okr closed patch-lane #2 (commit 35a0bb8): scripts/okf-check.mjs now reads
type: at root level only, so a type nested only in a sources[] entry no
longer passes as typed. Both implementations now agree the fixture's
concept is untyped, so the manifest's own note2 prediction ("flips to
'agree' only if okr scopes the checker's reader without touching inject")
has come true. Renamed the fixture (manifest key + corpus directory) to
match the red-*/green-* naming convention the parity unit test enforces,
and updated okf-frontmatter.mjs's header comment to match.
check-okf-parity.mjs: 10/10 fixtures pass. Full suite: 120/120.
The frontmatter reader matched `^\s*<key>:` with the m flag — indentation-
agnostic, so a block-form nested entry satisfied a top-level lookup. Measured
against okf/SPEC.md at frozen 3fcbb9f, this is a field confusion, not a near
miss: :467-469 names `resource`, `sources[].resource`, `executor.resource` and
`attester.resource` as DISTINCT fields. Top-level `resource` is the URI of the
asset a concept describes (:196); `sources[].resource` is the material it
derives from (:302). `sources` entries carry their own `title` and `type` too.
The consequence was not confined to warnings. Measured before the fix, a
concept with NO top-level `type:` and a `sources[].type` reported "0 files
without type: / OK: valid OKF bundle" — a false negative on §4.1's only
always-required field. `untyped` IS in the parity signature
(check-okf-parity.mjs:73-76), but okr vendors the same regex, so both impls
were blind identically and the gate stayed green while both were wrong.
Anchoring the key at column 0 fixes it. Flow-form never had the bug: in
`sources: [{ id: s1, resource: fixture }]` the nested key is mid-line, so `^`
cannot match it — measured against llm-ingestion-okf's v0.2 golden bundle
(6e0a7c0, read-only), which warns about `resource` and `description` both
before and after.
The divergence from okr is deliberate and is NOT okr lagging. Their reader is
SHARED, and the nested match is documented as load-bearing for their injector
(lib/frontmatter.mjs:7-9 -> inject:69) — while the same module backs their
scripts/okf-check.mjs:101, which needs the opposite. Pinned as parity fixture
`red-nested-key` (catalog FAILs on the nested type, okr passes it), so the
split is a running red/green signal instead of a note. It flips to `agree`
only if okr scopes the checker's reader without touching inject.
Correcting two premises carried in from the previous session, both measured:
- The reader was NOT flat/top-level-only. It read nested keys, so the suspected
false POSITIVE on `resource` was actually a false NEGATIVE, opposite sign.
- "No v0.2 bundle exists" held for our own corpora and emitters only.
llm-ingestion-okf ships a v0.2 golden bundle, where the previous commit's
version-conditional list has real effect — and behaves correctly there.
docs/okf-second-brain/spec.md is untouched deliberately: it makes no claim
about key scope, so gate and convention do not disagree here.
Tests 103 -> 106 (okf-check 22 -> 25), parity 9/9 -> 10/10. All six suites
green; check-versions 11 OK / 0 WARN / 0 ERROR.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01RGZGiDPYcHUMSDCVJavRhp
The 2026-07-23 reservation said enforcement waits until "the emitters have
migrated". Measured rather than assumed, and the emitter set turned out to be
TWO, not three:
okr @0059da7 okf_version: 0.1 + okf_layout: kb-layout-2026-06. Migrated.
linkedin-studio scaffold.ts:38 -> okf_version: 0.1. Never carried a layout
string; has no okf_layout and needs none.
ms-ai-architect NOT an emitter. Zero index.md in the repo; okf_version
appears in one planning doc. The status table already said
"designed, not built" -- only the word "emitters" implied it.
Swept the whole marketplace plus the sibling consumer repos: every live
okf_version value is 0.1. The flip is a no-op today and locks the invariant.
The gate checks SHAPE (/^\d+(\.\d+)*$/), never membership: the upstream value
set is Google's (spec §12), so a bundle targeting a newer version passes. A
membership check would be the convention claiming a set it says it does not own
-- the over-reach class this round has corrected three times. Presence stays
unenforced (reported, not failed) as a separate §3 MUST.
