Two producer-side findings from the consumer's S7c acid test (ordre 20260908T063454Z-3648220855-from-.claude), both measured on K2 before and after, both with the corpus rebuilt from scratch.
FUNN 3 -- THE FORM. The converter's default markdown writer emits simple tables, which pad every cell out to the width of the widest cell in its column. Measured on the tender's price sheet: one 594-character prose cell produced a 67 244-character whitespace carpet with runs of up to 887 characters between a label and its amount, 19 integral amounts carrying a converter `.0`, and a header row naming one column. The bytes reached a live model in 2 of 11 prompts and 0 of 11 answers. The spreadsheet row now writes pipe tables with `--columns=1` (load-bearing: the pipe writer pads to a width computed from it, so at the default 72 a narrow table gains runs of up to 45). Same sheet after: 11 048 characters, longest run 2, one row per line, 0 artificial `.0`. Spreadsheet-only, and the scoping is pinned by three digests -- the same change moves the odt fixture 1366 -> 1105, so it can fail.
The `.0` rewrite is bounded twice: to a cell whose whole content is such a number, anchored between unescaped pipes, and skipped when the literal is in the workbook's shared string table -- the converter renders the number 92 and the TEXT "92.0" identically, so the output alone cannot tell them apart. Read with zipfile and xml.etree; no new dependency.
FUNN 2 -- THE LOG LINK. `link_log_in_root_index` (95eb271) is removed. Consumption contract SS 9.2 forbids a consumer from enumerating the bundle directory unless the profile says the index is derived, so the index tree is the entire map a consumer may use and everything it links is a document: their navigator returned 630 where our pre-pass counts 629, and a corpus run's own log was citable as content. The log is still written to the bundle root (SPEC section 9); `tools/okf_consume.py` keeps its exclusion for the bundles already built with the link.
K2 rebuilt twice. BEFORE reproduces the consumer's ref exactly (`sha256-tree:f14872a0...c8a92a`, 629 concepts) and their three consume figures to the token (57 289 / 62 149 / 58 401). AFTER: 629 concepts, `merged + coded rejections = 43 = N`, new ref `sha256-tree:c26eed6a...e3261f`, 627 of 629 concepts byte-identical, 1104 of 1108 files identical to the delivered bundle.
ONE REGRESSION, MEASURED AND NOT FIXED: on the mandate-shaped question with the vocabulary bridge the priced concept moves from candidate rank 10 to 19, so `--k 12` withholds it `below_k`; `--cost-vocabulary --k 20` delivers it at 65 912 o200k. The cause is measured rather than argued -- restoring only the concept's title on the new short body ranks it 10 again. The chain ends at the orphan check (`propose.py:461`), which drops the sheet heading once a table block opens two lines below it. That is the already-reported orphan gate, and changing it is a default-ON segmentation rule affecting every document type. The specific question is unaffected: rank 1 before and after. The priced excerpt's budget share falls from 56.5 % to 9.7 %.
11 new tests (RED first), 8 mutations, 8 red, with an unmutated control green each time. One mutation survived twice before the fixture could make it fire, and both survivals are written down. 1279 -> 1287 tests. mypy --strict clean on 28 files. ruff clean. Both proposer goldens byte-unchanged. One frozen literal moved with the fix and is reported rather than hidden.
Report: docs/2026-09-08-prisform-og-loggen-k2.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Until now "run the door over a folder" was a shell loop over two scripts
under `tools/`, with nine flags between them and a `--path-prefix` rule
that lived in a code block in a measurement report. Neither script was
packaged (`pyproject.toml` ships `src/llm_ingestion_okf` only), so the
path the published K1/K2 numbers were measured on was reachable from a
clone and nowhere else.
`okf build <folder> --bundle <dir>` is that path, packaged, declared as a
console script and installed with the wheel. It is orchestration only:
the proposer and the corpus harness MOVED into the package
(`llm_ingestion_okf.propose`, `llm_ingestion_okf.corpus`) and the two
`tools/` scripts became thin entry points to them, so the published
reproduction blocks still run and there is exactly one implementation of
each rule. Neither move adds a dependency or a model call.
Two decisions belong to this layer and are stated where they are made.
A document's proposed paths are scoped by its RELATIVE PATH minus the
extension, not its basename: the door walks recursively now, and two
documents named alike in different folders would otherwise collide on a
path Door B is supposed to make impossible rather than merely detect.
And omitted timestamps do not come from the clock -- `--ingested-at` and
`--proposed-at` default to one shared epoch constant, because a
wall-clock default would put a changing byte in the artifact and take
rebuild-equals-incremental away from every caller who did not pass them.
Arm C and Arm D stay off and are not exposed here.
Measured on the 43-file K2 corpus, one invocation against the two-script
bundle of 2026-09-03: N = 43 computed, merged 39/43, coded rejections
4/43 (`extractor_unknown` 3, `extractor_empty_pdf` 1), K1b 39 + 4 = 43,
exit 0, 779.43 s. 1107 of 1108 files byte-identical. The one that
differs is the root `index.md`, by exactly the `log.md` link a commit
fifteen hours younger than the stored artifact adds -- appending that
line to the stored file reproduces the new one byte for byte. Against
the two scripts at THIS commit the trees agree in full, which is what
the byte-identity test holds.
