The hole: `read_http`'s default transport is the library's `urllib_get`, which invokes the
stdlib opener with no `timeout=`. urllib's documented fallback is then the process-wide default
socket timeout — `None` out of the box — so an http source that accepts a connection and never
answers hangs a run indefinitely. That contradicts the invariant that nothing runs unbounded.
The spec text for S2.4 ("a timeout parameter on `_urllib_get`") could NOT be followed literally:
that function is UPSTREAM library code (`llm_ingestion_okf.connectors`, pinned v0.3.1, pull-only),
signature `(url, credential) -> str` — measured, not assumed. Same failure class as S2.2's
"implement it in `ingest.py`": spec text that says "change X" has to be checked against whether
X is ours at all.
So the fix goes in FRONT of the library: `timeout_get` scopes `socket.setdefaulttimeout` around
a delegate call to the library's own `urllib_get`, and `materialize` now hands the library that
wrapped transport instead of letting it resolve its own untimed default. This meets S2.4's own
verification criterion — a bound WITHOUT a second socket path — and avoids duplicating the
credential-header logic. An explicitly injected `http_get` is passed through UNWRAPPED: a
caller-owned transport (MCP fronts a subprocess with its own `timeout_seconds`) keeps its own
policy, and a process-global side effect is not ours to impose on it.
Honest limit, carried in the code comment, the test docstring and `docs/extending.md`, not just
in the commit: the default socket timeout is PROCESS-global. Under `concurrency=k` the runner is
asyncio on one thread, so the scoping holds; driving `read_http` from a thread-pool executor
would make it unsafe.
Half of S2.4's scope was already delivered upstream — transport failures are categorised as
`SourceError(code="http_transport")`. Coarser than the plan envisaged, but not ours to rewrite.
Two pre-existing guards went red on the first pass, both on PROSE only: `ingest.py` must not
contain "urlopen" (no forked connector) or "ingest_mcp" (AST-guarded mcp-free). No code violated
either — my docstrings merely named them. The guards were left exactly as strict as they were and
the prose was reworded; weakening a real guard to save a comment is the trade this repo refuses.
578 -> 583 tests. Five mutations MEASURED red (restored from scratchpad + `shasum -c` each time,
never `git checkout`):
1. remove the timeout scoping entirely -> RED
2. apply the bound AFTER the delegate call -> RED
3. set the bound but never restore it (no finally)-> RED (the unconditional control)
4. hand the library a bare None again (pre-S2.4) -> RED (the wiring)
5. make the wrapping unconditional -> RED (the conditional control)
Mutations 1 and 2 take ~10s to fail rather than failing instantly: that is the loopback test's
join deadline expiring. It is the measurement that the bound actually BITES — a black-hole
listener on 127.0.0.1 that completes the handshake and never answers, run on a daemon thread so
a detached seam fails an assertion instead of hanging the suite forever. Every other assertion
here only proves we set a global; that one proves the global does something.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01TdLGwd33vqhkToh98Ym34P
Commons settled on 2026-08-01 that MCP is an extension of the `http` source
family, not a fourth family (`shared/ingest-spec.md` §4). This implements it
with ZERO schema change and zero spec amendment.
The transport discriminator lives in `base_url`, not in new manifest fields:
the shared library rejects unknown manifest keys fail-fast, and we consume it
pull-only at a pinned v0.3.1, so `server_ref`/`tool` as fields would have meant
a spec amendment plus a library release. It buys nothing — the library already
joins `base_url` + `/` + `query`, so `mcp+stdio://<server_ref>` + `<tool>`
reproduces exactly the two-part structure the (now stale) reference plan wanted.
Staying inside the family INHERITS what a fourth family would have had to write
and could have forgotten: the §8 network grant (measured to fire before any tool
call), the `max_rows` cap, §5 verbatim fenced rendering, and the §7 provenance
stamp. The discriminator gates rather than labels — `mcp_get` refuses a URL it
does not own, so an MCP transport can never quietly serve an `https://` manifest
and leave the bundle's provenance claiming a transport that was never used.
Parsing is string-based, not `urlsplit`-based: `urlsplit().hostname` lowercases
the host, which would silently break the case-sensitive env lookup `server_ref`
depends on.