Convention bumped 0.1 -> 0.2 by this log's own criterion: the set of conforming
bundles changed (the spec explicitly said a layout string "conforms today", and
rollout rule 6 defines conformance as gate output). The §12 per-plugin re-check
is pre-measured as finding zero violations.
Also closes a parity blind spot found while landing this: check-okf-parity
compared the okf_version VALUE, which is identical exactly when two impls
disagree about whether it is acceptable -- a false "agree" on the axis the gate
exists to watch. The signature now carries a boolean shape verdict, with
red-marker-layout as the committed red proof. Its "diverge" expectation encodes
okr's lag (they still pure-echo) and flips to "agree" when they mirror it.
And a correction the round earned: portfolio-optimiser enumerated their own
bundle surface and it is four, not three. The dormant fourth
(reference_domain.py:49 -> package data at :70) has no flag form at all, so our
published claim that the re-measurement surfaced "one" unreported entry was
itself one-of-two. Sharpens the standing rule: a search shaped like one entry
type cannot see another; install-vs-fixture is one instance, not the class.
Suite 73 -> 78. coord: PO replied, okr + llm-ingestion-okf notified (the latter
under the standing promise to flag any okf-check.mjs change).
Consume commons' nav-golden fixture class byte-exact from
portfolio-optimiser-commons @ b641741 (nav-golden-hierarchy positive +
nav-golden-escape boundary) into test/nav-golden-corpus/ and wire a thin
gate scripts/check-nav-golden.mjs (+ .test.mjs, 10 tests).
Scope (operator decision, thin): the catalog is the convention owner and
holds no consumer (null konsument), and the shared retrieval skill is
deferred (spec.md §10 Stage 3). So the gate does NOT run a read-context
navigator and does NOT assert the goldens byte-exact. It asserts only what
the catalog owns: each fixture bundle/ is a conformant OKF bundle under the
existing §3 checkBundle (every concept typed + root okf_version), and the
committed expected-read-context.md golden is present and non-empty. Byte-exact
navigator conformance stays a consumer concern (okr STEG 4 / Stage 3 skill).
Fixtures pinned byte-exact (.gitattributes -text); manifest carries source
repo+SHA per the vendoring-provenance rule. Naming: the stale "§5 pts 1-5"
read-context label maps to the settled method-spec §3 Step 1 (commons 9801d35);
no open §5 dependency. commons confirmed b641741 complete + goldens derived
from §3 Step 1 (via coord).
Verified: check-nav-golden 10/10; gate CLI exit 0 (2 fixtures PASS); full
suite 73/73 across the six test files.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NeK9hkxrU9wFPBYGYnSV1V
Make OKF §3 checker parity a RUNNING per-file red/green signal instead of a
stale one-shot claim. The catalog and okr checkers provably diverge on the same
input (catalog walks everything + no BOM/CRLF norm; okr skips innboks/dot-dirs +
normalizes); this gate turns that divergence into a monitored, tested fact.
- scripts/check-okf-parity.mjs: n-way runner, zero-dep. Normalizes each impl's
existing checkBundle(root) return to {conceptCount, untyped[], okfVersion} and
compares per file over default read-mode. Impl registry is availability-guarded
so a catalog-only checkout degrades gracefully; a documented subprocess seam
awaits llm-ingestion-okf's Python checker (fase 2) + Node port (fase 4).
- test/okf-parity-corpus/: committed byte-exact adversarial corpus + manifest.
Red-proof fixtures (expected: diverge) the gate MUST go red on — byte axis
(BOM+CRLF) and tree axis (innboks, dot-dir) each carry one; canon = both.
.gitattributes -text pins the BOM/CRLF bytes. Green fixtures pin agreement
incl. a SHARED gap (both descend into node_modules).
- check-okf-parity.test.mjs: 8/8. Corpus assertions + byte-tracking red-proof +
runtime-materialized symlink/NFC-NFD meta-tests + graceful-skip seam.
Honest scope: only 2 impls expose a runnable per-file checker today, so the gate
runs 2-way and is architected n-way — no faked third impl, no cross-repo code.
spec §7 + log.md updated (no self-certified parity; fixes stay upstream-first).
Verified: parity 8/8, CLI exit 0; regression 33/33; check-versions 10 OK.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NeK9hkxrU9wFPBYGYnSV1V
