Kjell Tore Guttormsen
8c52bdb2e4
B2 (router tiering) was already delivered in S14, so S15 = B1 + B3 only. No surface/count/version change -> within-v4.1.0 refinement (S11-S13 precedent). - B1 (commands/onboarding.md): replace the "Run /linkedin:first-post" dead-end hand-off in Phase 3 with the first-post drafting steps embedded inline (3.1 topic -> 3.2 3-line draft -> 3.3 QC -> 3.4 present+clipboard -> 3.5 state-update that sets first_post_date). Wizard now yields a draft in-flow; 0 dead-end strings. Stays within the existing allowed-tools (Read/Bash/AskUserQuestion); UI-brief §12b scope-guard honored (no provider seams / progressive-disclosure added). - B3 (commands/carousel.md): Step 6 now assembles the ENTIRE deck (every slide's copy + the caption) into the clipboard payload, not just the caption; full-deck assembly precedes the clipboard-helper.mjs call. Independent /trekreview (2 Opus reviewers): brief-conformance 0 findings; code-correctness 1 MAJOR that is PRE-EXISTING and out of S15 scope (onboarding Phase 2 saves need Write in allowed-tools; lines 142/157, untouched by the S15 diff) -> DEFERRED to next session per "ekte design-funn -> neste sesjon". Verdict ALLOW for the delivered scope (not a WARN-override). Gate: test-runner.sh 74/0/0; node --test 98/98; commands=29; v4.1.0 unchanged. See docs/remediation/review.md for the full record (ALLOW + 1 deferred MAJOR). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
143 lines
8.2 KiB
Markdown
143 lines
8.2 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
type: trekreview
|
||
review_version: "1.0"
|
||
task: "S15 — UX finish §6c on the final 29-command set: B1 onboarding inline-draft + B3 carousel full-deck clipboard (B2 router-tiering already delivered in S14)"
|
||
slug: remediation
|
||
project_dir: docs/remediation/
|
||
brief_path: docs/remediation/brief.md
|
||
scope_sha_start: baca30f
|
||
scope_sha_end: baca30f
|
||
reviewed_files_count: 2
|
||
verdict: ALLOW
|
||
mode: default
|
||
effort: standard
|
||
profile: premium
|
||
findings: []
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
# Review — linkedin-studio S15 (UX finish §6c: B1 onboarding inline + B3 carousel full-deck)
|
||
|
||
## Executive Summary
|
||
|
||
**Verdict: ALLOW** for S15's delivered scope — 0 BLOCKER, 0 MAJOR, 0 MINOR, 0 SUGGESTION
|
||
**attributable to the S15 diff**. Two independent reviewers (brief-conformance,
|
||
code-correctness) ran COLD, without cross-feeding, on the as-delivered uncommitted
|
||
working tree (HEAD `baca30f` + the S15 delta = two command files).
|
||
|
||
- **brief-conformance-reviewer:** 0 findings. B1 and B3 both trace to delivered code; the
|
||
binding §12b scope-guard is honored (no extensibility / provider-seam / progressive-
|
||
disclosure / detect-and-offer language entered the diff); no version/count drift
|
||
(19/29/25/6 intact, v4.1.0 untouched); no files outside the two in scope.
|
||
- **code-correctness-reviewer:** 1 MAJOR — but **pre-existing and outside S15's scope**
|
||
(see Findings). The S15 changes themselves are correct: branches all terminate, the
|
||
state-updater + clipboard snippets mirror the established `first-post.md` pattern
|
||
exactly, `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}` is the established path var, and the larger carousel
|
||
clipboard payload introduces no new failure mode over the uniform plugin pattern.
|
||
|
||
S15 = **B1 + B3 only**. B2 (router tiering) was already delivered in S14 (the finish-plan
|
||
S15 body still lists B2, but the S14 amendment + the session-state label supersede it);
|
||
its absence here is correct, not a gap.
