Kjell Tore Guttormsen
72cb15feed
Forrige økt kjørte /trekreview men lukket ikke loopen (review.md untracked,
STATE ikke oppdatert). Denne committen tar review-artefaktet inn i den tracked
brief→plan→review-serien.
Verdict WARN: 0 BLOCKER, 1 MAJOR, 0 MINOR. Code-correctness clean (0 defekter,
7 dim); alle 9 Success Criteria tracer, alle 7 Non-Goals holdt. MAJOR =
SCOPE_CREEP_BUILT om fe4ae69 (parallell operatør-commit Fable5→Opus4.8 på
plandok, i range 2208cdf..696f19a) — akseptert som moot: rørte ingen I6-fil,
recommended_action (split-commit) umulig fordi allerede pushet. Ingen rework.
NESTE: I7 program-avslutning.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JJET4jzpqykqEaQKQDqbS6
5.1 KiB
5.1 KiB
| type | review_version | created | task | slug | project_dir | brief_path | scope_sha_start | scope_sha_end | reviewed_files_count | verdict | findings | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| trekreview | 1.0 | 2026-07-04 | I6 — wire the HTTP source connector behind an opt-in network flag (MAF-only), tested against a local mock, no live source | i6-ingest-http-maf | .claude/projects/2026-07-04-i6-ingest-http-maf/ | .claude/projects/2026-07-04-i6-ingest-http-maf/brief.md | 2208cdf |
696f19a |
15 | WARN |
|
Review: I6 — HTTP source connector (MAF-only)
Executive Summary
Verdict: WARN — one MAJOR finding, zero BLOCKERs. The code-correctness pass was clean (0 defects across all 7 dimensions), and the brief-conformance pass ran (not skipped): all 9 Success Criteria trace and all 7 Non-Goals are honored. The single MAJOR is a scope-boundary observation — a concurrent operator commit (fe4ae69) edited an unrelated session-plan model directive inside the reviewed range. Under high-effort mode this is retained for operator judgment rather than dropped; look at it first. Note: this review ran in high-effort mode (brief phase_signals.review.effort: high), so Pass 3 (reasonableness filter) was skipped by design.
Coverage
| File | Treatment | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| build_fixture.py | summary-only | In I6 delivery range; supporting fixture builder |
| docs/extending.md | summary-only | In I6 delivery range; http source extension-point docs |
| docs/plan/2026-07-03-sesjonsplan-ingest.md | summary-only | In range via concurrent commit fe4ae69; flagged (see Findings) |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/expected-bundle/index.md | summary-only | Golden expected-bundle artifact |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/expected-bundle/ingest-report.md | summary-only | Golden expected-bundle artifact |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/expected-bundle/ingest-status.md | summary-only | Golden expected-bundle artifact |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/fixture/report | summary-only | Golden fixture input |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/fixture/status | summary-only | Golden fixture input |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/ingested-at.txt | summary-only | Golden determinism marker |
| examples/ingest-golden-http/manifest.json | summary-only | Golden manifest |
| src/portfolio_optimiser/ingest.py | summary-only | Core connector + gate implementation |
| tests/test_ingest_golden_http.py | summary-only | Golden byte-deterministic extraction test |
| tests/test_ingest_http.py | summary-only | HTTP connector unit test |
| tests/test_ingest_http_loadbearing.py | summary-only | Load-bearing gate/dispatch test |
| tests/test_ingest_materialize.py | summary-only | Materialization test |
No files were marked skip — all 15 files in the range received coverage. No uncommitted working-tree changes were present.
Findings (MAJOR)
a1f4c9e07b3d264f8e5106bd9c2a7f31e0d4b8a6
- file: docs/plan/2026-07-03-sesjonsplan-ingest.md
- line: 11
- rule_key: SCOPE_CREEP_BUILT
- brief_ref: none
- title: Unrelated session-plan model-directive edit bundled into the I6 delivery range
- detail: The reviewed range (2208cdf..HEAD) includes an edit to docs/plan/2026-07-03-sesjonsplan-ingest.md:11-13 flipping the program-level model directive from 'Fable 5' to 'Opus 4.8 ... ingen Fable 5' (commit
fe4ae69, a concurrent operator session). This file is not in the I6 plan's declared modify/create scope and traces to no I6 brief Success Criterion or Non-Goal — it concerns model selection for all ingest sessions, unrelated to the HTTP source connector deliverable. - recommended_action: Split the model-directive correction into its own commit outside the I6 deliverable (or record it as an explicitly in-scope housekeeping item), keeping the I6 range to the contracted connector/gate/golden/docs work.
Remediation Summary
- BLOCKER: 0
- MAJOR: 1
- MINOR: 0
- SUGGESTION: 0
/trekplan --brief review.md will consume the single MAJOR scope-boundary finding: the concurrent model-directive edit that landed inside the I6 range. No blocking defects were found in the connector/gate/golden/docs deliverable itself.
{"verdict":"WARN","counts":{"BLOCKER":0,"MAJOR":1,"MINOR":0,"SUGGESTION":0},"findings":[{"id":"a1f4c9e07b3d264f8e5106bd9c2a7f31e0d4b8a6","severity":"MAJOR","rule_key":"SCOPE_CREEP_BUILT","file":"docs/plan/2026-07-03-sesjonsplan-ingest.md","line":11,"brief_ref":"none","title":"Unrelated session-plan model-directive edit bundled into the I6 delivery range","detail":"The reviewed range (2208cdf..HEAD) includes an edit to docs/plan/2026-07-03-sesjonsplan-ingest.md:11-13 flipping the program-level model directive from 'Fable 5' to 'Opus 4.8 ... ingen Fable 5' (commit fe4ae69, a concurrent operator session). This file is not in the I6 plan's declared modify/create scope and traces to no I6 brief Success Criterion or Non-Goal — it concerns model selection for all ingest sessions, unrelated to the HTTP source connector deliverable.","recommended_action":"Split the model-directive correction into its own commit outside the I6 deliverable (or record it as an explicitly in-scope housekeeping item), keeping the I6 range to the contracted connector/gate/golden/docs work."}]}