, er 600 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Familier som ikke tar vaktene sine, betaler en dugnadsavgift på 800 kr per vakt."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Leietakeren skal vaske hytta før avreise. Blir hytta ikke vasket, belastes et vaskegebyr på 600 kr."
}
],
"why": "The handbook sets the shift fee at 800 kr and the annual report the cleaning fee at 600 kr."
},
{
"id": "no2b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Idrettsskolen hadde seks flere barn høsten 2025 enn våren samme år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Idrettsskolen hadde 52 barn våren 2025 og 58 barn høsten 2025."
}
],
"why": "58 in the autumn minus 52 in the spring is 6."
},
{
"id": "no2b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Innsamlingen av merkebånd i Granlirunden lørdag 18. april 2026 er planlagt med seks personer og fire timers varighet per vakt, med Arnstein Vold som ansvarlig.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Dato | B: Ukedag | C: Oppgave | D: Sted | E: Ansvarlig | F: Antall personer | G: Varighet per vakt (t) | H: Teller som vakter | I: Status | J: Merknad"
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 18.04.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Innsamling av merkebånd | D: Granlirunden | E: Arnstein Vold | F: 6 | G: 4 | H: 1 | I: Planlagt"
}
],
"why": "The header names columns E, F, G and I as responsible, number of people, hours per shift and status, and the row gives Arnstein Vold, 6, 4 and Planlagt."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Granlirunden ble preparert for første gang lørdag 24. januar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 17.01.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Granlirunden | D: 9.5 | E: Ja | F: 34 | G: -9 | H: 4.5 | I: Torgeir Haugland | J: Første preparering av Granlirunden"
}
],
"why": "The row marks the first preparation of Granlirunden on 17.01.2026, not 24 January."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u01",
"claim": "Granlirunden ble preparert for første gang lørdag 17. januar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 17.01.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Granlirunden | D: 9.5 | E: Ja | F: 34 | G: -9 | H: 4.5 | I: Torgeir Haugland | J: Første preparering av Granlirunden"
}
],
"why": "The row dated 17.01.2026, a Saturday, notes the first preparation of Granlirunden."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi utgiftene til trenerutdanning steg fra 28 000 til 42 000 kr, tok ni trenere grunnkurset.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Kostnaden til trenerutdanning økte fra 28 000 kr til 42 000 kr, fordi ni trenere tok grunnkurset."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the cost rose because nine coaches took the course, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u02",
"claim": "Fordi ni trenere tok grunnkurset, steg utgiftene til trenerutdanning fra 28 000 til 42 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Kostnaden til trenerutdanning økte fra 28 000 kr til 42 000 kr, fordi ni trenere tok grunnkurset."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the nine coaches on the basic course as the reason for the rise from 28 000 to 42 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Søskenrabatten gjelder treningsavgiften og idrettsskolen, men ikke medlemskontingenten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Søskenmoderasjon gis på treningsavgiften: barn nummer to får 25 prosent rabatt, og barn nummer tre og videre trener gratis. Moderasjonen gjelder ikke idrettsskolen og ikke medlemskontingenten."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt explicitly excludes the sports school from the sibling discount."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u03",
"claim": "Søskenrabatten gjelder treningsavgiften, men verken idrettsskolen eller medlemskontingenten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Søskenmoderasjon gis på treningsavgiften: barn nummer to får 25 prosent rabatt, og barn nummer tre og videre trener gratis. Moderasjonen gjelder ikke idrettsskolen og ikke medlemskontingenten."
}
],
"why": "The discount is given on the training fee and does not apply to the sports school or the membership fee."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Etter forslaget gjøres arbeidet sommeren 2026, og hytta leies ikke ut mellom 15. juni og 20. august det året; de som allerede har bestilt, får pengene tilbake.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Arbeidet foreslås gjort sommeren 2026, og hytta stenges for utleie fra 15. juni til 20. august 2026."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says nothing about refunds to people who have already booked."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u04",
"claim": "Etter forslaget gjøres arbeidet sommeren 2026, og hytta leies ikke ut mellom 15. juni og 20. august det året.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Arbeidet foreslås gjort sommeren 2026, og hytta stenges for utleie fra 15. juni til 20. august 2026."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt proposes the work for summer 2026 and closes the cabin for rental from 15 June to 20 August 2026."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Ungdom 13–16 år betalte 400 kr i startkontingent, mens ungdomskontingenten på 150 kr foreslås uendret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Startkontingenten var 100 kr for barn opp til 12 år, 150 kr for ungdom 13–16 år og 300 kr for alle fra 17 år."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Kontingenten for barn (300 kr), ungdom (400 kr) og honnør (300 kr) foreslås uendret."
}
],
"why": "The 150 kr belongs to the race start fee and the 400 kr to the youth membership fee; the claim swaps them."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2c-u05",
"claim": "Ungdom 13–16 år betalte 150 kr i startkontingent, mens ungdomskontingenten på 400 kr foreslås uendret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Startkontingenten var 100 kr for barn opp til 12 år, 150 kr for ungdom 13–16 år og 300 kr for alle fra 17 år."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Kontingenten for barn (300 kr), ungdom (400 kr) og honnør (300 kr) foreslås uendret."
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt gives the youth start fee of 150 kr and the second the unchanged youth membership fee of 400 kr."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle løypene ble gjort klare for Lyngmorennet lørdag 7. februar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 07.02.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Storrunden | D: 4.2 | E: Ja | F: 46 | G: -6 | H: 2.5 | I: Arnstein Vold | J: Klargjort for Lyngmorennet"
}
],
"why": "The row records only Storrunden as made ready for Lyngmorennet, not every trail."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u06",
"claim": "Storrunden ble gjort klar for Lyngmorennet lørdag 7. februar 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 07.02.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Storrunden | D: 4.2 | E: Ja | F: 46 | G: -6 | H: 2.5 | I: Arnstein Vold | J: Klargjort for Lyngmorennet"
}
],
"why": "The row dated Saturday 07.02.2026 for Storrunden notes it was made ready for Lyngmorennet."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Medlemmer er alltid dekket av lagets ulykkesforsikring når de trener.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Lagets ulykkesforsikring dekker medlemmer under trening, men bare når medlemskontingenten for året er betalt."
}
],
"why": "Cover holds only when the year's membership fee is paid, not always."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u07",
"claim": "Medlemmer er dekket av lagets ulykkesforsikring når de trener, forutsatt at årets medlemskontingent er betalt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Lagets ulykkesforsikring dekker medlemmer under trening, men bare når medlemskontingenten for året er betalt."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt makes training cover conditional on the year's membership fee being paid."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Når de 420 000 kronene til nytt tak holdes utenfor, er de budsjetterte kostnadene 744 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Budsjetterte kostnader er 1 154 000 kr, medregnet 420 000 kr til nytt tak."
}
],
"why": "1 154 000 minus 420 000 is 734 000 kr, not 744 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no2c-u08",
"claim": "Når de 420 000 kronene til nytt tak holdes utenfor, er de budsjetterte kostnadene 734 000 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Budsjetterte kostnader er 1 154 000 kr, medregnet 420 000 kr til nytt tak."
}
],
"why": "Total budgeted costs of 1 154 000 kr include 420 000 kr for the roof, leaving 734 000 kr."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Lørdag 10. januar 2026 ble Granlirunden preparert, selv om snøen ikke holdt kravet på 30 cm.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 10.01.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Granlirunden | D: 0 | E: Nei | F: 27 | G: -6 | H: 0 | I: Torgeir Haugland | J: Ikke preparert – for lite snø (krav 30 cm)"
}
],
"why": "The row says Granlirunden was not prepared that day."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no2c-u09",
"claim": "Lørdag 10. januar 2026 ble Granlirunden ikke preparert, fordi snøen ikke holdt kravet på 30 cm.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-kontingent-dugnad-loypepreparering.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 10.01.2026 | B: lørdag | C: Granlirunden | D: 0 | E: Nei | F: 27 | G: -6 | H: 0 | I: Torgeir Haugland | J: Ikke preparert – for lite snø (krav 30 cm)"
}
],
"why": "The row notes no preparation because of too little snow against a 30 cm requirement."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fordi overskuddet i 2024 ble lavere, kjøpte laget nytt tidtakingsutstyr for 168 000 kr det året.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Overskuddet i 2024 var lavere fordi laget det året kjøpte nytt tidtakingsutstyr for 168 000 kr."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the equipment purchase caused the lower surplus, not the reverse."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u10",
"claim": "Fordi laget kjøpte nytt tidtakingsutstyr for 168 000 kr i 2024, ble overskuddet lavere det året.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Overskuddet i 2024 var lavere fordi laget det året kjøpte nytt tidtakingsutstyr for 168 000 kr."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names the 168 000 kr timing equipment purchase as the reason for the lower 2024 surplus."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Kassereren tar imot spørsmål om faktura og betaling og svarer innen tre virkedager, mens spørsmål om treningstider og grupper går til gruppelederen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Spørsmål om faktura og betaling rettes til kassereren. Spørsmål om treningstider og grupper rettes til lederen av gruppa."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt sets no response time for the treasurer.",
"audit": "FIX: Keep one change from the reworded twin t11."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no2c-u11",
"claim": "Kassereren tar imot spørsmål om faktura og betaling, mens spørsmål om treningstider og grupper går til gruppelederen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-haandbok-trenere-og-foreldre-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Spørsmål om faktura og betaling rettes til kassereren. Spørsmål om treningstider og grupper rettes til lederen av gruppa."
