The known-negative for stripping a namespace prefix -- "N101 ships 574 `tbx:`
tags, and not one of their local names is a role" -- was published in four
docstrings (CLAUDE.md, tools/okf_witness.py, this file, the round's report)
and asserted nowhere. A measurement presented as a fact, with nothing that
could turn red when it stopped being true.
The walk is written HERE rather than taken from `okf_witness`: the witness's
own reader is what this known-negative judges, so counting through it would
make the two agree by construction.
RED on the claim, not on an import:
assert sum(tbx.values()) == 574
AssertionError: assert 568 == 574
where 568 = sum(dict_values([94, 94, 94, 94, 94, 94, 1, 1, 1, 1]))
Three independent counts of the delivery agree on 568 -- raw `tbx:` substring,
regex over `"tag": "tbx:`, and node traversal -- against 574 in the tree.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Found by running the gate against the working tree: R761 goes from 0 to
**19 claimed and not found** the moment the conversion lands, and 19 is
exactly its RLE8 BMP count.
The cause is a rule that was right until this round. `asset_holds` proves a
carry by hashing the SOURCE file and looking for those bytes under their own
content address in `assets/`. A converted image's source bytes are not in the
bundle and never will be -- the run carried the picture under a new digest,
which the bundle states on the pointer line beside the old one.
Red on the claim: `asset_holds` returns False for a build whose bundle
declares the conversion and whose `assets/` holds the named file. Two
known-negatives are in the same test so the second route cannot become a way
of believing the report: a bundle that claims a conversion and ships no file,
and a bundle shipping a file under a digest it never tied to this source.
Both must stay False, because the judge has to hash the asset itself.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Reproduced 2026-09-19: `okf build` on N200 proposes 0 plans, prints
`FAILED - no segmentation plans` and exits 2 BEFORE the accounting door
is reached -- no accounting file is written at all. Every one of the
16 549 elements then lands as `u` with `no declared fates`, which reads
like a finding about the build and is a finding about the run.
Two tests and a known-negative, so a rule that calls every corpus blank
fails too.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The guard at the end of `main` asked whether the corpora named by the
ARGUMENTS are available. Row 6 is SKIPPED precisely when none of them
is, so the branch could never fire; PM read it as dead code and no test
covered it. The question it meant to ask is about the machine: a corpus
that is HERE and was pointed away from is a row that did not run, and
with `CI=1` the gate then printed a qualified GREEN and exited 0.
Two tests, so a guard that fires on everything fails too: with the
default source present and the arguments pointing elsewhere the run
exits 1 and names the row; with no corpus on the machine at all it
exits 0, because nothing to measure is not a row that did not run.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
PM measured it on N200 Vegbygging:2024: 74 `mml:math` carrying 2 811
characters and 49 `figcaption`, and the witness counted 0 and 0. Two
independent causes and both are in this red:
- `count_sts_xml` takes every tag through `_local`, which strips a
Clark-notation namespace AND a prefix; `count_sts_json` compared the
raw string, so `mml:math` never reached `tag == "math"`.
- the publisher's JSON puts a figure's caption in `figcaption` under
the `graphic`, not in the `fig/caption` NISO-STS writes. Measured
over the eight deliveries on this machine: 430 `figcaption`.
Three tests. The JSON half of `sts-rikt.xml`'s family carries both
shapes as a committed fixture; the real N200 carries PM's four numbers
and skips where the corpus is absent; and the known-negative for
stripping a prefix is N101's 574 `tbx:` tags, whose local names name
no role -- a generalising rule measured against what it must NOT take.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The mirror of the `persisted` refusal, driven from both sides: a report
declaring `rejected` while a concept in the bundle names the document
is `invalid >= 1` with the note quoted, and the same declaration with
its elements booked as coded rejections and no concept naming it is
`invalid == 0` and `refused == 3`. Without the second arm the test
would pass on a gate that refused every rejected document.
Measured against the X2 mutant from the previous commit: rc 0 before
(98 passed), rc 1 after.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The harness returned `2 if errors else 0`, so a run printing `killed 0
of 1` and naming its survivor exited 0. PM measured it on a copy
carrying only the X2 mutant. Red on the claim: the module imports, and
offers no verdict to ask.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The gate gains a FIFTH column, `Unit.refused`, and it is the only one
that is not a defect in the report: the elements of a document the
build read and persisted nothing of. Their fate is declared honestly,
so `unaccounted` and `double_booked` both stay 0 -- which is exactly
why nothing else could see the loss. `refused_whole` asks its question
only for a corpus that persisted NOTHING, so one refused source beside
an accepted one, the ordinary case on a heterogeneous corpus, reached
row 3 as clean.
Row 3's reason now carries `N element(s) lost with R of D document(s)
refused whole`, and each unclean unit's detail line carries
`refused=` beside u, d, unverified and invalid, with the document's
own rejection code in the note.