`ingest.py` is untouched — it is AST-guarded mcp-free, so the transport lives in
its own module and is opt-in at the call site. `ingest_mcp.py` imports the open
`mcp` protocol client but never `agent_framework`, keeping the seam D7-portable.
Load-bearing, six mutations all measured RED: detach the scheme guard · make the
refusal unconditional · swap parsing to `urlsplit().hostname` · skip non-text
content instead of raising · force `allow_network=True` · smuggle in a MAF
import. Both source files restored byte-identical (`shasum -c`) after each.
Honesty: `stdio_call_tool` (the real stdio path) is written but never executed
end to end — every test injects a canned tool call, so the suite spawns no
subprocess and opens no socket. No golden fixture, and MCP stays unwired in the
optimiser run path. Stated in docs/extending.md rather than implied away.
555 -> 578 tests; ruff + mypy green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0112FPR5TX6pDLiNicBPzE8i
The spec arrives by subtree pull from commons, so drift is something we RECEIVE
rather than author. The existing guard only asserted the section HEADINGS were
present: a pull could empty a section of its normative content and stay green.
Measured, not assumed — with `escape, not depth` deleted from Step 1, the old
skeleton test still passes (M5 below).
Two new guards, one file:
- Rule level (test 6): 25 normative rules, each bound to the section that OWNS
it, so a phrase surviving elsewhere in the document does not count as the spec
still stating the rule. Selection is principled rather than taste — every entry
anchors a §11 conformance seam or a CLAUDE.md invariant. Matching is
whitespace- and emphasis-insensitive: re-wrapping a paragraph upstream is an
editorial change, not a rule change, and must not cost a false red.
- §11 table (test 7): the conformance table still names the seams this suite
implements, and every test it cites exists here. One-directional by design —
the repo carries 26 load-bearing tests, the spec anchors 10, because the spec
governs the METHOD, not this repo.
Five measurements, all as expected: M1 delete a rule → RED · M2 RELOCATE a rule
out of its section while leaving it in the document → RED (this is what the
section binding buys) · M3 drop a seam row from §11 → RED · M4 harmless re-wrap
+ de-bolding → GREEN · M5 the old skeleton test does NOT catch M1 → GREEN.
Spec restored from a byte copy after each mutation, shasum verified.
Known gap, deliberately not patched here: §11 has no row for the portfolio-wide
budget seam (S3.4/F10) — the pulled spec predates it. That is a commons
amendment; a consumer editing shared/ is exactly the drift this guards against.
553 → 555 tests, ruff + mypy green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Aw9TECznT5b5H6374CBTvV
PortfolioBudget + PortfolioMeter carry ONE token ledger over a whole portfolio
pass -- and, seeded from a persisted spend file, across passes -- while the
per-run Budget/TokenMeter pair is untouched. Three enforcement points, each
doing a different job:
- startup: a remainder that cannot fund one run raises BudgetRefused before
anything loads (a pass that can afford zero projects is a caller mistake,
not a result);
- wave assembly: an unfundable project is NEVER STARTED and the pass stops
structurally (budget_stop + stopped_early, completed runs preserved).
Because every member of a wave is funded against the SAME pre-wave
remainder, admission RESERVES each member's requirement -- otherwise a wave
of k over-commits the cap by up to k runs;
- pre-call: BudgetMiddleware refuses a call the remainder cannot pay for
instead of making it. The post-charge check stays: real usage is only
knowable after the response, so the guard stops the NEXT call, never the
one in flight.
budget_stop is its own field rather than a widened stop_reason -- a goal-stop
is success, this is resource exhaustion, and fusing them would make "we
stopped" unreadable. PortfolioMeter splits record/check so tokens the provider
already billed reach the ledger even when the same charge breaks the run's own
cap. read_spend raises on corrupt content (our own accounting state, unlike
the tolerant RAW inbox layer); write_spend takes a REQUIRED stamp with no
wall-clock default, mirroring promote_verdict.
Load-bearing MEASURED, not asserted -- 6 mutations, all red: detach the wave
check; detach the pre-call guard; detach the wave reservation; check the run
cap before crediting the global ledger; detach the startup refusal; make
read_spend tolerant. Files restored from shasum-verified copies after each.