}
],
"why": "Invoice and payment questions go to the treasurer and training-time and group questions to the group leader.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt only says such questions are directed to the group leader, not that the leader answers them; 'svarer på' goes slightly beyond it."
},
{
"id": "no2c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Det kom 34 personer på hyttedugnaden lørdag 6. juni 2026, og neste store dugnad blir hyttedugnaden 7. juni.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hyttedugnaden 7. juni samlet 34 personer, som hogg og stablet om lag 18 favner ved."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Neste store dugnad er hyttedugnaden lørdag 6. juni 2026."
}
],
"why": "The 34 participants belong to the cabin work day on 7 June, while 6 June 2026 is the next one; the claim swaps the dates."
},
{
"id": "no2c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no2c-u12",
"claim": "Det kom 34 personer på hyttedugnaden 7. juni, og neste store dugnad blir hyttedugnaden lørdag 6. juni 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hyttedugnaden 7. juni samlet 34 personer, som hogg og stablet om lag 18 favner ved."
},
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmote-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Neste store dugnad er hyttedugnaden lørdag 6. juni 2026."
}
],
"why": "The first excerpt gives 34 participants on 7 June and the second names Saturday 6 June 2026 as the next big work day."
},
{
"id": "no2c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Fristen for å melde seg på gikk ut onsdag 5. februar kl. 23:59, altså fire dager før rennet ble arrangert.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Påmeldingsfristen var onsdag 5. februar kl. 23:59, fire dager før rennet."
}
],
"why": "It restates the registration deadline and that it fell four days before the race."
},
{
"id": "no2c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "En familie med barn i orientering som ikke tar noen av sesongens vakter, må betale 1 600 kr i dugnadsavgift.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "lyngmo-il-aarsmelding-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Dugnadsordningen er uendret fra 2024: hver familie med barn i langrenn eller orientering skal ta to dugnadsvakter per sesong, og familier som bare har barn i idrettsskolen skal ta én vakt. En vakt varer minst fire timer. Familier som ikke tar vaktene sine, betaler en dugnadsavgift på 800 kr per vakt."
}
],
"why": "Such a family owes two shifts per season at 800 kr per missed shift, which is 1 600 kr."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Trompeten TS-07 står oppført som til service og ventes tilbake i uke 45, og det er notert at ventil nr. 2 henger.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TS-07 | B: Trompet | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2003 | E: 5200 | F: Til service | H: 02.10.2026 | I: Ventil nr. 2 henger, ventet tilbake uke 43"
}
],
"why": "The row says the trumpet is expected back in week 43, not week 45.",
"audit": "FIX: The 'fordi' links the service status to the sticking valve as a reason the row does not state; removed here to keep its twin one change away after the twin's fix. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t01 so the pair stays one change (the week) apart."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Fra høsten 2026 koster hvert seminar 750 kroner i deltakeravgift, ettersom Granlia leirskole har varslet dyrere overnatting.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Deltakeravgiften øker til 700 kroner per seminar fra høsten 2026 fordi Granlia leirskole har varslet høyere pris for overnatting."
}
],
"why": "The fee rises to 700 kroner per seminar, not 750."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Julekonserten ble holdt i den mindre storsalen fordi det ble solgt færre billetter enn året før.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Julekonserten ble holdt i storsalen og ikke i kirken, fordi kirken var opptatt den helgen. Som følge av den mindre salen ble det solgt færre billetter enn året før."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the smaller hall caused fewer tickets sold, and the venue was chosen because the church was occupied."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Fra 1. august 2026 fikk dirigentene et honorar som er 8 prosent høyere, og årsaken er at kontingenten gikk opp fra samme dato.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Kontingenten ble økt fra 1. august 2026 etter vedtak i årsmøtet 4. juni 2026. Økningen skyldes at den nye avtalen med dirigentene gir 8 prosent høyere honorar fra samme dato."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the fee increase is caused by the higher conductor pay, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to mirror the reworded twin t04 so the pair stays one swap apart."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Ingen musikanter, uansett alder, får oppholde seg alene i lageret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Musikanter under 13 år skal ikke være alene i lageret."
}
],
"why": "The rule only applies to musicians under 13, not to all ages."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle rommene korpset bruker, har en regel om at bare vann er lov der.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "I musikkrommet er kun vann tillatt, og det kan være maks 25 personer i rommet."
}
],
"why": "The water-only rule is stated for the music room only, not for every rehearsal room.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to mirror the reworded twin t06 so the pair stays one change apart."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Hovedkorpsets dirigent Ingeborg Haugstøl går nå inn i sin femte sesong og er utdannet ved Norges musikkhøgskole.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Ingeborg Haugstøl er dirigent for Hovedkorpset og begynner nå sin femte sesong."
}
],
"why": "Her education is not stated anywhere in the excerpt."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Althornet AH-04 i Hovedkorpset ble kjøpt i august 2026 etter et vedtak på årsmøtet for å erstatte et althorn med lekkasje, og er lånt ut til Selma A.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: AH-04 | B: Althorn | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2026 | E: 16900 | F: Utlånt | G: Selma A. | I: Kjøpt august 2026 etter vedtak på årsmøtet"
}
],
"why": "The row gives no reason such as replacing a leaking alto horn."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Det går an å være medlem av Aspirantkorpset og Hovedkorpset på samme tid.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "En musikant kan være med i både Hovedkorpset og Drill- og slaggruppa. Det er ikke mulig å være med i både Aspirantkorpset og Hovedkorpset samtidig."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says it is not possible to be in both the aspirant band and the main band at the same time."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Drill- og slaggruppa har øvelse i gymsalen på onsdager fra 17:00 til 18:30, og der er det ikke lov å bruke innesko.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Drill- og slaggruppa øver onsdager 17:00–18:30 i gymsalen, og innesko er påbudt."
}
],
"why": "Indoor shoes are mandatory, not forbidden."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Drill- og slaggruppa tar, i likhet med Aspirantkorpset, imot barn fra og med 3. trinn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Aspirantkorpset tar imot barn fra og med 3. trinn. Aspirantene får gruppetimer på sitt instrument og spiller samspill hver mandag."
},
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Drill- og slaggruppa tar imot barn fra og med 4. trinn, uten prøve."
}
],
"why": "The 3rd-grade start belongs to Aspirantkorpset; Drill- og slaggruppa takes children from 4th grade."
},
{
"id": "no3a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Tubaen TU-01, som bare brukes på øvelser og står i storsalen, ble kjøpt i mars 2026 for 27 900 kroner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Den største enkeltutgiften var en ny tuba til 27 900 kroner, kjøpt i mars 2026 fordi den eldste tubaen fra 1984 hadde en sprekk i klokka og ikke lenger kunne repareres."
},
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TU-01 | B: Tuba | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 1998 | E: 19000 | F: Utlånt | G: Aksel D. | H: 12.07.2026 | I: Brukes bare på øvelser, står i storsalen"
}
],
"why": "The March 2026 purchase at 27 900 kroner belongs to the new tuba in the report, not to TU-01, whose row shows 1998 and 19000."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u01",
"claim": "Trompeten TS-07 står oppført som til service og ventes tilbake i uke 43, og det er notert at ventil nr. 2 henger.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TS-07 | B: Trompet | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2003 | E: 5200 | F: Til service | H: 02.10.2026 | I: Ventil nr. 2 henger, ventet tilbake uke 43"
}
],
"why": "The row states the trumpet is at service, valve 2 sticks, and it is expected back in week 43.",
"audit": "FIX: The row puts 'Til service' and 'Ventil nr. 2 henger' side by side but never states the valve as the reason for the service, so 'fordi' adds a reason. | FIX2: The second half copied the note cell nearly verbatim, and the colon still reads the sticking valve as the reason for the service status."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u02",
"claim": "Fra høsten 2026 koster hvert seminar 700 kroner i deltakeravgift, ettersom Granlia leirskole har varslet dyrere overnatting.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Deltakeravgiften øker til 700 kroner per seminar fra høsten 2026 fordi Granlia leirskole har varslet høyere pris for overnatting."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt states the fee rises to 700 kroner per seminar from autumn 2026 because Granlia announced a higher price for lodging."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u03",
"claim": "Det ble solgt færre billetter til julekonserten enn året før fordi den ble holdt i den mindre storsalen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Julekonserten ble holdt i storsalen og ikke i kirken, fordi kirken var opptatt den helgen. Som følge av den mindre salen ble det solgt færre billetter enn året før."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says fewer tickets were sold as a consequence of the smaller hall."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u04",
"claim": "Fra 1. august 2026 gikk kontingenten opp, og årsaken er en ny avtale som fra samme dato gir dirigentene et honorar som er 8 prosent høyere.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Kontingenten ble økt fra 1. august 2026 etter vedtak i årsmøtet 4. juni 2026. Økningen skyldes at den nye avtalen med dirigentene gir 8 prosent høyere honorar fra samme dato."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the increase is due to the new agreement giving conductors 8 percent higher pay from the same date.",
"audit": "FIX: The claim copies two long stretches of the excerpt in their original order ('Kontingenten ble økt fra 1. august 2026', 'gir ... 8 prosent høyere honorar fra samme dato'), so it reads as a near copy."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u05",
"claim": "Musikanter som er yngre enn 13 år, får ikke oppholde seg alene i lageret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Musikanter under 13 år skal ikke være alene i lageret."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt states musicians under 13 must not be alone in the storeroom."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u06",
"claim": "Musikkrommet har en regel om at bare vann er lov der.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "I musikkrommet er kun vann tillatt, og det kan være maks 25 personer i rommet."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says only water is allowed in the music room.",
"audit": "FIX: 'I musikkrommet er vann det eneste som er tillatt' keeps the excerpt's words in the same order with only 'kun' reshaped, so it counts as a copy."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u07",
"claim": "Hovedkorpsets dirigent Ingeborg Haugstøl går nå inn i sin femte sesong.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Ingeborg Haugstøl er dirigent for Hovedkorpset og begynner nå sin femte sesong."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says she conducts the main band and is starting her fifth season."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u08",
"claim": "Althornet AH-04 i Hovedkorpset ble kjøpt i august 2026 etter et vedtak på årsmøtet, og er lånt ut til Selma A.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: AH-04 | B: Althorn | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2026 | E: 16900 | F: Utlånt | G: Selma A. | I: Kjøpt august 2026 etter vedtak på årsmøtet"
}
],
"why": "The row shows AH-04, an alto horn in Hovedkorpset, lent to Selma A., bought August 2026 after an annual meeting decision."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u09",
"claim": "Det går ikke an å være medlem av Aspirantkorpset og Hovedkorpset på samme tid.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "En musikant kan være med i både Hovedkorpset og Drill- og slaggruppa. Det er ikke mulig å være med i både Aspirantkorpset og Hovedkorpset samtidig."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt states it is not possible to be in both at once."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3a-u10",
"claim": "Drill- og slaggruppa har øvelse i gymsalen på onsdager fra 17:00 til 18:30, og der må man bruke innesko.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Drill- og slaggruppa øver onsdager 17:00–18:30 i gymsalen, og innesko er påbudt."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the time and place and says indoor shoes are mandatory."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3a-u11",
"claim": "Aspirantkorpset tar imot barn fra og med 3. trinn, mens Drill- og slaggruppa først tar imot fra og med 4. trinn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Aspirantkorpset tar imot barn fra og med 3. trinn. Aspirantene får gruppetimer på sitt instrument og spiller samspill hver mandag."
