S7a-3 pkt. 1. Til i dag NEKTET reconcile_bundle_id en base som erklaerte en id
katalogen ikke bar. Maalt mot K2 - den foerste leverte basen som erklaerer sin
egen id (618 av 630 konseptfiler + rot-index, alle "k2-trinn1-20260903", levert
som "K2-bundle-20260903") - betydde det at basen ikke kunne aapnes slik den var
levert, og at eneste botemiddel var aa montere den paa nytt for haand, en gang
per leveranse. PM-beslutning: konsumenten slakker.
- Erklaert vinner (B1s rekkefoelge uroert), avviket REGISTRERES:
ResolvedBundleId.mount + ProvenanceStamp.bundle_id_source +
DryRunReport.bundle_id_source + run.bundle_id_notice (None ved enighet).
Stempel-feltet er PAAKREVD uten default: None er en VERDI (veg-stien).
- Det som fortsatt nekter er den EKTE kollisjonen: to KONSEPTER i en base som
erklaerer ULIKE id-er (okf.assert_declared_ids_agree, kalt ved hver doer som
aapner en base). Rot-index er IKKE med i enighets-settet - konsept-slaar-index
er en presedens-regel, saa en index i utakt er fallbacken som taper.
- KONSEKVENS, ikke scope-krype: explore._bundle_index loeser naa den erklaerte
id-en. Den brukte Path(raw).name mens dispatcheren brukte reconcile...id; med
erklaert-vinner ville explore() myntet approaches som navngir MOUNTET mens
dispatcheren ruter paa ERKLAERINGEN - en utforskning med uruterbart mandat.
Load-bearing MAALT: 10 mutasjoner alle roede mot HELE suiten, groenn kontroll
1243 passed / 5 skipped og golden demo-transcript.stdout byte-uendret
(shasum -a 1 = ea8c534773acdbe41ae68f2c55724d69aaf8be4f).
M1 1 / M2 1 / M3 1 / M4 9 / M5 2 / M6 1 / M7 1 / M8 2 / M9 2 / M11 1.
Tre armer i test_bundle_id_reconciliation_loadbearing er SKREVET OM (ikke
slettet) - de pinnet nekten beslutningen fjernet. (j) ble skarpere enn den den
erstattet: erklaert id ruter, mountet nektes.
Kontrakt: docs/okf-konsum-kontrakter.md § 3.1. Invariantrad i CLAUDE.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MAJOR-4 (misjonsreview v2 section 7), owner B = the consumer. Neither existing
projection into ir.CostBaseline can serve an ingested tender corpus:
cost-baseline.json is hand-written per project and baseline_from_project belongs
to the road domain, so a K2-shaped bundle could be navigated and never anchored.
okf.derive_cost_baseline reads the numbers already in the bundle.
The premise was MEASURED before anything was built on it, and the order's two
pointers named two different forms. examples/*/expected-bundle/ carry pipe
tables, but every one of them is csv- or sql-sourced via render.render_table --
the xlsx path never reaches render_table at all. Measured with pandoc 3.10.2
under the producer's own writer and arguments: extract._extract_office converts,
and inbox.py hands that text to render_inbox_concept untouched, so an
xlsx-sourced concept file carries a pandoc SIMPLE table whose dash rule defines
the column spans. A pipe-only reader would have been inert on exactly the corpus
this exists for. Both forms are read, by two scanners over one role mapping and
one number grammar.
No judgement anywhere: the header vocabulary and the number grammar are closed,
and every ambiguity refuses -- no candidate table, more than one, two columns
claiming one role, two rows sharing a cost code, a row that prices nothing. A
partly-priced schedule refuses in full, because a half-derived baseline anchors
some codes while cost_baseline_anchored reports True.
Wired behind --derive-cost-baseline and never silently: one resolution in
run.py's bundle arm serves both the full run and the dry run, and the refusal
propagates rather than degrading to the file loader.
The two fixtures are pandoc's output verbatim, not hand-typed. The unpriced one
is K2's actual pre-award shape, and the columns survive as blanks -- so the
table IS a candidate and the refusal is the sharp one.
