Clarification 17 of the pre-registration, approved 2026-11-13 before anything is computed: the conditions of a solution can be named when every target it holds under conditions in has one that can be named, and the condition behind M5 counts as named and is written out with the source. Dated entry with the reason under «Endringer». The grid connection of a nuclear plant stays out of the business economics, and the report says so. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
129 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
129 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
# Changelog
|
||
|
||
All notable changes to this project will be documented in this file.
|
||
|
||
## Unreleased
|
||
|
||
- Pre-registration of what is tested and what it takes for the hypothesis to hold (`FORHANDSREGISTRERING.md`).
|
||
- Source bank: 948 entries in 21 areas, each checked against its primary source (`kilder/`). The second round
|
||
(areas 13–21) covers the parameters that lacked a source when the model was specified.
|
||
- Model specification, draft 3 (47 equations), after a pre-read of draft 2, two independent reviews of draft 3
|
||
and a control of the corrections (`modell/`).
|
||
- Parameters frozen before anything is computed: 124 parameters in 2025 kroner, one distribution each, with the
|
||
source entries they rest on (`modell/parametere.json`). The checksum is recorded in the pre-registration.
|
||
No code and no results yet.
|
||
- Eight clarifications of the pre-registered criteria, approved by the project owner after the parameter freeze
|
||
and before anything is computed (`FORHANDSREGISTRERING.md`, «Presiseringer»). The parameter file is unchanged.
|
||
- First code (`src/tokenfabrikker/`): one function per equation for the power plant, the data centre and the
|
||
revenue (S1–S21, S36, S43–S47), a strict reader for the frozen parameter file with unit conversion, and the
|
||
10 000 Monte Carlo draws stored in `data/`. Python with pinned numpy and scipy, pytest, ruff `ALL` and mypy strict.
|
||
No result for the hypothesis has been computed.
|
||
- An independent reader coded the key equations from the specification alone. The two implementations agree on
|
||
all 23 functions. The 19 ambiguities the reader found are settled in a new, dated chapter 16 of the
|
||
specification (`modell/`); the parameter file and the pre-registration are unchanged.
|
||
- Known-answer tests against Argonne, NOU 2026: 4, Epoch and NVE with the sources' own assumptions
|
||
(`tests/test_fasit.py`). The misses are kept as documented expected failures: wind on land and offshore wind
|
||
come out 5–6 % below NVE, and three rows of Argonne's table depend on a reading the source does not settle.
|
||
- Build-out, power system and cash flow in code (`src/tokenfabrikker/`): when each facility starts and which
|
||
vintages of IT hardware it gets (S22, S33), the export rule with its own stored stream of random numbers
|
||
(`data/aarshendelser.npy`), the fitted price lines and the power and capacity balances (S23–S25, S38), and the
|
||
yearly cash flows with residual value, the additionality rule and net present value for Norway (S26, S34, S35,
|
||
S40, S45). Tested on made-up numbers only; no result for the hypothesis has been computed.
|
||
- A second independent reader coded these equations from the specification alone and found 28 ambiguities. They
|
||
are settled in clarifications 21–40 in chapter 16 of the specification. With the readings aligned, the two
|
||
implementations agree on 10 000 made-up build-out paths. The clarifications that are choices are marked and put
|
||
to the project owner (`modell/fagfellevurdering-utkast-2-og-3.md`, part 5).
|
||
- The price lines of S38 are held against NVE's twelve scenarios: within 5 % for Norway and three price areas,
|
||
6.0 % and 7.7 % off in one scenario for NO3 and NO4, kept as documented expected failures.
|
||
- Business economics, ownership, scale, environment and verdicts in code (`nivaaisert.py`, `eierskap.py`,
|
||
`skala.py`, `miljo.py`, `dommer.py`; S15, S19, S27 to S32, S37, S42), tested on made-up numbers only. A third
|
||
independent reader coded the same chapters from the specification alone and found 60 points, 14 of them
|
||
objections to the economics; a new reader then recoded from the clarifications in four more rounds (17, 5, 1
|
||
and 0 new points). The readings stand in clarifications 41–61 in chapter 16; the two implementations agree on
|
||
1 000 made-up paths. Corrected after the readers: the accident cost stays when the additionality rule binds,
|
||
tax depreciation loses real value with price growth, and the special tax only meets return above the cost of
|
||
capital. Weaknesses in the comparison of ownership forms that are not corrected are listed in clarification 61
|
||
and put to the project owner (`modell/fagfellevurdering-utkast-2-og-3.md`, part 6). No result for the
|
||
hypothesis has been computed.