},
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Drill- og slaggruppa tar imot barn fra og med 4. trinn, uten prøve."
}
],
"why": "One excerpt gives 3rd grade for Aspirantkorpset and the other 4th grade for Drill- og slaggruppa."
},
{
"id": "no3a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3a-u12",
"claim": "En ny tuba ble kjøpt i mars 2026 for 27 900 kroner, mens tubaen TU-01 bare brukes på øvelser og står i storsalen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Den største enkeltutgiften var en ny tuba til 27 900 kroner, kjøpt i mars 2026 fordi den eldste tubaen fra 1984 hadde en sprekk i klokka og ikke lenger kunne repareres."
},
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TU-01 | B: Tuba | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 1998 | E: 19000 | F: Utlånt | G: Aksel D. | H: 12.07.2026 | I: Brukes bare på øvelser, står i storsalen"
}
],
"why": "The report gives the new tuba's price and date, and the TU-01 row says it is used only at rehearsals and kept in the main hall.",
"audit": "FIX: The report excerpt does not say who bought the new tuba, so 'Korpset kjøpte' adds an actor; passive voice keeps the claim within both excerpts and one change from u12."
},
{
"id": "no3a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Kornetten TS-03 i Aspirantkorpset ble kjøpt inn i 2015, har en verdi på 7800 kroner og er lånt ut til Ida M.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Instrument-ID | B: Instrument | C: Avdeling | D: Innkjøpsår | E: Verdi (kr) | F: Status | G: Utlånt til | H: Siste service (dato) | I: Merknad"
},
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: TS-03 | B: Kornett | C: Aspirantkorpset | D: 2015 | E: 7800 | F: Utlånt | G: Ida M. | H: 12.07.2026 | I: Aspirant, første år uten leie"
}
],
"why": "The header names column D as purchase year, E as value in kroner and G as lent to, and the TS-03 row gives 2015, 7800 and Ida M."
},
{
"id": "no3a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "På en regional drillmønstring i Bergen 21. mars 2026 kom Drill- og slaggruppa på tredjeplass blant ni grupper i juniorklassen, med 81 av 100 mulige poeng.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Drill- og slaggruppa deltok også på en regional drillmønstring i Bergen 21. mars 2026, der gruppa fikk 81 av 100 poeng og endte på tredjeplass av ni grupper i juniorklassen."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt states the date, place, score 81 of 100 and third place of nine junior groups."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Med tillatelse kan marsjtrommen SL-01 tas med hjem når som helst.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: SL-01 | B: Marsjtromme | C: Drill- og slaggruppa | D: 2014 | E: 4800 | F: På lager | H: 12.07.2026 | I: Hjemlån bare før konkurranse, med tillatelse"
}
],
"why": "The row allows taking SL-01 home only before a competition, not at any time."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u01",
"claim": "Med tillatelse kan marsjtrommen SL-01 tas med hjem før en konkurranse.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: SL-01 | B: Marsjtromme | C: Drill- og slaggruppa | D: 2014 | E: 4800 | F: På lager | H: 12.07.2026 | I: Hjemlån bare før konkurranse, med tillatelse"
}
],
"why": "The row says home loan only before a competition, with permission."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle musikanter i korpset må delta på seminarene, siden det er der konsertprogrammet øves inn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Seminarene er obligatoriske for musikanter i Hovedkorpset, fordi konsertprogrammet øves inn der."
}
],
"why": "The seminars are stated as mandatory only for musicians in Hovedkorpset, not for every musician in the band."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u02",
"claim": "Musikanter i Hovedkorpset må delta på seminarene, siden det er der konsertprogrammet øves inn.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Seminarene er obligatoriske for musikanter i Hovedkorpset, fordi konsertprogrammet øves inn der."
}
],
"why": "The seminars are mandatory for Hovedkorpset musicians because the concert programme is rehearsed there."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Skader skal meldes innen 14 dager til Siri Nyhagen, som er instrumentansvarlig.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Skader meldes til instrumentansvarlig Siri Nyhagen innen sju dager."
}
],
"why": "Damage must be reported within seven days, not 14."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u03",
"claim": "Skader skal meldes innen sju dager til Siri Nyhagen, som er instrumentansvarlig.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Skader meldes til instrumentansvarlig Siri Nyhagen innen sju dager."
}
],
"why": "Damage is reported to instrument manager Siri Nyhagen within seven days."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Overnattingen på Herberget Kastanjegården er ført som en utgift på 55 800 kroner for 45 personer i fire netter, med frokost, altså 340 kroner per overnatting.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Overnatting Herberget Kastanjegården | B: Utgift | C: 180 | D: 310 | E: 55800 | F: Kari Enerhaug | G: 45 personer x 4 netter, frokost inkludert"
}
],
"why": "The price per night is 310 kroner (180 x 310 = 55 800), not 340.",
"audit": "FIX: The row shows only an expense line (B: Utgift), so 'budsjettert' adds a budget status the excerpt does not state; reworded to the row's own terms, the error stays the price 340. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t04; the error stays the price 340, now certainly wrong since 55 800 over 45 x 4 nights is 310."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no3b-u04",
"claim": "Overnattingen på Herberget Kastanjegården er ført som en utgift på 55 800 kroner for 45 personer i fire netter, med frokost, altså 310 kroner per overnatting.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Overnatting Herberget Kastanjegården | B: Utgift | C: 180 | D: 310 | E: 55800 | F: Kari Enerhaug | G: 45 personer x 4 netter, frokost inkludert"
}
],
"why": "180 units (45 persons x 4 nights) at 310 kroner each, breakfast included.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Budsjettert' goes beyond the row, which only marks the line as an expense (B: Utgift); reworded so the twin stays one change (310 vs 340) from u04. | FIX2: Without a header the price per night rests on reading column D as a unit price; the claim now gives the total so 310 follows by one division from the row's own note."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Alle trærne ble solgt fordi juletresalget stengte to timer før planen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Juletresalget ga nest mest, selv om salget ble stengt to timer tidligere enn planlagt fordi alle trærne var solgt."
}
],
"why": "The sale closed early because all trees were sold, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u05",
"claim": "Juletresalget stengte to timer før planen, fordi alle trærne allerede var solgt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Juletresalget ga nest mest, selv om salget ble stengt to timer tidligere enn planlagt fordi alle trærne var solgt."
}
],
"why": "The sale closed two hours early because every tree was sold."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Dirigentene har fått 8 prosent høyere honorar som følge av økningen som gjelder fra 1. august 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Økningen gjelder fra 1. august 2026 fordi dirigentene har fått 8 prosent høyere honorar."
}
],
"why": "The increase is caused by the conductors' higher fee; the claim makes the fee rise a result of the increase."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u06",
"claim": "Dirigentene har fått 8 prosent høyere honorar, og det er grunnen til økningen som gjelder fra 1. august 2026.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Økningen gjelder fra 1. august 2026 fordi dirigentene har fått 8 prosent høyere honorar."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives the higher fee as the reason for the increase from 1 August 2026."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Den som skal være borte fra en øvelse, gir beskjed til kontaktpersonen i avdelingen på SMS senest kl. 14:00 samme dag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Fravær meldes til avdelingens kontaktperson innen kl. 14:00 samme dag som øvelsen."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt names no channel for reporting absence; SMS is added."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u07",
"claim": "Den som skal være borte fra en øvelse, gir beskjed til kontaktpersonen i avdelingen senest kl. 14:00 samme dag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Fravær meldes til avdelingens kontaktperson innen kl. 14:00 samme dag som øvelsen."