Load-bearing MEASURED: 18 mutations all red against the WHOLE suite, green
control 1230 passed / 5 skipped (from 1208/5, superset, 0 removed), golden
demo-transcript.stdout byte-unchanged (ea8c534773acdbe41ae68f2c55724d69aaf8be4f).
M17 is the one that matters for arm (b): dropping the positivity guard makes the
mutant raise pydantic ValidationError, which IS a ValueError but is NOT the named
class -- so pytest.raises(ValueError) would have stayed green against exactly the
mutation the arm exists to catch. Verified directly, not argued.
Honesty limits stated in the invariant row: NS 3451 section rows are not
classified (K2 itself was not available to measure), the stamp records that a run
was anchored and never which projection anchored it, the hosted surface is
deliberately untouched, and no live K2 file was read.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
[skip-docs]
PM addendum 5 to order 20260902T151931Z-250257273, reported at the close of B4
and deliberately left unfixed there as outside that order.
evidence_for(path, key="sources") raised ValueError. The tier was derived
unconditionally through trust_tier, which refuses an entry that names no `by`
actor -- correctly, because a trust level derived from an entry identifying
nobody mints the provenance it claims to read. But `by` is required of a
VERIFICATION entry (SPEC 5.2), not of every provenance key: the agreed
segmented form carries segment_id/source_offset and a sources list carries
id/resource. The guard belonging to one key was being applied to all of them.
trust_tier is UNCHANGED. evidence_for stops applying it to keys it was never
about: _TIERED_KEY names the one key SPEC 5.3 tiers, and every other key comes
back with state / reason / items_seen / entries and tier=None.
admits_falsification moved WITH it, and that is the same fact rather than
scope: it read `tier != "unverified"`, and None != "unverified" is TRUE, so a
present `sources` list would have cleared a threshold about verification. It
now names the tiers that clear it. For every value reachable before this change
both spellings are identical, which is why the existing K5 arms stay green.
Measured, and it corrected the test: an actorless `verified` value never
reaches trust_tier through evidence_for at all -- the decoder refuses that shape
first as unreadable / unsupported-flow. Both guards are now asserted where each
actually lives instead of one asserted where it is not.
Load-bearing measured, four mutations, all red against the WHOLE suite: derive
the tier unconditionally (3 red) - revert the K5 threshold (1, the consequence
arm alone) - "fix" it by never tiering at all (3, including two pre-existing
falsification arms) - loosen trust_tier instead (2, including its own
pre-existing gate). Green control 1208 passed / 5 skipped; golden
demo-transcript.stdout unchanged (ea8c534773acdbe41ae68f2c55724d69aaf8be4f).
[skip-docs] — the invariant row for this plan lands in Step 13, where the mutations
that force it have been measured. Documenting a seam before its measurement is
the claim-without-evidence class this repo writes rows against.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <claude-opus-5>
_carries_complete_ingest_stamp sammenlignet generated kun mot literalen "true" og
feilet AAPENT: en pinnet ingest-writer som skrev "yes"/"on" ville sluppet det
komplette eierskaps-stempelet forbi write_concept_file uten en eneste lokal diff.
_YAML_TRUE_LITERALS ({"true","yes","on"}, case-insensitivt) er naa ENESTE vokabular,
malt mot PyYAML sin safe_load-resolver; "1"/bare "y"/"n" er bevisst utelatt siden en
YAML-leser aldri leser dem som bool. Halv-stempel forblir lovlig.
RED-foerst (tests/test_ingest_stamp_fail_closed_loadbearing.py), fire mutasjoner
alle roede mot hele suiten (904 passed/5 skipped): revert til literalen "true"
(2 roede) - over-widen til aa inkludere 1/y (1 roed) - and->or paa halv-stempel
(4 roede) - detach gaten helt (4 roede).
Ordre: 20260821T152153Z-432035430-from-portfolio-optimiser
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01UhxZ7XNjAFHFenWX5j9pev
okf._walk toleret en ulesbar/utenfor-basen lenke uten aa etterlate spor (okf.py:182
"continue # broken link"), og navigate_bundle returnerte kun filene den FANT. En base
der halve innholdet aldri ble lest var derfor umulig aa skille fra en base der de
dokumentene aldri ble skrevet - og toerrkjoeringen sa ingenting.