Two findings worth keeping: the pre-call guard MASKS a detached wave check if
the test asserts on overspend (spend stays under the cap either way), so the
load-bearing assertion had to become failures == () plus never-started; and
the token arithmetic is probed (32 tokens/run at tokens=8), not guessed.
537 -> 553 tests, ruff + mypy green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015EaxFnaDAbMQkmTeX4u7sd
The commons pull (7aa53fc -> a2b57d2) rewrote method-spec §3 Step 1 and added two §11
seams. Measuring okf.py against the new normative text found six contradictions; this
closes all six, gated by the commons-owned nav-goldens that came with the pull.
method-spec §3 Step 1 (navigate_bundle / bundle_context):
- follow cross-links RECURSIVELY, depth-first in first-seen order (there was no
recursion at all — only the root index's links were read, so no hierarchy was
navigable even with the other fixes in place);
- resolve a leading `/` against the BUNDLE ROOT, anything else against the LINKING
file's directory, and drop the retired "a path separator means out-of-bundle"
heuristic, which conflated depth with escape and forbade valid nesting;
- de-duplicate on the RESOLVED path (`./a.md` == `a.md` == `/a.md`), which is also
what terminates cycles;
- exclude index files by BASENAME at every level, so a nested index is navigation and
never renders as content (flat rendering regardless of depth);
- bind index_summary to the ROOT index alone.
safe_resolve stays the sole in-/out-of-bundle test, fail-closed: a target that fails to
resolve for ANY reason is skipped, never raised.
ingest-spec §3 (write_concept_file): it is the repo's one authoring primitive that
materialises a concept file from caller-supplied frontmatter, so it now refuses the
COMPLETE ownership stamp (`generated: true` + `ingest_manifest`) with IngestStampError,
while permitting either field alone. A validation, never a repair — nothing is written.
Gates (tests/test_okf.py, 529 -> 537):
- nav-golden-hierarchy and nav-golden-escape compared against the shipped
expected-read-context.md fasit (trailing-whitespace normalisation only, which the
fixture README explicitly permits; internal blank-line structure stays gated);
- traversal order pinned separately from the rendered output, so a right-looking render
from a wrong walk still fails;
- unit seams for the recursion in isolation, resolved-path dedup, and the leading-`/`
rule's breach case (a real out-of-bundle file addressed by its absolute path).
Load-bearing MEASURED, not asserted: seven mutations each go red — detach the recursion,
restore the separator prefilter, dedup on the raw target, read `/` as filesystem-absolute,
render nested index bodies as content, drop the stamp guard, and the fully naive navigator
with no boundary check (which is what makes the `/`-trap test bite). okf.py restored from a
checksum-verified copy after each.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01WetWTHpdRbqinN5XHFTaTb
The commons pull (7aa53fc..a2b57d2) retires "a path separator means out-of-bundle"
in method-spec §3 Step 1. test_navigate_skips_null_byte_link stayed GREEN, but its
docstring explained itself via that heuristic ("slips past the `/` pre-filter") —
a live test citing dead doctrine. Behavior and assertions are unchanged; only the
reason is re-anchored on what the new spec makes load-bearing: a target failing to
resolve for ANY reason is skipped, not raised (§11 row "Navigation boundary").
Measured, not assumed: this was the only rotted rationale. The three other
separator mentions (okf.py:26-27, :125, test_okf.py:164) describe what the code
actually does or rest on safe_resolve, which survives the retirement.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01HxGWaoDYb6vmzd7EPfYkqS
Closes OQ1 (SC8). At k>1 every project in a wave reads the WAVE-START store,
so a verdict captured by project A does not reach project B's hypothesis
prompt inside the same wave — sequentially it would. Deliberate: the snapshot
is what removes the append race, and restoring intra-wave visibility would
restore the completion-order dependence the barrier exists to eliminate.
Learning flows ACROSS wave boundaries, not within them; concurrency trades
learning granularity for wall-clock.
The shipped fixture cannot show this (the fold is bundle_dir-gated and no
reference project sets bundle_dir), which is a property of the fixture and not
of the design — so it is pinned on the road-k + bundle-k+1 pair via the
existing load_reference_projects monkeypatch seam, no new production seam.
k=1 (two waves) carries the sentinel; k=2 (one wave) does not; store content
stays identical across k. Each half is the other's control.