}
],
"why": "Absence is reported to the section's contact person by 14:00 on the day of the rehearsal."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Altsaksofonen AS-02 er på service for å få ny pute på G-klaffen, ventes tilbake i uke 42 og skal da lånes ut til en ny musikant.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: AS-02 | B: Altsaksofon | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2018 | E: 15800 | F: Til service | H: 28.09.2026 | I: Ny pute på G-klaff, ventet tilbake uke 42"
}
],
"why": "Nothing in the row says AS-02 will be lent to a new musician when it returns."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u08",
"claim": "Altsaksofonen AS-02 er på service for å få ny pute på G-klaffen og ventes tilbake i uke 42.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: AS-02 | B: Altsaksofon | C: Hovedkorpset | D: 2018 | E: 15800 | F: Til service | H: 28.09.2026 | I: Ny pute på G-klaff, ventet tilbake uke 42"
}
],
"why": "The row shows status Til service, a new pad on the G key and expected return in week 42."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Musikanten får låne bort instrumentet, også til søsken.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Musikanten har ikke lov til å låne instrumentet bort, heller ikke til søsken."
}
],
"why": "Lending the instrument out is forbidden, including to siblings; the claim makes it allowed."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u09",
"claim": "Musikanten får ikke låne bort instrumentet, ikke engang til søsken.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Musikanten har ikke lov til å låne instrumentet bort, heller ikke til søsken."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt forbids lending the instrument out, siblings included."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Korpset betaler ikke lenger for å erstatte kasser som er slitt av vanlig bruk.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Fordi tre av kassene var ødelagt ved uaktsomhet, har foreldreutvalget bestemt at familien fra 2026/2027 skal betale for ny kasse i slike tilfeller, innenfor egenandelen på inntil 1 000 kroner. Kasser som er slitt ved vanlig bruk, erstattes fortsatt av korpset."
}
],
"why": "Cases worn by ordinary use are still replaced by the band; only negligently damaged cases are now paid by the family."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3b-u10",
"claim": "Korpset betaler fortsatt for å erstatte kasser som er slitt av vanlig bruk.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Fordi tre av kassene var ødelagt ved uaktsomhet, har foreldreutvalget bestemt at familien fra 2026/2027 skal betale for ny kasse i slike tilfeller, innenfor egenandelen på inntil 1 000 kroner. Kasser som er slitt ved vanlig bruk, erstattes fortsatt av korpset."
}
],
"why": "Cases worn by ordinary use are still replaced by the band."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "En borte uniformsjakke koster familien 1 000 kroner, det samme som egenandelen familien betalte for bulken i kornettens munnstykkerør.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Hvis en uniformsjakke blir borte, betaler familien 1 500 kroner. Bukse og lue erstattes med 400 kroner hver."
},
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "en kornett fikk en bulk i munnstykkerøret, og familien betalte egenandelen på 1 000 kroner etter reglene for instrumentlån."
}
],
"why": "1 000 kroner is the excess paid for the dented cornet; a lost uniform jacket costs 1 500 kroner."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3b-u11",
"claim": "En borte uniformsjakke koster familien 1 500 kroner, mer enn egenandelen på 1 000 kroner som familien betalte for bulken i kornettens munnstykkerør.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Hvis en uniformsjakke blir borte, betaler familien 1 500 kroner. Bukse og lue erstattes med 400 kroner hver."
},
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "en kornett fikk en bulk i munnstykkerøret, og familien betalte egenandelen på 1 000 kroner etter reglene for instrumentlån."
}
],
"why": "The handbook prices a lost jacket at 1 500 kroner and the report says the cornet excess was 1 000 kroner."
},
{
"id": "no3b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Festivalavgiften er økt fra 550 kroner til 700 kroner, like mye som musikanter i de andre avdelingene betaler per seminar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Festivalavgift | B: Utgift | C: 38 | D: 650 | E: 24700 | F: Ingeborg Haugstøl | G: Økt fra 550 kr i oktober 2026; voksne ledere betaler ikke"
},
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Musikanter i de andre avdelingene betaler 700 kroner per seminar."
}
],
"why": "700 kroner is the seminar fee; the festival fee was raised from 550 to 650 kroner."
},
{
"id": "no3b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3b-u12",
"claim": "Festivalavgiften er økt fra 550 kroner til 650 kroner, 50 kroner mindre enn musikanter i de andre avdelingene betaler per seminar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Festivalavgift | B: Utgift | C: 38 | D: 650 | E: 24700 | F: Ingeborg Haugstøl | G: Økt fra 550 kr i oktober 2026; voksne ledere betaler ikke"
},
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Musikanter i de andre avdelingene betaler 700 kroner per seminar."
}
],
"why": "The row shows 650 (raised from 550) and the slide gives 700 kroner per seminar; 700 - 650 = 50."
},
{
"id": "no3b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Før konserter møter musikantene i Hovedkorpset et kvarter tidligere enn aspirantene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Oppmøte før konserter er 60 minutter før start for Hovedkorpset og 45 minutter før start for Aspirantkorpset."
}
],
"why": "60 minutes before start versus 45 minutes is a 15-minute difference."
},
{
"id": "no3b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "Uniformene leveres inn senest 15. juni, altså før korpset sender dem til rens i juli.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Musikanter i Hovedkorpset låner korpsuniform. Uniformen deles ut på første øvelse i september og leveres inn sammen med instrumentet innen 15. juni."
},
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Uniformen skal ikke vaskes i maskin. Korpset sender alle uniformer til rens én gang per år, i juli."
}
],
"why": "One excerpt gives the 15 June return deadline, the other the cleaning in July."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Utgiftsposten for diett til dirigent og instruktør er beregnet for 3 personer i 5 dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Diett dirigent og instruktør | B: Utgift | C: 12 | D: 400 | E: 4800 | F: Mona Fjellstad | G: 3 personer x 4 dager"
}
],
"why": "The row says 3 persons for 4 days, not 5 days."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u01",
"claim": "Utgiftsposten for diett til dirigent og instruktør er beregnet for 3 personer i 4 dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Diett dirigent og instruktør | B: Utgift | C: 12 | D: 400 | E: 4800 | F: Mona Fjellstad | G: 3 personer x 4 dager"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says 3 personer x 4 dager for the expense line Diett dirigent og instruktør."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "I alle korpsets grupper tar familiene foreldrevakt to ganger i semesteret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Familier i Hovedkorpset og Drill- og slaggruppa har foreldrevakt to ganger per semester."
}
],
"why": "The rule of two parent watches per semester is stated only for families in Hovedkorpset and Drill- og slaggruppa, not for all families.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from the reworded twin t02."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u02",
"claim": "I Hovedkorpset og Drill- og slaggruppa tar familiene foreldrevakt to ganger i semesteret.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Familier i Hovedkorpset og Drill- og slaggruppa har foreldrevakt to ganger per semester."
}
],
"why": "It restates that families in these two sections take parent watch twice per semester.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy of the excerpt (same words in the same order with two or three swaps)."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Musikanten får ikke låne bort instrumentet til andre, men søsken er unntatt fra forbudet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Musikanten har ikke lov til å låne instrumentet videre til andre, heller ikke til søsken."
}
],
"why": "The rule explicitly includes siblings in the ban; the claim excludes them."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u03",
"claim": "Musikanten får ikke låne bort instrumentet til andre, og forbudet gjelder også søsken.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Musikanten har ikke lov til å låne instrumentet videre til andre, heller ikke til søsken."
}
],
"why": "The rule forbids lending the instrument on to others, siblings included."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Kravet om minst én voksen per seks musikanter skyldes at sju voksne reiser med på turen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Korpset skal ha minst én voksen per seks musikanter, og derfor reiser sju voksne: dirigent Ingeborg Haugstøl, instruktør Live Aasmyr, turleder Kari Enerhaug og fire foresatte som trekkes blant dem som melder seg."
}
],
"why": "The text says the ratio requirement is the reason seven adults travel, not the other way round."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u04",
"claim": "At sju voksne reiser med på turen, skyldes kravet om minst én voksen per seks musikanter.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Korpset skal ha minst én voksen per seks musikanter, og derfor reiser sju voksne: dirigent Ingeborg Haugstøl, instruktør Live Aasmyr, turleder Kari Enerhaug og fire foresatte som trekkes blant dem som melder seg."
}
],
"why": "The text says seven adults travel because of the requirement of at least one adult per six musicians (\"og derfor\")."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Deltakerne på alle dugnadene i sesongen må være minst 16 år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 09.01.2027 | B: Varetelling hos lokal dagligvarebutikk | C: 12 | D: 9000 | E: 100 | F: 9000 | G: Henrik Bråtveit | H: Turvakt; deltakere må være minst 16 år"
}
],
"why": "The age limit of 16 is noted only for the stocktaking at the local grocery store, not for every dugnad."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u05",
"claim": "Deltakerne på varetellingen hos den lokale dagligvarebutikken må være minst 16 år.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 09.01.2027 | B: Varetelling hos lokal dagligvarebutikk | C: 12 | D: 9000 | E: 100 | F: 9000 | G: Henrik Bråtveit | H: Turvakt; deltakere må være minst 16 år"
}
],
"why": "The row for the stocktaking notes that participants must be at least 16 years old."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Nye aspiranter har sin første øvelse mandag 7. september 2026 klokken 17:30.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Første øvelse for nye aspiranter er mandag 7. september 2026 kl. 16:30."
}
],
"why": "The first rehearsal starts at 16:30, not 17:30."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u06",
"claim": "Nye aspiranter har sin første øvelse mandag 7. september 2026 klokken 16:30.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Første øvelse for nye aspiranter er mandag 7. september 2026 kl. 16:30."