Toleransen er UROERT: OKF SPEC §4 krever at navigasjonen ikke kaster, og den kaster
fortsatt ikke. Dette er synlighet, ikke en ny nekt.
To tenner (samme form som ordre 20260821T092039Z, synlig uforankring):
1. okf.SkippedLink + Bundle.skipped - strukturert spor, aldri en streng: hvilken fil
lenken sto i, lenketeksten ORDRETT (operatoeren redigerer den teksten, ikke den
resolverte stien), og hvilken av de TO grunnene som gjaldt - outside-bundle (escape,
ofte bevisst) eller missing (inne i basen, ingen lesbar fil, nesten alltid en
skrivefeil). Dedup-grenen (canonical in seen) registreres ALDRI: den er korrekt
navigasjon og det som terminerer sykler.
2. run.skipped_links_notice - EN renderer, tar den alt opploeste tuppelen, returnerer
None naar ingenting ble hoppet over. Printes paa BEGGE flater: --live-dry-run og
den fulle enkeltkjoeringen (en kjoering som PRODUSERTE et forslag fra en halvlest
base er der tausheten kostet mest).
Defaulten er MOTSATT forrige ordres, og forskjellen er innsikten: cost_baseline_anchored
er paakrevd fordi begge defaults lyver, mens en TOM tuppel her er et aerlig positivt
utsagn ("hver lenke ble fulgt") - external_calls-presedensen. Vei-stien navigerer ingen
base, saa tom er bokstavelig sant der ogsaa.
Sporet bor paa RunResult.skipped_links (RUN-nivaa: navigasjonen skjer EN gang per
kjoering, foer noe forslag finnes), aldri paa ProvenanceStamp, som beskriver gaten som
doemte EN kandidat. Ingenting av dette naar bundle_context - derfor er de commons-eide
nav-goldenene byte-uendret, og Bundle( har fortsatt EN konstruksjons-sted (maalt).
Load-bearing MAALT (tests/test_navigation_visibility_loadbearing.py), aatte mutasjoner
alle roede mot HELE suiten + groenn kontroll 897 passed / 5 skipped:
detach missing-registreringen (6 roede) · detach outside-bundle (2) · kollaps de to
grunnene til en (2) · registrer dedup-grenen (1) · renderer returnerer alltid linja
(3, inkl. kontrollene - omisjonen er selv gatet) · detach dry-run-printen (1) ·
detach full-run-printen (1) · konstant tom trace ut av run_project (4).
Docs rettet der de paasto det motsatte: kunnskapsbase-for-en-kjoring.md §5.7 + §6,
presentasjon-bygge-kunnskapsbase.html (steg 8, steg 9, fallgruve 3, avslutningen),
README-ens navigasjonsavsnitt, og CLAUDE.md-ens navigasjons-kontrakt-invariant.
Two rules existed. verdicts._unquote took quotes off correctly; the
bundle_context title renderer stripped only `"`. Measured before the fix:
`title: " Spaced "` rendered as `## concept: Spaced ` (the whitespace
half kø-(a) named), and `title: 'Single'` rendered its quotes verbatim —
both ordinary YAML a hand-authoring curator writes, and both reach the
agent's read-context.
The (p) defect class: a duplicated conversion drifts, and the drifted copy
decides something. Same fix shape — ONE source, owned by the module that
owns parse_frontmatter. okf.unquote_scalar is now the rule; verdicts
delegates by identity, so the structural key that _mint_id hashes is
unchanged.
The commons-owned nav-goldens could never have caught this: every golden
title is double-quoted with no inner whitespace, so both rules render them
byte-identically. That is asserted as a control, and it goes RED if a
future golden gains a discriminating title.
Load-bearing MEASURED against the whole suite, three mutations:
- weaken the renderer back to .strip('"') -> ONLY the 2 new rows red,
643 others green (incl. nav-goldens) = it covers ground nothing did
- reintroduce a private _unquote copy in verdicts -> only the identity
test red, 644 green (the copy is behaviourally identical TODAY, which
is exactly why identity is the only thing that catches the class)
- (control, kø-(n)) add `import numpy` to a second src module -> the
existing test_semretrieval_is_the_sole_numpy_importer goes red alone,
confirming that gate is live rather than green-but-dead
638 -> 645 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DVMsih6tXx39VMyq6wJ5H7
Every stage of validate_proposal reasoned only about numbers the proposal itself
supplied, so an internally-consistent hallucination cleared the whole gate (F3).
A new stage 0 reconciles each affected_item against the project's CostBaseline
before the CBC solve: an unknown cost code is rejected, and a real code carrying
a quantity/unit_cost outside the configured tolerance (5% default, relative to
the baseline value) is rejected. Validation, never repair.
The baseline argument is OPTIONAL (None = pre-S4.0 behaviour), but both run
paths set it: the road path projects project.cost_items, the bundle path loads
cost-baseline.json when the bundle ships one. Bundles written before the
amendment stay un-anchored, so the commons-owned goldens run byte-identically;
a baseline that exists but is malformed still raises on both loaders.
F8: the method-specific cap now comes from the METHOD_CAPS registry (measure
type -> fraction, injectable) instead of an energy_efficiency string comparison.
The baseline format and tolerance semantics were decided locally — the commons
amendment (D-A pt. 2) never arrived, exactly as in S3.2. D7 mirroring stays open.
Three portfolio fixtures quoted cost codes belonging to OTHER projects; the new
gate caught them. They now quote each project's own lines, and the two copied
REPLIES tables import the single source instead of drifting from it.
Load-bearing measured (tests/test_s40_cost_baseline_loadbearing.py), six
mutations all red: detach the reconciliation stage; detach the magnitude
tolerance; detach the road wiring; detach the bundle wiring; ignore the injected
cap registry; make the optional loader tolerant of malformed content. Control:
with the road wiring detached the repaired portfolio fixtures still pass, so
they are not masking the seam. 597 -> 612 tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JdwK7bQ4BZkWH4t8MRDKb4
The commons pull (7aa53fc -> a2b57d2) rewrote method-spec §3 Step 1 and added two §11
seams. Measuring okf.py against the new normative text found six contradictions; this
closes all six, gated by the commons-owned nav-goldens that came with the pull.
method-spec §3 Step 1 (navigate_bundle / bundle_context):
- follow cross-links RECURSIVELY, depth-first in first-seen order (there was no
recursion at all — only the root index's links were read, so no hierarchy was
navigable even with the other fixes in place);
- resolve a leading `/` against the BUNDLE ROOT, anything else against the LINKING
file's directory, and drop the retired "a path separator means out-of-bundle"
heuristic, which conflated depth with escape and forbade valid nesting;
- de-duplicate on the RESOLVED path (`./a.md` == `a.md` == `/a.md`), which is also
what terminates cycles;
- exclude index files by BASENAME at every level, so a nested index is navigation and
never renders as content (flat rendering regardless of depth);
- bind index_summary to the ROOT index alone.
safe_resolve stays the sole in-/out-of-bundle test, fail-closed: a target that fails to
resolve for ANY reason is skipped, never raised.
ingest-spec §3 (write_concept_file): it is the repo's one authoring primitive that
materialises a concept file from caller-supplied frontmatter, so it now refuses the
COMPLETE ownership stamp (`generated: true` + `ingest_manifest`) with IngestStampError,
while permitting either field alone. A validation, never a repair — nothing is written.
Gates (tests/test_okf.py, 529 -> 537):
- nav-golden-hierarchy and nav-golden-escape compared against the shipped
expected-read-context.md fasit (trailing-whitespace normalisation only, which the
fixture README explicitly permits; internal blank-line structure stays gated);
- traversal order pinned separately from the rendered output, so a right-looking render
from a wrong walk still fails;
- unit seams for the recursion in isolation, resolved-path dedup, and the leading-`/`
rule's breach case (a real out-of-bundle file addressed by its absolute path).
Load-bearing MEASURED, not asserted: seven mutations each go red — detach the recursion,
restore the separator prefilter, dedup on the raw target, read `/` as filesystem-absolute,
render nested index bodies as content, drop the stamp guard, and the fully naive navigator
with no boundary check (which is what makes the `/`-trap test bite). okf.py restored from a
checksum-verified copy after each.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01WetWTHpdRbqinN5XHFTaTb
Close the last agentic-loop seam (målbilde §3/§6/§7/§11 step 6): an
APPROVED verdict is promoted from the raw output layer into the context
layer (the OKF bundle) as a navigable `type: verdict` concept file, so
human/persona-approved knowledge reaches the next run's hypothesis.
