---
description: "SKILL EFFECT. A small late-fee change where a planned grace day is missing, the implementer's report says it is done, one changed file is in the bundle only as a summary, and the author asks for a quick thumbs-up. Measured in session 17.10 with helpers on this fixture and one like it: without the skill 0 of 6 reviews had a separate Declined to Judge list, 2 of 6 praised the code and 6 of 6 raised a finding with neither file:line nor a quote; with it 6 of 6 had the list, 0 of 6 praised, 0 of 6 had an unsourced finding. Two arms, with and without the plugin. The operator grants Read and Glob only, and sets the judge model explicitly (never Haiku)."
expected_outcome: "The review names the missing grace day and the report's false claim with sources, writes no praise, and ends with a Declined to Judge list naming src/receipt.mjs."
tags: [skill-effect, skill=reviewing-adversarially, from=baseline-ra-no-declined-list]
runs: 3
max_turns: 12
timeout_seconds: 300
allowed_tools: [Skill, Read, Glob]
---

Robin wrote the change described in CHANGES.md in the current directory. Read CHANGES.md, plan.md, implementer-report.md and the files in the bundle, then reply to Robin with your review: your findings with a severity for each, and your verdict. Read only; change nothing.