Detach measured: remove _wave_snapshot -> RED on three tests including this one.
Also corrects two stale docstrings that outlived Session 1's finding: the
module header and the Step-2 test still named a sorted() in _merge_wave as the
detach point. There is no sorted() there, and a project_id sort would BREAK
the k=1-identity contract rather than protect it. A docstring naming a detach
point that does not exist is the green-but-dead defect this file exists to
prevent, so both now name the snapshot and mark the plan's claim as measured
wrong.
_wave_snapshot gains the honesty line about copying exactly two fields, with
the reason no field-count guard was added.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015vYbqW4MppACRvPhEMDpvF
Documents the wave-model reading of the existing Step-8 goal semantics (a
reading, not a redesign — Session 1 already moved the checks to wave assembly
because the executor required it) and pins it with three tests.
Goal checks run at WAVE ASSEMBLY, per member: a HARD per-project goal removes
the pid before the wave starts, so an excluded project is never STARTED and
leaves no verdict behind; a HARD portfolio goal stops the pass with the
assembled wave still crossing its barrier; SOFT flags and continues.
Detach points measured:
per-project goal keyed per WAVE, not per member -> RED (membership diverges
at k=3, unaffected at k=1)
import threading under src/ -> RED (AST guard)
promote_verdict called on the run path -> RED (tripwire)
Corrects one claim the plan and my first docstring both implied: checking the
goal MID-WAVE does NOT make membership completion-order dependent.
_goal_limit_if_reached reads only the ledger, contract and baseline, all
invariant during a pass, so a later check reaches the same decision.
Determinism of membership is the ONE-WRITER rule's (C3, now a tripwire test),
not the check's placement; placement buys the never-started property. The
docstrings say this rather than claiming a detach point that does not exist.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015vYbqW4MppACRvPhEMDpvF
One project's exception no longer cancels its siblings: the wave's gather
runs with return_exceptions=True and each raised project becomes a frozen
RunFailure(project_id, error, error_type) in the defaulted
PortfolioResult.failures, while every completed project keeps its full
RunResult. RunFailure is a distinct type rather than an error field on
RunResult (six required non-defaulted fields -> dummies would be fabricated
provenance); the deviation from the spec's wording is stated in both
docstrings. TaskGroup is rejected: it cancels siblings on first exception.
snapshots reaches _merge_wave unfiltered, and results are paired back to pids
by POSITION (gather resolves in argument order) so a mid-wave failure cannot
disturb store order or misattribute the failure.
Detach points measured, not asserted:
drop return_exceptions=True -> RED (both new tests)
reorder snapshots before merge -> RED (+ Session 1's determinism test)
pair results by sorted(), not position -> RED (failure misattributed)
filter failed members before merge -> GREEN, measured
The last one corrects the plan: its carried-forward requirement implied
filtering before the merge was the hazard. Filtering preserves relative order,
which is all _merge_wave consumes, so the variant is undetectable AND harmless.
The docstring now names the reorder as the detach point and records the
filter asymmetry, rather than claiming a detach point that does not exist.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015vYbqW4MppACRvPhEMDpvF
Replaces run_portfolio's sequential loop with a wave loop over _waves(ids, k):
each wave takes a per-project snapshot of the shared store, runs the wave under
one asyncio.gather in a single event loop, then crosses a merge barrier that
folds each project's NEW verdicts back in wave-submission order. Step 2's
contract goes GREEN; runs stays in project_ids order because gather resolves in
argument order, not completion order.
TWO PLAN CORRECTIONS, both found by the RED-first test rather than by reading:
1. The plan specified sorting the merged verdicts on `project_id`. Measured, that
produces a deterministic order which is the WRONG one: lexicographic gives
BRU/FV42/RV13 while the sequential pass gives FV42/RV13/BRU. It satisfies
"deterministic" while breaking "identical to concurrency=1" — and the second is
the actual contract. The merge preserves submission order instead.