- okf.py (pure stdlib, MAF-free): render_frontmatter / write_concept_file
/ link_in_index — the D7-portable OKF write counterpart of navigate.
- verdicts.py: promote_verdict + PromotionRefused gate (fail-closed; only
approved decisions enter the wiki, never raw agent output), provenance
stamp (who/experiment/when; timestamp a required kwarg), neutral index
label (signal reaches a prompt only via the gated ExpeL fold, never
bundle_context), _safe_filename_token (id sanitised for path/link).
- R4 = optional+gated: a public opt-in primitive, NOT wired into
run_project (mirrors write_verdict — the system reads, the gate promotes).
- Load-bearing trio (test_step8_promotion_loadbearing.py): gate refuses a
non-approved verdict, approved verdict is navigable, promoted signal
stays out of the read-context — all proven RED-on-detach. Suite 144->148.
Design hardened by an adversarial plan-critic (12 findings; the BLOCKER —
index-link leak into bundle_context via index_summary — closed by the
neutral label + a no-leak test). Honesty limits documented: promoted file
is minimal (signal as prose only), and the learning-key id means
same-candidate approvals share a filename (last-write-wins).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MHR8iKxJRxDiDfNw8HZmWE
Closes the honest Fase 2a limitation: docs_dir==bundle_dir let keyword
chunk-stuffing leak the verdict's realization rate ("0.82") into the debate /
generation prompt regardless of the ExpeL fold (it surfaced from both
verdict-led-fro.md AND golden.json). The realization signal now reaches the
hypothesis prompt ONLY via the gated ExpeL fold.
- okf.py: bundle_context() + Bundle.context_files render the navigated bundle
(index + frontmatter + cross-links) as the agent read-context, EXCLUDING
type: verdict (maalbilde §2/§4). Pure stdlib, still MAF-free.
- datasource.py: bundle_citations() derives first-class citations from the
navigated non-verdict files.
- run_project: on the bundle path context + citations + debate tools come from
navigation (tools=[]; navigation replaces query-time RAG); the road path keeps
chunk-stuffing unchanged.
Load-bearing (maalbilde §7): the marker is upgraded from the minted verdict id
to the realization signal itself. The empty-store control now asserts "0.82"
reaches NO prompt — RED against the pre-2b chunk-stuffing path, green after
navigation (TDD red->green). New okf-level test_bundle_context_excludes_verdict_layer
guards the seam directly.
Suite 133->134 passed, 4 skipped; mypy + ruff check clean. Reverted unrelated
ruff-format drift (backends/budget/verdicts/test_contracts) to keep the diff
surgical.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MHR8iKxJRxDiDfNw8HZmWE
Closes maalbilde §5 gap #1 (the one missing "feedback-into-prompt" dataflow)
for the OKF-bundle path. Before, ExpeL was computed AFTER generation into a
discarded SessionContext, so a prior verdict could not influence any hypothesis
(context_providers=0).
- New okf.py: framework-neutral OKF bundle navigation (index + frontmatter +
cross-links), pure stdlib, no agent_framework/mcp (D7-portable), enforced by
test_okf_is_maf_free.
- verdicts.py: seed_store_from_bundle + bundle_candidate_features build the
ExpeL substrate + the pre-hypothesis query key from a bundle.
- run_project(bundle_dir=...): folds the candidate's prior verdicts into the
generation context BEFORE generate_via_llm; the road path is unchanged.
Load-bearing (maalbilde §7): test_step1_expel_loadbearing proves a prior verdict
reaches the hypothesis prompt and goes RED when the fold is detached (shown via
TDD red->green). The marker is the minted verdict id (content hash) because
docs_dir==bundle_dir lets keyword chunk-stuffing leak the realization rate;
clean layer separation is Fase 2b.
Suite 121->133 passed; mypy + ruff check clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MHR8iKxJRxDiDfNw8HZmWE