}
],
"why": "It restates the date and time of the new aspirants' first rehearsal."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Melding om skader går skriftlig til instrumentansvarlig, og fristen er sju dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Skader skal meldes til instrumentansvarlig innen sju dager."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the report must be in writing.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (skriftlig) from the reworded twin t07."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u07",
"claim": "Melding om skader går til instrumentansvarlig, og fristen er sju dager.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Skader skal meldes til instrumentansvarlig innen sju dager."
}
],
"why": "It restates the seven-day deadline for reporting damage to the person responsible for instruments.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy in the excerpt's word order, and 'på instrumentet' adds a scope the bare word 'Skader' does not state."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "På turen dekker korpsets ordinære forsikring instrumentene korpset eier, og den dekker også private instrumenter.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Instrumentene som korpset eier, er forsikret gjennom korpsets ordinære forsikring også på turen. Private instrumenter er ikke dekket, med mindre familien selv har forsikret dem."
}
],
"why": "Private instruments are stated not to be covered by the band's insurance; the claim says they are."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u08",
"claim": "På turen dekker korpsets ordinære forsikring instrumentene korpset eier, men den dekker ikke private instrumenter.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Instrumentene som korpset eier, er forsikret gjennom korpsets ordinære forsikring også på turen. Private instrumenter er ikke dekket, med mindre familien selv har forsikret dem."
}
],
"why": "The band's own instruments are insured on the trip, while private instruments are not covered unless the family insured them itself."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Et instrument som blir skadet på grunn av uaktsomhet, koster familien 2 500 kroner i egenandel.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Ved skade som skyldes uaktsomhet, betaler familien en egenandel på inntil 1 000 kroner. Hvis et instrument blir borte fordi det ble etterlatt uten tilsyn, betaler familien en egenandel på 2 500 kroner."
}
],
"why": "The 2 500 kroner excess is triggered by an instrument lost after being left unattended, not by damage through negligence (which costs up to 1 000 kroner).",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (the cause) from the reworded twin t09. | FIX2: Reworded in step with t09 so the pair stays one change (the cause) apart."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u09",
"claim": "Et instrument som går tapt fordi det ble etterlatt uten tilsyn, koster familien 2 500 kroner i egenandel.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Ved skade som skyldes uaktsomhet, betaler familien en egenandel på inntil 1 000 kroner. Hvis et instrument blir borte fordi det ble etterlatt uten tilsyn, betaler familien en egenandel på 2 500 kroner."
}
],
"why": "The second sentence sets the 2 500 kroner excess for an instrument lost after being left unattended.",
"audit": "FIX: Largely the excerpt's second sentence with its two clauses swapped; reworded. | FIX2: Still a near-verbatim copy of the excerpt's second sentence: same order with only synonyms swapped (Hvis/Når, blir borte/forsvinner, etterlatt/stående)."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Musikanter som blir med på turen, trenger gyldig pass eller nasjonalt ID-kort, som turlederen tar vare på under reisen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Alle musikanter som reiser, må ha gyldig pass eller nasjonalt ID-kort."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says the trip leader keeps the documents during the journey."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no3c-u10",
"claim": "Musikanter som blir med på turen, trenger gyldig pass eller nasjonalt ID-kort.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "Alle musikanter som reiser, må ha gyldig pass eller nasjonalt ID-kort."
}
],
"why": "It restates the travel document requirement for travelling musicians."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Hvis en ekstra turvakt ikke blir gjennomført, sendes det en regning på 300 kroner; for en ordinær vakt som ikke blir gjennomført, er regningen 300 kroner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "En ordinær vakt som ikke blir gjennomført, faktureres med 300 kroner."
},
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "For hver ekstra turvakt som ikke blir gjennomført, faktureres familien 400 kroner, fordi dugnadsinntekten er en forutsetning for at egenandelen kan holdes på 3 900 kroner."
}
],
"why": "The 300 kroner fee belongs to an ordinary watch; a missed extra trip watch costs 400 kroner.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (400 given as 300) from the reworded twin t11. | FIX2: It differed from its twin in sentence shape as well as the amount; now only 400 is given as 300."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3c-u11",
"claim": "Hvis en ekstra turvakt ikke blir gjennomført, sendes det en regning på 400 kroner; for en ordinær vakt som ikke blir gjennomført, er regningen 300 kroner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "En ordinær vakt som ikke blir gjennomført, faktureres med 300 kroner."
},
{
"file": "sesongrapport-2025-2026-og-reiseplan-2027.pdf.md",
"text": "For hver ekstra turvakt som ikke blir gjennomført, faktureres familien 400 kroner, fordi dugnadsinntekten er en forutsetning for at egenandelen kan holdes på 3 900 kroner."
}
],
"why": "One excerpt gives 300 kroner for a missed ordinary watch, the other 400 kroner for a missed extra trip watch.",
"audit": "FIX: First half copies the PDF excerpt nearly verbatim, and 'en ordinær vakt koster 300 kroner' drops the condition that the 300 kroner is billed only when the watch is not carried out."
},
{
"id": "no3c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Moderasjon for søsken gis på kontingenten og på musikantenes egenandel, som betales i tre rater, men ikke på instrumentleien.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Søskenmoderasjonen gjelder bare kontingenten, ikke instrumentleien."
},
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Egenandel musikanter | B: Inntekt | C: 38 | D: 3900 | E: 148200 | F: Mona Fjellstad | G: Tre rater à 1 300 kr; ingen søskenmoderasjon"
}
],
"why": "The sibling discount applies to the membership fee only; the musicians' excess row says no sibling discount.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from the reworded twin t12."
},
{
"id": "no3c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no3c-u12",
"claim": "Moderasjon for søsken gis på kontingenten, men verken på instrumentleien eller på musikantenes egenandel, som betales i tre rater.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Søskenmoderasjonen gjelder bare kontingenten, ikke instrumentleien."
},
{
"file": "instrumentregister-og-reisebudsjett-2026-2027.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Egenandel musikanter | B: Inntekt | C: 38 | D: 3900 | E: 148200 | F: Mona Fjellstad | G: Tre rater à 1 300 kr; ingen søskenmoderasjon"
}
],
"why": "The handbook limits the sibling discount to the membership fee, and the budget row says the musicians' excess has no sibling discount.",
"audit": "FIX: As drafted the handbook's 'bare kontingenten' alone already supports the claim, so it did not need both excerpts; adding the three instalments makes the spreadsheet row necessary."
},
{
"id": "no3c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"claim": "Et rom med direkte sol eller en temperatur under 5 grader er ikke et sted der instrumentet skal oppbevares.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "foreldrehaandbok-og-regler-for-instrumentlaan-2026-2027.docx.md",
"text": "Instrumentet skal ikke oppbevares i rom som er kaldere enn 5 grader eller står i direkte sol."
}
],
"why": "It restates the storage rule against rooms colder than 5 degrees or in direct sunlight."
},
{
"id": "no3c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "En familie med to barn i korpset tar likevel bare tre ordinære dugnadsvakter i sesongen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "informasjonsmote-for-nye-foreldre-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hver familie tar tre ordinære dugnadsvakter per sesong, uansett hvor mange barn familien har i korpset."
}
],
"why": "Since the number of ordinary watches is three per family regardless of how many children it has, a family with two children also takes three."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Det nye tunnelhuset tas i bruk fra og med uke 19.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Tunnelhus | B: 120 | C: Tomat | D: 60 | E: 21 | F: 29 | G: 650 | H: Mira Holten | I: Nytt tunnelhus, i bruk fra uke 21"
}
],
"why": "The row says the new tunnel house is in use from week 21, not week 19."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u01",
"claim": "Det nye tunnelhuset tas i bruk fra og med uke 21.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Tunnelhus | B: 120 | C: Tomat | D: 60 | E: 21 | F: 29 | G: 650 | H: Mira Holten | I: Nytt tunnelhus, i bruk fra uke 21"
}
],
"why": "The row's note says the new tunnel house is in use from week 21."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle ville heller hente på lørdag enn på fredag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "64 prosent ønsket henting på lørdag i stedet for fredag."
}
],
"why": "Only 64 percent wanted Saturday instead of Friday, not everyone."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no4a-u02",
"claim": "Et flertall ville heller hente på lørdag enn på fredag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "64 prosent ønsket henting på lørdag i stedet for fredag."
}
],
"why": "64 percent wanting Saturday instead of Friday is a majority."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Den som flytter etter 15. april, får alltid halve andelen refundert.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelen refunderes ikke etter 15. april. Unntaket er flytting mer enn 50 km fra gården før 1. juli; da refunderes 50 prosent."
}
],
"why": "Half is refunded only when the move is more than 50 km from the farm and before 1 July, not for every move."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u03",
"claim": "Den som etter 15. april flytter mer enn 50 km fra gården før 1. juli, får halve andelen refundert.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelen refunderes ikke etter 15. april. Unntaket er flytting mer enn 50 km fra gården før 1. juli; da refunderes 50 prosent."