On the build side `Accounting.refused` is written into the JSON and
into the `**Accounting**` bullet of `log.md` as `R of D document(s)
refused whole`. The exit code is NOT moved: it belongs to the whole
run, and a corpus holding one unreadable file among many is ordinary,
so the order's other half -- state it in the accounting -- is the one
taken. `okf build` still exits 1 when it persisted nothing at all.
`test_a_corpus_refused_whole_under_the_default_gate_is_red` kept its
point and lost its premise: the numbers still balance, and that is now
asserted as u = 0 and d = 0 rather than as a clean unit.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
PM's checkpoint of ed8d9d7 measured it: an inbox holding one refused
document and one accepted one gave `clean = 4 of 4`, `refused_whole =
None` and `okf build` exit 0, while three elements of `avvist.html`
were gone unseen. `refused_whole` asks its question only when the
corpus persisted NOTHING, and a refused document's own unit balances
by construction -- every element booked as a coded rejection is u = 0
and d = 0.
Three tests, all red on the claim and not on an import:
- the unit of a document the build refused is not clean, and its note
names the code;
- the same beside a PERSISTED neighbour, which is the ordinary case on
a heterogeneous corpus, with row 3 RED and the source named in the
detail line;
- `okf build`'s own report says how many of M documents it refused
whole -- the exit code belongs to the whole run, so the count has to
stand in the accounting and in `log.md` or the loss is silent.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Row 6 was GREEN with R761 100 % rejected: every element of a refused document
is booked as a coded rejection, so u = 0 and d = 0 and the bundle is empty.
`refused_whole` asks that question on its own now -- the build order asked for
an honest red there, and PM re-measured the green on 2026-09-18 with
`okf build` exiting 1 unseen.
A skipped row no longer leaves the verdict unqualified (`GATE GREEN (row 6 not
run: ...)`), and the exit code is non-zero locally when a corpus source is on
the machine and its row did not run. m-2.
N200 Vegbygging:2024 joins R761 as a second real corpus. R761 holds 0 `fig`,
0 formulas and 0 references, so the only real corpus could not have found the
hole in the STS role map; N200 carries 194 citations, 49 figures and 135
footnotes. A `.json` whose root holds an STS node tree is counted as STS
rather than as keys and leaves -- the container is not the content.
M-4: the review's 26 mutants, ported to the code as it stands, plus 8 for the
new checks. 34 of 34 killed. `tools/okf_gate_mutants.py` runs on a copy of the
tree, and a pattern that does not match is an ERROR and exit 2 -- a mutant
that could not be applied was never measured. That fired once, on M13, after a
refactor moved the line it edits.
m-3: `APPROVED_EXCEPTIONS` was read by no row, so approving one changed
nothing. Each pair is now checked against the witness's own vocabulary and the
run says why it moves no denominator. The gate also prints its OWN limits
beside the verdict, m-5 among them.
The product's accounting tests state the new truth instead of the old one:
`okf build --accounting` over the fixture corpus exits 1 with SIX unaccounted
elements in its own vocabulary -- its first real finding, reachable only now
that fixtures carry the constructs. Four shared element names disagree with
the witness, each pinned with its cause; one of the four is a double count
this package makes (a text box's paragraph, once inside the box and again in
the paragraph carrying it).
Three fixture defects were found and fixed while building them, each of which
would have reported a loss the build never had: a shared string table not
related to the workbook, a `graphicData` with no `uri`, and an odt
`styles.xml` without `<office:styles/>`.
Report: docs/2026-09-18-regnskapsgaten-herdet.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Rows 2 and 3 require the build's inventory to EQUAL the witness's, so what
the witness does not count, nothing can lose visibly. An independent review
put a header and a comment in a docx, measured 0 of either in the bundle,
and the accounting still read "2 of 2 carried".
Thirteen classes are now counted, each with a red test written first:
docx header/footer, comment, endnote and text box (a box's paragraphs are
its own, or the text is booked twice) - pptx speaker note and hidden slide
(`show="0"`, no longer counted as an ordinary slide) - xlsx formula and
hidden sheet (the state lives in `workbook.xml` and is reached through the
relationship id, so the sheet part itself says nothing about it) - odt
header/footer from `styles.xml` and annotation (counted as prose, it made
the accounting demand a reader carry a note the author wrote to themselves)
- STS `mixed-citation`, `mml:math`, `fig` and its caption, measured by the
review at 4.1 % of N200's source text and 3.9 % of N100's.
M-2: the two STS witnesses had ONE role map between them, so row 5 -- "two
witnesses agree" -- could not see a hole in it. `_sts_role_xml` and
`_sts_role_json` are written apart, each for its own delivery, and a test
holds them apart.