|
||
- The comparison of ownership forms corrected before anything is computed (clarifications 62–67 in chapter 16):
|
||
a residual value at the final year as a taxable sale, the electricity tax as the state's only levy with what
|
||
displaced private data centres would have paid deducted, private owners who pay what their share is worth in
|
||
expectation, the state's cash flow valued with the required return for compute, and the cost of capital before
|
||
tax. An independent reader coded the corrections from the text alone in three rounds; its first-round finding
|
||
that the private owners and the state were priced with different rates changed the correction. With it every
|
||
ownership form has the same expected value in the main run, and they differ in risk and capital. The two
|
||
implementations agree to within one krone on 1 500 made-up paths. The project owner approved the corrections
|
||
before anything is computed.
|
||
- The direction of the project extended by the project owner (what can start quickly, a stepwise build-up, and
|
||
compute on the users' own machines), and four more clarifications of the pre-registered criteria (9–12), all
|
||
before anything is computed (`FORHANDSREGISTRERING.md`). The sources' figures for the emissions test M5 (i)
|
||
are set up and checked against the primary sources (clarification 68). The parameter file is unchanged.
|
||
- Source bank extended with areas 22–26 for the addition to the direction (188 entries: fast start on the grid,
|
||
power with short lead time, stepwise build-up, compute on the users' own machines, avoided emissions and
|
||
cooling water), each checked against its primary source by an independent controller (`kilder/`).
|
||
- The addition to the direction written into the specification as chapter 17 (equations S48–S54) and into the
|
||
pre-registration, before anything is computed: a new solution T, "stepwise", in two versions (modules of
|
||
100 MW on the grid with new renewable power, and the same with grid-connected nuclear power from when it can
|
||
come), which A must also beat; no gas power; a threshold and two labelled scenarios for compute on the users'
|
||
own machines; the calculation of emissions with a deduction; cooling water; and a timeline of megawatts in
|
||
operation per solution. An independent reader coded the chapter from the text alone in three rounds; its findings
|
||
changed the chip rule and the condition for nuclear power in the second version, the cap on early grid
|
||
connections and the lead time. The parameter file is unchanged; the new quantities are candidates until the
|
||
deviation from the freeze.
|
||
- One deviation from the parameter freeze, before anything is computed (`modell/parametere.json` version 1.1,
|
||
new checksum in the pre-registration): thirteen new quantities for the addition to the direction, seven new
|
||
sensitivities and three corrected lines in the list of sensitivities. None of the 124 frozen parameters got a
|
||
new value, range or distribution. 137 parameters, 91 drawn quantities, new draws in `data/`. Before the
|
||
deviation the project itself looked up the 30 source entries behind the new quantities in the primary
|
||
sources; four things changed from the candidates (see chapter 17.8 of the specification).
|
||
- The build-out of solution T in code (`src/tokenfabrikker/utbygging.py`, chapter 17.1): when each module of
|
||
100 MW starts in T-F and T-K, with the grid balance of the first stage, the condition for nuclear power (S49)
|
||
and the two stocks of chips, and the timeline of megawatts in operation per type of power (S50). The equations
|
||
S48–S54 are pure functions, and the new quantities are read into the input data. Written from the text
|
||
before the independent reader's code was opened, then run against it: 42 000 made-up build-outs and 20 000
|
||
made-up sets for S51–S54 without a difference. Six clarifications (70–75) in chapter 16 of the specification
|
||
say how chapter 17 is read where the text was silent. Solution T is not taken through the cash flow or the
|
||
verdicts yet, and no result for the hypothesis has been computed.