}
],
"why": "The exception refunds 50 percent for a move of more than 50 km from the farm before 1 July."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Etter funnet av tørråte i skifte D ble potetriset slått ned 12. august, fordi veksten hadde stanset.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Tørråten ble oppdaget i skifte D onsdag 6. august. Fordi sykdommen sprer seg raskt i fuktig vær, ble potetriset slått ned 12. august. Det stoppet smitten, men det stoppet også veksten"
}
],
"why": "The stopped growth was a consequence of cutting the haulm; the cause was that the disease spreads fast in wet weather.",
"audit": "FIX: Kept one change from the reworded twin t04, which no longer places the haulm in skifte D directly."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u04",
"claim": "Etter funnet av tørråte i skifte D ble potetriset slått ned 12. august, fordi sykdommen sprer seg fort i fuktig vær.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Tørråten ble oppdaget i skifte D onsdag 6. august. Fordi sykdommen sprer seg raskt i fuktig vær, ble potetriset slått ned 12. august. Det stoppet smitten, men det stoppet også veksten"
}
],
"why": "The haulm was cut because the disease spreads fast in wet weather, and that also stopped the growth.",
"audit": "FIX: The draft's 'noe som også stanset veksten' can be read as the blight stopping the growth, and 'potetriset i skifte D' goes slightly beyond the excerpt; the new wording keeps only the stated cause."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Fordi snegler ødela mye salat året før, får salatbedene en snegleskjerm i form av en bar stripe på én meter rundt seg.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: B | B: 2200 | C: Salat | D: 700 | E: 16 | F: 23 | G: 1100 | H: Mira Holten | I: Snegleskjerm: 1 m bar stripe rundt bedene"
}
],
"why": "The row gives the slug barrier but no reason for it and nothing about slug damage the year before."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u05",
"claim": "Salatbedene får en snegleskjerm i form av en bar stripe på én meter rundt seg.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: B | B: 2200 | C: Salat | D: 700 | E: 16 | F: 23 | G: 1100 | H: Mira Holten | I: Snegleskjerm: 1 m bar stripe rundt bedene"
}
],
"why": "The salad row's note describes a slug barrier of a 1 m bare strip around the beds."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "En luke ble stående åpen etter kveldsvakta fordi en rev hadde tatt tre høner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "En rev tok tre høner fordi en luke sto åpen etter kveldsvakta."
}
],
"why": "Cause and effect are swapped: the fox took the hens because the hatch was open."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u06",
"claim": "Tre høner ble tatt av en rev fordi en luke ble stående åpen etter kveldsvakta.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "En rev tok tre høner fordi en luke sto åpen etter kveldsvakta."
}
],
"why": "The open hatch after the evening shift is given as the reason the fox took three hens."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Hele overskuddet på 16 320 kr gikk til reservefondet, som ved årsskiftet hadde 64 300 kr og skal finansiere et nytt vanningsanlegg.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Økonomisk gikk andelslaget med et overskudd på 16 320 kr, som i sin helhet er satt av til reservefondet. Fondet var ved årsskiftet på 64 300 kr."
}
],
"why": "Nothing says what the reserve fund is to be spent on."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u07",
"claim": "Hele overskuddet på 16 320 kr gikk til reservefondet, som ved årsskiftet hadde 64 300 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Økonomisk gikk andelslaget med et overskudd på 16 320 kr, som i sin helhet er satt av til reservefondet. Fondet var ved årsskiftet på 64 300 kr."
}
],
"why": "The whole surplus of 16 320 kr was set aside for the reserve fund, which stood at 64 300 kr at the turn of the year."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Hodekålen dekkes med fiberduk mot kålflue først fra og med uke 26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: C | B: 2300 | C: Hodekål | D: 800 | E: 20 | F: 30 | G: 1000 | H: Ingrid Solhaug-Berntsen | I: Fiberduk mot kålflue til uke 26"
}
],
"why": "The note says fibre cloth until week 26, not from week 26."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u08",
"claim": "Hodekålen dekkes med fiberduk mot kålflue fram til uke 26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: C | B: 2300 | C: Hodekål | D: 800 | E: 20 | F: 30 | G: 1000 | H: Ingrid Solhaug-Berntsen | I: Fiberduk mot kålflue til uke 26"
}
],
"why": "The cabbage row's note says fibre cloth against cabbage fly until week 26."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "En andel kan gis videre til noen andre for resten av sesongen uten at kassereren trenger skriftlig beskjed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelen kan overdras til en annen person for resten av sesongen, men bare etter skriftlig melding til kassereren."
}
],
"why": "A transfer is allowed only after written notice to the treasurer."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4a-u09",
"claim": "En andel kan gis videre til noen andre for resten av sesongen dersom kassereren får skriftlig beskjed.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelen kan overdras til en annen person for resten av sesongen, men bare etter skriftlig melding til kassereren."
}
],
"why": "A share may be transferred for the rest of the season, but only after written notice to the treasurer."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Det nye skiftet leid av Arne Dyrstad ga bare 1 900 kg poteter på grunn av tørråte, og i 2026 dyrkes poteter der.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Tørråte i skifte D ga bare 1 900 kg poteter, 700 kg under planen."
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: H | B: 3000 | C: Poteter | D: 2800 | E: 19 | F: 30 | G: 2900 | H: Ingrid Solhaug-Berntsen | I: Nytt skifte 2026, leid av Arne Dyrstad"
}
],
"why": "The 1 900 kg late-blight yield belongs to skifte D; the field leased from Arne Dyrstad is new in 2026.",
"audit": "FIX: Kept one change from the reworded twin t10: the skifte D yield is given to the new leased field."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4a-u10",
"claim": "Skifte D ga bare 1 900 kg poteter på grunn av tørråte, og i 2026 dyrkes poteter på et nytt skifte leid av Arne Dyrstad.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Tørråte i skifte D ga bare 1 900 kg poteter, 700 kg under planen."
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: H | B: 3000 | C: Poteter | D: 2800 | E: 19 | F: 30 | G: 2900 | H: Ingrid Solhaug-Berntsen | I: Nytt skifte 2026, leid av Arne Dyrstad"
}
],
"why": "The slide gives skifte D's blight-hit yield and the potato row says the potatoes are on a new 2026 field leased from Arne Dyrstad.",
"audit": "FIX: 'Etter at' claims an order in time the excerpts do not date, 'potetene' widens one potato row to all potatoes, and the first clause copied the slide almost verbatim."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Gartnerassistent Mira Holtens stilling er økt med 30 prosentpoeng fra 2025, og hun har ansvaret for drivhuset og tunnelhuset.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Gartnerassistent Mira Holten (60 prosent stilling, opp fra 40 prosent i 2025) har ansvar for drivhuset og tunnelhuset."
}
],
"why": "The position went from 40 to 60 percent, an increase of 20 points, not 30."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no4a-u11",
"claim": "Gartnerassistent Mira Holtens stilling er økt med 20 prosentpoeng fra 2025, og hun har ansvaret for drivhuset og tunnelhuset.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Gartnerassistent Mira Holten (60 prosent stilling, opp fra 40 prosent i 2025) har ansvar for drivhuset og tunnelhuset."
}
],
"why": "From 40 percent in 2025 to 60 percent is an increase of 20 percentage points."
},
{
"id": "no4a-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Lørdagshentingen, som i 2026 avløser fredagshentingen, foregår kl. 15.00–19.00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hentingen foregikk to dager i uka: tirsdag kl. 16.00–20.00 og fredag kl. 15.00–19.00."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Hentetidene er tirsdag kl. 16.00–20.00 og lørdag kl. 09.00–13.00. Nytt i 2026: lørdag erstatter fredag som hentedag."
}
],
"why": "15.00–19.00 was the Friday pickup time; Saturday pickup is 09.00–13.00."
},
{
"id": "no4a-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4a-u12",
"claim": "Lørdagshentingen, som i 2026 avløser fredagshentingen kl. 15.00–19.00, foregår kl. 09.00–13.00.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hentingen foregikk to dager i uka: tirsdag kl. 16.00–20.00 og fredag kl. 15.00–19.00."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Hentetidene er tirsdag kl. 16.00–20.00 og lørdag kl. 09.00–13.00. Nytt i 2026: lørdag erstatter fredag som hentedag."
}
],
"why": "One excerpt gives Friday pickup as 15.00–19.00, the other says Saturday replaces Friday and is 09.00–13.00."
},
{
"id": "no4a-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"claim": "I drivhuset er det satt av 110 m² til tomat, med en forventet avling på 1 500 kg og første høst i uke 26.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Skifte | B: Areal skifte (m²) | C: Kultur | D: Areal kultur (m²) | E: Såing/utplanting (uke) | F: Første høst (uke) | G: Forventet avling (kg) | H: Ansvarlig | I: Merknad"
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Drivhus | B: 180 | C: Tomat | D: 110 | E: 15 | F: 26 | G: 1500 | H: Mira Holten"
}
],
"why": "The header names the columns, and the greenhouse tomato row gives 110 m², week 26 and 1500 kg."
},
{
"id": "no4a-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Avlingen endte 600 kg under det som var planlagt.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vi høstet 14 200 kg, som er 96 prosent av planen på 14 800 kg."
