open/portfolio-optimiser-claude
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Releases 1 Activity

docs(scope): the independence claim gets a date instead of a future it cannot keep

Browse source 
Operator decision 2026-08-09: the two implementations are developed in the open
against each other. Reading the sibling is permitted and exchange may go both ways;
code is copied only where it genuinely serves the solution, never as a shortcut. The
constraint that remains is what the Microsoft Agent Framework and the Claude Agent
SDK each actually offer — which is the difference the comparison exists to measure.

The old rule lived in three places and two of them would have started lying:

- CLAUDE.md carried the prohibition, and it is read at every session start — left
  alone it would have made the next session refuse exactly what was authorised.
- README stated in the present tense that this repo is "built from the shared spec
  alone" and "deliberately does not reverse-engineer the MAF sibling". True for
  every line written so far, and untrue for anything written from today.

So the README claim is DATED rather than deleted. Through 2026-08-09 the
independence is real and stays claimed; from 2026-08-09 the open-competition rule
applies and is stated plainly, with the consequence spelled out: anything comparing
the two implementations as INDEPENDENT evidence must be scoped to work on or before
that date. The honesty rule (method spec §1) does not let a claim outrun what was
actually done, and that applies to the README's claim about itself.

CHANGELOG is deliberately UNTOUCHED. It describes what was true at that release, and
it was true — 73 commits through 3e91072 were built from the spec alone. A changelog
records history; it is not rewritten because a forward rule changed.

What did NOT change, and is restated in the README so the dating cannot be misread as
a loosening of the method: the spec is still normative and the golden suite is still
the validator's only oracle.

787 tests green, ruff clean.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JYWMfPKmJtv7JvYnpomkdV
This commit is contained in:
Kjell Tore Guttormsen 2026-08-09 12:56:30 +02:00
commit 3bdf7f0669
2 changed files with 30 additions and 9 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

10
CLAUDE.md
View file

@ -3,8 +3,14 @@
## Kontekst
Søsken-implementasjon (beslutning D7) av portfolio-optimiser-metoden på **Claude Agent SDK**:
generisk, åpent Python-rammeverk som finner kostnadsbesparelser INNI hvert prosjekt i en
portefølje. Bygges **fra metode-spec-en alene** (`shared/method-spec.md`) — aldri ved
reverse-engineering av MAF-søskenet (`~/repos/portfolio-optimiser`). Program-planer
portefølje. Bygges på **metode-spec-en** (`shared/method-spec.md`) som normativ kilde.
**Åpen konkurranse med MAF-søskenet** (`~/repos/portfolio-optimiser`, operatørbeslutning
2026-08-09): alle tilgjengelige midler er lov for å nå den beste løsningen, inkludert å lese
søskenets kode, og utvekslingen kan gå begge veier. **Grensen er hensikten, ikke kilden:**
kopiér kun der det faktisk gir mening for løsningen — **aldri som snarvei**. De reelle
begrensningene er hva MAF og Claude Agent SDK hver for seg tilbyr, og det er nettopp den
forskjellen sammenligningen skal måle. Fram til 2026-08-09 ble repoet bygget fra speccen
alene; det er datert i README og skal ikke påstås om arbeid etter den datoen. Program-planer
(sesjonsplan S5–S12, sammenligningsprotokoll, frossent målbilde) bor i hovedrepoets
`docs/plan/`. Løpende state: `STATE.md` (local-only).