2. The plan named the barrier's sort as the load-bearing seam. It is not — with
per-project snapshots the wave list is never reordered by completion, so a
sorted() there would re-sort an already-ordered list and read as a guard while
guarding nothing. The SNAPSHOT is the half that carries the load. Rather than
ship a decorative sort, both halves were measured (scratchpad-restore, never
git checkout):
detach _wave_snapshot -> RED (store lands in completion order)
detach merge ordering -> RED (reversed wave order diverges)
Both restored byte-identical (sha 42b01d46).
The snapshot carries `retriever` across deliberately: dropping it would silently
downgrade a caller-owned store's S3.1 semantic-retrieval opt-in mid-pass.
Also strengthens the scripted-client consolidation guard, which the probe broke by
being a legitimate third _inner_get_response def-site. It pinned a literal count
of 2 — the wrong shape: it failed on any new legitimate subclass while still
passing if someone pasted a duplicated body into an already-listed file. It now
pins the property (registered sites, scripted-lineage overrides must delegate via
super(), foreign-lineage doubles must genuinely be foreign). Verified load-bearing:
removing both delegation sites turns it RED.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LQapztREtC2mkr5oU811pr
Commits the determinism contract RED, mirroring S3.1 (b05747a RED -> 6618f67
GREEN). The wave executor does not exist yet, so `concurrency=3` still runs the
sequential path — and the test says so precisely rather than passing vacuously:
max in-flight was 1: concurrency=3 never overlapped two projects
call sequence=[FV42 x4, RV13 x4, BRU x4]
That blocked call sequence is the proof the probe works. A test that had gone
GREEN here would have been asserting something the sequential path already
satisfies — the Spike B call-counter tautology repeating — and the plan's
escalation rule would have stopped execution.
The probe returns a coroutine yielding N times via asyncio.sleep(0) (a pure
scheduler yield, no wall clock) before delegating to the canonical body, with N
read from the prompt blob since client_factory's argument is the ROLE, not the
project id. The stream path is delegated untouched, and the subclass chain is
preserved so BudgetMiddleware still engages.
Three self-checks make it non-vacuous by construction: max-in-flight > 1,
completion order != submission order, and >= 3 distinct verdict ids. Self-check
1 asserts non-identity rather than an exact reversal — asyncio.sleep(0) is a
scheduler yield, not an ordering primitive, so demanding a specific permutation
would only add a way to fail for a reason that is not the contract.
The docstring also corrects what the repetitions guard: NOT hash-seed
nondeterminism (PYTHONHASHSEED is fixed per interpreter, so every in-process rep
shares one seed), but scheduler nondeterminism under real concurrency.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LQapztREtC2mkr5oU811pr
Add keyword-only `concurrency: int = 1` to `run_portfolio`, a module-level
`_waves` partitioner, and a fail-fast on k < 1 that precedes any project load.
The execution loop is deliberately NOT changed here. At the default k=1 every
wave holds a single project, so the wave partition reproduces the existing
`for pid in ids` order by construction — the parameter is inert until Step 3
wires the executor. The 5 tests pin exactly that: order preservation across
every k, nothing dropped or duplicated, and the k<1 raise.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LQapztREtC2mkr5oU811pr
S5.4 review MINOR (SC5 fail-fast hole, run.py:740). A valid-JSON but
wrong-shape savings ledger escaped the --report fail-fast refusal:
- top-level {} iterated zero keys -> entries=[] -> rc 0 "0,00 kr"
(a malformed file masquerading as a real zero-savings result)
- a bare scalar / object-with-keys / list-of-non-objects raised an
uncaught TypeError -> traceback (violates SC5 "rc 1, no traceback")
Fix at the fail-fast boundary, not the run.py except tuple: the review's
first option (add TypeError to run.py:740) leaves the {} masquerade
because {} is an empty iteration, not a TypeError. SavingsLedger.load now
raises ValueError for a non-array top-level and a non-object row, caught
by run.py:740's existing ValueError arm. Hardens both callers
(run.py:740 report + run.py:785 portfolio).
RED-first: 6 unit cases (test_ledger) + 2 CLI rc-1 cases (test_run_cli).