|
||
|
||
## Coverage
|
||
|
||
Scope: HEAD `baca30f` (S14's commit) + the **uncommitted S15 working-tree delta**
|
||
(annotated `[uncommitted]` — a brief-level contract; the brief's Assumptions allow
|
||
uncommitted review). 2 files = the operator's own changes. The 3 untracked not-mine files
|
||
(`docs/linkedin-studio-persona-brief.md`, `…-ui-brief.md`, `docs/voyage-build/progress.json`)
|
||
are explicitly excluded from scope and from the commit. **No silent skips.**
|
||
|
||
| Treatment | Count | Notes |
|
||
|-----------|-------|-------|
|
||
| `deep-review` | 0 | neither file is under `hooks/**` / `auth/**` / `crypto/**` / `**/security/**` |
|
||
| `summary-only` | 2 | `commands/onboarding.md` (Phase 3 rewrite + 1 Phase-4 summary line), `commands/carousel.md` (Step 6 clipboard) |
|
||
| `skip` | 0 | no lockfiles / svg / generated / dist |
|
||
|
||
**B1/B3 acceptance checks (orchestrator-run greps):**
|
||
- B1: `grep -E "[Rr]un \`?/linkedin:first-post" commands/onboarding.md` → **0 dead-end strings**;
|
||
inline draft steps 3.1–3.5 present (topic → 3-line draft → QC → present+clipboard → state-update that sets `first_post_date`).
|
||
- B3: full-deck assembly block at `carousel.md:191` precedes the `clipboard-helper.mjs` call at `:211`; payload contains slide text; caption-only `<CAROUSEL_CAPTION>` removed.
|
||
|
||
**Cross-cutting execution criteria:** `scripts/test-runner.sh` → **74 passed / 0 failed /
|
||
0 warnings**, exit 0. `node --test hooks/scripts/__tests__/*.test.mjs` → **98/98** (no hook
|
||
logic changed). `ls commands/*.md` → **29** (no surface-count change; no version bump —
|
||
consistent with S11–S13 precedent: within-scope refinements stay at the current version).
|
||
|
||
## Findings
|
||
|
||
**0 findings attributable to the S15 diff.** One MAJOR was raised by code-correctness; on
|
||
inspection it is **pre-existing and out of S15's scope**, and is routed to the next session
|
||
per the finish-plan's locked constraint ("fix-in-next-session for any review finding") and
|
||
the operator rule "ekte design-funn → neste sesjon" (in-session fix is reserved for the
|
||
session's *own* lockstep misses). It is recorded below and propagated to STATE.md — **not
|
||
dropped, not silenced.**
|
||
|
||
### [MAJOR — DEFERRED to next session] onboarding Phase 2 file-saves need `Write`, not in `allowed-tools`
|
||
|
||
*Raised by code-correctness (`PLAN_EXECUTE_DRIFT`), `commands/onboarding.md:142` (and `:157`).*
|
||
|
||
`onboarding.md` frontmatter grants `allowed-tools: [Read, Bash, AskUserQuestion]` — no
|
||
`Write`. **Phase 2** instructs "Save the responses to `assets/voice-samples/authentic-voice-samples.md`"
|
||
(`:142`, with a REPLACE-vs-append rule) and "Save to `config/user-profile.local.md`" (`:157`).
|
||
Persisting those profile files is a file write; the plugin's accepted pattern is the `Write`
|
||
tool, and the sibling `first-post.md` (same voice-save) declares `Write` (`first-post.md:9-14`).
|
||
With only Read/Bash/AskUserQuestion the agent cannot honor the two "Save to …" instructions
|
||
(the only scripted Bash writes are the `node -e` state and clipboard snippets). **Real defect.**
|
||
|
||
**Why DEFERRED, not fixed in S15:**
|
||
- **Pre-existing.** The gap exists identically at HEAD `baca30f` *before* the S15 edits —
|
||
`git show HEAD:…/onboarding.md` shows `allowed-tools: [Read, Bash, AskUserQuestion]` already.
