First public release, published as one snapshot. What changed between versions is in CHANGELOG.md. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
3.2 KiB
3.2 KiB
Known limitations of v1
The review of v1 (06.11.2026) found 2 BLOCKER and 48 MAJOR findings. Both BLOCKERs and the MAJOR findings that are defects were fixed, each with a test. The MAJOR findings below were accepted: each one is a gap or a limitation, not wrong behaviour on the build path, and the reason is given. The finding numbers are the review's own order.
Guards that work but have no test of their own
The guard exists and was read in the code; what is missing is a test that would catch a regression in it.
| # | Where | Untested guard |
|---|---|---|
| 12 | gates/answers.py |
breach rules for find actions, sed -i, absolute Glob patterns, unparseable Bash |
| 14 | gates/answerset.py |
gate on the held-out set; the threshold refusal; freeze without subset_of |
| 15 | gates/calibration.py |
the layout's refusal when too few distinct fillers remain; duplicate call names |
| 18 | gates/repair_gate.py |
the fix-case judgement (diff, excerpts, findings) on a handmade result |
| 27 | okfwiki/kassemble.py |
refusal of reserved (index, log) or unsafe concept ids |
| 28 | okfwiki/kassemble.py |
the stop after an unfinished swap (.<out>-old left behind) |
| 31 | okfwiki/kmerge.py |
the marked write: backup, marker and the recovery stop |
| 34 | okfwiki/kpack.py |
refusals to overwrite parts, home tasks, logs and the floor file |
| 36 | okfwiki/krepair.py |
unknown-key and ambiguous-key refusals in task and fix |
| 37 | okfwiki/krepair.py |
relink --work and its logged moved record |
| 40 | okfwiki/sources.py |
freeze's refusal of a bad name, a folder and a symlink; some check refusals |
Measurement tooling
| # | Where | Limitation | Why accepted |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | gates/answerset.py, gates/multidoc.py |
run from a git worktree nested in the main checkout, a held-out path in the main checkout is not refused | run the answer-set tools from the main checkout |
| 16 | gates/calibration.py, okfwiki/reader.py |
the gate reads the verdicts file twice (the green-run record now has one shared parser) | extra reading, not a wrong result |
| 22 | okfwiki/cost.py |
user text between an unrecorded message and the next is counted as derived output | it can only raise measured cost, so the cost stop comes earlier, never later |
| 23 | okfwiki/cost.py |
derived output before the first helper is projected per batch | it can only raise the projection, which is reported, not used to stop |
| 25 | okfwiki/cost.py |
cost isolation takes no list of breaches set aside |
the rule that asked for it was removed with the rule cut of 06.11.2026 |
| 26 | okfwiki/cost.py |
the read and diagnose breach count looks only at Read calls | the reader and diagnoser agents are given the Read tool only |
Other
| # | Where | Limitation | Why accepted |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | git history | three merge commits (62d5438, 73e5bf7, ad63d41) are not Conventional Commits | published history is not rewritten; later merges use merge(...) |
| 39 | okfwiki/reader.py |
when collect --gate-passed refuses a model, an older verdicts file at --out is left in place |
collect exits 1, and the skill then runs the calibration gate on that model before anything is scored; deleting the earlier file would destroy a valid reading |