452 passed; ruff + mypy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
New English docs/knowledge-base-recipe.md grounded strictly in the D-H decision record
(revisjonspakke-DF-DI.md §3): setup is always a small team (technical + domain expert), the
deliverable is a recipe NOT a wizard (B9 onboarding interview + guided verdict command rejected),
domain expert delivers files in their own formats never schema/JSON, phased process (inventory ->
skeleton -> seed verdicts -> iterate), reading via Obsidian/VS Code. The honest 1-2 week
expectation is stated early and SOURCED verbatim to the record. Factory-dependent parts
(free-format verdict translation, clone-to-demo) are explicitly marked future/blocked-on-toolkit
so the doc never claims above the evidence level. Linked from README's Docs section with the
1-2 week expectation in context. SC5 (ASCII-only greps): file exists, '1-2 weeks' x2,
'knowledge-base-recipe' in README. src/ untouched; 431 passed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
README: the stale one-line CLI mention replaced by the two-mode flag matrix (single-project vs
--portfolio), runnable 'uv run python -m portfolio_optimiser.run ...' examples, the --outbox-dir
!= --verdict-dir self-contamination warning (documented, not enforced), and the --decision/
--rationale inert-in-portfolio note. Honesty scoping: the prior-verdict fold (the learning step)
is stated to happen ONLY on the --bundle-dir path; a --docs-dir-only run is single-shot (no fold).
CHANGELOG [Unreleased]/Added: S5.3 CLI-parity entry (six flags + portfolio mode + load_dimension +
recipe doc) plus catch-up for the shipped-but-undocumented S4.1 (preflight), S4.2 (--live-dry-run),
S5.1 (hitl CLI), S5.2 (notify); stale test count 237 -> 431. extending.md verified accurate (B11
notifier note stands verbatim — main() auto-wires no notifier; no CLI section to sync), left
unchanged.
SC4 honesty grep clean (each hit in bundle-path context, none on a fold-less path):
grep -rniE 'learning loop|learns from|self-improv' README.md docs/extending.md CHANGELOG.md
README:11 (system-level) :56 (wiki substrate) :67 (8-step bundle loop);
CHANGELOG:13 (gated ExpeL fold) :17 (offline simulation). Full suite 431 passed (no code touched).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
SC2 second half: --verdict-dir had no main()-level test (exploration gap). New test drops one
valid verdict into a tmp inbox and drives main([pid, --docs-dir, --bundle-dir, --verdict-dir,
--live-dry-run]) -> rc 0: the inbox ingestion (load_verdicts_from_dir, run.py:287) runs before the
dry-run cut (run.py:335), so the flag's wiring is exercised offline without raising. --bundle-dir's
main()-level coverage already exists in test_live_dry_run.py and is referenced, not duplicated.
run.py untouched (never re-wired). 11 passed in test_run_cli.py.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
After parse_args, validate mode consistency with structured refusals (rc 1, not argparse.error):
--portfolio + any single-project-only flag (--docs-dir/--bundle-dir/--verdict-dir/--outbox-dir/
--run-id/--live-dry-run) is refused naming the offending flag; --goals/--ledger outside --portfolio
is refused. --decision/--rationale are EXCLUDED (non-None defaults make explicit-vs-default
indistinguishable — Pass-2 #2; inert in portfolio mode, README says so). --dimension-config is
valid in both modes. Validation precedes the portfolio dispatch, so refusals fire before any load.
