Advisor review caught this before the v0.23.0 tag landed: the guard
compared the projected line count only against the fixed 60-line max,
never against the file's current size, so trimming an already-oversized
STATE.md (e.g. 156 -> 100 lines, still over 60 but smaller) was denied
exactly like growing it would be.
Verified against the real tree: 23 of the machine's STATE.md files are
already over 60 lines today, one at 1405. Shipped as a flat gate, this
hook would have made most of them un-editable except by a single write
landing at <=60 in one shot -- backwards for a guard meant to make
trimming possible.
Fixed with a ratchet: deny only when the projection is over the max AND
larger than the file's current line count (0 for a file that doesn't
exist yet), for both Write and Edit. A compliant file still cannot grow
past the limit and a new file still cannot be created oversized, but an
oversized file can now be edited toward compliance one write at a time.
state-line-guard-selftest.sh: 16 -> 21 checks (new section 8: shrink
allows, same-size allows, grow-while-oversized still denies, new-oversized
still denies). Suite total: 191 + 152 + 69 + 21 = 433.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0186kZGKddxfA9N84HqMLbb2
Kjell Tore Guttormsen
c1dabf109d