All three pilots accepted. Their measurements land in the plan now rather than
as failed runs later, which is the entire return on asking before building.
Six corrections, each measured by the consumer rather than reasoned by us:
- A-E6 specified `okf_version: "0.2"` quoted. Catalog measured the quoted form
failing their shape regex with exit 1, and a UTF-8 BOM making the marker
invisible while still exiting 0. Both now stated as raw-byte expectations.
- A-E2 said the diff lies only *inside* the frontmatter block. No bundle whose
root index has no frontmatter block can satisfy that together with A-E6.
- B-E3 covers one of catalog's three gates; the other two cannot see our
fixture. Recorded so the report is not read as broader than it is.
- Our claim that no gate keys on the version value was wrong as formulated:
check-okf-parity.mjs puts the raw value in its signature. It compares without
judging -- verdict-invariant, not value-blind.
- C-E1's ground truth is 524 non-reserved documents, not 522; 522 was correct
at d2c12d2.
- `materialize_bundle` gains keyword-only `profile=DEFAULT` on po-claude's
request. The signature already has a `*`, so their three-positional call path
stays source-compatible and additivity becomes a property of the signature
instead of something a consumer measures.
Also recorded: po-claude closed their index-parser defect themselves (f41264f),
so do not design around it; the assumption under it -- "a generated index has no
frontmatter" -- is not peculiar to them. Dropping the superseded `timestamp`
draws one catalog warning per concept file, decided after the pilot, not before.
The estimate's open caveat is discharged by reading profiles.py:197: emit is one
formatting path, the validator already admits list values, so only the emitter
side is missing and the sizing stands.
CLAUDE.md gains a standing constraint: consumer content stays at form level in
public files. The wiki's bundle is private pending an Anthropic ToS assessment,
their report goes back through coord, and a push is not reversible.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01A2aKJxLejT9S8jYwoZ9fut
Kjell Tore Guttormsen
f7385fafdb