}
],
"why": "14 800 kg planned minus 14 200 kg harvested is 600 kg."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Natt til 9. oktober tok en rev 2 høner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 41 | B: 109 | C: 640 | D: 15 | E: 300 | F: 19 | G: Rev tok 3 høner natt til 9. oktober"
}
],
"why": "The row says the fox took 3 hens, not 2."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u01",
"claim": "Natt til 9. oktober tok en rev tre høner.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 41 | B: 109 | C: 640 | D: 15 | E: 300 | F: 19 | G: Rev tok 3 høner natt til 9. oktober"
}
],
"why": "The note in the row says a fox took 3 hens on the night to 9 October."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "I uke 36 ble 121 av 131 andeler hentet, som var sesongens laveste oppmøte.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Uke | B: Andeler hentet (av 131) | C: Høstet friland (kg) | D: Høstet drivhus (kg) | E: Egg til eggandeler (stk) | F: Nedbør (mm) | G: Merknad"
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 36 | B: 121 | C: 860 | D: 220 | E: 300 | F: 20 | G: Høyeste oppmøte i sesongen"
}
],
"why": "The note for week 36 says it was the highest attendance of the season, not the lowest."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4b-u02",
"claim": "I uke 36 ble 121 av 131 andeler hentet, som var sesongens høyeste oppmøte.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Uke | B: Andeler hentet (av 131) | C: Høstet friland (kg) | D: Høstet drivhus (kg) | E: Egg til eggandeler (stk) | F: Nedbør (mm) | G: Merknad"
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 36 | B: 121 | C: 860 | D: 220 | E: 300 | F: 20 | G: Høyeste oppmøte i sesongen"
}
],
"why": "The header gives column A as week and B as shares collected out of 131, and the week 36 row has 121 and the note on highest attendance."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "En rev tok tre høner natt til 9. oktober, og årsaken var at hønsegården manglet strømgjerde.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Natt til 9. oktober tok en rev tre høner fordi en luke i hønsegården ikke var lukket etter kveldsvakta. Etter hendelsen er det satt opp et strømgjerde på 1,2 meter rundt hønsegården, og sjekklista for kveldsvakta har fått et eget punkt om lukene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt gives an unclosed hatch as the cause; the electric fence was put up afterwards as a response."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u03",
"claim": "En rev tok tre høner natt til 9. oktober, og årsaken var en luke i hønsegården som sto åpen etter kveldsvakta.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Natt til 9. oktober tok en rev tre høner fordi en luke i hønsegården ikke var lukket etter kveldsvakta. Etter hendelsen er det satt opp et strømgjerde på 1,2 meter rundt hønsegården, og sjekklista for kveldsvakta har fått et eget punkt om lukene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the fox took three hens because a hatch was not closed after the evening shift."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Av eggene hønene la i 2025, gikk 780 til annet enn eggandelene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hønene ga til sammen 6 380 egg i 2025. Av disse gikk 5 700 egg til de 30 eggandelene, som fikk 10 egg per uke i 19 uker."
}
],
"why": "6 380 minus 5 700 is 680, not 780."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "inference",
"twin_of": "no4b-u04",
"claim": "Av eggene hønene la i 2025, gikk 680 til annet enn eggandelene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Hønene ga til sammen 6 380 egg i 2025. Av disse gikk 5 700 egg til de 30 eggandelene, som fikk 10 egg per uke i 19 uker."
}
],
"why": "6 380 eggs in total minus 5 700 to the egg shares leaves 680."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Grønnsakene fra alle dyrkingsområdene plukkes ikke av medlemmene selv, men står ferdig i kasser ved hentebordet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Medlemmer høster ikke selv i drivhuset eller tunnelhuset. Derfra settes grønnsakene fram ferdig plukket i kasser ved hentebordet."
}
],
"why": "The rule covers only the greenhouse and the tunnel house, not all vegetables.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten so it is one change (the scope) from its twin; the current wording differs from the twin in sentence shape as well."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u05",
"claim": "Grønnsakene fra drivhuset og tunnelhuset plukkes ikke av medlemmene selv, men står ferdig i kasser ved hentebordet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Medlemmer høster ikke selv i drivhuset eller tunnelhuset. Derfra settes grønnsakene fram ferdig plukket i kasser ved hentebordet."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says members do not harvest in the greenhouse or tunnel house and those vegetables are set out picked in crates."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Redskapsboden låner ut kniver, sakser og kurver mot et depositum, og de må vaskes og leveres tilbake før man drar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Kniver, sakser og kurver lånes i redskapsboden og skal leveres vasket før du går."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says nothing about a deposit."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u06",
"claim": "Redskapsboden låner ut kniver, sakser og kurver, som må vaskes og leveres tilbake før man drar.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Kniver, sakser og kurver lånes i redskapsboden og skal leveres vasket før du går."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says knives, scissors and baskets are borrowed in the tool shed and returned washed before leaving."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Ved ferie kan andelen settes på pause, men den refunderes ikke.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Det gis ikke pause eller refusjon for ferie. I ferien kan du i stedet la en andelsvenn hente."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says no pause is given for holidays."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u07",
"claim": "Ved ferie kan andelen verken settes på pause eller refunderes.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Det gis ikke pause eller refusjon for ferie. I ferien kan du i stedet la en andelsvenn hente."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says neither a pause nor a refund is given for holidays."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Morgenvakta i hønsegården tas av medlemmene alle dager i uka.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Medlemmene tar også morgenvakta i hønsegården i helgene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt limits the members' morning shift to weekends.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change from the reworded twin t08."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u08",
"claim": "Morgenvakta i hønsegården tas av medlemmene i helgene.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Medlemmene tar også morgenvakta i hønsegården i helgene."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says members also take the morning shift in the hen yard at weekends.",
"audit": "FIX: The cleft 'er det medlemmene som' implies only members take the shift, while the excerpt's 'også' gives no such exclusivity."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Deltakelse på vårdugnaden lørdag 9. mai gir 3 timer, og dugnaden avsluttes med felles middag.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vårdugnaden er lørdag 9. mai og teller 3 timer."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt does not mention any shared dinner."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u09",
"claim": "Deltakelse på vårdugnaden lørdag 9. mai gir 3 timer.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vårdugnaden er lørdag 9. mai og teller 3 timer."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the spring work day is Saturday 9 May and counts 3 hours."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "At ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri i 2025, var en følge av at vaktene i juli sto tomme.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri i 2025, og det ga tomme vakter i juli."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says the buy-outs caused the empty shifts, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Reworded to stay one change (cause and effect swapped) from the reworded twin t10."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4b-u10",
"claim": "At vaktene i juli sto tomme, var en følge av at ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri i 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri i 2025, og det ga tomme vakter i juli."
}
],
"why": "The excerpt says nine full shares buying out fully led to empty shifts in July.",
"audit": "FIX: Near-verbatim copy of the excerpt (same words in the same order, only 'og det ga' swapped for 'førte til')."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Tørråten ble oppdaget i skifte B 6. august, samme skifte der brunsneglen angrep salaten fra midten av august.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Salaten i skifte B ble angrepet av brunsnegl fra midten av august."
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 32 | B: 114 | C: 760 | D: 210 | E: 300 | F: 31 | G: Tørråte oppdaget i skifte D onsdag 6. august"
}
],
"why": "Late blight was found in plot D; plot B is where the slugs attacked the lettuce."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4b-u11",
"claim": "Tørråten ble oppdaget i skifte D 6. august, mens brunsneglen angrep salaten i skifte B fra midten av august.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Salaten i skifte B ble angrepet av brunsnegl fra midten av august."
},
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: 32 | B: 114 | C: 760 | D: 210 | E: 300 | F: 31 | G: Tørråte oppdaget i skifte D onsdag 6. august"
}
],
"why": "One excerpt places late blight in plot D on 6 August, the other the slug attack on lettuce in plot B from mid-August."
},
{
"id": "no4b-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "En andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra inntil tre timer og få pakket andel inntil 4 ganger i sesongen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hver andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra høyst 4 timer."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Du kan få pakket andel høyst tre ganger per sesong."
}
],
"why": "The limits are swapped: the buy-out cap is 4 hours and packed shares are capped at three times per season."
},
{
"id": "no4b-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4b-u12",
"claim": "En andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra inntil 4 timer og få pakket andel inntil tre ganger i sesongen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Hver andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra høyst 4 timer."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Du kan få pakket andel høyst tre ganger per sesong."
}
],
"why": "One excerpt caps buy-out at 4 hours, the other caps packed shares at three times per season."
},
{
"id": "no4b-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Når to kuber deles til våren, får andelslaget to bikuber flere i 2026 enn de fire som var sterke ved siste kontroll.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Alle fire kubene var sterke ved siste kontroll 3. desember. Til våren deles to av kubene, slik at andelslaget får seks bikuber i 2026."
}
],
"why": "Six hives in 2026 against four at the last check is two more."
},
{
"id": "no4b-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Prisen på en helandel har økt med 300 kr fra i fjor.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Helandel koster 4 400 kr, mot 4 100 kr i fjor."
}
],
"why": "4 400 kr minus last year's 4 100 kr is a rise of 300 kr."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u01",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "I 2026 regnes det med 114 helandeler som hver koster 4 400 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Helandeler | B: Inntekt | C: 401800 | D: 492800 | E: 98 × 4 100 kr i 2025, 112 × 4 400 kr i 2026"
}
],
"why": "The row gives 112 full shares in 2026, not 114."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t01",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u01",
"claim": "I 2026 regnes det med 112 helandeler som hver koster 4 400 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Helandeler | B: Inntekt | C: 401800 | D: 492800 | E: 98 × 4 100 kr i 2025, 112 × 4 400 kr i 2026"
}
],
"why": "The note says 112 × 4 400 kr i 2026."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u02",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Barn under 16 år har ikke adgang til gården.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Barn under 16 år skal ikke inn i bigården."
}
],
"why": "The ban covers only the bee yard, not the whole farm."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t02",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u02",
"claim": "Barn under 16 år har ikke adgang til bigården.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Barn under 16 år skal ikke inn i bigården."
}
],
"why": "The slide bars children under 16 from the bee yard."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u03",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "wrong-number",
"claim": "Medlemmene utførte 1 046 av de 1 178 pliktige timene i 2025, altså 92 prosent.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Arbeidsplikten i 2025 var 10 timer for en helandel og 6 timer for en halvandel. Til sammen skulle medlemmene dermed gjøre 1 178 timer. Det ble utført 1 046 timer, eller 89 prosent."