Suite 1127 passed after `git add` (1113 before), mypy --strict clean,
ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Door B listed `inbox.iterdir()` and kept only top-level files. A file in a
subdirectory was neither ingested nor refused: it appeared in none of the
result's buckets, so a nested drop produced a bundle that was silently short
of what was dropped and no count said so. That broke the K1b identity for any
inbox with folders in it. Operator decision 2026-09-06.
- `walk_inbox` is the ONE walk rule, shared with `tools/okf_corpus_run.py`:
the denominator N is now counted over exactly the set of files the door
ingests, rather than over a second listing that happened to agree.
- Sorted on the whole relative path, not the basename, so the order is a
function of the tree; that is what keeps rebuild-from-scratch byte-equal to
an incremental update.
- A concept's `source_file` is the path relative to the inbox root,
`/`-separated. The concept NAME still comes from the basename, so two
folders holding one basename hit the existing §3 collision refusal instead
of one silently claiming the other's concept.
- Dot-directories and a bundle directory inside the inbox are skipped with a
CODE, in a new `InboxResult.skipped`. Recursion makes the door's own output
reachable as its own input; a silent skip would be the same
absence-without-a-denominator defect one level down.
- `--path-prefix` reduces per component and rejoins with `/`, so the caller
driving a nested corpus can carry the relative directory. Reducing the whole
string folded the separator into a `-` and flattened `sub/sub2`.
`tests/test_inbox_flow.py::test_subdirectories_are_not_walked` asserted the
opposite and is superseded in place, with the reason written down.
Measured on the K2 corpus (flat, N=43): 39/43 merged, 4 coded, K1b holds. The
bundle digest is
`1472e98aec8643c5beee540f4c42b5e437bd26e7c61d69a91bcff799f06a6d13` over 1108
files -- byte-identical to a run of the same corpus at 190086f WITHOUT this
change (`diff -r` exit 0), so recursion costs a flat inbox nothing. It differs
from the stored 2026-09-03 artifact by one line in `index.md`
(`- [Corpus run history](log.md)`), which 95eb271 added 15 hours after that
bundle was built.
Suite 1113 passed, `ruff` clean, `mypy --strict src/ tools/` clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Measured on the K2 artifact by a consumer: `log.md` was on disk and no
index named it, so a reader entering the bundle at `index.md` -- the walk
section 8 exists to support -- never reached the one file carrying `N`.
Stated as a LOCAL choice rather than conformance, because it is one.
Upstream's own bundles do not link their log: measured at `9a15b13`, 0 of
the 24 shipped `index.md` files name the single `log.md` in the set, with
the same grep form finding `tables/index.md` in 4 of them as the
known-positive control. That shows the link is not REQUIRED -- not that
it is disallowed. `docs/plan/okf-v0.2-alignment.md` P1-F6 already
recorded the upstream shape; a line there now separates the two claims,
since reserved names still stay out of an `entries_match_directory`
listing and this profile has that off.
It lives in the harness because the library cannot make it. The log's
content IS the run's outcome, so it cannot exist when the indexes are
projected, and an index that enumerated it off the directory would gain
the link only from the second run onward -- breaking
rebuild-equals-incremental, the property the segmented bundle is built
on.
The membership test is load-bearing and was measured, not assumed. The
two reprojections disagree about this line: the per-directory one drops
every managed entry before re-emitting its block, while the flat one
keeps a managed line whose target is not an owned concept, deliberately,
so that a regex cannot delete curated content. Appending unconditionally
therefore doubled the entry on the second unsegmented run, which is why
both run modes are pinned separately.
1052 -> 1054 tests. `mypy --strict` clean, `ruff` clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`log.md` is written INTO a directory Door B enumerates on the next round: it
matches the concept glob and is excluded only by `index.md`'s name, so a
rebuild could have seen it as pre-existing curated content or pruned it.
Rebuild-equals-incremental is the property the segmented bundle rests on.
Measured on the real artifact, not only the synthetic: the K2 corpus was run
a second time into the same bundle and compared against a snapshot with
`diff -r`, exit 0 over all 1108 files. The test pins the same property in
seconds instead of 13 minutes.
Also corrects the report's reproduction command -- it documented plan
filenames the run did not use, and re-running it into the existing plans
directory would leave two files claiming one `source_sha256`, which
`_resolve_plans` refuses.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two defects a consumer measured on 2026-09-03 against the bundle built by
this harness, both with one cause: `measure` passed `profile=STRUCTURED_V1`
and no plans at all, though Step 17 of the plan says the harness reuses
`process_inbox` "with the per-document plan mapping from Step 15".
- `adjudication` was in 0 of 39 concepts, because the key is written only
inside the plan-covered branch and no plan was ever passed. `--plans-dir`
replays proposals produced per document first; the profile follows from
the flag rather than being something the harness may choose on its own.
`--bundle-id` and `--okf-version` are arguments, never constants: a
profile names a key and the caller owns its value (decision E1).
- `log.md` did not exist, so `merged` was countable from the bundle and `N`
was not -- K1b could only be taken on trust from a report that does not
travel with the artifact. Written in SPEC section 9 form and dated from
`ingested_at`, never the wall clock.
Additive: without `--plans-dir` the run stays the flat `STRUCTURED_V1` run
that produced the published K1/K2 numbers.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