|
||
- Solution T through the power system and the cash flow (`kontantstrom.py`): everything per module, renewable
|
||
modules with their own portfolio as in C, the nuclear modules of T-K on shared units as in B, and the fixed
|
||
cost of a new nuclear country counted to the first unit. The loss of demand of chapter 17.3 enters the
|
||
revenue and the disconnection arm of S47 (`regn_program(..., bortfall=...)`); without a loss every figure is
|
||
unchanged. Emissions "with deduction" (S53) and cooling water (S54) are put together over a programme for
|
||
all seven solutions (`miljo.py`). A new independent reader coded the same from the specification alone:
|
||
1 778 made-up paths through both codes without a difference, and the two sensitivities that are switches in
|
||
both. Six clarifications (76–81) in chapter 16 settle what the text left open
|
||
(`modell/fagfellevurdering-utkast-2-og-3.md`, part 11). The levelised cost, ownership, scale and verdicts
|
||
refuse solution T and a loss of demand until chapter 17 is taken through them. No result has been computed.
|
||
- Present values are now exactly rounded sums. As dot products the same computation did not give the same last
|
||
digit every time, for every solution. A test runs the same computation six times and requires equal numbers.
|
||
- Solution T and the loss of demand through the levelised cost, the business economics, the ownership forms
|
||
and scale (`nivaaisert.py`, `eierskap.py`, `skala.py`): the power cost per module, with a renewable module's
|
||
own portfolio as in C and the nuclear modules of T-K on shared units as in B; tariff, building, IT hardware
|
||
and residual value per module; and the factor of S51 per vintage in S19, S27, S31 and S42. For the five
|
||
solutions of chapters 0 to 16 without a loss every figure is unchanged to the last digit. A new independent
|
||
reader coded the same from the specification alone: 1 760 made-up paths through both codes, 6.6 million
|
||
figures compared, without a difference. Six clarifications (82–87) in chapter 16 say how the text is read
|
||
and name one property the reader found that is in favour of nuclear power on the grid in the business
|
||
economics (`modell/fagfellevurdering-utkast-2-og-3.md`, part 12). M5 and the verdicts do not know solution T yet. No
|
||
result has been computed.
|
||
- The technologies of a facility are kept in a fixed order. As a set of names their order differed from run to
|
||
run, and the last digit of the figures for solution C with it.
|
||
- M5 and the verdicts for five solutions (`miljo.py`, `dommer.py`): T-F meets M5 (i) and (ii) by definition
|
||
and T-K is judged as nuclear power; the ladder, part I and M7 cover A, B, C, T-F and T-K, and in M7 A must
|
||
beat each of the four others that can be built. Three sensitivities of chapter 17.8 are switches: full
|
||
displacement in the first stage (`regn_program(..., full_fortrengning_i_forste_trinn=True)`), new renewable
|
||
power first from 2031 for C and T (`lag_plan(..., ny_kraft_fra=2031)`), and modules of 50 and 200 MW
|
||
(`Inndata.med`). Next to S54 the withdrawal of water is also given with sea water only for the nuclear
|
||
production the data centres themselves use. With the switches off every figure for all seven solutions is
|
||
unchanged to the last digit. A new independent reader coded the same from the specification alone: about
|
||
400 000 comparisons of M5 and the verdicts on invented outcomes per draw, and 2 523 made-up paths with
|
||
10.1 million figures through both codes for the sensitivities, without a difference. Seven clarifications
|
||
(88–94) in chapter 16 say how the text is read (`modell/fagfellevurdering-utkast-2-og-3.md`, part 13). No
|
||
result has been computed.
|
||
- Clarification 17 of the pre-registration, approved by the project owner 2026-11-13 before anything is
|
||
computed: the conditions of a power solution can be named when every target it holds under conditions in
|
||
has a condition that can be named, and when M5 holds under conditions the condition is that the sources in
|
||
which nuclear power is not higher are the ones relied on, written out with the source. The independent
|
||
reader found that the text did not say this. The project owner also decided that the grid connection of a
|
||
nuclear plant stays out of the business economics, as the text says, and that the report states it
|
||
(clarification 87).
|