M-3: 20 of 63 element types had a count of ZERO in their only fixture. Seven
hand-built documents close it, every element type now occurs at least once
(a test asserts it), and ALL TWENTY documents carry a hand count read off
the fixture's own bytes (four did before). `.xlsx image` -- the operator's
own proposed exception -- could not be exercised at all until now.
Every witness also states WHAT IT STILL DOES NOT COUNT, per file type, and
the gate prints that list on every run.
THE FIXTURE ROWS ARE RED NOW, AND THAT IS THE POINT. Row 2 red on .docx,
.odt, .pptx, .xlsx and .xml; row 3 at u = 25, d = 2 over the new classes,
including a footnote and four spreadsheet cells the build genuinely drops.
`0 claimed and not found` on the same run: nothing the build DOES book as
carried failed the bundle check, so the red is the build's and not the
instrument's.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
An independent review of `0b00de4` found the judge was a calculator over a
report the judged writes: `account()` compared BOOKED NUMBERS with the
witness's counts and never opened a concept file. Reproduced here first --
a report that changes not one byte of the bundle and books every element as
carried gave `GATE GREEN`, exit 0, and so did booking every element as
rejected.
The witness now gives every element THE PIECES OF TEXT IT IS MADE OF, and
the gate looks for each of them in the concept bodies the run wrote. Pieces
and not one joined string: a reader writes a heading's marker and a
picture's pointer block between the parts of a container, so a section is
never one contiguous run even when every word of it is there.
Also in the judge, each with a test driving it from both sides:
- a negative booking, a document declared persisted that no concept names,
a document declared rejected that the bundle holds, a rejection code
outside a closed list, and an `accounting_version` the gate does not read
are each REFUSED rather than summed;
- a document the build PERSISTED whose report carries nothing from it is
never clean ("everything rejected" was);
- an asset proves a carry only when its BYTES hash to the source's and it
stands under the name the layout gives it. The check was a name check, so
a zero-byte file called `<sha12>-x.png` read as a carry (m-1).
NOT ONE ELEMENT COUNT MOVED: the 13 fixture documents' counts are identical
before and after, so this commit changes what the gate CHECKS and nothing
about what the witness counts. `texts` is additive in the committed fasit.
The rtf text scanner reads `\uN` escapes and skips `{\fonttbl}`-class
groups, or a fixture's font table reads as the first paragraph of its prose;
xlsx cell text is resolved through `sharedStrings.xml`, where a
spreadsheet's words actually live; a PDF page carries its own text lines,
which no row could see before.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The content accounting stays OPT-IN until the losses it reports on the
reference corpus are fixed; a default-on door would fail builds that pass
today. Of the three exceptions the gate proposed, only the PDF one
(heading, paragraph, table) is approved. Approving it moves no number,
because no witness counts a heading in a PDF: what it changes is that the
gap is a stated limit of the instrument rather than an open question
about the build. An image in a workbook, or in md/txt/csv/json/odt/rtf,
stays unaccounted and therefore stays red.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
okf build --accounting PATH inventories every source document before
extraction, in the gate's per-format vocabulary, and after the run gives
each element one fate (carried / pointer / coded rejection), written as
JSON and summarised in log.md. "carried" is checked against the written
concept bodies, so a gate that drops a line is found (test). Exit 1 on
anything unaccounted or double-booked. Opt-in: +744 s (+19 %) on the
43-document reference corpus, and that corpus fails the check on 24 real
losses (22 images on text-less PDF pages, 2 docx Title paragraphs).
Changed without the flag:
- okf build exits 1 when it extracted documents and persisted none.
Door B and corpus.measure are unchanged. One test relied on exit 0.
- An image file carried through a persisted document is its own K1b
column, no longer also extractor_unknown. The set is what the resolver
actually carried (ExtractedDocument.files), never a byte match.
tools/okf_accounting_gate.py (checks untouched) is green on all six rows,
R761 110 of 110 under both gates.
Report: docs/2026-09-17-innholdsregnskapet-bygget.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Capability loop step 3, no capability. tools/okf_accounting_gate.py asks,
per README file type, how many of the elements a SOURCE holds okf build
books as carried / pointer / coded rejection, with unaccounted and
double-booked both required to be 0. Exit 1 today on rows 2, 3, 4 and 6.
The fasit is tools/okf_witness.py (stdlib + pdfplumber + poppler, no
package import; tested on the live import graph), committed as
tests/fixtures/accounting/*inventory.json over one fixture per type.
Measured: no source inventory (0 of 13); two graphics/ files carried
through documents AND counted extractor_unknown (50 on R761 under
--gate none); a refused document logged "0 carried of 0 found"; R761
refused whole because guard 1.4.0 treats its 71 U+00AD soft hyphens as an
invisible carrier (asked of the security repo). The two R761 witnesses
agree once STS labels are counted by role, not tag.
Report: docs/2026-09-17-innholdsregnskapet-rod-gate.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
