The F15 report's shape repeated: result table, denominator discipline, one
command per claim. What the measurement changed against the order's own
framing:
- orchestrations CANNOT be lifted (1.1.1 is still the head on PyPI), so F15's
"the two floors are lifted together, there is no partial bump" is measurably
weaker after F16 -- and eight of the nineteen probe checks live in that
unmoved package, which is a property of the denominator, not a strength of
the probe.
- foundry/openai were NOT forced up; the coupling the order read belongs to the
LATEST releases, not the pinned 1.8.2. They were lifted for a measured reason
instead (two BREAKING bullets name core AND foundry in the same line).
- ONE of the order's transcriptions deviated from the source: #8219 lazy
loading is foundry/foundry-hosting/openai -- NOT core. Consequence, not
pedantry: had the floors stayed at 1.8.2, the change the order named as the
prime suspect for golden stderr would never have reached po at all.
- (a) touches NO U row. The wall-clock timeout is B4's own sketch word and G1;
and the primitive is `max_duration_seconds` degrading gracefully via
`budget_state["truncated"]` + a log line -- NOT a typed stop reason, so it
does not satisfy B4's "every breach -> a structured event, never a silent
stop". Recommendation: do not adopt it as B4's half. STATE's prohibition
stands, untouched.
- (b) does not move U13: `approval_mode` is 0 in src/ and 0 in tests/ (102 in
the venv). #7988 hardens the cooperative-marker path G4 already refused.
- (c) does not break: po's own parameters are typed `Sequence[Any] | None` and
all seven callsites pass lists, so sequence-only inputs are the only form po
can produce. 74 passed across the five middleware-bearing suites; no fix was
needed and none was made.
My own probe was WRONG FIRST and that is written down: five checks read
CHANGED/MISSING in BOTH versions because my queries sliced a Protocol stub,
counted `self`, and demanded two names be adjacent. Running it against BOTH
versions is what made the instrument failure visible.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Kjell Tore Guttormsen
9f14c642c8