|
||
- **Out of S15's diff scope.** The S15 hunks are `@@ -166` (Phase 3) and `@@ -201` (Phase 4
|
||
summary line); lines 142/157 (Phase 2) are untouched. S15's *own* inline steps (3.1–3.5)
|
||
stay within Read/Bash/AskUserQuestion and need no `Write` (3.4 clipboard = Bash, 3.5
|
||
state-update = Bash `node -e`).
|
||
- **Not introduced or worsened by S15.** The reviewer's "now owns the save flow" framing does
|
||
not hold on inspection: Phase 2's saves are reached identically before and after S15, and
|
||
the removed `/linkedin:first-post` hand-off was about *post creation* (Phase 3), not Phase 2's
|
||
profile saves. S15 added no save-flow that needs `Write`.
|
||
- **Operator governance.** Fixing a Phase-2 tool-contract bug inside an S15 (B1+B3) push would
|
||
be exactly the "rydd opp i pre-existing som del av en bugfix" / scope-expansion the operator's
|
||
rules forbid; the documented default for out-of-scope items is **defer** (record, route to
|
||
next session) — not silently fix, not silently drop.
|
||
|
||
**Recommended action (next session):** add `Write` to `onboarding.md`'s `allowed-tools`
|
||
(matching `first-post.md:9-14`), or replace the two "Save to …" instructions with a `node -e`
|
||
Bash write so the steps stay within the declared Bash grant. Natural home: fold into S16 (which
|
||
already opens the onboarding/saves surface) or the S17 triage pass.
|
||
|
||
## Remediation Summary
|
||
|
||
**Gate: ALLOW** for S15's delivered scope (B1 + B3). Both reviewers confirm the two changes
|
||
are conformant (brief) and correct (code); the binding §12b scope-guard held; no version/count
|
||
drift; the inline first-post flow and the full-deck clipboard both function within the existing
|
||
tool grants and established patterns. The single MAJOR is a **pre-existing, out-of-scope**
|
||
tool-contract gap in Phase 2 that S15 neither introduced nor worsened; per the operator's
|
||
explicit "ekte design-funn → neste sesjon" rule it is **deferred and recorded**, not fixed
|
||
as scope creep. This is a genuine ALLOW of the scoped delivery — **not** a WARN-override (there
|
||
is no open finding *against* S15's diff).
|
||
|
||
Per Handover 6, this `review.md` is consumable by `/trekplan --brief …`. With an ALLOW verdict
|
||
on the delivered scope and the one deferred finding routed forward, S15 may commit + push, and
|
||
the finish-plan continues at S16 (with the deferred `Write` gap reconciled there or in S17).
|
||
|
||
```json
|
||
{
|
||
"verdict": "ALLOW",
|
||
"verdict_scope": "S15 delivered changes (B1 + B3); 2 files",
|
||
"scope": { "sha_start": "baca30f", "sha_end": "baca30f", "reviewed_files_count": 2, "uncommitted_delta": true },
|
||
"counts": { "BLOCKER": 0, "MAJOR": 0, "MINOR": 0, "SUGGESTION": 0 },
|
||
"findings": [],
|
||
"deferred_findings": [
|
||
{
|
||
"severity": "MAJOR",
|
||
"title": "onboarding Phase 2 file-saves need Write, not in allowed-tools",
|
||
"file": "commands/onboarding.md",
|
||
"line": 142,
|
||
"rule_key": "PLAN_EXECUTE_DRIFT",
|
||
"status": "pre-existing, out of S15 scope (Phase 2; S15 diff = Phase 3 + Phase 4 line)",
|
||
"routed_to": "next session (S16 onboarding/saves surface, or S17 triage)",
|
||
"recommended_action": "add Write to onboarding.md allowed-tools (match first-post.md:9-14), or replace the two 'Save to ...' instructions with a node -e Bash write"
|
||
}
|
||
],
|
||
"dropped_findings": []
|
||
}
|
||
```
|