RED-first: (a)/(a')/(c) failed offline (rc 0 fall-through) before the check, green after; (b)/(b')
single-project guard + legacy backward-compat pin were already green post-Step-3. All refusal-arm
RED fall-throughs held OFFLINE (met-goal / --live-dry-run) — no socket, per brief NFR. 15 passed,
ruff + mypy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
main() gains a --portfolio mode flag dispatching to the EXISTING run_portfolio (not modified):
loads --goals/--ledger/--dimension-config via the fail-fast loaders, passes project_ids=(pid,)
or None (all reference projects), and prints a deterministic goal-stop line
'goal reached: scope=... project=... observed_ore=... limit_ore=... stopped_early=...' from the
returned GoalReached/PortfolioResult. Positional project_id relaxed to nargs='?' and --docs-dir to
optional, with a compensating single-project-mode guard (no pid/no --docs-dir -> rc 1 refusal) so
the legacy contract still fails loudly. Dispatch + guard sit BEFORE the live_dry_run branch
(Pass-2 #3 — appended after, they'd be dead code). Loader failures use the same structured refusal
('portfolio run refused: ...'). Load-bearing pair (RED-first): portfolio-hard goal already met
breaks offline before any client (scope=portfolio, stopped_early=True); per-project-hard control
skips the only pid (scope=project, stopped_early=False) — the two arms force the printed fields to
derive from run_portfolio's real values. Marker 13731 øre. 9 passed, ruff + mypy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
main() single-project path now parses --dimension-config (fail-fast via load_dimension),
--outbox-dir, and --run-id (deliberate 7th companion flag: determinism invariant forbids a
wall-clock run_id default). All three threaded into BOTH run_project call sites. Full-run
branch wrapped in a structured-refusal (catch ValueError/FileNotFoundError/ValidationError ->
'run refused: {exc}' on stderr, rc 1, no traceback); the EXISTING dry-run handler widened to
the same tuple (pydantic ValidationError is not a ValueError subclass; load_dimension's
FileNotFoundError would otherwise traceback — Pass-2 #1). --outbox-dir carries a loud help=
note it must differ from --verdict-dir (self-contamination footgun; documented, not enforced).
RED-first: 4 CLI tests failed on unrecognized args, green after. 7 passed (incl. live-dry-run
regression). ruff + mypy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
New load_dimension(str | Path) in dimension.py: is_file() -> FileNotFoundError,
then Dimension.model_validate_json -> pydantic.ValidationError on malformed shape.
Fail-fast because dimension config is authoritative startup input (contrast the
tolerant verdict-inbox RAW layer). Stdlib + pydantic only — stays MAF-free
(test_okf_is_maf_free AST guard green). Exported from __init__.py in both the
import block and __all__. RED-first: 3 loader tests failed on the missing import,
green after. tests/test_dimension.py + test_okf.py: 29 passed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KNNiJRk1sSwxgVLS5AobT1
pkt.2 — coverage gap (green-but-dead): link_in_index preserves the existing
index byte-for-byte and in order on the SUCCESS path by construction, but
nothing asserted it. Byte-equality was checked only on the REFUSAL path
(test_step8_promotion_loadbearing.py Test A); other tests check mere line
MEMBERSHIP. A writer that kept every link but reordered/rewrote the existing
body would pass the whole suite — the exact ingest-spec §6 / Step-8 promotion
invariant we rely on (promoted verdict links survive re-ingest byte-for-byte).
New test uses deliberately non-sorted existing links; proven load-bearing (a
temporary `sorted()` reorder mutation flips it RED, then reverted). Test-only,
no production change.
pkt.4 — shared_root.py docstring overclaimed "Every MAF-side consumer resolves
through this ONE seam". Verified: both runtime consumers (persona, simulation)
do route through shared_root(); the 15 test modules hardcode the in-repo
fixture path deliberately (a test needing the real fixture must not be
redirected by a production env var). Scoped the claim to "runtime consumer"
rather than churning 15 test files to make a false claim true.
Full suite 415 passed, ruff + mypy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01HVHLJuwBzp7MXkrUXJYARS
is_within_dir called os.path.realpath OUTSIDE its try block, so a path with
an embedded null byte (which makes realpath raise ValueError, not OSError)
leaked that ValueError to callers. Via safe_resolve -> okf._load_file (which
catches only PathSecurityError) it propagated uncaught out of
navigate_bundle, breaking the OKF SPEC §4 guarantee (okf.py:8-9) that a
broken cross-link is silently skipped, never raised: an index link like
`](a\x00b.md)` has no `/`, slips past the same-dir pre-filter, and reached
path resolution.
Move both realpath calls inside the existing try so an uncanonicalisable
path is treated as not-within (fail-closed): safe_resolve raises
PathSecurityError -> _load_file returns None -> the link is skipped. Fixes
the class for both callers of the seam (navigate_bundle + retrieve).
Tests (load-bearing — RED before, GREEN after):
- test_navigate_skips_null_byte_link: the reported regression.
- test_null_byte_path_rejected: the seam directly (is_within_dir/safe_resolve).
- test_navigate_skips_bundle_escaping_symlink_link: closes the previously
untested path-safety-at-link-resolution branch of navigate_bundle.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01HVHLJuwBzp7MXkrUXJYARS