}
],
"why": "The share of hours done was 89 percent, not 92."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t03",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u03",
"claim": "Medlemmene utførte 1 046 av de 1 178 pliktige timene i 2025, altså 89 prosent.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Arbeidsplikten i 2025 var 10 timer for en helandel og 6 timer for en halvandel. Til sammen skulle medlemmene dermed gjøre 1 178 timer. Det ble utført 1 046 timer, eller 89 prosent."
}
],
"why": "1 046 of 1 178 required hours were done, stated as 89 percent."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u04",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "overgeneralisation",
"claim": "Alle fellesarrangementene i andelslaget teller på arbeidsplikten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelslaget har to dugnader, én høstfest og ett medlemsmøte i året. Dugnadene teller på arbeidsplikten, men høstfesten og medlemsmøtet gjør det ikke."
}
],
"why": "Only the work days count; the harvest party and the members' meeting do not."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t04",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u04",
"claim": "Av fellesarrangementene i andelslaget er det bare dugnadene som teller på arbeidsplikten.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Andelslaget har to dugnader, én høstfest og ett medlemsmøte i året. Dugnadene teller på arbeidsplikten, men høstfesten og medlemsmøtet gjør det ikke."
}
],
"why": "The text says the work days count and the party and meeting do not."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u05",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "Fra 2026 må hver andel kjøpe seg fri fra minst 4 arbeidstimer, mens det i 2025 ble kjøpt fri 132 timer à 250 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Frikjøp av arbeidstimer | B: Inntekt | C: 33000 | D: 18000 | E: 132 timer à 250 kr i 2025; maks 4 timer per andel fra 2026"
}
],
"why": "The row sets a maximum of 4 hours per share, not a minimum."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t05",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u05",
"claim": "Fra 2026 kan hver andel kjøpe seg fri fra høyst 4 arbeidstimer, mens det i 2025 ble kjøpt fri 132 timer à 250 kr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Frikjøp av arbeidstimer | B: Inntekt | C: 33000 | D: 18000 | E: 132 timer à 250 kr i 2025; maks 4 timer per andel fra 2026"
}
],
"why": "The note says 132 hours at 250 kr in 2025 and at most 4 hours per share from 2026."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u06",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Arne Dyrstad får 6 000 kr i året for de 0,3 hektarene som leies av ham, på en femårig avtale.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vi leier 0,3 hektar av Arne Dyrstad for 6 000 kr per år."
}
],
"why": "Nothing is said about the length of the lease."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t06",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u06",
"claim": "Arne Dyrstad får 6 000 kr i året for de 0,3 hektarene som leies av ham.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vi leier 0,3 hektar av Arne Dyrstad for 6 000 kr per år."
}
],
"why": "The slide gives 0,3 hectares leased from Arne Dyrstad for 6 000 kr per year."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u07",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "Ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri fra timene sine og 14 andeler delvis, fordi åkervaktene i juli hadde for få folk.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Frikjøpet var ujevnt fordelt. Ni helandeler kjøpte seg fri fra alle sine timer, og 14 andeler kjøpte seg fri fra en del av timene. Som følge av dette var det for få folk på åkervaktene i juli, da ugraset vokser raskest."
}
],
"why": "The buy-outs caused the shortage on the field shifts, not the other way round.",
"audit": "FIX: Rewritten with the exact counts so it stays one swap away from its reworded twin."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t07",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u07",
"claim": "Åkervaktene i juli hadde for få folk fordi ni helandeler kjøpte seg helt fri fra timene sine og 14 andeler delvis.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Frikjøpet var ujevnt fordelt. Ni helandeler kjøpte seg fri fra alle sine timer, og 14 andeler kjøpte seg fri fra en del av timene. Som følge av dette var det for få folk på åkervaktene i juli, da ugraset vokser raskest."
}
],
"why": "The shortage in July is stated as a consequence of the buy-outs.",
"audit": "FIX: The adjective 'mange' is not given by the excerpt (it gives 9 full and 14 partial buy-outs), so use the counts."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u08",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "swapped-cause",
"claim": "To medlemmer ble stukket i 2025 som følge av at reglene for bigården ble skjerpet og bedre skiltet.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Bigården ligger bak skifte F og er merket med gule skilt. Fordi to medlemmer ble stukket i 2025, er reglene for bigården skjerpet og bedre skiltet."
}
],
"why": "The stings caused the stricter rules, not the reverse.",
"audit": "FIX: 'av bier' and the missing 'bedre skiltet' made it more than one change from its twin; now only the cause is swapped."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t08",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u08",
"claim": "Reglene for bigården ble skjerpet og bedre skiltet som følge av at to medlemmer ble stukket i 2025.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Bigården ligger bak skifte F og er merket med gule skilt. Fordi to medlemmer ble stukket i 2025, er reglene for bigården skjerpet og bedre skiltet."
}
],
"why": "The rules were tightened because two members were stung in 2025."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u09",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "En helandel kan betales i to rater, 15. april og 1. mai, og eggandel må man melde seg på innen 15. juli.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Helandel | B: 4100 | C: 4400 | D: 98 | E: 112 | F: 10 | G: 12 | H: Kan betales i to rater: 15. april og 15. juli"
},
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Påmeldingsfristen for eggandel er 1. mai."
}
],
"why": "1. mai is the egg-share sign-up deadline and 15. juli the second full-share instalment; the claim swaps them."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t09",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4c-u09",
"claim": "En helandel kan betales i to rater, 15. april og 15. juli, og eggandel må man melde seg på innen 1. mai.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Helandel | B: 4100 | C: 4400 | D: 98 | E: 112 | F: 10 | G: 12 | H: Kan betales i to rater: 15. april og 15. juli"
},
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Påmeldingsfristen for eggandel er 1. mai."
}
],
"why": "The spreadsheet gives the full-share instalments and the slide the egg-share deadline."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u10",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "reversed-polarity",
"claim": "I 2026 blir skifte G ikke lenger liggende med kløver som grønngjødsling.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Skifte G ligger i grønngjødsling med kløver også i 2026."
}
],
"why": "The slide says field G stays in clover green manure in 2026 too."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t10",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u10",
"claim": "Også i 2026 blir skifte G liggende med kløver som grønngjødsling.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Skifte G ligger i grønngjødsling med kløver også i 2026."
}
],
"why": "The slide says field G lies in clover green manure also in 2026."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u11",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "conflated-sources",
"claim": "Å kjøpe seg fri koster 600 kr timen, mens timer som mangler ut over 4 per 31. oktober, faktureres med 300 kr timen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Frikjøp koster 300 kr per time (fra 250 kr), og hver andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra høyst 4 timer."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Mangler du mer enn 4 timer per 31. oktober, faktureres de timene som går ut over 4, med 600 kr per time, og du mister fortrinnsretten til å fornye andelen."
}
],
"why": "300 kr is the buy-out price and 600 kr the charge for missing hours; the claim swaps them."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t11",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "synthesis",
"twin_of": "no4c-u11",
"claim": "Å kjøpe seg fri koster 300 kr timen, mens timer som mangler ut over 4 per 31. oktober, faktureres med 600 kr timen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "sesongevaluering-2025.pdf.md",
"text": "Frikjøp koster 300 kr per time (fra 250 kr), og hver andel kan kjøpe seg fri fra høyst 4 timer."
},
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Mangler du mer enn 4 timer per 31. oktober, faktureres de timene som går ut over 4, med 600 kr per time, og du mister fortrinnsretten til å fornye andelen."
}
],
"why": "The evaluation gives 300 kr per bought-out hour and the handbook 600 kr per missing hour over 4."
},
{
"id": "no4c-u12",
"label": "unsupported",
"kind": "not-mentioned",
"claim": "Etter en storm i februar 2025 fikk drivhuset ny plastduk, som ble dekket av forsikringen.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Vedlikehold drivhus | B: Utgift | C: 16900 | D: 9000 | E: Ny plastduk etter storm i februar 2025"
}
],
"why": "The row says nothing about insurance covering the cost."
},
{
"id": "no4c-t12",
"label": "filler-supported",
"kind": "paraphrase",
"twin_of": "no4c-u12",
"claim": "Etter en storm i februar 2025 fikk drivhuset ny plastduk.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "dyrkingsplan-hostelogg-okonomi.xlsx.md",
"text": "A: Vedlikehold drivhus | B: Utgift | C: 16900 | D: 9000 | E: Ny plastduk etter storm i februar 2025"
}
],
"why": "The note on the greenhouse maintenance row says new plastic sheeting after a storm in February 2025."
},
{
"id": "no4c-s01",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "På medlemsmøtet veier stemmen til en halvandel like mye som stemmen til en helandel.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemshaandbok-2026.docx.md",
"text": "Hver andel har én stemme på medlemsmøtet, uansett om det er en hel- eller halvandel."
}
],
"why": "Every share has one vote regardless of type, so half and full shares weigh equally."
},
{
"id": "no4c-s02",
"label": "supported",
"kind": "inference",
"claim": "Før innkjøpet av unghøner i april består flokken av 25 dyr.",
"excerpts": [
{
"file": "medlemsmote-mars-2026.pptx.md",
"text": "Vi kjøper inn 9 unghøner i april, slik at flokken blir på 34."
}
],
"why": "Buying 9 hens brings the flock to 34, so it was 34 - 9 = 25 before.",
"audit": "FIX: The excerpt does not say the whole flock is hens (it could include a rooster), so 'høner' goes beyond it."
}
]
}