Kjell Tore Guttormsen
a41cc54e73
Hardening phase S1. Tightened the hook character bound from one-sided (under 140) to the full canonical 110-140 band across the Start-journey creation surfaces, matching hooks/prompts/content-quality-gate.md: - quick.md: hook band on Step 2 + Step 5 checklist; added a buzzword check and a 150-500 length-band check; checklist tally 6 -> 7. - onboarding.md: hook band in Phase 3.2 + 3.3 (length + no-links already present). - first-post.md: hook band in Step 4 + Step 5 (length + no-links already present). - setup.md: zero-edit pass (all four axes already satisfied). Adds docs/hardening/log.md (per-command audit trail, 5-step method) and docs/hardening/review.md (cold /trekreview: ALLOW, 0 BLOCKER/0 MAJOR/1 MINOR). Lint Failed:0, counts 29/19/25/6 unchanged. No structural/version churn. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
64 lines
3.1 KiB
Markdown
64 lines
3.1 KiB
Markdown
---
|
|
type: trekreview
|
|
task: "linkedin-studio command hardening — S1 (method calibration + Start journey)"
|
|
slug: hardening
|
|
project_dir: docs/hardening/
|
|
session: S1
|
|
verdict: ALLOW
|
|
scope: "working-tree (uncommitted) vs HEAD 2f90880"
|
|
counts:
|
|
BLOCKER: 0
|
|
MAJOR: 0
|
|
MINOR: 1
|
|
SUGGESTION: 0
|
|
reviewers:
|
|
- brief-conformance-reviewer
|
|
- code-correctness-reviewer
|
|
findings:
|
|
- S1-MINOR-1
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
# /trekreview — S1 (quick · onboarding · first-post · setup)
|
|
|
|
**Verdict: ALLOW** (0 BLOCKER · 0 MAJOR · 1 MINOR · 0 SUGGESTION). Two cold,
|
|
independent reviewers (Opus); no cross-feed. Gate condition met: lint
|
|
`Failed: 0` + ALLOW.
|
|
|
|
## Scope reviewed
|
|
- `commands/quick.md`, `commands/onboarding.md`, `commands/first-post.md` (edited — hook-floor fixes)
|
|
- `commands/setup.md` (in S1 scope; deliberate **zero-edit pass**, logged PASS)
|
|
- `docs/hardening/log.md` (NEW — the per-command audit trail)
|
|
- Not-mine untracked (`*-persona-brief.md`, `*-ui-brief.md`, `voyage-build/progress.json`): untouched ✓
|
|
|
|
## brief-conformance-reviewer → ALLOW
|
|
- All 4 S1 commands have UNIQUE anchored `### /linkedin:<name>` entries (no doubles).
|
|
- SC-A…SC-E complete per entry; SC-C mechanical predicate present per type (never "N/A→judgment").
|
|
- **Claim-vs-reality (critical axis — author flagged 3 prior assert-before-verify errors):**
|
|
every logged HARDEN edit was traced to the file and **confirmed to exist** —
|
|
`quick.md:68,140,144,145,147`, `onboarding.md:200,209`, `first-post.md:101,125`.
|
|
The "length + no-links already present" claim is **true** (onboarding:204, first-post:113/120).
|
|
`setup.md:86` voice-trainer wiring resolves to a real `agents/voice-trainer.md`.
|
|
The prior failure mode did **not** recur.
|
|
- Non-Goals + stopping rule honored (29 commands, no version/count churn, surgical edits only).
|
|
|
|
## code-correctness-reviewer → ALLOW (0 findings)
|
|
- Internal consistency: every hook bound reads `110-140` on both the structural line and the
|
|
checklist line in all three files; no surviving one-sided `under 140` / `Under 500` bound.
|
|
- Checklist arithmetic (highest-risk): `quick.md` Step 5 has exactly **7** `- [ ]` items ↔
|
|
`**All 7 = Yes?**`. Correct.
|
|
- Bound matches canonical `hooks/prompts/content-quality-gate.md` (110-140 / 150-500); no off-by-one.
|
|
- No collateral damage; frontmatter, code fences, and `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}` blocks untouched.
|
|
|
|
## Findings
|
|
|
|
### S1-MINOR-1 — log hook char-counts tagged "node-verified" but cosmetically imprecise
|
|
- **severity:** MINOR · **file:** `docs/hardening/log.md` (quick before/after counts)
|
|
- The before/after hook counts (95 / 127) are tagged node-verified; the directional fact
|
|
(before < 110 floor → fixed by the edit) is correct and load-bearing, but the exact integers
|
|
are not worth the "node-verified" framing relative to the log's own Method-discipline rule.
|
|
- **Disposition:** accepted as-is for S1 (does not affect any axis verdict); the framing is
|
|
tightened going into S2 — char counts are computed with a tool and only then labelled verified.
|
|
|
|
## Gate decision
|
|
ALLOW → commit (own files only, `fix:`) → push. No BLOCKER/MAJOR; the single MINOR is
|
|
recorded, not gate-blocking.
|