fix(review): close the gate's fail-open paths an independent review found
An adversarial read of d88245c reproduced 15 problems; all fixed here, each
with a test that fails on the old code.
- verdict-gate: a greener verdict must be backed by the LAST fence being a
`json` block of the right shape, with no BLOCKER in the JSON (any case),
in `## Findings (BLOCKER)`, or a differing finding-id list; two verdict
lines and more than one file argument are exit 2. ({}, null, lowercase
"blocker", a trailing ```jsonc and a later json fence all gave exit 0.)
- engine-findings: a transcribed "narrower" key can no longer lower an
engine tier; absolute paths under --repo-root match the scope; "12" lines
parse; an empty scope is an error; out-of-scope engine findings are
unverified (`engine:out-of-scope`) and forbid ALLOW.
- recurrence: the catch-all engine keys and keys normalised from unknown
ones are never proposed; the same unfixed finding in two iterations is not
a recurrence; proposals are validated before they are offered; \r/U+2028
and damaged markers are refused; writes go through a symlinked CLAUDE.md.
Prose points --repo at the session directory, not the git toplevel.
- Workflow substrate: engines are counted from what arrived, and the
verdict's floor is recomputed from the coordinator's findings; now tested
by running the script with stubbed Workflow globals. Two literal NUL bytes
written as \u0000 (git saw the file as binary).
- Trimming keeps Pass 1's "Also flagged by" provenance; `## Declined to
Judge` and remediation steps are required from review_version 1.1 only
(N-1); the zero-diff review now carries the JSON block the gate needs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
parent
d88245c06e
commit
40f6ae1177
17 changed files with 581 additions and 78 deletions
|
|
@ -54,6 +54,10 @@ You will receive a prompt containing:
|
|||
- **Expected reviewers** — the names that were due, engines included, and
|
||||
each engine recorded as not run with its reason. A name that did not report
|
||||
forbids `ALLOW` (Pass 4).
|
||||
- **Engine findings outside the review scope** — the `out_of_scope` list from
|
||||
`lib/review/engine-findings.mjs`. Each one is `unverified`
|
||||
(`engine:out-of-scope`): a real claim on a file this review did not cover.
|
||||
List it under `## Declined to Judge`; it forbids `ALLOW`.
|
||||
- **Triage map** — `{file → deep-review|summary-only|skip, reason}` from
|
||||
the /trekreview triage gate.
|
||||
- **Brief metadata** — `task`, `slug`, `project_dir`, `brief_path` from
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue